יש צדיק שמדריגתו למעלה מדורו. ביאור חילוק בין צדיק וטוב לו לצדיק ורע לו.

Catalog entry: TANYA ENGLISH י no. ⁨23⁩ Pocket Guide p. 75 English 51 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 51 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Mashgiach's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

Learning Tanya chapter 10, the Mashgiach explains the difference between the tzaddik who has transformed his evil into good and the tzaddik in whom a hidden residue of evil remains, and describes the special tzaddikim, above their generation, who no longer have a yetzer hara.

The Mashgiach opens Tanya chapter 10 and says that now the Ba'al HaTanya begins answering the questions of chapter one: what are tzaddik v'tov lo and tzaddik v'ra lo. There are tzaddikim with no yetzer hara, like David HaMelech, whose heart was 'chalal', empty. He describes the special tzaddikim sent close to the days of Moshiach, like the Arizal and the tzaddikim of the Ba'al Shem Tov's era, who remembered earlier gilgulim, and explains why ordinary people forget: to keep their free choice. Pharaoh lost his choice as a punishment, and a story about Czar Nicholas shows that even a rasha's downfall can serve Hashem. The tzaddik who is not complete drives his evil away, but like David leaving Avimelech, it goes off on its own and can return. The complete tzaddik has transformed his evil and despises worldly pleasure, as the Apter Rav did, except where enjoyment itself is the mitzvah, as with eating matzah.

Topics: Tzaddik, Beinoni and Rasha (Tanya ch. 9-17)

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Tzaddikim with no yetzer hara listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach opens Tanya chapter 10 and says the Ba'al HaTanya now begins answering the questions of chapter one about tzaddik v'tov lo and tzaddik v'ra lo. He explains that some tzaddikim have no yetzer hara, as David HaMelech said his heart was 'chalal', which means empty, like chillul Shabbos empties Shabbos of its kedushah.

  2. 4:21 Exceptional tzaddikim near Moshiach's days listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach says that although the generations grow smaller, close to Moshiach's days there are tzaddikim beyond the normal descent, like the Arizal, whom Reb Chaim Vital describes as grasping more than the nevi'im. He explains that such people are needed because the state of Klal Yisrael today is so low, and he brings the Ohr HaChaim on falling into the fiftieth gate of impurity.

  3. 8:47 Tzaddikim who remembered earlier gilgulim Story listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach describes the era of the Ba'al Shem Tov, when great neshamos came down and spoke openly of their earlier gilgulim: the Ohev Yisrael of Apt and the Yismach Moshe, who remembered Matan Torah and the dispute of Korach and told his grandson he had stayed neutral. He adds that Korach was a great man with ruach hakodesh, and mentions Reb Shmelke of Nikolsburg and his brother in Mezritch.

  4. 12:55 Why we forget: preserving free choice listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that ordinary people do not remember earlier gilgulim because their task is to fight the yetzer hara, and remembering would remove their free choice. Perfect tzaddikim have finished their own task and live only to guide others, so they may remember; he laments that today there is no such leadership.

  5. 16:03 Pharaoh, Czar Nicholas and the rasha's purpose

    In reverse, Pharaoh lost his free choice as a punishment he brought on himself. The Mashgiach tells how a tzaddik explained why Czar Nicholas died a natural death: he was too wicked to merit a Kiddush Hashem through his downfall, whereas Pharaoh did merit it. He brings the passuk that even the rasha was created for the day of evil, and contrasts David HaMelech, who sanctified Hashem with his life.

  6. 21:07 The tzaddik in whom evil remains listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach lays out the four levels the Tanya will explain: the complete and incomplete tzaddik and the complete and incomplete rasha. He reads how a person fights until he drives the evil out of the left chamber of the heart, yet it was not transformed; a tiny subdued residue remains, which is the Gemara's tzaddik v'ra lo, and the tzaddik thinks it is gone. He then asks whether the Ba'al HaTanya uses a passuk merely as poetic language.

  7. 26:20 Vayegarshehu vayelech: the evil that leaves by itself listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains melitza, using a passuk out of context, and says the Ba'al HaTanya means every word exactly. He tells how David feigned madness before Avimelech, and points to the extra word in the passuk: Avimelech thought he drove David out, but David left of his own will. So too the incomplete tzaddik thinks he has driven out the yetzer hara, but it left on its own and is ready to attack again.

  8. 31:45 The complete tzaddik and the Apter Rav's matzah listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that in the complete tzaddik the evil was transformed into good, so he despises worldly pleasures not for the service of Hashem. He tells of the Apter Rav, who could eat an entire goose after a feast, yet at the end of his life said all food tasted like dust to him except the matzah of the Seder night.

