קיום המצות במחשבה דיבור ומעשה. אע"פ שהתורה לבוש לנשמה היא יותר גדול ממנה. התורה נשתלשל למטה עד שיש באפשריות של המוח גשמי להשיג אלקות.
Catalog entry: TANYA ENGLISH ד no. 11 Pocket Guide p. 73 English 47 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains why the garments of Torah and mitzvos are greater than the soul they clothe, and how Hashem reduced His infinite will and wisdom into Torah so that a human mind can grasp it.
The Mashgiach reviews the Tanya's teaching that a Jew fulfils the mitzvos in thought, speech and action, and that these become garments for the soul. He shows how thought enters a mitzvah, especially where the Torah gives its reason, as with tzitzis, which include all 613 mitzvos, and sukkah. An ordinary garment is secondary to its wearer, yet here the garment is greater, because Torah is G-dliness itself. He qualifies this: the soul in the body is only its lowest part, as he explains through yibum and chalitzah, and at its root the Jewish soul is even above Torah. Since the Creator and His wisdom are one, the human mind cannot grasp Him; it is a different category, as one cannot hear a picture. Out of kindness Hashem reduced the Torah into concepts of this world, like water turned to ice, wrapped like radium in lead, and like Shlomo HaMelech's chain of meshalim.
Topics: The Two Souls (Tanya ch. 1-8) · The Power and Greatness of Torah · The Reasons and Power of the Mitzvos
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Three garments: thought, speech and action listed in the guide
The Mashgiach reviews that a Jew fulfils the mitzvos in thought, speech and action, which become garments for the soul, and notes that a suit is secondary to the person who wears it. He shows how learning Torah and putting on tefillin involve all three, and how, where the Torah gives a mitzvah's reason, that reason becomes part of the mitzvah.
-
4:07 Tzitzis, sukkah and the reason in mind listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that tzitzis, which include all 613 mitzvos, differ from every other garment, and that the reason for sukkah is given in the Torah, so one keeps the reason in mind; where no reason is given, knowing one does a mitzvah is enough. He sums up thought, the brachah and the act, and asks how the garment can be greater than the soul.
-
10:00 Torah is G-dliness, so the garment is greater listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that Hashem and His wisdom are one, so Torah and every mitzvah are G-dliness itself, and the garment is more important than the soul. He notes that at its root the soul is higher than Torah, but sets that aside to speak of the soul as it is here.
-
13:15 The soul in the body and its root listed in the guide
Through yibum and chalitzah the Mashgiach explains that the soul within the body is only its lowest part, like the foot inside a shoe, while the rest reaches heaven as an encompassing light. He then explains that Yisrael preceded the Torah in thought and the world was created for them, so at its root the soul is above Torah, and the Tanya speaks of the soul as it is in the body.
-
20:14 Hashem reduced Torah into worldly concepts listed in the guide
The Mashgiach reads the Tanya that these garments are endlessly greater than the soul, and brings the Rambam that Hashem is the knower and the knowledge in one. Since our minds were made for this world, Hashem in great kindness reduced Torah into worldly cases such as an ox goring a cow.
-
24:00 Two meshalim: the picture and the water listed in the guide
With a mashal he heard from his rebbe, seeing a symphony or hearing a picture, the Mashgiach shows that the mind cannot grasp G-dliness because it is the wrong faculty, not a weaker one. He then compares how steam becomes water and ice, the same substance in coarser forms, to how Hashem lowered the Torah into a form our minds can hold.
-
30:00 No probing His greatness listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that Hashem is called Ein Sof and that His greatness has no 'cheker', explaining the word as deep probing and philosophy, which cannot reach Him. He describes a person paying a high price for something a neighbor values at a quarter, and says the soul senses something special even when the mind does not.
-
35:01 His will and wisdom in the halachos listed in the guide
The Mashgiach reads that no thought can grasp Hashem's will and wisdom, which are the halachos of the Torah: that one who damages pays, and that one shelters in a sukkah though an architect would not advise it. He brings several pesukim and Chazal's teaching that where Hashem's greatness is found His humility is found, and reads the Tanya that Hashem contracted His will and wisdom into the 613 mitzvos so the soul can grasp and fulfil them.
