דברים בטלים - חילוק העונש בין עם הארץ ותלמיד חכם. ביאור גודל חטא של ביטול תורה וביאור ענין חכמת חיצוניות.
Catalog entry: TANYA ENGLISH ח no. 20 Pocket Guide p. 74 English 51 min
Listen
About this shiur
Learning Tanya chapter 8, the Mashgiach explains why bittul Torah and secular wisdom studied for its own sake are graver than idle talk, tracing secular wisdom to the fragments of the Breaking of the Vessels that remain within kelipas nogah.
Continuing Tanya chapter 8: forbidden speech belongs to the three impure kelipos and needs the 'hot laundry' of Gehinnom. An am ha'aretz who cannot learn and talks idle talk receives only a general punishment; today's irreligious Jews, who were never taught, are anusim and cannot be blamed. A talmid chacham who wastes his time, however, transgresses bittul Torah, which carries its own punishment. The Mashgiach contrasts Torah, learned lishmah, with secular wisdom, permitted only as a means, and explains why studying it for its own sake is worse than talk about baseball: it defiles the faculties of Chabad, not only the middos. Drawing on the Ramchal and the kings of Edom, he traces secular wisdom to the Breaking of the Vessels: fragments of great lights within kelipas nogah, which can be raised to holiness. He ends with the Rambam and Ramban, Torah immunity and the Chazon Ish.
Topics: The Two Souls (Tanya ch. 1-8) · Kedushah and Kelipah · Torah Lishmah and Hasmadah · Tzimtzum, the Worlds and the Merkavah
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Idle talk: the am ha'aretz and the talmid chacham listed in the guide
The Mashgiach reviews that forbidden speech belongs to the three impure kelipos and needs Gehinnom to cleanse it. He explains that an am ha'aretz who cannot learn is punished only generally, that today's untaught Jews are anusim who cannot be blamed for the delay of the redemption, and that a talmid chacham who talks idly transgresses bittul Torah.
-
6:13 The special punishment for bittul Torah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that the kaf hakela, where two angels toss the soul back and forth, is not enough to cleanse bittul Torah; it is a positive commandment like others, yet worse, so it has a special punishment beyond the general one. He contrasts the Gehinnom of fire, for active sins that generate heat, with the Gehinnom of snow, for passive failure to do mitzvos.
-
9:40 Torah lishmah versus secular wisdom as a means listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Tanya's distinction: Torah must be learned lishmah and not as a tool, while secular wisdom may be learned only shelo lishmah, for a purpose such as medicine or a livelihood. Learning it to become wise, like the Greek philosophers, is forbidden, and for a talmid chacham it is worse because he could have learned Torah.
-
12:55 Why secular wisdom is worse than baseball talk listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains why studying secular wisdom is worse than idle talk about baseball. Such talk is empty and comes from a passion in the middos, so it defiles only the middos of the animal soul, whereas wisdom with real substance defiles Chabad, which is above the middos, and the blemish is far greater.
-
17:40 The Breaking of the Vessels and the kings of Edom listed in the guide
Citing the Ramchal in Derech Hashem, the Mashgiach explains that Hashem's light was too great for the vessels, which cracked, and their fragments became the kelipos. He reads the kings of Edom at the end of Vayishlach: of the first seven it says 'he died', while of the eighth, Hadar, it does not, and his wife is named; he illustrates the pattern of giver and receiver with the image of a fern.
-
24:19 Giver and receiver: fragments of Chabad listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that all of creation is built on giver and receiver, male and female, in time, space and soul. When the vessels, the receivers, were too small they broke; with Hadar a wife is named, a world with vessels that could receive and endure. The kelipos formed from the earlier worlds come from very great lights, so secular wisdom is the fallen fragments of Chabad.
-
29:07 Greek wisdom, kelipas nogah and Chanukah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that secular wisdom is not from the three impure kelipos but from kelipas nogah, and can be used for good. Greek wisdom was wisdom for its own sake and defiled the 'oils', which are Chabad; its basic principle of not accepting what one cannot understand is fear, not science. Yavan oppressed the Jews in Eretz Yisrael, and Chanukah's mehadrin min hamehadrin relates to Hadar, the eighth king.
-
35:02 Questions on the purpose of the Breaking
Answering listeners' questions, the Mashgiach compares the Breaking of the Vessels to a hava amina in the Gemara, which has holiness even though it is rejected, and says its purpose was to create a world of free choice. The kelipah keeps only a residue of life, which Hashem wants it to have, and he connects this to drinking on Purim; the true reason for the Breaking will be known when Moshiach comes.
-
39:54 The Tanya's words and the Rambam and Ramban listed in the guide
The Mashgiach reads the Tanya's lines that secular wisdom defiles the Chabad of the G-dly soul and is from kelipas nogah, so it can still serve holiness. He explains why the Rambam and Ramban engaged in it, to bring out the beauty of the Torah, and stresses that the Tanya names them because only someone great in Torah is protected from its harm.
