"וישמע אברם כי נשבה אחיו" - נשבה ניצוץ משיח
Catalog entry: פרשת השבוע לך לך no. 8 Pocket Guide p. 4 תשנ"ט (1998–99) Yiddish 54 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains that after the failed worlds of Adam and Noach, the world's tikkun had to come through Avraham and the Jewish people no matter what, which is why the Torah gives Avraham no introduction and why the kings captured Lot, from whom Moshiach was to come.
The Mashgiach opens by calling Bereishis and Noach a world that did not succeed: Adam sinned, the generation of the flood corrupted even the animals and the earth, and the new start after the flood was spoiled by those who sinned in the ark. Since creation was handed to man, each person's share of it rises or falls with his deeds; Noach's share, and Eretz Yisrael, stayed pure. Lech Lecha begins the world of tikkun through Avraham and his descendants. The Mashgiach brings the Ramban's charge that Avraham sinned by going to Egypt, and the Zohar's defense through Sarah's merit. He then shows that the Torah hides the merits of Moshe's parents and of Avraham because the Jewish people and the final redemption must come regardless. The kings captured Lot because Moshiach was to descend from him. He closes with Esav, who bites with a kiss, and warns against today's mingling with the nations.
Topics: Avraham Avinu · The Hidden Roots of Moshiach · The Exiles and Their Kingdoms · Netzach Yisroel
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 The disappointing worlds of Adam and Noach
The Mashgiach calls Bereishis and Noach a world that was spoiled: Adam ate from the tree, later generations sinned, and the flood came. He brings Noach's mention in the Rosh Hashanah zichronos and explains that Noach and the animals that kept their own species were saved to start a new world.
-
6:07 Creation is in man's hands
The Mashgiach explains that Hashem handed creation to man, so each person's share of the world depends on his deeds, as the fruit of Eretz Yisrael grew huge when the Jews kept the Torah. The flood generation sinned so much that even animals and the earth were corrupted, while Noach's share, including Eretz Yisrael, stayed pure.
-
12:17 The plan after the flood fails
The Mashgiach brings the Gemara that three sinned in the ark, Cham, the dog and the raven, so the plan for a world of tzaddikim was shattered. He asks how one can say Hashem was disappointed, citing 'vayinachem', and explains that the world's inhabitants did not keep the condition on which they were saved.
-
16:26 Avraham and the tikkun of the world
The Mashgiach says that with Avraham the world of tikkun begins: the Jewish people, through history and exile, slowly repair the world, as the nations learn from them and come to the foundations of the Torah, until Moshiach. He then begins the parsha's account of Avraham going down to Egypt and Pharaoh taking Sarah.
-
20:13 The Ramban's charge and the Zohar's defense
The Mashgiach brings the Ramban that Avraham committed a great sin, going to Egypt and not protecting Sarah, which caused the Egyptian exile. He explains that the Ramban had the Zohar, which defends Avraham: he knew that Sarah's purity in Pharaoh's house would protect all Jewish women in Egypt, as Yosef's restraint protected the men.
-
27:24 The Torah tells what will happen
The Mashgiach notes that Avraham's story opens with a sin, and compares the beginning of Shemos, where Moshe's parents are not named. He explains that Hashem runs the world with a plan, that the Torah, unlike other history books, tells what will happen, as Haazinu foretells the whole destiny of the Jewish people, and brings the Ramban's argument from the fulfillment of Haazinu that the end, Moshiach, must come too.
-
33:44 Why Avraham gets no introduction
The Mashgiach brings the Maharal that the Torah hides who Moshe's parents were because Moshe had to be born regardless of their merits. In the same way, the Torah introduces Noach as a tzaddik but begins Avraham's story only with 'lech lecha', leaving out his self-sacrifice in Ur Kasdim, because the Jewish people had to come, as Chazal read 'b'hibaram' as 'b'Avraham'.
-
41:05 Redemption comes regardless
The Mashgiach explains that the Ramban stresses Avraham's sin to show that Avraham had to come regardless, for the Jewish people must bring the world to its tikkun. He brings the Ramban at the end of Haazinu that the redemption will come at its time even without teshuvah, and applies it to every Jew, who must in the end reach his tikkun, since no one will be cast away.
