המקוה והתיבה הם כמו embassy של שמים על הארץ
Catalog entry: פרשת השבוע נח no. 5 Pocket Guide p. 3 תשמ"ג (1982–83) Yiddish 1 hr 19 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains that the mikveh, like Noach's teivah and the sukkah, is a piece of heaven on earth, an embassy of Shamayim where judgment is sweetened at its root and evil cannot follow.
The Mashgiach opens with the different wording of Noach's missions to the raven and the dove: the raven is a taker, the dove, likened to Knesses Yisrael, a giver. He then asks why Rabbi Yehuda in the Haggadah gives simanim for the makos, and ties it to his view that chametz is removed only by burning. The answer rests on sweetening judgment at its root: Noach's korban reached the root, so the yetzer hara that brought the flood became the reason for no more flood, and a unanimous Sanhedrin acquits for the same reason. The four ways of removing chametz match the four elements of Shem Havaya, with fire, Yehuda's element, as the root. From there he explains the mikveh as fire within water, an embassy of heaven on earth, like the sukkah and the teivah, and closes on immersing beyond obligation, with stories of tzaddikim.
Topics: Tumah, Taharah and Mikveh · Noach and the Mabul
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 The raven and the dove: taker and giver
The Mashgiach asks why the Torah describes the raven's mission and the dove's mission differently, and explains that the raven, cruel even to its own young, is a taker who would keep returning to Noach, while the dove, likened to Knesses Yisrael, prefers bitter food of its own to taking.
-
4:39 Rabbi Yehuda's simanim and burning chametz
The Mashgiach explains that saying the makos at the Seder draws plagues on Israel's enemies and healing on Israel, and asks what Rabbi Yehuda's simanim come to add. He then brings the Mishnah's dispute on removing chametz, where Rabbi Yehuda holds it is done only by burning.
-
8:18 Sweetening judgment at its root: Noach's korban
The Mashgiach introduces the principle that judgment is sweetened at its root, and shows it in the parsha: the yetzer hara is the reason given both for the flood and for the promise of no more flood, because Noach's korban brought a nachas ruach that reached the root of creation, where din turns into chesed.
-
15:29 Unanimous Sanhedrin, Tishrei and Nissan
The Mashgiach explains why a Sanhedrin that unanimously convicts lets the accused go free: each sage receives Torah through his own channel, like water in colored glass, and unanimity shows they reached the colorless root where chayav turns to zakai. He adds that Tishrei and Nissan, the roots of time, are when evil is nullified, through teshuvah and through removing chametz.
-
19:26 Four elements, four ways, and Yehuda as fire
The Mashgiach explains that the world was created from the four letters of Shem Havaya, which are the four elements; removing one element dissolves a thing, so the four ways of removing chametz each use one element. Fire is the root of all four, corresponding to Yehuda, the leading tribe, whose degel was under Gavriel, and Rabbi Yehuda is a gilgul of Yehuda.
-
27:24 Burning at the root and the simanim answered
The Mashgiach concludes that Rabbi Yehuda, standing for fire, wants chametz uprooted from its very root, and from the root one can sweeten judgment. Haggadah means drawing down, like a gid, and the more makos found the greater the salvation; Rabbi Yehuda's simanim, in line with his view, go to the root to draw healing for Israel, as on Rosh Hashanah with its many references to fire.
-
32:20 The mikveh of fire and the mikveh of water listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that whatever exists below exists above, and the heavenly mikveh is the Nehar Dinur, a river of fire. Since people cannot immerse in fire, Hashem joined fire with water; heaven itself is fire and water, and the mikveh's forty se'ah reflect Shem Havaya, four letters and ten in its filled spelling, so Mikveh Yisrael is Hashem.
-
40:20 The mikveh as heaven's embassy listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains why the mikveh removes evil: it is heaven, where evil does not dwell. Like a spy fleeing into a foreign embassy where he cannot be touched, a Jew pursued by impurity or illness flees into Hashem's embassy, which is why tzaddikim went to the mikveh with tefillah; there breathing stops and he emerges a new person.
