ע"י לימוד תורה - כביכול תופס ה' בתוכו' וה' מתיחד בו ביחוד עצום ונפלא.

Catalog entry: TANYA ENGLISH ה no. ⁨13⁩ Pocket Guide p. 74 English 46 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 46 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Mashgiach's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Mashgiach explains Tanya chapter five: when a Jew truly understands Torah he and the Torah envelop each other, and since Hashem encased Himself in the Torah, this is a union with Hashem that no mitzvah and no angel reaches.

The Mashgiach first reviews a passage of the Ba'al HaTanya about ten Jews: the Shechinah rests on any ten, so a group that sits idle 'squeezes' the Shechinah, and he brings the Maggid of Mezritch's saying that an angel would be burnt up among ten Jews. The Ba'al HaTanya therefore urges simple people to learn the aggados of Ein Yaakov, where the deepest secrets of the Torah are hidden. Turning to chapter five, the Mashgiach explains that a mitzvah envelops a person only from outside, while Torah understood with the mind is a double union: the person grasps the subject and the subject envelops him. Though no thought can grasp Hashem, He encased Himself in the halachos like radioactive matter in lead, so a Jew who understands a halacha grasps Hashem's will. Therefore Torah is called food and mitzvos clothing. He ends with sukkah as surrounding light and the Torah of Simchas Torah as inner light.

Topics: The Two Souls (Tanya ch. 1-8) · The Power and Greatness of Torah

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 The Shechinah among ten Jews

    The Mashgiach reviews the Ba'al HaTanya's words that the Shechinah rests wherever ten Jews gather, and brings the Maggid of Mezritch's saying that an angel would be burnt up among them. When they sit idle, he explains, they squeeze the Shechinah, which is one cause of the length of the golus.

  2. 5:12 The hidden secrets in the aggados

    The Mashgiach explains why the Ba'al HaTanya tells the common people to learn Ein Yaakov: aggados that sound like nonsense, such as the bird whose egg destroyed sixty cities, wrap the highest secrets of the Torah. Answering a listener who asks whether this is dangerous, he says that the straight walk in the Torah's ways while the crooked stumble.

  3. 12:20 Perek five: Torah envelops from both sides listed in the guide

    Opening chapter five, the Mashgiach notes that the Tanya develops one theme step by step. A mitzvah envelops a person like a cloak, but Torah is more: one who is immersed in learning grasps the Torah within him while it surrounds him from without, a double union.

  4. 17:47 Grasping Hashem encased in Torah listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that although no thought, not even an angel's, grasps Hashem, a Jew who learns does, because Hashem and the Torah are one. He compares it to radioactive matter held safely in a lead box and to a caress through a sleeve, and reads the Tanya's words on the mind enveloping the subject it understands.

  5. 24:39 A halachah is Hashem's will listed in the guide

    Unlike a mathematical equation, a halachah is Hashem's wisdom and will, even in cases that may never happen, such as the Gemara's question about one born with two heads. Understanding it is a wondrous two-way union that has no parallel in the physical world.

  6. 29:17 Knowing Torah surpasses every mitzvah listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that the mitzvah of knowing Torah is above all mitzvos, even above speaking words of Torah, since in lulav or tefillin the holiness only surrounds the person. He brings the Ba'al HaTanya's ruling about thinking Torah before the blessing, and shows with a boy learning 'tashma' that each person must work to his own full capacity.

  7. 35:31 Torah is food, mitzvos are clothing listed in the guide

    Torah that is learned becomes a person's food and the mitzvos he does become his clothing, which the Mashgiach says is why clothing costs more than food: money should be spent on mitzvos, while Torah is given free. Like bread absorbed into the body, understood Torah becomes part of a person, and spoken Torah is both garment and food.

  8. 41:50 Sukkah surrounds, Torah is within

    After a question about kavanah in mitzvos, the Mashgiach explains that the sukkah is a surrounding light and that on Simchas Torah the inner light of the Torah follows. He connects this to the generation of the flood, which merited only the ark, a kind of sukkah, and to Shavuos and Shemini Atzeres, which have no special mitzvah.