-
45:30 Lot captured for the spark of Moshiach listed in the guide
The Mashgiach asks why the four kings went to war to capture Lot of all people, and answers that Moshiach was to come from Lot through Moav and Rus, which the kings, as sorcerers, knew; Avraham went to war to ensure Moshiach would come. He adds that the four kings are the four exiles, the last being Edom, the 'king of nations' of today's Western society.
-
50:04 Esav bites with a kiss
The Mashgiach brings the explanation that when Esav kissed Yaakov he really wanted to bite him, and when he could not bite, he 'bit' with a kiss. He applies this to the exile of Edom, which once persecuted the Jews and now draws them in through friendship and intermarriage, and warns the young men in yeshiva to strengthen themselves before they go out into the world.
The shiur, written up
The disappointing worlds of Adam and Noach
The Mashgiach opens by saying that tzaddikim called Bereishis and Noach a world that did not last. Hashem created Adam, who ate from the tree; the generations after him served idols and filled the earth with violence, and Hashem decided to wipe the world clean with the flood. He points to the Rosh Hashanah zichronos, which recall that Hashem remembered Noach in mercy and saved him: the plan was that the wicked would be destroyed and a new world would come out of the ark. a
Creation is in man's hands
Why were those animals saved? The Mashgiach explains that Hashem gave all of creation into man's hands; Adam named the creatures because he was in charge of them. Each person has his share of creation, and it prospers when he lives by the Torah. So the fruit of Eretz Yisrael grew so large in the generation of the desert that it took several men to carry one cluster, and when Jews sin the fruit does not grow.
The plan after the flood fails
But Hashem's plan for a society of tzaddikim was disappointed. The Gemara says three sinned in the ark, Cham, the dog and the raven, and each was punished. The Mashgiach asks how one can speak of Hashem being disappointed, as the passuk says 'vayinachem', when He knows the future; he leaves that for the commentators and explains that the world's inhabitants broke the condition on which they were saved. Bereishis and Noach were two attempts that did not succeed. d,e
Avraham and the tikkun of the world
Then Avraham comes, and from him the Jewish people, who over the course of history repair the world. Because the nations rub shoulders with the Jews in exile, they improve: most of the world now believes in the Ribono shel Olam on foundations taken from the Torah, in a lighter form the nations could carry. This will continue until Moshiach brings the world to what Hashem intended at creation. The parsha then tells how Avraham went down to Egypt and Pharaoh took Sarah.
The Ramban's charge and the Zohar's defense
The Ramban writes that Avraham committed a great sin: he should not have left Eretz Yisrael for Egypt because of the famine, and he failed to protect Sarah, letting her say she was his sister. Since judgment comes in the place of the sin, his descendants were later enslaved to Pharaoh in Egypt. f
The Mashgiach explains that the Zohar, though not yet published, was in the Ramban's hands, which is why his commentary is full of kabbalah; as the Ramban himself writes in his introduction, these need a teacher. The Ramban cites the Zohar's question without its answer. The Zohar defends Avraham: he knew that Sarah would keep herself holy in Pharaoh's house, and in her merit, as the Midrash says, no Jewish woman sinned in Egypt, just as in Yosef's merit no man did. The one exception, Shlomis bas Divri, is the Torah's proof. g,h,i,j
The Torah tells what will happen
Why does the Torah introduce Avraham and immediately record a sin? The Mashgiach compares the start of Shemos: 'a man from the house of Levi took a daughter of Levi', and Moshe is born, but only later, in Va'eira, do we learn they were Amram and Yocheved. l,m
Hashem runs the world with a plan and reveals it. Other history books tell what happened; the Torah tells what will happen. Haazinu lays out the Jewish people's whole destiny, ending with Hashem avenging His servants. The Ramban there argues that if a gentile astrologer had foretold all this and it came true, everyone would trust the rest; so too the comfort, the Beis HaMikdash and Moshiach must come. n,o
Why Avraham gets no introduction
The Maharal explains why Moshe's parents are not named at his birth. Had the Torah said a tzaddik married a tzaddeikes and Moshe was born, one might think that without such parents there would be no Moshe. But it was inevitable: the Jews had to leave Egypt, receive the Torah and enter Eretz Yisrael, whoever the parents were.
