רצון הנפש האלוקות הוא שהגוף יהיה בטל לה לגמרי. חילוק בין אהבה עזה לאהבה רבה. רצון הפנימי של היצה"ר הוא שיהיה מנוצח.

Catalog entry: TANYA ENGLISH ט no. ⁨22⁩ Pocket Guide p. 75 English 1 hr 2 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 1 hr 2 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Mashgiach's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

Learning Tanya chapter nine, the Mashgiach explains that the G-dly soul wants the whole body to be utterly nullified to it, distinguishes strong love (ahavah azah) from great love (ahavah rabbah), and shows that the inner wish of the yetzer hara is to be conquered.

The Mashgiach rereads the end of Tanya chapter nine, opening with the verse in Koheles about a small city besieged by a great king and saved by a poor wise man: the city is the body, and the two souls are two kings fighting over it. The G-dly soul wants every limb to be nullified to it like a pen to the writer or a chariot to its rider, with mind, heart, speech and action given over to Hashem. He explains that the right chamber of the heart should overflow into the left and transform its desires, and distinguishes passing strong love from great love, a delight felt in the mind itself. He describes tzaddikim whose every word and movement served Hashem, with examples from Daniel, Yosef, Pharaoh's reversed heart, the Satmar Rav, the Arizal and the Maggid. He ends with the Zohar's parable showing that the yetzer hara's inner wish is to be overcome.

Topics: Tzaddik, Beinoni and Rasha (Tanya ch. 9-17) · Ahavas Hashem and Dveikus · The Yetzer Hara and Nisyonos · Anavah and Bittul

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 The small city in Koheles

    The Mashgiach starts the page over and reads the verse in Koheles about a small city besieged by a great king and saved by a poor wise man whom nobody remembers. He explains that the city is the body and the poor wise man is the good inclination.

  2. 4:37 Two kings and the nullified body listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains the Tanya's image of the two souls as two kings warring over the body. The G-dly soul wants every limb nullified to it like a pen to the writer and a chariot to its rider, and the three chambers of the mind filled with understanding of Hashem's greatness that gives birth to fear and love.

  3. 10:43 The right chamber overflows into the left listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains the ultimate level: the yetzer hara driven out entirely, so that the love in the right chamber of the heart burns like a flame and overflows into the left chamber, overpowering and transforming its desires into love of Hashem, as in serving Hashem with both inclinations.

  4. 15:30 Ahavah azah and ahavah rabbah listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach distinguishes strong love, which comes and goes, from great love, which fills the heart and leaves no room for the yetzer hara. He explains that usually the mind arouses the heart, but in ahavah rabbah the mind itself feels a delight in grasping Hashem, like the thrill of solving a hard problem, and this transforms all the emotions.

  5. 24:41 Tzaddikim who speak only to Hashem

    The Mashgiach describes tzaddikim who feel no worldly pleasure and whose speech, even to people, is directed to Hashem. He notes that the Tanya is a book for beinonim, who should still know what a tzaddik is, and brings Daniel speaking to the king and Yosef's brothers' plea as words that were really addressed to Hashem, a holy language Pharaoh could not learn.

  6. 30:20 Pharaoh's heart was liver

    The Mashgiach explains how Pharaoh withstood plague after plague: the process ran in reverse, the left chamber overflowing into the right. He brings the Midrash on 'kaved lev Paroh' with the parable of the lion, the donkey and the fox, and explains that the liver is the seat of the yetzer hara, while a tzaddik's heart is a real heart.

  7. 35:46 The Satmar Rav: a rasha has no heart

    The Mashgiach brings a vort he heard from the Satmar Rav on 'all hearts fear You'. He explains that Hashem has no body, but the eye, mouth and heart said of Hashem are powers, and man, made in the image of G-d, has physical organs that are a likeness of them; a rasha's heart and eye do not deserve the name, since they do not do what a heart and eye are for.

  8. 43:50 Tzaddikim beyond their generation

    The Mashgiach returns to the perfect tzaddik whose whole day is bound to Hashem and explains that, though generations decline, sometimes a soul of earlier times is sent down, as with the Arizal, the Ba'al Shem Tov and his talmidim, and even the Vilna Gaon. He tells of the Maggid, who noticed a moved snuffbox and who held his hand still for hours because he found no holy reason to move it.