-
43:57 Immunity before approaching secular wisdom listed in the guide
The Mashgiach compares the higher, more dangerous kelipah of secular wisdom to the nations whose land is off limits now, since overcoming it needs greater strength than the middos. Only people like the Rambam and Ramban were immunized; even innocent subjects like medicine are taught today mixed with heresy such as evolution, so one must be well prepared.
-
47:24 Wisdom from the Torah: the Chazon Ish listed in the guide
The Mashgiach says the Gedolei Yisrael knew the sciences from the Torah, as the Ramban writes in his introduction, and tells how great neurosurgeons consulted the Chazon Ish, who mapped out brain surgery and said he knew it from the Torah. He closes by answering a listener's question about Hadar, the eighth king.
The shiur, written up
Idle talk: the am ha'aretz and the talmid chacham
Continuing Tanya chapter 8, the Mashgiach recalls that desires from kelipas nogah can be elevated, while forbidden speech belongs to the three impure kelipos and needs Gehinnom, a 'hot laundry' with strong cleaning agents, to cleanse the stain. A person who simply cannot learn and talks about baseball receives only a general punishment for not learning. a
The Mashgiach asks why Moshiach does not come when the time seems ripe, and rejects blaming the irreligious: they were never taught, do not even know Shema Yisrael, and are anusim. He cites the Gemara that one who does not recite Krias Shema is an am ha'aretz, and the Rambam that such people cannot be blamed. If anyone is to blame, the Mashgiach says, it is those who know; a talmid chacham who talks idly transgresses bittul Torah. b
The special punishment for bittul Torah
For bittul Torah, the Mashgiach explains, the kaf hakela is not enough. It is a positive commandment like others, but worse, since Torah leads to everything, so it carries its own punishment. The Gehinnom of fire answers active sins, because action generates heat; the Gehinnom of snow answers a cold, passive failure to do a mitzvah.
Torah lishmah versus secular wisdom as a means
The Mashgiach brings the Tanya's distinction: Torah must be learned lishmah, not as a hatchet to chop with, while secular wisdom may be learned only as a means, such as medicine to help people or computer science to support a family. Studying it to be wise, like the Greek philosophers, is forbidden, and for a talmid chacham it is worse, since he could have learned Torah. a,c
Why secular wisdom is worse than baseball talk
The Mashgiach explains why such study is worse than arguing about who will win the pennant. Baseball talk is empty and comes from a passion of the middos, so it defiles only the middos. Secular wisdom has real substance and engages Chabad, which is above the middos, so the blemish is much greater.
He illustrates: the fan screaming when his team hits a home run expresses pride from the middos of his animal soul, while intellectual pursuits draw on Chabad, which an am ha'aretz's small talk never touches.
The Breaking of the Vessels and the kings of Edom
To explain the Tanya's next words, the Mashgiach turns to the Ramchal in Derech Hashem on the 'kings'. When Hashem began creating, His light was too much to tolerate, like looking at the sun without dark glass, so He made tzimtzumim. At first a surge of light came into vessels too small; they cracked, and the fragments fell and became the kelipos. d
Giver and receiver: fragments of Chabad
Giver and receiver run through time, space and soul: summer gives and winter lives from it; rebbe and talmid; male and female; even positive and negative in electricity. When the light came and the vessels were too small, they broke, which is why kiddush is made over a whole vessel. By Hadar there was already a receiver, a new creation that endured.
These kelipos therefore come from very great lights, from before this world was built. Secular wisdom is the fallen fragments of Chabad, from a high level.
Greek wisdom, kelipas nogah and Chanukah
Unlike other kelipos, secular wisdom is not from the three impure kelipos and can be tilted to holiness when used to heal or to understand Torah better. Greek wisdom, though, was wisdom for its own sake, and so the Greeks defiled the 'oils', which are Chabad. Of the four kingdoms, the sefarim tie Yavan to kelipas nogah.
Greek philosophy's first principle, still held by scientists, accepts only what can be shown in a test tube. The Mashgiach calls this fear, not science: a real scientist knows there are things he cannot understand.
Questions on the purpose of the Breaking
Asked why holiness was meant to come and then scattered, the Mashgiach compares the Breaking to a hava amina in the Gemara, which holds holiness though rejected. Hashem gave existence to something without substance to create a world of free choice, with tumah and kelipah too.
He cites the Arizal that this is why we cannot return to Mitzrayim: what holiness could be extracted has been, and only a residue of life remains, which Hashem wants to exist. This is why one drinks on Purim, to bless even Haman. The true reason for the Breaking will be known when Moshiach comes. h
The Tanya's words and the Rambam and Ramban
The Mashgiach reads the Tanya: secular wisdom defiles the Chabad of the G-dly soul, but it is kelipas nogah, from the fragments of the Breaking, so it can still serve holiness. This is why the Rambam and Ramban engaged in it, using it, in the Rambam's expression, as cooks and kitchen maids to bring out the beauty of the Torah. a
Immunity before approaching secular wisdom
The seven nations correspond to the middos, as the Lubliner explains, while three more are off limits now; secular wisdom is harder to overcome than the middos, needing greater strength. Only the Rambam, Ramban and their like were immunized; even medicine is taught today with heresy such as evolution thrown in, so one must be prepared.