The same holds for Avraham. The Torah introduces Noach as a perfect tzaddik, but Avraham simply hears 'lech lecha' with great blessings, with no word of why. The Midrashim tell how in Ur Kasdim he searched for the truth, rejected the idols and let himself be thrown into the fire. The Torah omits it because the Jewish people had to come regardless; Chazal read 'b'hibaram' as 'b'Avraham', for the world was created for him. p,q,r,s
Redemption comes regardless
This is why the Ramban stresses that Avraham's story begins with a great sin: Avraham had to come regardless, because the Jewish people must bring the world to the perfection the whole creation awaits, as said in Aleinu. The Ramban at the end of Haazinu notes that the prophecy speaks of the redemption without teshuvah; teshuvah can hasten it, but at its set time Moshiach must come. t,u
Lot captured for the spark of Moshiach
The parsha tells of the four kings who made war and captured Lot, 'the son of Avraham's brother'. What did they want with Lot of all people? From Lot, through Moav and Rus the grandmother of Dovid HaMelech, Moshiach had to come. The kings, sorcerers, knew it, and Avraham went to war so Moshiach could come. x,y,z
Esav bites with a kiss
When Esav met Yaakov and kissed him, a sefer asks how one who wants to bite can kiss, and answers that unable to bite with a bite, Esav bit with a kiss. Edom bit the Jews through history to force Christianity on them; now it bites with a kiss, through friendship, interfaith gatherings and intermarriage, once impossible and now promoted. ac
The Mashgiach calls this a great danger. He tells the young men in yeshiva to fortify themselves now, so that when they go out into the world they hold fast to Yiddishkeit.
Sources
Torah
- e Bereishis 6:6 text index In the write-up: 12:22
- j apparently Vayikra 24:10-11 index In the write-up: 23:09
- l Shemos 2:1 text index In the write-up: 27:24
- m Shemos 6:20 text index In the write-up: 27:24
- n Devarim 32:43 text index In the write-up: 29:47
- p Bereishis 6:9 text index In the write-up: 36:33
- q Bereishis 12:1-2 text index In the write-up: 36:33
- s apparently Bereishis 2:4 index In the write-up: 36:33
- x Bereishis 14:1 text index In the write-up: 46:03
- y Bereishis 14:12 text index In the write-up: 46:03
- z apparently Bereishis 19:30-38 index In the write-up: 46:03
- ac apparently Bereishis 33:4 index In the write-up: 50:19
Nevi'im
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
- b apparently Rashi on Bereishis 6:12 index In the write-up: 3:58
- f apparently Ramban on Bereishis 12:10 index In the write-up: 20:17
- h apparently Ramban, Introduction to Bereishis index In the write-up: 23:09
- k apparently Rashi on Shemos 2:11 26:09 index
- o apparently Ramban on Devarim 32 (Haazinu) index In the write-up: 29:47
- u apparently Ramban on Devarim 32, end of Haazinu index In the write-up: 41:15
- ab apparently Ramban on Bereishis 14:1 index In the write-up: 48:44
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 16:06 Bereishis and Noach describe two attempts at a proper world that did not succeed; Lech Lecha begins the world of tikkun through Avraham.
- 6:40 Hashem gave creation into man's hands, so each person's share of the world flourishes or is spoiled according to his deeds; the sins of the flood generation spoiled even the animals and the earth.
- 33:44 The Torah does not say who Moshe's parents were at his birth, nor what merits made Avraham chosen, because the Jewish people had to come into being regardless of anyone's merits.
- 42:51 Following the Ramban at the end of Haazinu, the Mashgiach says the redemption will come at its set time whether or not the Jews do teshuvah, and likewise every Jew must in the end reach his tikkun.
- 46:42 The four kings captured Lot because they knew that Moshiach was to come from him, and Avraham went to war to make sure Moshiach would come.