The shiur, written up

The Shechinah among ten Jews

0:11

The Mashgiach reviews the Ba'al HaTanya's words that the Shechinah rests wherever ten Jews gather, even when they are not speaking words of Torah. He brings the Maggid of Mezritch's saying that an angel standing among ten Jews would be burnt up by their holiness. a

2:57

When such a group sits idle, the Mashgiach explains, they squeeze the Shechinah, as people crowd someone out of a room until there is no place for him. This, he says, is one of the things that keep the Jews in golus.

The hidden secrets in the aggados

5:16

Speaking to simple people who waste their time, the Ba'al HaTanya does not ask them to learn deep matters but the aggados of Ein Yaakov, a compilation of the aggados of Shas. Many aggados, like the bird whose egg destroyed sixty cities, sound like nonsense. The Mashgiach explains that just as Hashem concealed His holiness in the halachos, He wrapped the highest secrets of the Torah in even more coverings, and one who learns them here has the base to understand them in the World to Come. c

11:01

A listener asks whether this is not dangerous for people who take such aggados literally. The Mashgiach answers that the righteous walk in the Torah's ways and the sinners stumble in them: one who learns with simplicity is not harmed, while one who examines the Torah critically can find a path to heresy in it.

Perek five: Torah envelops from both sides

12:21

Beginning chapter five, the Mashgiach notes that the Tanya, unlike other chassidic seforim, develops one theme from chapter to chapter. Earlier chapters taught that a mitzvah envelops a person like a cloak. Torah is more: one who is steeped in his learning, with every outside thought shut out, holds the Torah within his mind while it surrounds him from without, a double union. d

Grasping Hashem encased in Torah

17:52

This holds for any deep subject a person truly understands. But no thought, not even of the angels, can grasp Hashem, and still a Jew grasps Him in Torah, the Mashgiach explains, because Hashem and the Torah are one, and He brought Himself into the Torah so that it can be grasped.

19:24

He compares it to radioactive material, dangerous in the hand but safe in a lead box: Hashem is encased in the physical matters the halachah deals with, yet it is truly Hashem, as a caress through a sleeve is still a caress. A learning Jew thus surpasses the souls in Gan Eden, who receive only light radiating from the Shechinah. g

A halachah is Hashem's will

24:39

A mathematical equation is only mathematics, the Mashgiach says, but a halachah, such as a claim between Reuven and Shimon in beis din, is Hashem's wisdom and will. The Gemara even asks about a child born with two heads, a case that may never occur, because Hashem's will is what the ruling would be if it did. Understanding it is a wondrous two-way union with no parallel in the physical world. h

Knowing Torah surpasses every mitzvah

29:27

Therefore knowing Torah is above all mitzvos: in shaking a lulav the holiness only surrounds a person. It surpasses even the mitzvah of speaking words of Torah, and the Mashgiach notes that the Ba'al HaTanya rules in his Shulchan Aruch that one may think in learning before the blessing on the Torah. i

32:55

Each person learns to his own capacity. A boy who grasps that 'tashma' means 'come and hear' is fully engaged, while a mature scholar must work until his mind runs at full capacity and everything else is cut out.

Torah is food, mitzvos are clothing

35:36

As the Arizal explains, the Torah a person learns becomes his food and the mitzvos he does become his clothing. This, the Mashgiach says, is why clothing costs more than food: money should be spent on mitzvos, while Torah is to be taught free.

38:16

Like bread absorbed into the body, Torah understood with the mind becomes part of a person, as the verse says that Your Torah is within my insides. Torah that is also spoken is both garment and food. k

Sukkah surrounds, Torah is within

41:59

Asked about kavanah in mitzvos, the Mashgiach agrees that intent joins Torah to the mitzvah. The sukkah, he explains, surrounds a person and the lulav draws some of it inward; when Sukkos ends, the Torah gives an inner light on Simchas Torah. The generation of the flood merited only the ark, a kind of sukkah, not the inner light, and Shavuos, like Shemini Atzeres, has no special mitzvah.

