התורה יורדת בסתר המדריגות כדי שכל אחד יוכל לתפוס בה' ועי"ז זוכה ליחוד נפלא ועצום בהקב"ה.
Catalog entry: TANYA ENGLISH ד no. 12 Pocket Guide p. 74 English 53 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains, on Tanya chapter four, that the Torah came down through hidden rungs so that every Jew can grasp it, and that through learning Torah and doing mitzvos a person is bound to Hashem Himself in a union greater than the souls in Gan Eden enjoy.
The Mashgiach begins with the idea that this world is an imaginary world, while the truth is that Hashem is present here as before creation. Since no thought can grasp Hashem and the Torah is one with Him, Hashem brought the Torah down like water, rung by rung, clothing it in halachos, words and physical mitzvos, as radium is held in a lead case. Thought, speech and even the shaking of a Jew in learning are clothed in Torah, so the whole person becomes a chariot for the Shechinah. We do not feel it because aveiros insulate the body from the soul, yet one should believe it. This is why one hour of Torah and mitzvos in this world is better than all of Olam Haba, where souls only enjoy the rays of the Shechinah. He compares it to embracing a king through his garments, digresses on the seven notes of creation and Shabbos, contrasts philosophers with ovdei Hashem through the Satmar Rav at his Shabbos table, and answers a question about water as chesed.
Topics: The Two Souls (Tanya ch. 1-8) · The Power and Greatness of Torah · Ahavas Hashem and Dveikus · Reward, Olam HaBa and Techiyas HaMeisim
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 This world as an imaginary world
The Mashgiach recalls that Hashem lowered Himself into the Torah and its mitzvos so every soul can understand it, and explains that the physical world we think is real is the imaginary world, while Hashem fills it as before creation.
-
3:11 Torah descends like water through hidden rungs listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains why the Torah is compared to water that flows down to the lowest place, brings the mashal of radium held in a lead case, and shows how the Torah clothed itself in halachos like those of sukkah, which are all names of Hashem, changing its form but not its essence, like water, ice and steam.
-
9:43 Thought, speech, action and the shaking of a Jew listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that the Torah reaches down past thought into speech and the physical actions of learning, even the shaking over a Gemara, tells the account of two mixed-up children recognized by their shaking, and explains the shaking with the passuk that the soul of man is a candle of Hashem.
-
13:47 Bound to Hashem, but insulated by aveiros listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that one who learns Torah is bound from head to toe to Hashem and becomes a chariot for the Shechinah, as great tzaddikim visibly felt, and that we do not feel it because aveiros insulate the body from the soul; still, he says, one should believe it and act accordingly.
-
18:47 One hour in this world is better than Olam Haba listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the passuk of the shield of Hashem's will that surrounds the tzaddik and the Mishnah in Pirkei Avos that one hour of teshuvah and good deeds in this world is better than all of Olam Haba, explaining that here Hashem's full presence rests on a person, while in Olam Haba only a light of the Shechinah reaches the souls.
-
22:05 The pleasure of grasping: Ziv HaShechinah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach compares the rays of the Shechinah to the rays of the sun, describes the pleasure of understanding a sugya or a scientific discovery, and explains that this is the pleasure tzaddikim have in Olam Haba as they rise from level to level, while no creature, not even the angels, can grasp Hashem Himself.
-
25:46 Embracing the King through His garments listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that understanding a mitzvah through a blatt Gemara is grasping Hashem Himself, unlike the souls in Gan Eden, and answers that the physical clothing does not matter, with the mashal of embracing a king through garments and sleeves; he connects this to the passuk 'His right hand embraces me' and to the Torah given from the right, the attribute of chesed and water.
-
30:01 The seven voices: music, creation and Shabbos
In a digression, the Mashgiach explains that Kabbalas Shabbos begins with Mizmor l'Dovid Havu, whose seven voices are the seven notes of music with which the seven days were created, says this world is wonderful for one who uses it for closeness to Hashem, and describes the harmony of the third, the seventh day as the completion that lets us sing, and Eretz Yisrael and the Kinneres as the seventh of the lands and seas.
