התיבה היתה צריך להיות עולם התיקון אלא שחם קלקול אותה
Catalog entry: פרשת השבוע נח no. 6 Pocket Guide p. 3 תשמ"ז (1986–87) Yiddish 1 hr 4 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains that the ark was meant to be the seed of a renewed world of tikkun, free of decay and predation, and that Cham's sin inside it spoiled the plan, so Noach was remembered only for the sake of Avraham Avinu.
The Mashgiach opens with the Midrash that Noach found favor for the sake of his offspring, and with the Chasam Sofer's reading that the 'tzaddik tamim' of the opening verse is Avraham Avinu. He asks why the parsha first says 'tzaddik tamim in his generations' and later only 'tzaddik in this generation', and why Hashem's remembering Noach, the first verse of Zichronos, counts as great love. He then raises the questions about the ark: its size, feeding every creature, the lion that struck Noach, food that did not spoil. He explains that the bris prevented decay, which entered the world through the sin of the Tree of Knowledge. Hashem's plan was to restart the world of tikkun from Noach's righteous share of creation, where even the lion ate straw. Cham's sin ruined this; the lion again needed meat. Noach was saved only for Avraham. He closes that Cheshvan, after Tishrei, can still be turned around through teshuvah.
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Noach saved for the sake of Avraham
The Mashgiach brings the Midrash that Noach found favor because of his offspring, and the Chasam Sofer, based on the Ibn Ezra's reckoning that Avraham was fifty-eight when Noach died, that the 'tzaddik tamim' of the opening verse is Avraham. He adds the Zera Kodesh's reading of the verse as an acronym for the Jewish people.
-
5:29 Two descriptions of Noach; Zichronos
The Mashgiach asks why the parsha opens with 'tzaddik tamim in his generations' but later says only 'tzaddik in this generation'. He then turns to the Zichronos of Rosh Hashanah, whose first remembrance is Hashem's remembering Noach with love, and asks what great love there was in remembering Noach when saving him in the ark was the plan all along.
-
12:57 The lion's blow and the ark's capacity
The Mashgiach brings Rashi that the word 'ach' in 'only Noach remained' means a lion struck Noach for bringing its food late. He then asks how the ark, three hundred amos long with three floors, could hold every species and how eight people could feed them all on schedule.
-
16:25 Miracles in the ark; the Ibn Ezra on meat
The Mashgiach brings Rabbeinu Bachya that the ark was run by miracles, and asks what happened to the miracles on the day the lion's food was late. He cites the Ibn Ezra, who answers the question of meat for carnivores by saying they ate plants, and contrasts it with Chazal that Noach prepared each creature's own food.
-
20:21 The bris that prevents decay
The Mashgiach brings Rashi that the covenant with Noach was so the food in the ark would not spoil, and explains that decay entered creation through the sin of the Tree of Knowledge, a breach of bris. Where there is bris nothing spoils: Yosef's grain and the body of Rabbi Elazar the son of Rabbi Shimon.
-
24:12 Rebbe Elimelech's grave and a tzaddik's ink Story
The Mashgiach tells of a Jew he knew who was forced by the Nazis to open Rebbe Elimelech's grave in Lizhensk and saw him whole, and of a letter he owns whose signature stayed black. He concludes that Noach, the shomer habris, kept the ark's food from spoiling, so the Ibn Ezra's question never begins.
-
28:08 The world of tikkun and its return
The Mashgiach describes the world as Hashem created it, with people and animals that live forever and sing with the angels, and how Adam's sin brought decay. He brings Yeshayahu's prophecy that the lion will eat straw and the Ramban that in the days of Moshiach there will be no wild beasts, as at creation.
-
33:36 The ark as a new world from Noach's portion listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that Hashem wanted to wipe out the spoiled world and start anew from Noach. Every person owns a share of creation that his sins spoil; Noach's animals and his land, Eretz Yisrael, had not sinned, which is why the flood did not reach Eretz Yisrael, and the ark was a gathering of tzaddikim from which the world of tikkun would restart.
-
39:31 The lion ate straw until Cham sinned listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that the lion in the ark, part of Noach's world of tikkun, ate straw, so Noach brought no meat, which answers the Ibn Ezra's question differently. Then Cham sinned in the ark, together with the raven and the dog, repeating Adam's breach of bris, and the plan of a new world was nullified.