  9. 36:48 Achila means enjoyment: the body feels the mitzvah listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach suggests that the mitzvah with matzah is achila, which means enjoying the food, and brings a proof that one must eat it with appetite. He adds that enjoyment leaves a mark on the body: the Gemara holds one who is mis'asek with forbidden fats liable because he had pleasure, and on Pesach the body itself is to be sanctified by feeling the mitzvah.

  10. 41:53 Two reasons the tzaddik hates evil listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that every desire comes from the sitra achra, and the complete tzaddik hates it for two reasons: Hashem hates it, and his heart is so full of love for Hashem that no room remains for another love, as in 'ohavei Hashem sinu ra'. He raises the question of how one can also love a fellow Jew, and answers that one loves the part of G-d in him, so the love is not divided.

  11. 46:45 Tachlis sinah: hatred and revulsion listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach brings David HaMelech's words that he hates the resha'im with utmost hatred and asks Hashem to search his heart, showing that the measure of his love is the measure of his hatred of evil. He distinguishes mius, revulsion felt toward objects, from sinah, hatred of people, and explains that the tzaddik's soul is revolted by evil as the senses are by spoiled food. He stops at the complete tzaddik.

The shiur, written up

Tzaddikim with no yetzer hara

0:32

The Mashgiach opens Tanya chapter 10 and says that here the Ba'al HaTanya begins to answer the questions of chapter one: what is tzaddik v'tov lo and what is tzaddik v'ra lo. There are tzaddikim who have made the yetzer hara null and void. David HaMelech said his heart was 'chalal' within him, and chalal means empty, just as chillul Shabbos empties Shabbos of its kedushah. David had no yetzer hara left, and so no free choice in that sense. a,b

Exceptional tzaddikim near Moshiach's days

5:04

Although the generations keep growing smaller, the Mashgiach says, close to the days of Moshiach there are tzaddikim who stand outside this descent and belong with the early generations. Reb Chaim Vital writes that his Rebbe, the Arizal, grasped more than the nevi'im. Such people are needed because we are so low. The Mashgiach brings the Ohr HaChaim: in Egypt, falling into the fiftieth gate of impurity would have been final, but before Moshiach the Jews will fall into it and be pulled out by the power of Torah. That gate, he says, is apikorsus, which is rampant today, alongside assimilation and machlokes. c

Tzaddikim who remembered earlier gilgulim

8:58

The Ba'al Shem Tov and his era injected Klal Yisrael with 'adrenaline' so its heart would keep going. Great neshamos came down and spoke openly of earlier gilgulim. The Yismach Moshe remembered Matan Torah, and told his grandson that in Korach's dispute he stayed neutral; had the grandson been there, he would have sided with Korach. Korach, the Mashgiach explains, was a very great man, who saw with ruach hakodesh, as Rashi says, the great descendant who would come from him. d

Why we forget: preserving free choice

13:03

We do not remember such things, the Mashgiach explains, because we are not perfect tzaddikim and our duty is to wage war with the yetzer hara. If a person remembered why he was sent down again, nobody would fail to be a tzaddik, so forgetting preserves free choice. Perfect tzaddikim have already accomplished their task and live only to guide us and instill emunah, so they may remember.

Pharaoh, Czar Nicholas and the rasha's purpose

16:04

The reverse happened to Pharaoh, who also had no free choice. He brought himself to that state while he still could choose; losing his choice was already the start of his punishment, which he merited to receive in this world.

17:36

A tzaddik was asked why Czar Nicholas, who had Jewish children seized for decades of army service, died without a visible punishment. He answered that some resha'im merit a Kiddush Hashem through their downfall, but Nicholas lacked even that merit. Pharaoh had a merit, having said 'Hashem is the righteous one'. Everything serves Hashem, the Mashgiach adds, even the rasha on his day of downfall. e,f

The tzaddik in whom evil remains

21:28

The Mashgiach lays out the levels the Tanya will explain: the complete tzaddik, the tzaddik who still has a yetzer hara, the complete rasha with no good left, and the rasha in whom a good point still surfaces. A person fights the animal soul until he drives the evil out of the left chamber of the heart, as the passuk speaks of removing evil from within. Yet the evil was not transformed: a tiny residue remains, subdued and nullified. This is the Gemara's tzaddik v'ra lo, who thinks his yetzer hara is gone. g,h

Driven out, or went away?

