ביאור האיך התאוות באים מהלב אל המח. מלחמת שני מלכים על הגוף.
Catalog entry: TANYA ENGLISH ט no. 21 Pocket Guide p. 75 English 53 min
Listen
About this shiur
Learning Tanya chapter 9, the Mashgiach explains that desires rise from the heart's left chamber to the mind while holiness starts in the mind and comes down to the heart, and that the two souls wage war like two kings over the small city of the body.
The Mashgiach reviews the two inclinations and reads Tanya chapter 9: the animal soul sits in the blood of the heart's left chamber. With the example of a person who sees an ice cream, he shows that desire begins in the heart and sends the mind to carry it out, while love and fear of Hashem must begin with the mind contemplating Hashem's greatness and only then move the heart. He supports this from the contrast between David speaking to his heart and Haman speaking in his heart, and explains the prohibition of blood as not strengthening one's own animal soul. He then shows the same order in the blessings before Krias Shema, discusses why the Tanya places anger last and how rarely anger is truly for Heaven, and describes the war of the two kings over the body, with Avraham and the four kings and the war against chametz. He ends with the godly soul's wish to rule alone and the pleasure that lies in the mind.
Topics: Tzaddik, Beinoni and Rasha (Tanya ch. 9-17) · The Two Souls (Tanya ch. 1-8) · Ahavas Hashem and Dveikus · The Yetzer Hara and Nisyonos
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 The animal soul seated in the left chamber listed in the guide
The Mashgiach reviews the godly soul and the yetzer hara and begins Tanya chapter 9: the animal soul is in the heart's left chamber, in the blood that carries biological life. He recalls that the midos are called 'double' since they can serve good or bad, and asks why the intellect is not called so.
-
6:25 Desire rises from heart to mind listed in the guide
With the example of a person who sees an ice cream, the Mashgiach explains that desire starts in the heart and the mind only implements it, while love and fear of Hashem must start with the mind and trickle down to the heart's right chamber. A listener asks about the drive for secular wisdom, and the Mashgiach says most intellectual pursuit comes from pride.
-
13:23 David's heart, Haman's heart, and the blood listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Midrash contrasting David, who spoke to his heart, with Haman, who spoke in his heart, and Rashi on Beshalach and Yisro, to show that the wicked begin with the heart and the righteous with the mind. He then explains the prohibition of blood: the blood is the soul, and eating it would strengthen one's own animal soul. He wonders why the Tanya changes the order of the midos and leaves it for later.
-
19:29 The godly soul in the brain listed in the guide
Continuing the Tanya, the Mashgiach explains that the desires rise from the heart to the brain only to be implemented, while the godly soul's seat is the brain, which he connects to the tefillin of the head and of the arm. Love of Hashem burns in the right chamber like flames, but it comes from deep thought in the mind, since the mind itself is cold logic.
-
24:13 The order of the blessings before Shema listed in the guide
The Mashgiach shows the same order in davening: the blessing of Yotzer describes the vast creation and the awe of the angels, which brings fear, then Ahavah Rabbah brings love, and only then comes Shema. He brings a remark of the Rebbe Rashab that by Ahavah Rabbah the angels are no longer mentioned, and adds that contemplating Hashem's glory brings joy of the heart.
-
27:58 Why anger is placed last
The Mashgiach suggests that the Tanya, being about avodas Hashem, first lists the midos the mind stimulates for good and puts anger at the end, since anger is rarely a tool for serving Hashem. In a discussion with listeners he says anger purely for Heaven is reserved for very special people, and that anger at others usually hides insecurity or pride in one's own group.
-
34:56 Two kings and the small city listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that each of the two powers strives to conquer the other, and reads the body as the small city of Koheles with 248 inhabitants, over which two kings wage war. He links this to Avraham's war with the four kings as the four klipos, and to Pesach, bringing the Radbaz's answer to Tosafos' question why chametz is treated so strictly: chametz is the yetzer hara.