  9. 52:26 The yetzer hara wants to be conquered listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that the yetzer hara, though the opposite of the G-dly soul, is for a person's good: its inner wish is to be conquered. He brings the Zohar's parable of the king who hired a harlot to test his son, and explains the angel of Esav fighting Yaakov on the night before his turn to sing shirah: his shirah was to be overpowered, just as the sun's shirah is its motion, which is why Yehoshua told it to be silent.

  10. 58:10 Questions: a bigger tzaddik, a bigger yetzer

    Listeners ask questions about the decline of the generations and the yetzer hara of a tzaddik. The Mashgiach answers that there must always be a balance, so a bigger tzaddik has a bigger yetzer, until he reaches the level of David, who said his heart was hollow within him.

The shiur, written up

The small city in Koheles

0:09

Having gone quickly down the page the week before, the Mashgiach starts it over for the sake of continuity. He opens with the verse in Koheles where Shlomo HaMelech describes a small city with few people, besieged by a great king who built fortresses around it, and saved by a poor wise man whom nobody afterwards remembered or listened to, because he was poor. The city, he explains, is the body, and the poor wise man is the good inclination. a

Two kings and the nullified body

4:37

The Tanya in chapter nine takes up this verse: the body is the small city, and the G-dly soul and the animal soul, the source of all lusts, are two kings waging war over it, each wanting to rule it alone. The G-dly soul wants every limb to be nullified to it without even asking why, as the Mashgiach explains with a pen: it does not argue with the writer about what to write. Likewise a chariot has no will of its own apart from its rider. b

8:53

It also wants no stranger to enter, and the three chambers of the mind to be filled with understanding of Hashem's infinite greatness, so that chochmah and binah, through da'as, give birth to fear and then love. b

The right chamber overflows into the left

10:49

The ultimate in serving Hashem, the Mashgiach explains, is to be void of the yetzer hara altogether. With nothing but the G-dly soul, the love would burn like a flame, since nothing would extinguish it. The love in the right chamber of the heart should fill to overflowing until it spills into the left chamber, the yetzer hara's place, overpowers its evil, and transforms its desires into love of Hashem.

14:56

This, he says, should at least be a person's ambition: to love Hashem with both chambers, as Chazal say, with both inclinations. c

Ahavah azah and ahavah rabbah

15:40

The Mashgiach distinguishes two levels. Ahavah azah, a strong love, is a burst that servants of Hashem feel from time to time; while it lasts it is strong, but it can subside. Ahavah rabbah, great love, fills the heart to the brim, so that no place is left for the yetzer hara in the left chamber.

17:00

To explain why it is higher, he recalls the previous chapters: in holiness the mind arouses the heart, while in impurity the heart's desires send up their vapors and the mind devises ways to satisfy them. Ahavah rabbah is something new: the mind itself becomes the seat of feeling. When a person finally solves a hard problem, the Mashgiach says, it is like a bolt of lightning, a delight greater than the heart can feel.

21:42

This love of delight needs nothing physical; it is like the pleasure souls have in the World to Come in grasping Hashem. Even ahavah azah carries a physical pleasure of the heart, but this delight of the mind transforms all the emotions to Hashem alone.

Tzaddikim who speak only to Hashem

24:41

Such a person has no pleasure from this world; great tzaddikim did not even feel the taste of their food. The Mashgiach notes that this seems foreign to us, but the Tanya, a book for beinonim, wants them at least to know what a tzaddik is. d

27:13

Even when great tzaddikim spoke to people, their words were directed to Hashem. As the Rama MiPano explains, Daniel spoke to the king while really addressing Hashem, and the Midrash says the plea to Yosef was really a plea to Hashem. This is the holy tongue, which only those with ruach hakodesh can speak, and which Pharaoh, master of seventy languages, could not learn. e

Pharaoh's heart was liver

30:45

How did Pharaoh withstand plague after plague? In him, the Mashgiach explains, the process ran in reverse: the left chamber overflowed into the right.

32:47

On "kaved lev Paroh", kaved meaning liver, the Midrash tells of a lion who tore apart a donkey that demanded toll even from the king. The fox ate the heart, and told the king that a donkey with a heart would never have spoken so. The Mashgiach explains that the liver is the yetzer hara's seat; Pharaoh's heart was only liver, while a tzaddik's heart is a real heart. f,g

The Satmar Rav: a rasha has no heart

35:46

The Mashgiach brings a vort he heard from the Satmar Rav on the words "all hearts shall fear You": many hearts do not fear Hashem. To explain it he says that Hashem has no body, as the Rambam teaches, and cannot even be imagined as a ball of fire. h