26:43

The Ba'al HaTanya uses the words of a passuk here, and the Mashgiach explains that this is not mere melitza, a poetic borrowing out of context; the Tanya means every word exactly. The passuk says David was driven out by Avimelech and went. Fleeing Shaul, David feigned madness, and Avimelech sent him away. Avimelech thought he was chasing David out, but David went of his own will because his time there was up. i

30:59

So too, the tzaddik who is not complete thinks he has driven out the yetzer hara and need not watch out. But it left on its own and is ready to attack again.

The complete tzaddik and the Apter Rav's matzah

32:34

In a complete tzaddik, like David HaMelech or the Yismach Moshe, the evil itself was transformed into good, so no residue is left. He despises the pleasures of this world when they are not for the service of Hashem. The Apter Rav once ate an entire roasted goose after everyone was full. Yet at the end of his life, very sick, he insisted on eating matzah at the Seder, telling his worried children that all year his food tasted like dust and the matzah was his only taste.

Achila means enjoyment

36:54

The Mashgiach suggests why: the mitzvah of matzah is achila, eating, and achila means enjoying the food. His proof is that one should eat the matzah with appetite. Since the passuk commands eating matzah, the eating itself must be felt. j

39:47

Enjoyment leaves a mark on the body. The Gemara holds that one who is mis'asek, acting without awareness, is usually exempt, yet with forbidden foods he is liable, because his body had pleasure. The opposite is eating matzah, which leaves a desirable mark, since Pesach is the time to sanctify the body. k

Two reasons the tzaddik hates evil

42:10

Every desire comes from the sitra achra, and the complete tzaddik hates it for two reasons: Hashem hates it, and his heart is so full of love for Hashem that no room is left for any other love. As the passuk says, those who love Hashem hate evil, for the two loves are opposites. l

45:03

The mefarshim ask how one can then also be commanded to love a fellow Jew. The answer is that one loves the part of G-d in him, so the love is undivided.

Hatred and revulsion

47:17

David HaMelech says he hates the resha'im with utmost hatred and asks Hashem to search his heart and see it is wholly His. The measure of the tzaddik's love is the measure of his hatred of evil. The Mashgiach distinguishes mius, revulsion at objects like spoiled food, from sinah, hatred of people; the tzaddik's soul is revolted by evil the way the senses are by something foul. Here he stops, at the complete tzaddik. m

Sources

Torah

  1. e apparently Shemos 9:27 index In the write-up: 17:36
  2. g apparently Devarim 13:6 index In the write-up: 21:28
  3. j apparently Shemos 12:18 index In the write-up: 36:54

Kesuvim

  1. b apparently Tehillim 109:22 index In the write-up: 0:32
  2. f apparently Mishlei 16:4 index In the write-up: 17:36
  3. i apparently Tehillim 34:1 index In the write-up: 26:43
  4. l apparently Tehillim 97:10 index In the write-up: 42:10
  5. m apparently Tehillim 139:22-23 index In the write-up: 47:17

Talmud Bavli

  1. h apparently Berachos 7a index In the write-up: 21:28
  2. k Gemara (place not identified) index In the write-up: 39:47

Rishonim

  1. d apparently Rashi on Bamidbar 16:7 index In the write-up: 8:58

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. a apparently Tanya ch. 10 index In the write-up: 0:32
  2. c Ohr HaChaim (place not identified) index In the write-up: 5:04

Key points

  1. 1:48 There are tzaddikim who have rendered their yetzer hara null and void; David HaMelech said his heart was 'chalal', empty of it, and so he no longer had free choice in that sense.
  2. 5:08 Close to the days of Moshiach Hashem sends exceptional tzaddikim, above the normal descent of the generations, like the Arizal and the tzaddikim of the Ba'al Shem Tov's era, to keep Klal Yisrael going.
  3. 13:03 Ordinary people do not remember their earlier gilgulim so that they keep their free choice; perfect tzaddikim, who live only to guide others, may remember.
  4. 22:36 The tzaddik who is not complete has driven the evil out of the left chamber of the heart, but it was not transformed; a tiny residue remains, subdued and nullified.
  5. 32:43 The complete tzaddik's evil has been transformed into good, so he despises worldly pleasures that are not for the service of Hashem.
  6. 42:41 The complete tzaddik hates evil for two reasons: Hashem hates it, and his heart is so filled with love of Hashem that no room is left for any other love.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 12:51 Why do ordinary people not remember their earlier gilgulim?

    Answer: 13:18 So that they keep their free choice in the war against the yetzer hara; perfect tzaddikim, who live for others, may remember.

  2. Question: 16:14 How could Pharaoh be punished if he had no free choice?

    Answer: 16:23 He brought himself to that state while he still had choice; losing it was already the beginning of his punishment, given in this world.

