כנגד עשר ספירות דקדושה יש זה לעומת זה “עשר כתרין דמסאבותא” . סימן להשראת הקדושה - שבטל להקב"ה ובטומאה להיפוך.

Catalog entry: TANYA ENGLISH ו no. ⁨14⁩ Pocket Guide p. 74 English 51 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 51 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Mashgiach's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

Learning Tanya chapter six, the Mashgiach explains that opposite the ten holy powers of the soul stand ten 'crowns of impurity', and that holiness rests only on what is batel to Hashem, which every Jew is in potential.

The Mashgiach opens Tanya chapter six: just as the soul of holiness has ten powers, the soul from kelipas nogah has ten powers of impurity, 'zeh l'umas zeh'. He notes that only impurity is called 'crowns', because it attributes greatness to itself, and links its ten to the ten sons of Haman. Impurity, he adds, is never truly ten but nine or eleven, shown by the Teivah's eleven amos, the Mishkan's eleven goat-hair curtains and the eleven spices of the ketores. He then explains that the middos can serve Hashem or nonsense; there is no neutral reshus, and pointless pursuits are 're'us ruach', a breaking of the soul's connection. Holiness rests only on what is batel to Hashem; every Jew is batel in potential, as the history of mesiras nefesh shows, an inheritance from Avraham Avinu. He closes with a story of the Ba'al Shem Tov's daughter and questions from listeners.

Topics: Kedushah and Kelipah · The Two Souls (Tanya ch. 1-8) · Anavah and Bittul

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Ten powers of holiness and ten of impurity listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach recalls the ten holy powers of the soul and introduces Tanya chapter six: opposite them, 'zeh l'umas zeh', stand ten powers of impurity in the soul from kelipas nogah, so a person can become a seat for either side.

  2. 4:33 Why impurity is called 'crowns' listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach points out that the word 'crowns' appears only for impurity, because impurity is haughty and sees itself as something. He lists the seven bad middos from the four elements and the intellect above them, and links the ten crowns to the ten sons of Haman in the Megillah.

  3. 9:02 Impurity is nine or eleven, never ten listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that the ten of impurity only appear to be ten and are really nine or eleven. He shows this from Rashi's eleven amos of the Teivah, the eleven goat-hair curtains of the Mishkan, the eleven spices of the ketores and the order in which they are listed, and the eleven verses said on Motzaei Shabbos.

  4. 16:16 Middos for Hashem or for nonsense listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that the same middos can serve Hashem, such as chesed, gevurah for milchemes Hashem and pride in being a Jew, or can be spent on nonsense, like insisting on a designer tie or anger over trifles. There is no reshus: it is either a mitzvah or an aveirah, and the middos follow the level of a person's intellect, as with a child.

  5. 23:14 Re'us ruach: breaking the connection listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that worldly pursuits that are not for Hashem are 'havel' and 're'us ruach'. He illustrates with a ball game, where grown men scream over a stitched pigskin, and explains re'us as breaking: such pursuits sever the soul's connection to Hashem like a cut wire.

  6. 29:08 The ice cream: two sides of the fence

    The Mashgiach explains 'sitra achra' as the other side of the fence. Ice cream eaten to lift one's spirits is a mitzvah, and recreation in measure for health is good, but indulgence for its own sake falls to the other side, since there is no reshus.

  7. 33:00 Holiness rests on what is batel listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that Hashem's holiness rests only on what is batel to Him: the angels in fact, like a machine run by its operator, and every Jew at least in potential, as shown by Jews throughout history who gave their lives rather than commit avodah zarah.

  8. 36:13 Chalav akum and readiness for mesiras nefesh

    Citing the Tzemach Tzedek on Jews who are not ready for mesiras nefesh, the Mashgiach digresses to chalav akum: government-inspected milk, the views of Rav Moshe Feinstein and the Chazon Ish, and a story of a Rebbe who made himself vomit milk he learned was chalav akum. He returns to say such things can dull a person's readiness to give his life.

