רשע וטוב לו - יש לו חרטה אחר העבירות אבל לא עשה תשובה. רשע ורע לו - נשמות שמסר יעקב לעשו - אבל יש להם נקודת יחידה ומצטרפים למנין.
Catalog entry: TANYA ENGLISH י"א no. 25 Pocket Guide p. 75 English 53 min
Listen
About this shiur
Learning Tanya chapter 11, the Mashgiach explains the rasha who still feels regret and the rasha in whom the good has departed, and shows that even the lowest Jew keeps a surrounding holiness that joins him to a minyan and that Purim, especially in Adar Sheni, celebrates.
The Mashgiach continues Tanya chapter 11. A rasha v'tov lo sins often, yet the living good in him brings thoughts of regret between his sins, though he lacks the strength to stop; the Slonimer Rebbe's mashal of the drunkard who rewarded his three sober days with a drink illustrates him. The rasha v'ra lo never thinks of teshuvah; these are the souls Yaakov sent to Esav, and the Midrash of the am ha'aretz shows they will return to Yaakov when Moshiach comes. The good in such a person has left its nest but hovers above him as a makif. In a long Purim digression the Mashgiach explains, through Amalek, the tribe of Dan, Haman's silver and the silver hooks of the Mishkan, that Hashem never rejects the Jews outside the camp. He then explains that this makif of Yechidah is why ten reshaim make a minyan, and closes with Adar Sheni, Shushan Purim in Yerushalayim, and questions from the listeners.
Topics: Tzaddik, Beinoni and Rasha (Tanya ch. 9-17) · The Greatness of Every Jew · The Pintele Yid: The Inner Point of Every Jew · Davening with the Tzibbur and the Beis HaKnesses
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 The rasha who still feels regret listed in the guide
After finding the place in Tanya chapter 11, the Mashgiach explains that a momentary sinner is a rasha only at that moment, and then describes the rasha v'tov lo who sins often and harshly, yet has thoughts of teshuvah between his sins from the living good in him, without the strength to stop.
-
6:00 The Slonimer Rebbe's mashal of the drunkard listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Slonimer Rebbe's reading of the passuk 'mi yiten tahor mitamei lo echad' with the mashal of a drunkard who stayed sober three days and then rewarded himself with a drink, and applies it to the rasha who has regret but not the strength of a firm 'no'.
-
9:12 The souls Yaakov sent to Esav listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that those ruled by the yetzer hara are the souls Yaakov sent to Esav, and tells the Midrash of an am ha'aretz who taught Rabbi Hoshaya that Esav's kings will return the gift to Moshiach; he explains that this was the am ha'aretz's own portion in the Torah, that these souls will return to Yaakov.
-
15:15 The rasha v'ra lo and the hovering good listed in the guide
The Mashgiach reads the Tanya's description of the rasha v'ra lo, who never has thoughts of teshuvah because the good has left its place in his heart, and explains that it still hovers above him as a makif, like a bird above a nest occupied by a serpent, comparing it to the tzelem Elokim that hovers above a non-Jew.
-
19:02 Adar, the tribe of Dan and Amalek
Turning to the month of Adar, the Mashgiach explains that Adar at the end of the year corresponds to the lowest souls, and recalls that the idol-carrying Jews of the camp of Dan were expelled from the Clouds of Glory and fell to Amalek; Hashem does not forgive Amalek for having no mercy on them, because no Jew is rejected by Him.
-
24:00 Haman's silver and the hooks of the Mishkan
The Mashgiach explains that Haman's ten thousand talents were meant to cancel the half-shekel of the six hundred thousand, but he did not redeem the surplus that became the silver hooks outside the holiness of the Mishkan, the portion of the rejected Jews; this was the 'parashas hakesef' Mordechai told Esther. He adds that the thirteenth month, Adar Sheni, lies outside the twelve combinations of Hashem's Name, and the Purim miracle happened in it.