-
45:42 Sukkah, teivah and the holy names listed in the guide
The Mashgiach extends the idea to the sukkah, built by halachos that are holy names, into which Yaakov fled from Esav, and to Noach's teivah, which had to follow its halachos so that the decree of the flood did not apply to those inside. He brings the Yalkut Reuveni that the teivah's dimensions are Shem Havaya, and the Targum that Haman's fifty-amah beam came from the teivah.
-
54:37 Kavanas haMikveh: rebirth through bitul listed in the guide
The Mashgiach says the halachos of mikveh are holy names, and reads from the Kavanas haMikveh in the Ba'al HaTanya's siddur: at creation the earth lay beneath the water, and man, who is from the earth, returns through tevilah to his root and is created anew, provided he immerses with bitul to Hashem. He adds the Reishis Chochmah that the mikveh is the World to Come, like Noach's teivah.
-
1:00:25 Why immerse when it is not required
The Mashgiach asks why one should immerse when Ezra's enactment of tevilah was annulled, and answers from Mesilas Yesharim's chapter on chassidus: a son who loves his father does what he hints at, not only what he commands. Hashem loves purity, as seen in the Beis HaMikdash, korbanos, the regel and Matan Torah, for which Moshe added a day so that Israel would be pure.
-
1:08:05 Benayahu on the snowy day
The Mashgiach brings the Gemara that Benayahu ben Yehoyada broke the ice to immerse on a snowy day so he could learn, centuries before Ezra's enactment, showing self-sacrifice for purity beyond obligation. He cites Rav Hai Gaon and Rabbeinu Chananel and the saying of Rabbi Aharon HaGadol that mikveh is not a mitzvah, yet nothing brings to mitzvos like it.
-
1:11:15 Stories of tzaddikim and the mikveh Story
The Mashgiach tells of a Slonimer chassid who sensed that meat came from a shochet who had not gone to the mikveh, of a Lechovitcher chassid who immersed in a Moscow river before onlookers and was greeted by Rabbi Mordechai of Lechovitch, of Rabbi Yitzchak Elchanan going to the mikveh over a difficult question, and of Rabbi Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld's answer to Rabbi Isser Zalman Meltzer.
-
1:15:40 Hashem as the mikveh, and closing wishes
The Mashgiach brings the Arizal and the Shelah on tevilah for a pure heart, notes that Hashem cleansed the world with the waters of the flood, and that Hashem Himself is the mikveh and the source of living water, the opposite of kareis. He closes by wishing that the warmth of Sukkos continue through the mikveh, and that learning and davening be done in purity.
The shiur, written up
The raven and the dove: taker and giver
The Mashgiach notes that the raven was sent to go back and forth until the water dried up, while the dove was sent to see whether the water had lessened. He explains that generous people love to give and hate to take, while a taker hates to give, and the raven, which Chazal call cruel even to its own young, is such a taker. a,b
The dove, likened to Knesses Yisrael, would rather eat bitter food of its own than take from Noach. Once the water lessened it would not come back, so that is all Noach could learn from it; the raven would keep returning while food was still bitter, so only its staying away showed the land was dry.
Rabbi Yehuda's simanim
Saying the makos at the Seder, the Mashgiach explains, draws plagues on the enemies of Israel and, as the Zohar says, healing for Israel. He asks what Rabbi Yehuda's simanim come to add. He then brings the Mishnah: chametz may be crumbled to the wind or cast into the sea, the Gemara speaks of nullifying it in the heart, but Rabbi Yehuda holds it is removed only by burning. e,d,f,g
Sweetening judgment at its root
To explain, the Mashgiach brings the principle of the seforim, which the Ba'al HaTanya also discusses, that judgment is sweetened at its root. Before the flood Hashem decided to wipe out man because the inclination of man's heart is evil; after Noach's korban He promised never again to destroy the world, for the very same reason. h,i
How can one reason demand both? The Mashgiach explains that Noach's korban brought a nachas ruach that reached the root of creation, Hashem's first will to create the world. At the root din turns into chesed, so the reason that demanded a flood now demands that there be none, just as a deeper look into a sugya can turn the same sevara from chayav to zakai.