-
42:51 Why the lion now needed meat listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that a predator needs meat as concentrated food, while a tzaddik needs little, as Rashi says and as with Rabbi Nachum of Chernobyl. Once the ark's creatures were spoiled the lion needed meat, Noach had none, the straw came too late and the lion struck him; Hashem makes no miracles for sinful creatures, and Cham's sin reached back to Noach himself.
-
48:04 Remembered with love for Avraham's sake listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains 'only Noach remained' as a diminishing: the plan was undone, and by strict judgment the ark too should have been erased. Hashem remembered Noach with love because Avraham would come from him. This answers the opening question: 'tzaddik in this generation' was Hashem's word before the flood, while the parsha's opening, written by Moshe, points to Avraham, the tzaddik tamim.
-
52:19 Tishrei's tikkun and Cheshvan's flood
The Mashgiach explains that each year retells the story: Rosh Hashanah is the creation of a Jew's personal world of tikkun, and after the holy days comes a weekday world that floods it. Cheshvan, a dark month with no Yom Tov, is when parshas Noach is read, telling of Hashem's covenant and of remembering Noach for the sake of Avraham.
-
57:14 Turning the flood around through teshuvah
The Mashgiach says a Jew must believe he will yet become the Jew for whom the world was created, and that decrees can still be annulled until Chanukah, as the flood came down with mercy in Cheshvan. He shows that the very cause of the flood, the evil inclination, became the reason for the promise of no more flood, and closes that each person can at least repair his own world.
The shiur, written up
Noach saved for the sake of Avraham
The Mashgiach opens with the Midrash on 'and Noach found favor': Noach found favor because of his offspring, the Jewish people who would come from him generations later. a,b
The Chasam Sofer, using the Ibn Ezra and the reckoning of the Seder HaDoros, shows that Avraham was fifty-eight when Noach died, so the 'tzaddik tamim' of the parsha's opening verse is Avraham, Noach's true offspring. The Zera Kodesh likewise reads the verse as an acronym for the Jewish people. c,d,e,g,f
Two descriptions of Noach; Zichronos
The parsha first calls Noach 'a tzaddik tamim in his generations', but later Hashem calls him only 'a tzaddik in this generation'. Chazal explain the missing 'tamim': only part of a person's praise is said in his presence. The Mashgiach asks why the first verse says 'his generations', many generations, and the later one only 'this generation'. g,h,i
He then turns to the Zichronos of Rosh Hashanah, which the Gemara explains are said so that our remembrance rises before Hashem. Their first remembrance is that Hashem remembered Noach with love, from the verse 'and G-d remembered Noach'. The Mashgiach asks what love this was, since saving Noach in the ark was the plan from the start. j,k,l
The lion's blow and the ark's capacity
Miracles in the ark; the Ibn Ezra on meat
Rabbeinu Bachya answers that the ark ran by miracles; then why, the Mashgiach asks, was the lion's food late? The Ibn Ezra dismisses the question of meat for carnivores: lacking meat, they eat plants. Chazal say instead that Noach prepared each creature its own food, so the lion had meat. o,p,r
The bris that prevents decay
Rashi says Hashem's covenant with Noach kept the ark's food from spoiling. The Mashgiach explains that decay came from the sin of the Tree of Knowledge, when Adam broke the bris; where bris is kept, nothing spoils. So, as Rashi brings, Yosef's stored grain did not rot, and the Gemara tells that the body of Rabbi Elazar the son of Rabbi Shimon stayed fresh for years. s,u,v
Rebbe Elimelech's grave and a tzaddik's ink
The Mashgiach tells of a Jew he knew, one of ten whom the Nazis forced to open Rebbe Elimelech's grave in Lizhensk; the Rebbe was found whole, and the Nazis fled. He also owns a letter whose ink faded to brown while the tzaddik's signature stayed black. So too Noach, whom the Zohar praises as a guardian of the bris, kept the ark's food fresh. w
The world of tikkun and its return
Hashem first created a world of tikkun, the Mashgiach explains, where people and animals live forever and sing His praise with the angels. Adam's sin brought decay, and so it stays until that world returns.
The ark as a new world from Noach's portion
Corruption grew until the flood, when even the animals sinned because the air itself was spoiled. Hashem wanted to erase the spoiled world and begin again from one tzaddik, Noach.