Sources

Torah

  1. l Vayikra 23:42 45:06 text index

Nevi'im

  1. b apparently Yeshayahu 52:2 4:26 index

Kesuvim

  1. k Tehillim 40:9 text index In the write-up: 38:16

Talmud Bavli

  1. h apparently Menachos 37a index In the write-up: 24:39

Zohar and Kabbalah

  1. f Zohar (place not identified) 18:56 index
  2. j apparently Tikkunei Zohar, second introduction (Patach Eliyahu) 34:53 index

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. a apparently Tanya, Iggeres HaKodesh 23 index In the write-up: 0:11
  2. d Tanya ch. 5 text index In the write-up: 12:21
  3. e Tanya (place not identified) 18:47 index
  4. g apparently Tanya ch. 4 index In the write-up: 19:24
  5. i Shulchan Aruch HaRav (place not identified) index In the write-up: 29:27

Other

  1. c Ein Yaakov (place not identified) index In the write-up: 5:16

Key points

  1. 1:37 Wherever ten Jews gather the Shechinah rests on them, so idle talk there presses on the Shechinah; the Mashgiach says ten Jews together should learn Torah.
  2. 5:34 Many aggados of the Gemara that seem senseless hide the highest secrets of the Torah, which is why the Ba'al HaTanya tells simple people to learn Ein Yaakov.
  3. 15:08 A mitzvah envelops a person from outside, but Torah that is understood is a double union: the person envelops the Torah and the Torah envelops him.
  4. 18:22 No thought, not even of angels, can grasp Hashem, yet a Jew grasps Him in Torah, because Hashem and the Torah are one and He encased Himself in the halachos.
  5. 30:00 The mitzvah of knowing Torah with the mind surpasses even the mitzvah of speaking words of Torah, because the Torah enters within the person.
  6. 35:36 Torah is therefore called food, which becomes part of the body, while the mitzvos are called clothing.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 18:22 How can a Jew grasp Hashem if no thought, not even of the angels, can grasp Him?

    Answer: 18:40 Hashem and the Torah are one, and He brought Himself into the Torah, encased in its physical subject matter so that it can be grasped.

  2. Question: 26:18 Why does the Gemara deal with cases, like a person with two heads, that may never happen?

    Answer: 26:40 Because the halachah is Hashem's will about what should be if it did happen.

  3. Question: 29:17 Why is knowing Torah greater than other mitzvos, such as shaking a lulav?

    Answer: 29:34 In a mitzvah the holiness only surrounds the person from outside, while understood Torah is also within him.

  4. Question: 35:58 Why is clothing more expensive than food?

    Answer: 36:43 Clothing corresponds to mitzvos, on which money should be spent, while food corresponds to Torah, which is given free.

Insights

  1. 2:57 Idle sitting by ten Jews is not merely wasted time: since the Shechinah is there regardless, they 'squeeze' it, like people crowding someone out of a room, and this is counted among the causes of golus.
  2. 7:09 Just as Hashem concealed His holiness in physical things through the halachos, He wrapped the deepest secrets of the Torah in even more coverings, the aggados that seem like nonsense.
  3. 19:24 The Torah is Hashem encased in physical subject matter like radioactive material in lead: the casing does not interrupt the contact, just as a caress through a sleeve is still a caress.
  4. 21:11 By learning Torah a Jew rises above the angels and the souls in Gan Eden, who receive only light that radiates from the Shechinah, while he holds the Shechinah itself.
  5. 26:18 The Gemara discusses cases that may never occur, such as a person with two heads, because each halachah is Hashem's own will about what would be if it happened, so understanding it is grasping His will.
  6. 36:00 Clothing costs more than food because mitzvos, which are clothing, should be paid for, while Torah, which is food, comes free.
  7. 42:26 The sukkah is a surrounding light and the lulav draws some of it inward; when Sukkos ends, the Torah of Simchas Torah gives an inner light, which the generation of the flood, given only an ark like a sukkah, did not merit.

What the Mashgiach says to take from it

  1. 5:12 The Mashgiach says that when ten Jews are together they should learn Torah together.
  2. 37:12 The Mashgiach advises paying something for every mitzvah, for example putting a few cents into the pushka when given an esrog as a gift.
  3. 40:11 The Mashgiach says it is good to prepare oneself before learning by keeping in mind that Hashem gave the Torah.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Eliyahu HaNavi, the Arizal, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Maggid of Mezritch, the Raavad, the Rambam

Terms יחוד, ליצנות, לית מחשבה תפיסא ביה, מקיף, סודות התורה, רבונו של עולם, שכינה

Report an error on this page