37:13

When Tanach speaks of "the eyes of Hashem" or of His heart, these are powers through which He appears in this world. Since man is created in the image of G-d, he has physical organs that hold a likeness of those powers: the eye to know what is happening, the mouth to convey the content of the heart, the heart for will and emotion. i,j,k

42:57

Returning to the Satmar Rav, the Mashgiach explains that every eye looks to Hashem and every heart fears Him, but a rasha's eye and heart do not deserve those names. h

Tzaddikim beyond their generation

44:26

The G-dly soul wants a person's conversation all day to be with Hashem, so that even speaking to the mailman he is speaking to Hashem. Such perfect tzaddikim were seen in recent generations against the order of the generations. As the Gemara says, the generations grow smaller, but sometimes a soul from earlier times is sent down. l

45:59

Rabbi Chaim Vital writes that the Arizal, who lived after the Rishonim, grasped more than them. So too the Ba'al Shem Tov and his talmidim; and the Litvaks say that the Vilna Gaon could argue with Rishonim. The Mashgiach adds that great-grandparents still saw such tzaddikim seventy or eighty years ago.

49:51

Their hands, too, did only mitzvos. The Maggid noticed that a visitor's child had moved his snuffbox, since everything he put down was where it belonged, and once kept his hand behind his back for hours despite the pain, having found no holy reason to move it.

The yetzer hara wants to be conquered

52:42

The animal soul's wishes are the opposite, yet still for a person's good: the yetzer hara's deep wish is that a person master it. The Zohar's parable tells of a king who hired a harlot to test his son; she was in the king's service, and so is the yetzer hara. m

54:50

So too the angel of Esav, who wrestled Yaakov and could not prevail, picked the fight on the night before his turn to sing shirah. His shirah was to be overpowered, since every creature's shirah is its function. Thus when Yehoshua told the sun to be silent, the sun stopped its shirah. n,o

A bigger tzaddik, a bigger yetzer

1:01:05

Answering a question, the Mashgiach says there must always be a balance: the bigger the tzaddik, the bigger his yetzer, or the yetzer would be no match for him, until he reaches David's level of "my heart is hollow within me". q

Sources

Torah

  1. f Shemos 7:14 text index In the write-up: 32:47
  2. j apparently Bereishis 8:21 index In the write-up: 37:13
  3. k Bereishis 1:27 text index In the write-up: 37:13
  4. n Bereishis 32:26 text index In the write-up: 54:50

Nevi'im

  1. o Yehoshua 10:12 text index In the write-up: 54:50

Kesuvim

  1. a Koheles 9:13-15 text index In the write-up: 0:09
  2. i Tehillim 33:18 text index In the write-up: 37:13
  3. q Tehillim 109:22 text index In the write-up: 1:01:05

Mishnah

  1. c Berachos 54a text index In the write-up: 14:56

Talmud Bavli

  1. l Gemara (place not identified) index In the write-up: 44:26

Midrash

  1. e Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 27:13
  2. g Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 32:47
  3. p Midrash (place not identified) 56:56

Zohar and Kabbalah

  1. m Zohar (place not identified) index In the write-up: 52:42

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. b apparently Tanya ch. 9 index In the write-up: 4:37, 8:53
  2. d apparently Tanya, title page index In the write-up: 24:41

Tefillah and Piyut

  1. h Nishmas prayer (place not identified) index In the write-up: 35:46, 42:57

Key points

  1. 4:37 The small city in Koheles is the body, and the G-dly soul and the animal soul are two kings each fighting to rule it alone.
  2. 7:07 The G-dly soul wants every limb to be nullified to it without asking why, like a pen to the writer or a chariot to its rider.
  3. 15:40 Ahavah azah is a strong love that can come and go, while ahavah rabbah fills the heart to the brim so that no room is left for the yetzer hara.
  4. 20:06 Ahavah rabbah is a delight felt in the mind itself, higher than any feeling of the heart, like the joy of finally grasping a hard idea.
  5. 27:13 In great tzaddikim even ordinary speech and every movement of the hand were directed to Hashem.
  6. 52:55 The yetzer hara is in the King's service, and its deep inner wish is that a person master and conquer it.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 15:37 Why is ahavah rabbah a higher level than ahavah azah?

    Answer: 16:13 Ahavah azah, however strong, can subside, while ahavah rabbah fills the heart to the brim and leaves no place for the yetzer hara, and its delight is in the mind itself.

  2. Question: 30:45 How was Pharaoh able to withstand one plague after another?

    Answer: 30:57 In him the process ran in reverse: the left chamber overflowed into the right, so nothing in him inclined to good.