Each person, the Mashgiach says, owns a share of creation that his sins spoil; the Midrash says the earth itself sinned. Noach's animals and his land, Eretz Yisrael, did not sin, so, the Gemara says, the flood did not fall there. The ark was a gathering of tzaddikim from which the world of tikkun would restart. ab,ac
The lion ate straw until Cham sinned
Why the lion now needed meat
Remembered with love for Avraham's sake
Tishrei's tikkun and Cheshvan's flood
Every year, the Mashgiach explains, the story repeats. Rosh Hashanah creates a Jew's private world of tikkun, but after the holy days a weekday flood comes, and he must flee into the 'teivah', which the Ba'al Shem Tov explains as the words of Torah and tefillah.
Turning the flood around through teshuvah
The Mashgiach says a Jew must believe he will yet become the Jew for whom the world was created. Decrees can still be annulled until Chanukah; Rashi says the flood began with mercy so they might still repent. aj
Sources
Torah
- b Bereishis 6:8 text index In the write-up: 0:10
- g Bereishis 6:9 text index In the write-up: 1:53, 5:32, 50:24
- h Bereishis 7:1 text index In the write-up: 5:32, 50:24
- l Bereishis 8:1 text index In the write-up: 7:36
- m Bereishis 7:23 text index In the write-up: 13:14, 48:08
- q Bereishis 6:21 18:29 text index
- z Bereishis 6:7 34:40 text index
- ai Bereishis 9:13 56:51 text index
- am Bereishis 6:5 text index In the write-up: 1:02:10
- an Bereishis 8:21 text index In the write-up: 1:02:10
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
- i apparently Eruvin 18b index In the write-up: 5:32
- j apparently Rosh Hashanah 16a index In the write-up: 7:36
- r apparently Sanhedrin 108b index In the write-up: 16:27
- v apparently Bava Metzia 84b index In the write-up: 20:33
- ac apparently Zevachim 113a index In the write-up: 35:49
- ad apparently Sanhedrin 108b index In the write-up: 39:42
Midrash
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
- d Ibn Ezra (place not identified) index In the write-up: 1:53
- n Rashi on Bereishis 7:23 text index In the write-up: 13:14
- o Rabbeinu Bachya (place not identified) index In the write-up: 16:27
- p apparently Ibn Ezra on Bereishis 6:21 index In the write-up: 16:27, 39:42
- s Rashi on Bereishis 6:18 text index In the write-up: 20:33
- u Rashi (place not identified) index In the write-up: 20:33
- y apparently Ramban on Vayikra 26:6 index In the write-up: 31:10
- ae Rashi on Vayikra 26:5 text index In the write-up: 43:26
- af Rashi on Bereishis 9:20 text index In the write-up: 45:43
- aj Rashi on Bereishis 7:12 text index In the write-up: 57:14
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 1:04 Noach was saved from the flood for the sake of his offspring, above all Avraham Avinu and the Jewish people.
- 28:11 Hashem created a world of tikkun with no decay, death or predation; the sin of the Tree of Knowledge brought decay, and in the days of Moshiach the original world will return.
- 35:17 The ark was meant to be a gathering of righteous creatures, Noach's own unspoiled portion of creation, from which Hashem would rebuild the world of tikkun.
- 42:13 Cham's sin in the ark nullified the plan: the creatures became mortal and spoiled again, and the lion became a predator that needed meat.
- 49:08 After the sin, by strict judgment the ark too should have been wiped out; Hashem remembered Noach with love only because Avraham would come from him.
- 54:04 Cheshvan, after the holy days of Tishrei, is like a flood for a Jew's personal world of tikkun, yet it can still be turned around through teshuvah.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 6:17 Why does the parsha open with 'tzaddik tamim in his generations' but later say only 'tzaddik in this generation'?
Answer: 50:24 The later verse is Hashem's word to Noach before the flood, when a new world was to begin from him in that generation; the opening, written by Moshe after the plan failed, points to Avraham, the tzaddik tamim, for whose sake Noach was saved.
-
Question: 9:21 What great love was there in Hashem's remembering Noach, if saving him in the ark was the plan from the start?
Answer: 49:08 After Cham's sin the plan was void and by strict judgment the ark too should have been erased; Hashem remembered Noach with love because Avraham would come from him.
-
Question: 14:53 How could the ark hold every species, and how could eight people feed them all on time?
Answer: 16:27 Following Rabbeinu Bachya, the whole running of the ark was by miracles, with Hashem giving Noach the strength.