-
41:31 The godly soul wants to rule alone listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains the godly soul's wish that all the limbs be under its discipline and nullified to it, like a beast of burden to its owner and, more, like a chariot to its rider. It wants not even a passing thought for the other king, as Edom refused even to let Israel pass through its land.
-
46:50 Overflowing love and the pleasure of the mind listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that the intellectual fear and the love that come from the mind should fill the heart's right chamber until it overflows into the left and conquers it, as David did. He describes Ahavah Rabbah and the higher love of delight, whose source is the pleasure of the mind in grasping a deep idea, and discusses with a listener how this differs from the satisfaction of accomplishment, with the example of a man alone on an island.
The shiur, written up
The animal soul seated in the left chamber
The Mashgiach recalls that the Tanya has shown that a Jew's yetzer tov is more than an inclination: it is a godly soul, a part of G-d above, while the yetzer hara opposes it and both contend over how the person will behave. To understand how this works, Tanya chapter 9 gives the location of each. a
The animal soul, from klipas nogah, sits in the left chamber of the heart, the larger chamber that pumps blood through the whole body. The physical blood is the seat of the yetzer hara, the pursuit of biological drives that people share with animals. These drives are necessary to exist in this world, but they must be used with holiness. a
Desire rises from heart to mind
The Mashgiach explains that people stay alive not because they decide to, but because they want to eat and sleep; this is Hashem's device for keeping the world going. A person sees an ice cream and his heart wants it, so it sends a message up to the mind, and the mind works out how to get it: to buy, borrow or even steal it.
In holiness it is the other way around. Nobody naturally desires to learn or daven; it starts with the mind, cold logic, contemplating Hashem's greatness, and this trickles down to the right chamber of the heart, which is stirred with love and fear of Hashem. Asked about the drive for secular wisdom, the Mashgiach says most intellectual pursuit comes from pride.
David's heart, Haman's heart, and the blood
The Mashgiach brings the Midrash: of David it says he spoke to his heart, while of Haman it says he spoke in his heart. For the tzaddik the message is sent to the heart; for the rasha it starts in the heart and the mind then carries it out. He points to the same contrast in Rashi on the Egyptians at the sea and on Yisrael at Sinai, where the order is reversed. c,d,e,f,g
The godly soul in the brain
Continuing in the Tanya, the Mashgiach notes that desires originate in the heart and only rise to the brain to be implemented, while the godly soul's seat is the brain, which he links to the tefillin of the head and of the arm. Love of Hashem burns in the heart like flames, yet it comes from those who think deeply, since the mind has no emotions; its grasp of Hashem's greatness trickles down and kindles the heart. a
The order of the blessings before Shema
The Mashgiach shows this order in davening. The blessing of Yotzer describes the vast universe, the angels and their awe, and from that fear is built; then Ahavah Rabbah brings love. The Rebbe Rashab remarked that there the angels are no longer mentioned, since Yisrael stands higher. Only with fear and love does one say Shema, and contemplating Hashem's glory brings joy of the heart. k
Why anger is placed last
Returning to his question, the Mashgiach suggests that since the Tanya is concerned with avodas Hashem, it first lists the midos the mind stimulates for good and relegates anger to the end, because anger is rarely a tool for serving Hashem, and when needed it is imitation anger. He adds that one must be careful with it.
When listeners speak of hating the ways of others, the Mashgiach says pure anger for Heaven is reserved for very special people. A person can deceive himself; such anger usually reflects insecurity, or the pride of thinking that one's own Rebbe and crowd are better and others dare suggest they are wrong.
Two kings and the small city
The godly soul wants to rule alone
The godly soul wants all the limbs under its discipline and nullified to it: not only obeying, like a beast of burden toiling for its owner, but like a chariot with no will of its own before its rider.
Overflowing love and the pleasure of the mind
Intellectual fear and love from the mind should fill the heart's right chamber until it overflows into the left, extinguishing its fire and occupying it like a king taking enemy territory, as David did with his yetzer. Beyond Ahavah Rabbah is the higher love of delight, rooted in the mind's pleasure. r
Asked whether accomplishing a goal is the same pleasure, the Mashgiach says it can come from pride. Pure intellectual pleasure is solving a problem alone on an island; running to tell a friend shows it is already mixed.