-
38:13 Tanya is for ovdei Hashem, not philosophers listed in the guide
Returning to his point, the Mashgiach explains that water is chesed and the source of every pleasure, so Hashem's right hand embraces a person through the Torah. He then says the Ba'al HaTanya wrote for ovdei Hashem: a philosopher may see depth in the Tanya but has no taste for the union with Hashem, like a person with no ear for music.
-
44:39 The Satmar Rav's Shabbos fish Story
The Mashgiach tells how he saw the Satmar Rav at his Friday night tish, his face flaming at Kiddush and eating the fish with delight because he felt the Shabbos in it, and tells of a poor Jew who asked Hashem to give him Shabbos for his challos and fish. He concludes that the Tanya spoke to Chassidim who understood and were delighted by it.
-
49:51 Why water is chesed: a question
A listener asks that other sefarim describe water as passive and static; the Mashgiach answers that this is a mashal, but in its depth water reaches out and spreads, and it goes down to lower places to bring growth to the world, unlike gas, which spreads but rises away.
The shiur, written up
This world as an imaginary world
The Mashgiach recalls that Hashem lowered Himself, as it were, into the Torah and its mitzvos so that every soul can understand it. A plain person thinks the table he can touch is real and G-dliness abstract; the truth, the Mashgiach says, is the opposite. This is the imaginary world: Hashem fills it just as before creation, but hides Himself, so we take as real only what our five senses grasp.
Torah descends like water through hidden rungs
Therefore, the Tanya says, the Torah is compared to water, which flows from a high place down to the lowest. No thought can grasp Hashem, and since the Torah is one with Him, no thought should grasp the Torah either. So Hashem brought it down through the hidden rungs, rung by rung, until it was clothed, like radium held safely in a lead case. a
The Torah clothed itself in the halachos of each mitzvah. No one can explain why two walls and a tefach suffice for a sukkah, because every detail of those halachos is a detail of the Name of Hashem from which the mitzvah comes; as the Ramban explains, the whole Torah is names of Hashem. It changed its form, not its essence, as water remains water whether ice or steam. b
Thought, speech, action and shaking
The Torah descends further, from thought into speech, the movements of the lips, and the hands of one explaining a sugya, even his shaking over a Gemara. Only Jews shake: the Mashgiach cites a sefer, without vouching for it, where two mixed-up children were told apart by which one shook when learning Gemara.
Bound to Hashem, but insulated
One who learns Torah is thus bound from head to toe to Hashem Himself and becomes a chariot for the Shechinah. The Mashgiach says he has seen tzaddikim, rare today, on whose faces this was visible even in the street, and whose fear on Yom Kippur was a delighting fear.
We do not feel it, he explains, because uncorrected aveiros insulate the body from the soul, as insulation lets one touch a live wire. The soul feels everything; every Jew could be a prophet. Still, he says, one should have the emunah to know that when he learns, davens or does a mitzvah, the Shechinah rests on him.
One hour here, better than Olam Haba
The Mashgiach brings the passuk 'like a shield, with will You crown him': Hashem's will, which is Hashem Himself, surrounds the tzaddik like armor, since a mitzvah is His will. This explains the Mishnah that one hour of teshuvah and good deeds in this world is better than all of Olam Haba: here Hashem's full presence rests on a person, while there the souls receive only a light emanating from the Shechinah. f,g
Ziv HaShechinah
Those rays are like the sun's rays reaching the earth, not the sun itself. Their pleasure is that of understanding, the greatest pleasure even in this world, as when a sugya suddenly fits together like one organism, or a physicist's discovery works. In Olam Haba tzaddikim rise in this from level to level; this is Ziv HaShechinah. But, as the Tanya says, no creature, not even the angels, can grasp Hashem Himself. h
Embracing the King
Yet when Hashem clothes Himself in the mitzvos, one who understands a mitzvah through a blatt Gemara grasps Hashem Himself, the sun itself, not only the rays the souls in Gan Eden receive. The physical clothing, like a cup of wine for Kiddush, does not matter: one who embraces a king through royal garments and his own sleeves holds the king himself. So Shlomo HaMelech says 'His right hand embraces me', and the Tanya says the Torah was given from the right, chesed and water. i,j
The seven voices of creation
In a digression, the Mashgiach notes that Kabbalas Shabbos begins with Mizmor l'Dovid Havu, whose seven voices are the seven notes of music with which the seven days were created. For one not steeped in this world, who uses it for mitzvos and closeness to Hashem, he says, this world is wonderful. k
Each day is a note: Monday, the day of strife on which Gehinnom was created; the third, harmony, like colors blending in a picture. With the seventh, Shabbos, the notes are complete, and we sing the psalm for the Shabbos day. The Midrash counts seven lands and seven seas: the seventh are Eretz Yisrael, a land of song, and the Kinneres, shaped like a violin. l,n
Tanya is for ovdei Hashem
Returning to his point, the Mashgiach explains that water is chesed, since every physical pleasure involves liquid. Hashem's right hand embraces a person through the Torah, water that comes down from above and takes the form of mitzvos, enveloping him from head to toe.