-
40:38 Radium in lead and Shlomo's meshalim listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that Hashem's greatness is that we cannot grasp Him and His humility is that He bent down to us, comparing Torah to radium carried safely in a lead container. He explains Shlomo HaMelech's three thousand meshalim as a chain, each explaining the one above it, as Hashem brought Torah down through the worlds to earth, so that people grasp it better than the angels.
The shiur, written up
Three garments: thought, speech and action
The Mashgiach recalls that a Jew fulfils the mitzvos in thought, speech and action, and that these become garments for the soul. A suit, he notes, is secondary to its wearer: it serves the person and adds to his dignity. Learning Torah includes all three, thinking, articulating and moving the mouth, and putting on tefillin involves thinking about what tefillin are, since for some mitzvos the Torah states the reason, and that reason becomes part of the mitzvah.
Tzitzis, sukkah and the reason in mind
Tzitzis, the Mashgiach explains, contain all the mitzvos, as Rashi counts them to 613. Every other garment is tailored for one purpose, with sleeves for the arms, while tzitzis are a single piece of material one wraps around oneself, and one keeps in mind that they recall all of Hashem's mitzvos. Sukkah is the same, since the Torah gives its reason. Where no reason is given, knowing that one is doing a mitzvah is enough. b
So every mitzvah has thought, speech, usually the brachah, and the act, and these become a garment for the soul. A garment would seem secondary to its wearer, yet here, the Mashgiach says, the garment is more important.
Torah is G-dliness
The Mashgiach says some concepts in the Tanya must for now be accepted as truth, and will fall into place with further learning. Hashem's thinking and its product are one, so Torah is G-dliness itself, and so is every mitzvah. Wrapping oneself in a mitzvah means wrapping oneself in G-dliness, and that garment is greater than the soul. At its root the soul is higher still, but he sets that aside.
The soul in the body and its root
The soul within us, the Mashgiach explains, is only a small part of it. He illustrates this with yibum and chalitzah: when a brother declines to provide a new body, a new shoe, for the departed soul, his shoe is removed, because the part of the soul in a body is like the foot inside a shoe. The real soul reaches up to heaven; the part within a person is the inner light, and the part above him is the encompassing light. e
Yisrael preceded everything in Hashem's thought, and the world and the Torah were made for them, so at the root Torah is secondary to the Jewish soul. The Tanya's statement that the garments are greater refers to the soul within the body, which learns Torah; at its root the soul is above it. d
Torah reduced into worldly concepts
The Mashgiach reads the Tanya that these garments, though they clothe the soul, are endlessly greater than it. As the Rambam teaches, Hashem is the knower and the knowledge, indivisible. Our minds and senses were made for this world, so Hashem reduced the Torah into its concepts, such as an ox goring a cow, and this is a great kindness. a,c,f
The picture and the water
The Mashgiach brings a mashal he heard from his rebbe. One who claims to have seen a symphony or heard a picture is not hearing worse than others; hearing does not apply to a picture at all. Likewise the mind fails to grasp G-dliness not for lack of intelligence but because it was made for this world.
Hashem, wishing us to bind ourselves to Him, lowered the Torah into graspable concepts. Steam, water and ice are the same substance in coarser forms; so Torah came down from its spiritual state into a form the mind can hold.
No probing His greatness
Hashem is called Ein Sof, and the passuk says His greatness has no 'cheker'. The Mashgiach explains the word as probing deeper and deeper, as in philosophy, and says such probing will never reach Him. He describes a person paying two hundred dollars for something his neighbor values at a quarter, and says the soul feels something special even when the mind does not. g
His will and wisdom in the halachos
The Mashgiach reads in the Tanya that no thought can grasp Hashem's will and wisdom, which are the halachos: that one who damages pays, and that on Sukkos one shelters in a sukkah, though no architect would recommend it. Pesukim say there is no probing His understanding, and that His thoughts are not like ours, for His thought is Himself. h,i,k
Chazal say that where one finds Hashem's greatness, one finds His humility. So the Tanya continues that Hashem contracted His will and wisdom into the 613 mitzvos and their halachos, so that the soul can grasp them and fulfil them in thought, speech and action, and clothe itself in them with all ten of its faculties. l,m
Radium in lead and Shlomo's meshalim
Hashem's greatness, the Mashgiach explains, is that we cannot grasp Him; His humility is that He bent down and reduced Himself so we can. Radium would harm anyone who touched it, yet in a lead container it can be carried. So too G-dliness is fire, and wrapped in the garments of the 613 mitzvos we can handle it.