  3. Question: 17:42 Why did Czar Nicholas receive no visible punishment?

    Answer: 18:19 He was too wicked to merit a Kiddush Hashem through his downfall, which is itself a merit.

  4. Question: 29:48 Why does the passuk about David and Avimelech use both 'driven out' and 'went'?

    Answer: 30:00 Avimelech thought he drove David out, but David left of his own will because his time there was up.

  5. Question: 45:11 How can one love a fellow Jew if all of one's love belongs to Hashem?

    Answer: 45:45 One loves the part of G-d in that person, so it is one undivided love of Hashem.

Stories

  1. 10:12 The Yismach Moshe remembers Korach's dispute

    The Yismach Moshe said he remembered Matan Torah and near whom he stood there. His grandson asked whether he remembered the dispute of Korach and assumed he had sided with Moshe Rabbeinu; he answered that he was neutral. When the grandson wondered at this, he said that had the grandson been there, he would have sided with Korach, because Korach was a very great man, not a mischievous quarreler.

    In the story: the Yismach Moshe, Korach, Moshe Rabbeinu, Yaakov Avinu, the Yetev Lev, the Apter Rav (the Ohev Yisrael)

    told in 3 other shiurim →

  2. 17:31 Why Czar Nicholas died a natural death

    A great tzaddik, perhaps of Tchortkov or Sadigura (the Mashgiach is unsure), was brought the news that Czar Nicholas had died. He was asked why this tyrant, who decreed that Jewish children be seized for decades of army service, did not receive a visible punishment from Heaven. The tzaddik answered that some resha'im merit to sanctify Hashem's name through their downfall, but he was so wicked that he lacked even that merit, so he died a natural death.

    In the story: Czar Nicholas

  3. 34:42 The Apter Rav and the matzah of the Seder

    The Apter Rav used to eat a great deal. Once, at a feast with great tzaddikim, after everyone was full from the first course, a roasted goose was brought and he ate it all by himself. At the end of his life, when he was very sick and allowed only liquids, he took a piece of matzah on the Seder night as every year; his children warned that it was dangerous, and he answered that all year everything he ate tasted like dust, and the only taste he had was the matzah of Pesach night.

    In the story: the Apter Rav (the Ohev Yisrael)

Insights

  1. 3:22 'Chalal' means empty: a person who dies is called a chalal because he is emptied of his nefesh, and chillul Shabbos means emptying Shabbos of its kedushah; so David's 'chalal' heart was empty of the yetzer hara.
  2. 5:15 The tzaddikim of the Ba'al Shem Tov's era were sent close to Moshiach's days, outside the normal descent of the generations, to inject Klal Yisrael with 'adrenaline' so that its heart keeps beating.
  3. 13:37 Forgetting earlier gilgulim is what makes free choice possible: whoever remembered why he was sent back would not fail to be a tzaddik; perfect tzaddikim, who live only for others, have no choice to protect and so may remember.
  4. 18:19 Even a rasha's downfall is a merit, since it brings a Kiddush Hashem; Czar Nicholas was so wicked that he was denied even that and died a natural death.
  5. 30:00 The double wording about David and Avimelech, that he was driven out and that he went, describes the yetzer hara of the incomplete tzaddik: he thinks he drove it out, but it left of its own will and is ready to attack again.
  6. 36:54 The mitzvah of matzah is achila, and achila means enjoying the eating; this is why the Apter Rav, who tasted nothing all year, would not give up the matzah of the Seder, and why on Pesach the body itself is to feel the mitzvah.
  7. 49:20 Mius, revulsion, is felt toward objects and sinah toward people; David's utmost hatred of the resha'im is the soul's revulsion at their spiritual being, as the senses are revolted by spoiled food.

What the Mashgiach says to take from it

  1. 13:03 The Mashgiach says that since we are not perfect tzaddikim, our duty is to wage war with the yetzer hara and conquer it.
  2. 31:03 The Mashgiach says one who is not a complete tzaddik should not think he is relieved of the battle, because the yetzer hara that seems gone is ready to attack again.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Avimelech, Czar Nicholas, Dovid HaMelech, Korach, Moshe Rabbeinu, Pharaoh, Rabbi Chaim Vital, Rabbi Shmelke of Nikolsburg, Rashi, Shaul HaMelech, the Apter Rav (the Ohev Yisrael), the Arizal, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Baal Shem Tov, the Maggid of Mezritch, the Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh, the Yismach Moshe

Terms בחירה, גלגול, יצר הרע, סטרא אחרא, צדיק גמור, צדיק ורע לו, קליפת נוגה, שנאה

Report an error on this page