Wisdom from the Torah: the Chazon Ish
The Gedolei Yisrael knew the sciences from the Torah, as the Ramban writes in his introduction. People still remember great neurosurgeons consulting the Chazon Ish, who mapped out where to cut and said he had learned it in the Torah. The Mashgiach closes by answering a question on Hadar, the eighth king. i
Sources
Torah
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 2:13 An am ha'aretz who cannot learn receives only the general punishment for idle talk, but a talmid chacham who wastes his time transgresses bittul Torah, which has a special punishment of its own.
- 9:47 Torah must be learned lishmah, for its own sake, while secular wisdom is permitted only as a means, such as medicine to heal people or a skill to earn a livelihood, never for the sake of the wisdom itself.
- 12:55 Studying secular wisdom for its own sake is worse than idle talk such as baseball, because idle talk comes from the middos while secular wisdom defiles Chabad, the higher faculties of the soul.
- 28:25 Secular wisdom comes from fragments of Chabad that fell in the Breaking of the Vessels; it belongs to kelipas nogah and can therefore be raised to holiness.
- 43:16 Only those with great Torah attainment, like the Rambam and Ramban, are immune to the harm in secular wisdom and may use it for Torah; the Gedolei Yisrael knew such wisdom from the Torah itself.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 3:15 If the time is ripe for the redemption, why doesn't Moshiach come; is it because of the irreligious Jews?
Answer: 3:46 No: they were never taught and are anusim who cannot be blamed; if anyone is to be blamed, it is those who know.
-
Question: 12:49 Why is studying secular wisdom worse than idle talk about baseball?
Answer: 13:33 Idle talk comes from the middos and defiles them, while secular wisdom defiles Chabad, which is above the middos.
-
Question: 21:06 Why does the Torah name the wife of Hadar, the eighth king, and not say 'he died' of him as of the other seven?
Answer: 26:51 Because by the eighth king there was already a receiver, a vessel able to receive the light, so that world endured.
-
Question: 35:11 If holiness was meant to come into the world, why was there a Breaking that scattered it?
Answer: 35:24 Like a hava amina in the Gemara, it gave existence to something without substance, to create a world of free choice with tumah and kelipah.
Stories
-
48:45 The Chazon Ish and the brain surgeons
The Mashgiach relates that there are people today who still remember that great professors, neurologists and neurosurgeons, used to consult the Chazon Ish on how to perform brain surgery. He mapped out for them exactly where to cut, and they listened to him. Asked how he knew all this, he said that he had learned it from the Torah.
In the story: the Chazon Ish
Insights
- 7:34 The Gehinnom of fire answers active sins, since every action needs energy and generates heat, while the Gehinnom of snow answers the passive failure to do a mitzvah, a coldness in which no heat was generated for a mitzvah.
- 13:26 Idle talk about baseball comes from a passion of the middos and defiles only them, but substantive secular wisdom defiles Chabad, the soul's intellect, which is above the middos; this is why the more serious study is the greater blemish.
- 27:57 Secular wisdom is a kelipah precisely because it comes from very great lights: the vessels could not receive them and broke, and the fallen fragments of Chabad became this wisdom.
- 23:25 The wife's name given only for Hadar, the eighth king, shows that a receiver had now come into being alongside the giver, so that world could endure, unlike the seven kings of whom it says 'he died'.
- 31:26 The founding principle of Greek philosophy, still held by scientists, that one does not accept what one cannot understand, is not science but fear; a real scientist who delves into creation knows better than anyone that there are things he cannot understand.
- 34:07 Chanukah's unique mehadrin min hamehadrin, found by no other mitzvah, is tied to Hadar, the eighth king who did not die, because the wisdom of Yavan is not a total kelipah and can return to holiness.
- 35:24 The Breaking of the Vessels is like a hava amina in the Gemara, which holds holiness even though it is rejected: Hashem gave existence to something without substance so that the world would be one of free choice.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 3:04 The Mashgiach says that if anyone is to be blamed for the delay of the redemption, it is those who know and are not doing the right thing, not the untaught Jews.
- 43:32 The Mashgiach says one should first learn Torah and attain a great grasp of it; only then, using secular wisdom for a livelihood or another purpose, is one equipped against its harm.
- 46:35 The Mashgiach warns that even innocent subjects like medicine are taught today with heresy thrown in, so one must be careful and adequately prepared before learning them.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Hadar, Moshe Rabbeinu, the Arizal, the Chazon Ish, the Rambam, the Ramban, the Ramchal (Rabbi Moshe Chaim Luzzatto)
Terms ביטול תורה, גיהנום, דברים בטלים, הוה אמינא, חב"ד, לשמה, משפיע ומקבל, נפש הבהמית, עם הארץ, קליפת נוגה, שבירת הכלים, שלש קליפות הטמאות