  9. 41:01 Avraham's inheritance and Fayvish the thief listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that readiness for mesiras nefesh is an inheritance from Avraham Avinu, and that the Ba'al HaTanya says a Jew who sins remains holy because he is ready to die for Hashem. He tells of the Ba'al Shem Tov's daughter Adel, who said Hashem chose wisely, since even a thief named Fayvish gave his life rather than convert, and adds that at the shofar of Moshiach even the farthest Jew will run after him.

  10. 46:38 Questions: intention and Krias Shema

    Answering a listener, the Mashgiach suggests that an act begun for Hashem keeps its first intention even if the mind wanders, as with learning Gemara, and that the morning declaration of readiness for mesiras nefesh carries through the day. On whether to imagine actual death at Krias Shema, he says the sefarim say to imagine it.

The shiur, written up

Ten powers of holiness and ten of impurity

0:00

The Mashgiach recalls that every Jew has ten holy powers, a reduced form of the ten sefiros, active in his intellect and his middos, and clothed in thought, speech and action. Tanya chapter six now explains that opposite them, as Koheles says, 'zeh l'umas zeh', there is a balance: the soul from kelipas nogah, the sitra achra, also has ten powers, ten kingdoms of impurity. A person therefore carries both possibilities, to become a seat for holiness or a seat for impurity. a,b

Why impurity is called 'crowns'

4:33

The Mashgiach notes that this is the first time Tanya uses the word 'crowns'. The holy powers were never called crowns, because a crown is the top of a power structure, and impurity is haughty: it has a sense of being and attributes greatness to itself. These crowns are the seven bad middos, which come from the four bad elements, together with the intellect that gives birth to them. b

7:20

He adds that the ten sons of Haman in the Megillah are these ten crowns of the sitra achra. c

Impurity is nine or eleven, never ten

9:19

The Mashgiach returns to a point he made earlier: the ten of impurity only look like ten and are really nine or eleven, since ten is reserved for holiness. This is why Rashi works out that the Teivah sank eleven amos into the water: its refuge reached down to the eleventh level. For the same reason the Mishkan had eleven goat-hair curtains, set against the 'goat' of impurity. d,e

11:28

Nothing nullifies the sitra achra like the ketores, he explains, which is why Aharon stopped the plague with it, and it has eleven spices. In the list of spices, which goes by weight, the order is broken so that kinnamon comes last, both ninth and eleventh. The siddurim likewise bring eleven verses on Motzaei Shabbos, when the sitra achra seeks to retake its kingdom. f,g

Middos for Hashem or for nonsense

16:51

The Mashgiach explains that the same middos can serve Hashem: chesed for the service of Hashem, gevurah for milchemes Hashem and zealotry where it is permitted, and pride in being a Jew. Or they can be spent on nonsense. There is no reshus, no neutral ground: since a Jew is meant to be batel to Hashem, anything not for Him is already in the realm of impurity.

19:04

His examples are a man who must have a fitting designer tie, someone who argues hard over trifles, and anger over nonsense. Tanya says the middos follow the measure of the intellect, so a child, whose mind is small, gets angry if someone upsets his blocks. h

Re'us ruach: breaking the connection

24:07

Pursuits that are not for Hashem, the Mashgiach explains, are 're'us ruach'. He shows it with a ball game: a pig's skin is cut, stitched and blown up with air, and two teams kick it while crowds shout, with nothing produced at all. A visitor who objects to the loud singing of Nishmas in the Mashgiach's beis medrash will pay for a ticket and scream over that pigskin. i

27:09

He reads 're'us' as breaking. Hashem gave a person a ruach that connects his neshamah to Him; such pursuits sever it, like snapping a wire that carries current.

The ice cream: two sides of the fence

29:35

'Sitra achra', the Mashgiach says, means the other side of the fence; one cannot serve Hashem and also have fun for its own sake. If someone feels down and eats ice cream to lift himself, with that intention it is a mitzvah. If he only wants to indulge, it is from the other side, because there is no reshus. A ball game for health, a measured amount of recreation for body and mind, is good; excess is from the sitra achra.