A unanimous Sanhedrin
By this the Mashgiach suggests a reason for the Gemara in Sanhedrin that when the whole court convicts, the accused goes free. Each sage receives Torah through the channel of his own soul, like water that looks green in green glass and red in red glass. Unanimity, nearly impossible, shows they reached the colorless root of Torah, where chayav can be turned to zakai. j
Four elements and Yehuda as fire
The world, the Mashgiach explains, was created with the four letters of Shem Havaya, which are the four elements, fire, air, water and earth, and everything is a mix of all four. When one leaves, the whole falls apart, as Sarah died in Kiryas Arba, the 'city of four'. So each way of removing chametz nullifies one element: burning by fire, the wind by air, the sea by water, and making it like dust by earth. m
Fire is the root and head of the elements, the most spiritual, and matches the yud of the Name. Rabbeinu Bachya writes that the four degalim match four angels, and Gavriel, who is fire, was over the degel of Yehuda, whom the passuk calls mightiest of his brothers. The Mashgiach brings from the Chiddushei HaRim in Sefer HaZechus that Rabbi Yehuda is a gilgul of Yehuda, which explains the Gemara in Shabbos that he speaks first everywhere. n,o,p,q
Burning from the root
Returning to the Mishnah, the Mashgiach explains that Rabbi Yehuda, who stands for fire, the root, holds that chametz is removed only by burning: weakening the yetzer hara is not enough, one must dig deep and pull it out with its root. And from the root one can also sweeten judgment. f
Haggadah means drawing down, like a gid, the channel that carries blood to every limb. That is why the Haggadah seeks ever more makos, fifty and then two hundred fifty at the sea, each a greater salvation. Rabbi Yehuda's simanim follow his view: instead of plain makos he goes to the root to bring healing to Israel. r,d
The mikveh of fire and the mikveh of water
Everything below has its counterpart above, the Mashgiach says, and so there is a mikveh in heaven. Chazal speak of the Nehar Dinur, a river of fire from the sweat of the chayos as they sing, where souls and angels immerse. Vessels too are kashered with fire, as the Torah says that what comes into fire must pass through fire. s,t
Why then is our mikveh water? People could not survive immersing in fire, so Hashem joined fire with water as a kindness, and the element of fire within the water is what purifies. Rashi brings that shamayim is esh and mayim, so the mikveh is a piece of heaven. u
Shem Havaya has four letters, and ten in its full spelling, like the reshus hayachid of Shabbos, four wide and ten high; four times ten gives the forty se'ah of a mikveh. Immersing is entering the Name and its fire, for Hashem is a consuming fire, and so Mikveh Yisrael is Hashem, as Rabbi Akiva says, before your Father in heaven you are purified. v,w,x
Heaven's embassy
A mikveh removes evil because it is heaven, and in heaven there is no evil; impurity and illness belong only to this world. The passuk asks who will go up to heaven for us: one who goes into the mikveh, the Mashgiach says, goes into heaven. aa
He compares it to a spy with stolen secrets who flees into a foreign embassy in Manhattan, where by international law no one may touch him. A Jew pursued by impurity that wants to take away his taste for a blatt Gemara or davening flees into Hashem's embassy, the mikveh. So the Ba'al Shem Tov and tzaddikim, when tefillah did not help, immersed and davened with kavanah there.