Shlomo HaMelech said three thousand meshalim: his wisdom was so great that each mashal needed another to explain it, until the chain reached people. Likewise Hashem brought the Torah down through the worlds to this earth, and through its meshalim people understand Torah better than the angels, who lack the concepts of this world. n
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 0:00 Thought, speech and action in Torah and mitzvos are garments for the soul.
- 1:21 Unlike an ordinary garment, which is secondary to its wearer, the garment of Torah and mitzvos is greater than the soul, because Torah is G-dliness.
- 16:08 The part of the soul inside the body is only its lowest part; at its root the Jewish soul is above Torah.
- 22:08 The human mind was made to understand this world and cannot grasp Hashem, not for lack of intelligence but because G-dliness is outside its category.
- 22:42 Hashem reduced the Torah into concepts of this world, such as the laws of damages, so that our minds can grasp it.
- 39:12 Where one finds Hashem's greatness, that He cannot be grasped, one finds His humility, that He lowered His will and wisdom into the 613 mitzvos.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 9:27 If the mitzvos are garments for the soul, should they not be secondary to it, as a suit is to its wearer?
Answer: 11:17 Torah is G-dliness itself, so a mitzvah wraps the soul in G-dliness, and here the garment is greater than the wearer.
-
Question: 12:20 How can Torah be greater than the soul if the soul's root is above Torah?
Answer: 19:48 The Tanya speaks of the part of the soul within the body; only at its root is the soul above Torah.
-
Question: 26:13 If Torah is G-dliness, which the mind cannot grasp, how can we understand it?
Answer: 26:18 Hashem, wishing to bind us to Him through Torah, reduced it into concepts of this world that the mind can hold.
-
Question: 43:33 Why is it a great thing that Shlomo HaMelech said three thousand meshalim?
Answer: 44:32 His wisdom was so great that each mashal needed another to explain it, until a chain of three thousand brought it down to people.
Insights
- 1:21 Ordinarily a garment is secondary to its wearer, but the garments of Torah and mitzvos are greater than the soul they clothe, because Torah is not a product of Hashem's wisdom but G-dliness itself.
- 16:19 The Mashgiach reads chalitzah through the soul: the soul in the body is like a foot in a shoe, only its lowest part, while the rest stays above as an encompassing light, and the more refined a person is, the more of it he draws in.
- 18:13 The Tanya's claim that the garments surpass the soul refers to the soul as it is in the body; at its root, since Yisrael preceded everything in Hashem's thought, the soul is above Torah, and Torah is secondary to it.
- 24:38 The mind's failure to grasp G-dliness is a matter of category, not capacity: just as hearing a million times better will never let one hear a picture, a mind of any intelligence cannot reach what lies beyond this world.
- 36:31 Hashem's greatness and humility appear together: His greatness is that no mind can grasp Him, and His humility is that He contracted His will and wisdom into halachos of oxen and sukkos so that our minds can.
- 44:54 Shlomo HaMelech's three thousand meshalim were a chain, each mashal explaining the one above it, and in the same way Torah came down through the worlds, so that people on earth grasp it better than the angels, who lack this world's concepts.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 10:07 The Mashgiach says that some concepts in the Tanya must for now be accepted as truth, with the intention of learning further, and they will later fall into place.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Rashi, Shlomo HaMelech, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Rambam, the Ramban
Terms אין סוף, אלקות ממש, גשמיות, חקירה, לבושים, מחשבה דיבור ומעשה, מקיף, סוכה, עולם הזה, ציצית, צמצום, רבונו של עולם, שורש הנשמה, תרי"ג מצוות