Holiness rests on what is batel

33:00

The Mashgiach explains that Hashem's holiness rests only on what is batel to Him. The angels are batel in fact, with no will of their own, like a machine run by its operator. Every Jew is batel at least in potential, even a sinner: throughout history Jews who committed terrible aveiros gave their lives with joy rather than serve avodah zarah.

Chalav akum and readiness for mesiras nefesh

36:13

The Mashgiach mentions that the Tzemach Tzedek writes of Jews who are not ready to give their lives, and turns to chalav akum. He discusses government-inspected milk in America, the view of Rav Moshe Feinstein in Igros Moshe, and the Chazon Ish regarding infants. j

39:06

He tells of a Rebbe who was served milk in a town, learned it was chalav akum and made himself bring it all up. He concludes that such things can dull a person's readiness for mesiras nefesh.

Avraham's inheritance and Fayvish the thief

41:36

This readiness, the Mashgiach explains, is an inheritance from Avraham Avinu: actual mesiras nefesh is found by him, at his first test and at the Akeidah, not by Yitzchak or Yaakov. Therefore, as the Ba'al HaTanya says, a Jew who sins is clothed in sitra achra while sinning, yet he himself remains holy, because he stands ready to die for Hashem. l

44:41

He tells that the Ba'al Shem Tov's daughter Adel said Hashem chose wisely: Fayvish, a thief sentenced to death, was offered his life if he converted and refused. Even those not ready, he adds, will run after Moshiach when his shofar sounds.

Questions: intention and Krias Shema

46:50

A listener asks about one who starts the ice cream for Hashem and gets carried away. The Mashgiach has no source at hand, but thinks the first intention carries, as with one who begins learning Gemara for the mitzvah and becomes absorbed in it. Likewise, the morning declaration of readiness for mesiras nefesh carries through the day.

50:05

Asked whether to picture actual death at Krias Shema, he says the sefarim say to imagine it, without calling the alternative unacceptable.

Sources

Torah

  1. e Shemos 26:7 text index In the write-up: 9:19
  2. g apparently Bamidbar 17:11-13 index In the write-up: 11:28

Kesuvim

  1. a Koheles 7:14 text index In the write-up: 0:00
  2. c Esther 9:7-9 text index In the write-up: 7:20
  3. i apparently Koheles 1:14 index In the write-up: 24:07

Talmud Bavli

  1. f apparently Kerisus 6a index In the write-up: 11:28
  2. k apparently Makkos 24a 42:10 index

Rishonim

  1. d apparently Rashi on Bereishis 8:4 index In the write-up: 9:19

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. b Tanya ch. 6 text index In the write-up: 0:00, 4:33
  2. h Tanya ch. 6 text index In the write-up: 19:04
  3. l apparently Tanya ch. 6 index In the write-up: 41:36
  4. m Toldos Yaakov Yosef (place not identified) 43:39 index

Other

  1. j Igros Moshe (place not identified) index In the write-up: 36:13

Key points

  1. 0:47 Opposite the ten holy powers of the soul there are ten powers of impurity from kelipas nogah, so a person can become a seat either for holiness or for impurity.
  2. 4:33 The powers of impurity are called 'crowns' because impurity has a sense of self and attributes greatness to itself.
  3. 9:19 The ten of impurity are not truly ten but nine or eleven; the number ten is reserved for holiness.
  4. 17:57 There is no neutral reshus: whatever is not done for the sake of Hashem belongs to the other side, the sitra achra.
  5. 33:00 Holiness rests only on what is batel to Hashem, and every Jew is batel to Hashem at least in potential.
  6. 41:36 The readiness of Jews to give their lives for Hashem is an inheritance from Avraham Avinu.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 4:33 Why does Tanya call the powers of impurity 'crowns', a word never used for the powers of holiness?