Sukkah, teivah and holy names
Other mitzvos work the same way. A sukkah must follow its halachos, and halachos are holy names; one sitting in it is in the embassy, set apart from the world, and draws protection for the whole year. Yaakov sent Esav gifts, which the Mashgiach links to Yom Kippur, and then fled into Sukkos, and so Sukkos follows Yom Kippur. ad,ae
So with Noach: Hashem decreed destruction on all that lives, but told Noach to build a teivah by its halachos of length, width and height. Inside it Noach was not in this world but in heaven, and the decree did not apply. The Yalkut Reuveni brings that the teivah's dimensions are Shem Havaya, the Name that is a tower of strength, and the Mashgiach works out how yud times hei gives the fifty-amah width. af,ag,ah
Kavanas haMikveh: reborn through bitul
The halachos of mikveh, studied down to the Igros Moshe, are holy names, so one who immerses is immersed in Hashem Himself, which annuls harsh decrees. The Mashgiach reads from the Kavanas haMikveh in the Ba'al HaTanya's siddur: at creation the earth lay under water until the waters were gathered, and man, who is from the earth, returns in the mikveh to his root and is created anew. al,am
Why immerse when not required
Why immerse at all? The Gemara in Berachos says Ezra enacted that a ba'al keri immerse before davening and learning, and later the enactment was annulled. The Mashgiach answers from Mesilas Yesharim on chassidus: everyone knows the obligations, but one who loves Hashem is like a son who understands from a hint what his father wants, and does it. ao,ap
And Hashem loves purity: to enter the Beis HaMikdash, eat kodashim or terumah, come for the regel or receive the Torah, one had to be pure. Moshe added a day before Matan Torah so that Israel would be pure, though the world hung on the Torah being given on the sixth, which the Mashgiach brings from a vort he heard. Each day's learning should be like Sinai, in purity. aq
Benayahu on the snowy day
The passuk says Benayahu ben Yehoyada struck the lion on a snowy day, and the Gemara in Berachos explains that he broke the ice and immersed so he could learn, centuries before Ezra. The Mashgiach mentions Rav Hai Gaon and Rabbeinu Chananel on the annulment, and Rabbi Aharon HaGadol's saying that mikveh is not a mitzvah, yet nothing brings to mitzvos like it, because one who is pure longs for Hashem. ar,as
Stories of the mikveh
A Slonimer chassid in a misnagdish town would not eat kosher meat, sensing a bad smell from a shochet who had not immersed; whatever is done in purity, the Mashgiach says, is another reality. A Lechovitcher chassid in Moscow, with no mikveh, immersed in a river before people sitting on its banks, and Rabbi Mordechai of Lechovitch came out to thank him for removing a kitrug.
Rabbi Yitzchak Elchanan would go to the mikveh over a hard question. Rabbi Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld told Rabbi Isser Zalman Meltzer that if a mikveh makes a gentile into a Jew, it surely makes a Jew a better Jew, and Rabbi Isser Zalman began to go.
Hashem is the mikveh
The Arizal finds tevilah hinted in the request for a pure heart, and the Shelah says one who wants an awakening should immerse, like the Kohen Gadol on Yom Kippur. Hashem cleansed the world with the flood's waters, and He Himself is the mikveh, the source of living water, the opposite of kareis. The Mashgiach closes wishing that the warmth of Sukkos continue through the mikveh, with learning and davening in purity. at,au,av
Sources
Torah
- a Bereishis 8:7 text index In the write-up: 0:19
- b Bereishis 8:8 text index In the write-up: 0:19
- h Bereishis 6:5-7 text index In the write-up: 9:04
- i Bereishis 8:21 text index In the write-up: 9:04
- m Bereishis 23:2 text index In the write-up: 19:29
- t Bamidbar 31:23 text index In the write-up: 32:51
- v Devarim 4:24 text index In the write-up: 37:28
- z Bereishis 1:6 text index In the write-up: 44:22
- aa Devarim 30:12 text index In the write-up: 40:20
- ab Bereishis 7:22 text index In the write-up: 44:22
- ad Bereishis 32:4 text index In the write-up: 45:50
- ae Bereishis 33:17 text index In the write-up: 45:50
- af Bereishis 6:15 text index In the write-up: 48:03
- ak Shemos 17:16 text index In the write-up: 52:27
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Targum
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
- c apparently Eruvin 18b 2:42 index
- g apparently Pesachim 4b index In the write-up: 5:32
- j Sanhedrin 17a text index In the write-up: 16:15
- k apparently Rosh Hashanah 10b index In the write-up: 18:05
- q apparently Shabbos 33b index In the write-up: 23:12
- s apparently Chagigah 13b index In the write-up: 32:51
- ao Berachos 22a text index In the write-up: 1:00:34
- aq apparently Shabbos 87a index In the write-up: 1:05:40
- as apparently Berachos 18b index In the write-up: 1:08:07
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
- p Sefer HaZechus (place not identified) index In the write-up: 23:12
- ag apparently Yalkut Reuveni, Parshas Noach index In the write-up: 48:03
- an Reishis Chochmah (place not identified) index In the write-up: 58:24
- ap apparently Mesilas Yesharim ch. 18 index In the write-up: 1:00:34
- au Shelah (place not identified) index In the write-up: 1:15:40
Tefillah and Piyut
Other
Key points
- 1:11 The raven, a taker, would keep coming back to Noach while food was still bitter, while the dove, a giver, would not return once it could find any livelihood at all.