-
Question: 16:58 If the ark ran by miracles, why was the lion's food late, so that it struck Noach?
Answer: 45:53 After Cham's sin the lion became a predator that suddenly needed much meat; Noach had none, the straw came too late, and miracles are not made for creatures that have sinned.
-
Question: 20:29 How could the food in the ark, kept for about a year, not spoil?
Answer: 21:08 Through the covenant Hashem made with Noach, as Rashi explains; a bris prevents decay, which came from the sin of the Tree of Knowledge.
-
Question: 43:06 Why must a lion eat meat while a cow does not?
Answer: 43:19 Meat is concentrated food with far more life-force than straw; an ox eats grass for two weeks to grow the two pounds of meat a lion eats in one meal, and a predator cannot digest that much grass.
Stories
-
24:12 Rebbe Elimelech's grave in Lizhensk
The Mashgiach tells of a Jew he knew who saw Rebbe Elimelech, though the Rebbe passed away nearly two hundred years earlier. When the Nazis entered Lizhensk they wanted to disgrace Jews and forced ten Jews to dig open Rebbe Elimelech's grave. One of them later lived in Skver, a respected talmid chacham among the people of the previous Skverer Rebbe. Some hundred and fifty years after his burial the Rebbe was found whole; when the Nazis saw it they ran away, and the grave was closed again.
In the story: Rebbe Elimelech of Lizhensk (the Noam Elimelech), the Skverer Rebbe
-
25:52 A letter whose signature stayed black
The Mashgiach says he has at home a letter from about sixty or seventy years earlier, written by a gabbai and signed by a Stoliner Rebbe. Ordinary ink turns light brown with age, as seen in old sefarim, and so did the gabbai's writing. The signature, however, stayed black as if written the day before, because a tzaddik is not something that spoils.
In the story: Rabbi Yisrael of Stolin
Insights
- 21:27 The Mashgiach explains that decay entered the world through the sin of the Tree of Knowledge, a breach of bris, so wherever bris is kept nothing spoils: the ark's food, Yosef's grain, the bodies of tzaddikim.
- 35:29 According to the Mashgiach, every person owns a portion of creation that his sins spoil; Noach's animals and his land, Eretz Yisrael, had not sinned, which is why the flood did not fall there.
- 39:42 The Mashgiach holds that the lion in the ark ate straw as in the world of tikkun, so Noach brought no meat at all, and the Ibn Ezra's question about carnivores never arises.
- 45:53 The Mashgiach explains the lion's blow: after Cham's sin the lion suddenly needed meat, Noach had none, the straw came too late, and Hashem no longer made miracles for creatures that had sinned.
- 50:24 He reads the two descriptions of Noach as two moments: 'tzaddik in this generation' is Hashem's word before the flood, when the world was to restart from Noach, while 'tzaddik tamim in his generations', written later by Moshe, points to Avraham.
- 53:20 The Mashgiach sees Tishrei as a Jew's personal world of tikkun and Cheshvan as its flood, and following the Ba'al Shem Tov, the ark he must enter is the words of Torah and tefillah.
- 1:02:19 He points out that the same evil inclination that brought the flood became the reason for the promise of no more flood, showing a Jew's power to turn things around.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 57:14 The Mashgiach says every Jew must believe in himself that he will one day become a fine Jew, the Jew for whose sake the world was created.
- 57:38 He says a Jew should strengthen himself with parshas Noach in Cheshvan and know that he can still do teshuvah and annul decrees, even until Chanukah.
- 1:01:08 The Mashgiach says Cheshvan is the month to take upon oneself the yoke of Torah, mitzvos and tefillah, knowing that everything can be turned around.
- 1:03:37 He says that even one who cannot repair the whole world can at least repair himself, since every person is a whole world.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Adam HaRishon, Avraham Avinu, Cham, Moshe Rabbeinu, Noach, Rabbeinu Bachya, Rabbi Elazar ben Rabbi Shimon, Rabbi Menachem Nachum of Chernobyl (the Me'or Einayim), Rashi, Rebbe Elimelech of Lizhensk (the Noam Elimelech), the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Baal Shem Tov, the Chasam Sofer, the Ibn Ezra, the Ramban, Yeshayahu HaNavi, Yosef HaTzaddik
Terms זכרונות, מבול, מדת הדין, עולם התיקון, עץ הדעת, קדושת הברית, רבונו של עולם, תיבה