The Ba'al HaTanya, he says, wrote for ovdei Hashem. A brilliant former student who became a professor of philosophy came to discuss the Tanya; such people see its depth but have no taste for it. The Tanya says that learning Torah is a complete union with Hashem: the philosopher knows only that such a union exists, while an eved Hashem could dance for joy. It is like one with no ear for music, or the visitor at Carnegie Hall who liked the tuning best. o
The Satmar Rav's Shabbos fish
Fifty years ago, the Mashgiach says, he would go to the Satmar Rav's tish on Friday night. At Kiddush his face flamed, and he ate the fish with great delight though he was above physicality: he felt the Shabbos in the fish. The Mashgiach also tells of a poor Jew who, eating his Shabbos challos and fish, asked Hashem to give him Shabbos for them.
One whose insulation is not thick, he says, can feel Hashem in this world. The philosopher does not know what the Tanya means, but the Chassidim it addressed nearly two hundred years ago were delighted and fired to learn.
Why water is chesed
A listener asks that some sefarim call water passive and static. The Mashgiach answers that this is a mashal; in its depth water reaches out, spreading over a table where a sefer stays in its place. Gas spreads more but rises, while water goes down to the lower levels, as rain from the clouds brings growth and food, and that is chesed. p
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
- c Mishlei 20:27 text index In the write-up: 12:41
- f Tehillim 5:13 text index In the write-up: 19:24
- i Shir HaShirim 2:6 text index In the write-up: 25:59
- k Tehillim 29 text index In the write-up: 30:01
- n Tehillim 92:1-2 text index In the write-up: 33:45
- p apparently Tehillim 104:13 index In the write-up: 50:06
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
- l Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 33:45
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 1:31 This world is an imaginary world in which Hashem hides Himself, while in truth He is present here just as before creation.
- 3:41 Since no thought can grasp Hashem and the Torah is one with Him, Hashem lowered the Torah through hidden rungs, like water flowing down, into halachos and physical mitzvos.
- 9:02 The Torah changed only its form, not its essence, like water that becomes ice or steam and stays the same water.
- 11:07 When a person learns Torah with thought, speech and action, his whole being is bound to Hashem and becomes a chariot for the Shechinah, even if he does not feel it.
- 14:34 Aveiros insulate the body from the soul, so the body does not feel the Shechinah that the soul knows is resting upon it.
- 20:04 In Olam Haba the souls enjoy only the rays of the Shechinah, while in this world Hashem Himself is present in the Torah and mitzvos, which is why one hour here is better than all of Olam Haba.
- 27:53 Embracing Hashem through the Torah is like embracing a king through his garments: the king himself is in one's arms.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 4:23 If no thought, even of a great person, can grasp Hashem, and the Torah is one with Hashem, how can anyone grasp the Torah?
Answer: 4:38 Hashem brought the Torah down through the hidden rungs and clothed it, as radium is encased in lead, so that it can be held.
-
Question: 11:43 Why do Jews shake when they learn and daven?
Answer: 12:41 Because the soul of man is a candle of Hashem, and a flame is never still; the fire of the Shechinah in a person makes him shake.
-
Question: 14:16 If learning Torah makes a person a chariot for the Shechinah, why does he not feel it?