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Midrash
- c Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 13:26
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 1:59 The animal soul and the yetzer hara are seated in the blood of the heart's left chamber, which carries the body's biological life.
- 7:58 Physical desire starts in the heart and sends a message up to the mind, which only works out how to get what the heart wants.
- 8:56 In holiness the order is reversed: nobody naturally desires to learn or daven, so it must begin with the mind contemplating Hashem's greatness, which then brings love and fear into the heart.
- 16:29 Blood is forbidden even where it is not brought on the altar, because the blood is the soul, and eating it would add to a person's own animal soul.
- 36:33 The two souls are two kings waging war over the body, a small city of 248 inhabitants, each wanting all the limbs to follow its rule.
- 42:16 The godly soul wants to rule alone, with the body as nullified to it as a chariot to its rider, so that not even a passing thought serves the other side.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 5:49 If the intellect can also serve good or bad, why are only the midos called 'double'?
Answer: 11:44 Because the yetzer hara never originates in the mind but in the heart; the heart has two sides, so the midos are the double ones.
-
Question: 16:31 Why is blood forbidden even from wild animals and birds, which are not brought on the altar?
Answer: 16:58 Because of the second reason, that the blood is the soul: eating it would add the animal's soul to one's own animal soul and reinforce it.
-
Question: 18:37 Why does the Tanya change the order of the midos and place anger at the end?
Answer: 28:00 Possibly because the Tanya is concerned with avodas Hashem, so it first speaks of what the mind stimulates for good, and anger is not an important tool for serving Hashem.
-
Question: 40:12 Why are we so stringent with chametz, more than with any other prohibition?
Answer: 40:52 The Radbaz answers that chametz is the yetzer hara, and the war against it is waged with full determination.
-
Question: 51:04 A listener asks whether the pleasure of accomplishing a goal is not the same as the pleasure of the mind.
Answer: 51:20 The Mashgiach says accomplishment can come from pride; pure intellectual pleasure is what one feels solving a problem with nobody to tell.
Insights
- 6:47 The animal soul is what keeps creatures, people included, alive: people do not live because they decide to, but because natural desires to eat and sleep drive them, and this is Hashem's device to keep the world going.
- 14:50 Rashi's description of Mitzrayim and of Yisrael at Sinai uses the same phrases in reverse order: for the yetzer hara the heart comes first and then the person, for the yetzer tov the mind comes first and then the heart.
- 24:17 The order of the blessings of Krias Shema mirrors the Tanya: contemplating creation and the angels' awe produces fear, then love, and only with both does one say Shema; at Ahavah Rabbah the angels are no longer mentioned, since Israel stands higher.
- 31:18 Anger at people who live differently usually reveals insecurity about one's own path, or pride in one's Rebbe and crowd, rather than true zeal for Heaven.
- 40:19 The Radbaz answers why chametz is treated so strictly with searching and destroying: chametz is the yetzer hara, and in the war against it one goes with full determination.
- 50:27 The source of pleasure is in the mind: true intellectual delight is what one feels solving a problem alone on an island, while rushing to tell a friend shows the pleasure is already mixed with something else.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 29:32 The Mashgiach says one has to be careful with using anger in avodas Hashem, since a person can deceive himself into thinking his anger is for holiness when a personal motive is mixed in.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Dovid HaMelech, Esav, Haman, Rashi, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Baalei Tosafos, the Radbaz, the Rebbe Rashab (Rabbi Sholom Dovber of Lubavitch), Yaakov Avinu
Terms אהבה בתענוגים, אהבה רבה, חלל השמאלי, חלק אלוק ממעל, חמץ, יצר הרע, יצר טוב, כעס, נפש האלקית, נפש הבהמית, קליפת נוגה, רמ"ח אברים, תענוג