-
34:25 Yechidah and the minyan of ten reshaim listed in the guide
The Mashgiach asks why ten reshaim make a minyan while nine tzaddikim cannot, and answers that above every Jew hovers a level of the soul, Kedushas Yisrael or Yechidah, the fusion of all souls in the soul of Yaakov Avinu, that no sin affects; Korach's flaw reached up to Levi but not to Yisrael, and ten Jews together reveal this makif.
-
38:58 The end of the perek and the Purim of Yerushalayim listed in the guide
The Mashgiach reads the last lines of the perek, that even the worst rasha has the makif above him and therefore Chazal say the Shechinah rests on every ten Jews, and returns to the joy of Adar Sheni; he explains that Purim is for the rasha who still has regret, and Shushan Purim of Yerushalayim, a walled city, is for those who have nothing but the makif.
-
45:27 Questions: the inner point, sukkah and the minyan listed in the guide
Answering listeners, the Mashgiach explains that the point in every Jew is truly his, but it comes to expression only as a makif when he davens with a minyan; he compares the makif to the sukkah and says it can become inner on Simchas Torah. He adds that one guards against the contagion of rishus but must still care for the rasha, and that the minyan is learned from Korach's congregation.
The shiur, written up
The rasha who still feels regret
The Mashgiach explains that Tanya chapter 11 describes the rasha v'tov lo, in contrast to the tzaddik of the previous chapter. As learned earlier, a person who sins is a rasha at that moment, even a great tzaddik who stumbles in a trace of lashon hara; that does not make him a bad man, for the good in him is still vibrant. a
The Slonimer Rebbe's mashal
The Mashgiach brings the Slonimer Rebbe on the passuk 'mi yiten tahor mitamei lo echad', with a mashal: a drunkard resolved to stop, stayed sober three days, then rewarded his heroism with a glass of brandy and was a drunkard again. Only a firm, healthy 'no' frees a person. Such are the reshaim full of regret who lack the willpower to change. b
The souls Yaakov sent to Esav
Some people are ruled constantly by the yetzer hara. The Mashgiach explains that these are the souls Yaakov sent to Esav: the five hundred eighty animals, the gematria of Yisrael, now under the jurisdiction of Esav, the yetzer hara, but destined to return. e
He tells the Midrash of an am ha'aretz who asked Rabbi Hoshaya to repeat his Torah in his name: the kings will return the gift to Moshiach, meaning Esav will return Yaakov's animals. Rabbi Hoshaya agreed, and it is still learned. The Mashgiach explains that every Jew has a letter in the Torah and says a chiddush matching it; these sheep were amei ha'aretz in Esav's lot, so this am ha'aretz's Torah was that they will return to Yaakov and become tzaddikim. c,d
The good that hovers above
Adar, the tribe of Dan and Amalek
With Adar already blessed, the Mashgiach explains that Adar, the end of the year, corresponds to the lowest souls. He recalls that Jews at the end of the camp of Dan carried the idol of Michah and were expelled from the Clouds of Glory, as Rashi explains, so Amalek gained power over them. f
Hashem still does not forgive Amalek for having no mercy on them. Amalek thought Hashem did not care for these rejected Jews, but He does, because there is good in them and they will return to be tzaddikim.