- 51:10 The exile of Edom first bit the Jews openly and now bites them with a kiss, through friendship and mingling, which the Mashgiach calls a great danger.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 6:07 Why were particular animals saved in the ark and not others?
Answer: 11:39 Because the animals under Noach's share of creation did not sin; his righteousness kept them pure.
-
Question: 24:15 According to the Ramban Avraham sinned by going to Egypt and letting Sarah be taken; how does the Zohar defend him?
Answer: 24:29 Avraham knew the Jews would go down to Egypt and that Sarah's steadfast purity in Pharaoh's house would bring holiness to all Jewish women there, so none of them sinned.
-
Question: 29:27 Why does the Torah not say who Moshe's parents were when it tells of his birth?
Answer: 33:55 So that no one should think Moshe came only because of his parents' righteousness; the exodus and the giving of the Torah were inevitable, and the Torah mentions their righteousness only later.
-
Question: 36:43 Why does the Torah introduce Noach as a tzaddik but tell nothing of Avraham's merits before 'lech lecha'?
Answer: 39:56 Because the Jewish people had to come into being regardless; the world was created for Avraham, so his coming did not depend on his merits.
-
Question: 46:42 Why did the four kings capture Lot of all people?
Answer: 46:52 Moshiach was to come from Lot through Moav and Rus, and the kings, being sorcerers, knew it and wanted to prevent it.
-
Question: 50:34 If Esav wanted to bite Yaakov, why did he kiss him?
Answer: 50:44 When he saw he could not bite him with a bite, he tried to bite him with a kiss.
Stories
-
37:33 Avraham in the fire of Ur Kasdim
As the Midrashim relate, Avraham sought the truth and tried all the idols, seeing that none could be true. With his own understanding he grasped that there must be one Master of the world who created the sun and moon, summer and winter, day and night. He was ready to give his life for this, and was thrown into the fire after telling them that their idol was not G-d. A miracle happened and he was saved from the fire.
In the story: Avraham Avinu, Nimrod, Terach
-
47:07 Haran and the fire
Haran, Avraham's brother, waited to see what would happen to Avraham in Ur Kasdim. When he saw that Avraham was saved, he declared that he sided with Avraham, was thrown into the fire as well, and was burned. The Mashgiach says it was not entirely for the sake of Heaven, yet Haran did sanctify Hashem's name, and his son was Lot.
In the story: Haran, Avraham Avinu, Lot
Insights
- 11:39 The animals saved in the ark were those under Noach's share of creation: since each person's part of the world follows his deeds, Noach's righteousness kept his part pure, and Eretz Yisrael, also his share, was not flooded.
- 29:59 The Torah differs from other history books in that it tells not what happened but what is going to happen, so the fulfillment of its prophecies proves the coming of the end as well.
- 34:08 The Torah deliberately hides the merits behind the great turning points, Moshe's parents and Avraham's self-sacrifice in Ur Kasdim, so that no one should think the Jewish people came about by chance merit; it had to come from somewhere regardless.
- 41:06 The Ramban opens Avraham's story with his sin precisely to stress that Avraham's coming did not depend on his merits; the purpose of creation required him.
- 46:52 The war of the four kings was a war against Moshiach: they captured Lot because Moshiach was to descend from him, and Avraham's victory over them foreshadows the Jews passing successfully through the four exiles.
- 50:44 Esav's kiss was another form of his bite, and the exile of Edom, after failing to destroy the Jews by force, succeeds more by embracing them.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
Mentioned in this shiur
People Adam HaRishon, Amram, Avraham Avinu, Cham, Dovid HaMelech, Esav, Haran, Lot, Moshe Rabbeinu, Noach, Pharaoh, Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, Rus, Sarah Imeinu, Shlomis bas Divri, the Maharal of Prague, the Ramban, Yaakov Avinu, Yocheved, Yosef HaTzaddik
Terms אור כשדים, ארבע מלכיות, גלות אדום, זכרונות, מבול, מסירות נפש, עולם התיקון, עשו, שבירת הכלים, תיבה