- 12:40 Judgment is sweetened at its root: Noach's korban reached the root of creation, where the same reason that demanded the flood demanded that there be no more flood.
- 22:18 The four ways of removing chametz correspond to the four elements, which come from the four letters of Shem Havaya; fire is the root of them all, and Rabbi Yehuda, linked to Yehuda and to fire, holds that only burning removes chametz.
- 35:16 The mikveh is a piece of heaven on earth: heaven is fire and water, and the mikveh's water holds the element of fire, so whoever enters it is in a place where evil does not exist.
- 42:40 Like an embassy where a country's police may not enter, the mikveh, the sukkah and Noach's teivah are places of heaven where earthly decrees do not apply.
- 1:00:34 Though Ezra's enactment requiring tevilah was annulled, one who loves Hashem does more than the obligation, as Mesilas Yesharim describes the trait of chassidus.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 0:48 Why does the Torah word the raven's mission and the dove's mission differently?
Answer: 1:11 Because the raven is a taker who would return until the land was dry, while the dove is a giver who would stop returning once it found any livelihood, so each could signal only one thing.
-
Question: 11:32 How can the same reason, the evil inclination of man, require both the flood and the promise of no more flood?
Answer: 12:04 Noach's korban brought a nachas ruach that reached the root of creation, and at the root the same reason for judgment turns into a reason for mercy.
-
Question: 15:15 Why does a unanimous verdict of guilt in the Sanhedrin lead to acquittal?
Answer: 16:35 Unanimity shows the sages reached the root of Torah before it divides into channels, and there a reason to convict can be turned into acquittal.
-
Question: 6:31 Why does Rabbi Yehuda give simanim for the makos in the Haggadah?
Answer: 30:55 Consistent with his view that chametz is removed only by burning, from the root, he wants to reach the root with the makos too, where judgment is sweetened and healing drawn down for Israel.
-
Question: 34:17 If the heavenly mikveh is fire, why is our mikveh water?
Answer: 34:35 People could not survive immersing in fire, so Hashem joined fire with water as a kindness; the mikveh's water holds the element of fire, and that is what purifies.
-
Question: 1:01:10 Why go to the mikveh if Ezra's enactment was annulled and one is not obligated?
Answer: 1:01:46 One who loves Hashem does not stop at the obligation; like a loving son who acts on his father's hint, he does what gives Hashem nachas ruach, and Hashem loves purity.
Stories
-
1:11:24 The Slonimer chassid who would not eat the meat
A Slonimer chassid came to a misnagdish town and was given meat, but he did not eat it. When asked why, he said he had learned from his Rebbe to sense things: the meat was kosher, but it gave off a bad smell from a shochet who had slaughtered while he needed the mikveh and had not immersed.
In the story: Rabbi Mordechai of Lechovitch, the Slonimer Rebbe
-
1:12:42 The Lechovitcher chassid in Moscow
A disciple of Rabbi Mordechai of Lechovitch, a big businessman, traveled to Moscow, where under the Czar Jews were not allowed to live, with a license for a few days. With no mikveh there, he went to a small river where people sat on benches on both sides, and with self-sacrifice he undressed and immersed. When he returned, Rabbi Mordechai went out to greet him and thanked him, saying he had removed a kitrug that his chassidim were not moser nefesh for mikveh.
In the story: Rabbi Mordechai of Lechovitch
-
1:14:18 Rabbi Yitzchak Elchanan and a difficult question
The Mashgiach heard through a chain of listeners, going back to the secretary of Rabbi Yitzchak Elchanan, that when Rabbi Yitzchak Elchanan had a difficulty in psak or in Gemara that he could not resolve, he would go to the mikveh, hoping that with a little more purity he would understand it.