  3. Question: 45:14 If the generations keep declining, how could the Arizal grasp more than the Rishonim before him?

    Answer: 45:37 Sometimes a soul belonging to much earlier generations is sent down to a small generation, outside the usual order of the generations.

  4. Question: 55:27 Why would the angel of Esav put himself at risk fighting Yaakov the night before his turn to sing shirah?

    Answer: 55:48 Because his shirah was to be overpowered by Yaakov: the shirah of every creature is doing Hashem's will in its function.

  5. Question: 57:03 Why did the sun stop singing shirah when Yehoshua only told it to stop moving?

    Answer: 57:19 Because the sun's shirah is its rotation; when it stops functioning it stops its shirah.

Stories

  1. 33:14 The lion, the donkey and the fox

    The Mashgiach brings a Midrash: the lion, king of the jungle, walked with his ministers and came to a log across a stream where the donkey collected the toll. The donkey insisted that even the king pay, and the furious lion tore him apart and told the fox to prepare a meal from him. The fox ate the heart himself, and when the king asked for it the fox answered that if the donkey had had a heart he would never have spoken to the king that way.

    In the story: Pharaoh

    told in 4 other shiurim →

  2. 50:00 The Maggid's snuffbox

    A great tzaddik came to visit the Maggid with his child. While the Maggid stepped out, the child picked up the silver snuffbox on the table, looked at it and put it back. When the Maggid returned he asked who had touched it, and explained that when he puts something down he puts it where it is supposed to be, and it had been moved from its place.

    In the story: the Maggid of Mezritch

  3. 51:11 The Maggid's hand behind his back

    Once the Maggid kept his hand behind his back for a number of hours without moving it, though it was evidently painful. Asked why he did not relax it, he explained that he does not move a limb without a holy purpose, and he had not found a reason to move his hand forward.

    In the story: the Maggid of Mezritch

  4. 53:12 The king who tested his son

    The Mashgiach brings the Zohar's parable of a king who wanted to test the purity of his son the prince, and hired a harlot to try to seduce him, to see whether he was strong enough to overcome his yetzer hara. The harlot was really in the king's service, and so too the yetzer hara is in the service of Hashem.

    told in 1 other shiur →

Insights

  1. 7:14 Nullification means the limbs serve the soul the way a pen serves a writer: the pen does not argue about what to write, and a chariot has no will of its own apart from its rider.
  2. 17:00 In holiness the mind arouses the heart; in impurity the heart's desires send up their vapors and the mind becomes their servant, devising ways to satisfy them.
  3. 20:06 Ahavah rabbah is a pleasure that does not need the heart: the mind itself has a delight of understanding, like the flash of grasping a hard idea, and this is a taste of what souls enjoy in the World to Come.
  4. 30:48 Pharaoh withstood the plagues because in him the process of the tzaddik ran in reverse: the left chamber overflowed into the right, and his heart became only liver, the seat of the yetzer hara.
  5. 37:34 Man's organs are likenesses of the powers Scripture attributes to Hashem, so a rasha's heart that does not fear Hashem does not deserve to be called a heart, and his eye that does not look to Hashem is not truly an eye.
  6. 55:30 The angel of Esav picked a fight with Yaakov on the very night before his turn to sing shirah because his shirah was to be overpowered: every creature's shirah is fulfilling its function, just as the sun's shirah is its motion.

What the Mashgiach says to take from it

  1. 26:15 The Mashgiach says that even though the tzaddik's level seems remote, the Tanya was written for beinonim so that they should at least know what a tzaddik is.
  2. 14:51 The Mashgiach says that what Hashem asks should at least be a person's ambition: to love Him with both chambers of the heart, so that even the left chamber's desires become love of Hashem.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Daniel, Dovid HaMelech, Esav, Moshe Rabbeinu, Pharaoh, Rabbi Chaim Vital, Rabbi Yosef Karo (the Beis Yosef), Shlomo HaMelech, the Arizal, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Baal Shem Tov, the Maggid of Mezritch, the Rema MiPano, the Satmar Rav (Rabbi Yoel Teitelbaum), the Vilna Gaon, Yaakov Avinu, Yehoshua bin Nun, Yosef HaTzaddik

Terms אהבה רבה, ביטול, בינוני, חלל השמאלי, יצר הרע, יצר טוב, לשון הקודש, מדות, מוחין, מרכבה, נפש האלקית, נפש הבהמית, עיר קטנה, רבונו של עולם, רוח הקודש, שירה, תענוג

Report an error on this page