Answer: 14:34 Aveiros that were not corrected insulate the body from the soul, like an insulated live wire, so the body is numbed while the soul knows.
-
Question: 20:04 How can one hour of teshuvah and good deeds in this world be better than all of Olam Haba?
Answer: 21:01 In this world Hashem's full presence rests on the one who learns and does mitzvos, while in Olam Haba the souls receive only a light that emanates from the Shechinah.
-
Question: 26:59 Since the Torah and mitzvos are clothed in physical things, like a cup of wine for Kiddush, how is this grasping Hashem Himself?
Answer: 27:53 One who embraces a king through his royal garments and his own sleeves still holds the king himself in his arms.
Stories
-
11:54 The two mixed-up children
The Mashgiach says he saw in a sefer, though he cannot promise it is true, that a Jewish child and a non-Jewish child were once mixed up. A sage was asked what to do, and he said to send both to cheder and see, when they begin learning Gemara, which child shakes. The one who shakes is the Jew.
-
40:21 The professor of philosophy who came to discuss Tanya
The Mashgiach says he once had a very brilliant student who became a professor of philosophy at a university. He came with a colleague to discuss the Tanya, which they found to be a work of philosophical depth, but, the Mashgiach says, they had no taste for its flavor.
-
44:01 The visitor at the symphony
The Mashgiach tells of a man who had just come from Africa and was taken to Carnegie Hall to hear a wonderful symphony. Asked which part he enjoyed most, he picked the noises the musicians made while tuning their violins before the symphony began.
-
45:26 The Satmar Rav at his Shabbos tish
The Mashgiach says that about fifty years earlier he used to go to the Satmar Rav's tish on Friday night and saw how he enjoyed every fiber of Shabbos. When he made Kiddush his face became red and flaming. When the fish was served he ate it with great delight, yet he was above physicality and did not care for its taste; he felt the Shabbos in the fish.
In the story: the Satmar Rav (Rabbi Yoel Teitelbaum)
-
47:04 Give me Shabbos for the challos
The Mashgiach tells of a Jew who struggled the whole week without a livelihood and fasted Monday and Thursday, partly because he had nothing to eat. He scraped together a little money and bought challos and fish for Shabbos. Eating the challos he said: Ribono shel Olam, You gave me challos for Shabbos, please give me Shabbos for the challos; and he said the same over the fish.
Insights
- 1:17 The Mashgiach reverses the common view: the physical table one can touch belongs to the imaginary world, while Hashem's presence, which seems abstract, is the true reality.
- 6:45 Every detail of the halachos of sukkah, such as two walls and a tefach, is a detail of the Name of Hashem from which the mitzvah comes, so the halachos cannot be explained but only accepted.
- 11:31 The shaking of a Jew in learning and davening is itself part of the act of Torah and is clothed in it; it comes from the fire of the soul, which moves like a flame.
- 17:28 Every Jew has the potential of prophecy, since the soul knows and feels everything; only the body, insulated by aveiros, fails to pick up the soul's messages.
- 26:20 Learning Torah in this world is grasping Hashem Himself, like the sun itself, while the souls in Gan Eden grasp only the rays of the Shechinah.
- 38:37 Water, which is chesed, is the medium of every physical pleasure, and Hashem's embrace of a person reaches him through the Torah, the water that comes down from above.
- 40:54 A philosopher can see depth in the Tanya yet miss its point entirely, like someone without an ear for music who cannot tell a symphony from a cat walking on a piano.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 18:11 The Mashgiach says that even if we do not feel it, we should at least have the emunah to know, and act accordingly, that when a person learns, davens or does any mitzvah the Shechinah rests on him.
- 31:54 The Mashgiach says that this world is a wonderful thing for one who uses it for his mitzvos and to function as Hashem wants, so that it brings him close to Hashem.
- 45:09 The Mashgiach tells his listeners that they have a reason for being placed in this generation and should do their own kind of avodas Hashem.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Shlomo HaMelech, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Ramban, the Satmar Rav (Rabbi Yoel Teitelbaum)
Terms דביקות, השראת השכינה, זיו השכינה, מדת החסד, מחשבה דיבור ומעשה, מרכבה, פועל דמיוני, קבלת שבת, רבונו של עולם