In the story: Rabbi Yitzchak Elchanan Spektor
-
1:14:50 Rabbi Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld's answer
Rabbi Isser Zalman Meltzer, the father-in-law of Rabbi Aharon Kotler, asked Rabbi Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld, who went to the mikveh very often, sometimes even in the middle of the day, why a great talmid chacham needs it. He answered that a convert becomes a Jew through the mikveh; if it can make a Jew out of a gentile, it can surely make a better Jew out of a Jew. When Rabbi Isser Zalman heard this he began going to the mikveh.
In the story: Rabbi Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld, Rabbi Isser Zalman Meltzer, Rav Aharon Kotler
Insights
- 3:27 The difference in the Torah's wording of the two missions follows the birds' natures: the raven, a taker, would come back to Noach until the land was fully dry, so its return could only signal dryness; the dove, a giver, would stop returning as soon as it found any food, even bitter, so its mission could only test whether the water had lessened.
- 11:41 The same verse, 'for the inclination of man's heart is evil', appears as the reason for the flood and for never bringing another flood, because Noach's korban reached the root where a reason for judgment becomes a reason for mercy, just as a deeper look in a sugya can turn the same sevara from chayav to patur.
- 16:12 A unanimous conviction acquits because the sages, who usually see Torah colored by their own soul's channel, all agreeing shows they reached the colorless root of Torah, where even a reason to convict can be turned to acquittal.
- 27:38 Rabbi Yehuda's ruling that chametz is removed only by burning reflects his root as a gilgul of Yehuda, the yud of Shem Havaya and the element of fire: he wants evil uprooted from its root, and that is why he gives simanim for the makos, to reach the root and draw down healing for Israel.
- 37:11 The mikveh's forty se'ah are Shem Havaya: four letters in plain spelling and ten in full spelling, like the reshus hayachid of Shabbos that is four wide and ten high, so whoever immerses enters the Name itself.
- 44:12 Breathing stops underwater, which the Mashgiach connects to the verse about all that has the breath of life perishing in the flood: in the mikveh a person's earthly life is suspended and he comes out like one revived, a new person.
- 46:00 Noach's teivah, the sukkah and the mikveh are all built from halachos, and halachos are holy names; that is why the teivah's dimensions follow Shem Havaya, and why Haman's beam taken from the teivah fulfilled 'Hashem's war with Amalek'.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 40:36 The Mashgiach says that when a Jew wants to draw good upon himself, the advice in the seforim is to go into a mikveh.
- 58:24 The Mashgiach says entering the water is not enough; one must have in mind bitul, giving oneself over entirely to Hashem.
- 1:10:32 The Mashgiach says one who truly wants to do Hashem's will would not daven or learn Gemara after becoming impure without first going to immerse.
- 1:18:03 The Mashgiach says the closeness of Sukkos should be continued through the year by going to the mikveh, so that learning and davening are done in purity.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Benayahu ben Yehoyada, Esav, Ezra HaSofer, Haman, Moshe Rabbeinu, Noach, Rabbeinu Bachya, Rabbeinu Chananel, Rabbi Aharon of Karlin (Rabbi Aharon HaGadol), Rabbi Isser Zalman Meltzer, Rabbi Mordechai of Lechovitch, Rabbi Yehuda (bar Ilai), Rabbi Yitzchak Elchanan Spektor, Rabbi Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld, Rashi, Rav Aharon Kotler, Rav Hai Gaon, Sarah Imeinu, the angel Gavriel, the Arizal, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Baal Shem Tov, the Chiddushei HaRim, the Shelah HaKadosh, Yaakov Avinu, Yehudah (son of Yaakov)
Terms ארבע יסודות, ביעור חמץ, המתקת הדינים, טבילה, מקוה, נהר דינור, נחת רוח, עלמא דאתגליא, עלמא דאתכסיא, קטרוג, רבונו של עולם, רשות היחיד, שם הוי"ה, תיבה