    Answer: 4:42 Because impurity is haughty: it has a sense of being and attributes greatness to itself.

  2. Question: 9:40 Why does Rashi work out exactly that the Teivah sank eleven amos into the water?

    Answer: 10:00 To show that the refuge of the Teivah reached down to the eleventh level, the number of impurity.

  3. Question: 13:53 Why does the list of ketores spices, which goes by weight, break its order to put kinnamon last?

    Answer: 14:33 To show that kinnamon, the lowest level, is both nine and eleven.

  4. Question: 46:46 A listener asks: if someone begins eating ice cream for the sake of Hashem and then gets carried away, was it impure from the start?

    Answer: 47:13 The Mashgiach has no source at hand but thinks the first intention carries over, as with someone who starts learning Gemara for the mitzvah and gets absorbed in its reasoning.

  5. Question: 50:05 At Krias Shema, should one actually picture dying for Hashem, or only be ready to?

    Answer: 50:16 The sefarim say one should actually imagine it, though the Mashgiach does not say it is unacceptable otherwise.

Stories

  1. 39:06 The Rebbe and the milk

    The Mashgiach tells a well-known story of a Rebbe who was given milk while visiting a town. When he found out it was chalav akum, he put his fingers down his throat and brought it all up.

  2. 44:41 Adel and Fayvish the thief

    The Ba'al Shem Tov's daughter Adel said that Hashem was clever to choose the Jewish people. There was a man named Fayvish, a thief who committed many aveiros. He was caught and sentenced to death, and told he would be spared if he converted, but he refused and gave his life. Adel said that if even a Fayvish the thief is ready to give his life for Hashem, Hashem chose wisely.

    In the story: Adel, daughter of the Baal Shem Tov, the Baal Shem Tov, Rabbi Yaakov Yosef of Polnoye (the Toldos), the Maggid of Mezritch

    told in 2 other shiurim →

Insights

  1. 4:33 Tanya uses the word 'crowns' only for the powers of impurity, never for holiness, because the essence of impurity is that it sees itself as something and claims greatness.
  2. 9:34 Impurity is always nine or eleven, never a true ten, which is why the Torah counts eleven amos for the Teivah, eleven goat-hair curtains and eleven spices of the ketores.
  3. 13:53 In the list of the ketores spices the order by weight is broken so that kinnamon comes last, making it both the ninth and the eleventh, the two numbers of impurity.
  4. 27:09 'Re'us ruach' means a breaking of the ruach: pursuits not done for Hashem cut the soul's connection to Him, like snapping a wire that carries current.
  5. 34:39 The proof that every Jew is batel to Hashem in potential is that even sinners have willingly given their lives rather than serve avodah zarah, as with Fayvish the thief.
  6. 41:48 Actual mesiras nefesh is found only by Avraham Avinu, not by Yitzchak or Yaakov, and Jews inherit their readiness to die for Hashem from him.

What the Mashgiach says to take from it

  1. 30:00 The Mashgiach says that eating ice cream because one feels down and needs a lift, with that intention, is a mitzvah, while eating it only to indulge belongs to the other side.
  2. 30:56 The Mashgiach says everyone needs a measured amount of recreation, such as a ball game, to keep body and mind healthy, and that done for this purpose it is good.
  3. 49:08 The Mashgiach says that the morning declaration of readiness to give one's life for Hashem carries through the rest of the day, even when the mind is busy with other things.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Adel, daughter of the Baal Shem Tov, Aharon HaKohen, Avraham Avinu, Haman, Rashi, Rav Moshe Feinstein, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Baal Shem Tov, the Chazon Ish, the Tzemach Tzedek

Terms ארבע יסודות, ביטול, זה לעומת זה, חלב עכו"ם, מדות, מסירות נפש, סטרא אחרא, עשר כתרין דמסאבותא, קטורת, קליפת נוגה, קריאת שמע

Report an error on this page