Haman's silver and the hooks of the Mishkan
Haman offered ten thousand talents of silver, which Tosafos connects to the half-shekel given in the desert. The Mashgiach brings the Chasam Sofer that Haman gave it for charity, to cancel out the half-shekels; the Jews gave a hundred talents, a talent per socket, and he gave a hundred times more. g,i
Where was Haman wrong? There were more than six hundred thousand Jews, and from the surplus half-shekels silver hooks were made for the pillars. These hooks, shaped like a vav, protruded outside the curtain and were the only part of the Mishkan outside its holiness. j
By Divine providence, the Mashgiach reasons, that silver came from the rejected Jews of the camp of Dan. Haman did not redeem it, thinking nobody cared for them, as in his day Jews bowed to the idol; but to Hashem they matter. This was the 'parashas hakesef' Mordechai told Esther, and from these Jews the salvation came. h
Yechidah and the minyan
The end of the perek and the Purim of Yerushalayim
The Mashgiach reads the perek's last lines: even the worst rasha has the makif above him, so Chazal say the Shechinah rests on every ten Jews, who together reveal it. This is the joy of Adar, especially Adar Sheni: the worst Jew is not rejected, even outside the twelve combinations. a,n
He adds that the most distant Jews rejoice on Purim more than others, feeling it is their festival. Purim is for the rasha v'tov lo with regret; Shushan Purim of the walled city, today known to be Yerushalayim, is a higher level for those with nothing but the makif. That is Klal Yisrael's hope.
Questions from the listeners
A listener recalls that every Jew has a point that can never be damaged. The Mashgiach agrees it is truly within him, but it does not come to expression in him; it appears as the makif only when he davens with a minyan. He compares it to the sukkah, whose covering is above.
Usually the makif is too high to become inner, but a person can rise until it does, as the makif of Sukkos becomes inner on Simchas Torah.
Asked about excluding a sinner, the Mashgiach says one makes safeguards because rishus is contagious, but a rasha remains a living being to care for. He recalls that the minyan is learned through 'toch' 'toch' from Korach's congregation: even reshaim who divided Jews are united by the makif. q
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Talmud Yerushalmi
Midrash
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 4:35 A rasha v'tov lo still has a living good inclination that brings regret between his sins, but it lacks the strength to make him abandon them.
- 15:20 A rasha v'ra lo never thinks of teshuvah; he is the counterpart of the tzaddik who never thinks of sinning.
- 16:24 The good that leaves such a person does not abandon him altogether but hovers above him as a makif, a surrounding light, like a bird hovering over its nest.
- 36:14 Above every Jew is a holiness of Yechidah, the fusion of all the souls of Klal Yisrael, that no sin can touch; it is revealed when ten Jews gather, which is why ten reshaim make a minyan and nine tzaddikim do not.
- 23:42 Hashem never rejects the Jews whom Amalek and Haman regarded as outcasts, and this is the special joy of Purim, especially in Adar Sheni.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 35:12 Why can ten reshaim make a minyan and say Kedushah while nine tzaddikim cannot?
Answer: 35:33 Because the minyan is formed by the makif of Yechidah above every Jew, which no sin affects and which is revealed when ten Jews come together.
-
Question: 24:48 How did Haman's ten thousand talents of silver relate to the half-shekel of the Jews in the desert?
Answer: 25:06 Haman gave the money for charity to cancel out the half-shekels of the six hundred thousand: they gave a hundred talents, a talent per socket, and he gave a hundred times as much.
-
Question: 26:31 Where did Haman go wrong?
Answer: 26:36 The Jews gave more than six hundred thousand half-shekels, and the surplus went into the silver hooks outside the holiness; Haman did not redeem those, thinking the rejected Jews mattered to no one.
-
Question: 45:36 A listener asks: is the point in every Jew that can never be damaged the same as the makif?
Answer: 45:56 The Mashgiach says it is truly within him, but it does not come to expression in him; it appears as the makif only when he davens with a minyan.
Stories
-
6:55 The drunkard who rewarded his sobriety
In the Slonimer Rebbe's mashal, a habitual drunkard firmly resolved to stop drinking. He went a whole day without a drink, then a second and a third. Proud of his heroism, he decided he deserved to treat himself to a glass of brandy, and that was the end of his heroism; he was a drunkard again.
In the story: the Slonimer Rebbe
-
10:26 The am ha'aretz and Rabbi Hoshaya
As the Midrash tells, an am ha'aretz asked Rabbi Hoshaya whether, if he told him a piece of Torah, he would say it in his name in the beis medrash. Rabbi Hoshaya agreed if it was suitable. The am ha'aretz said that the kings will return the gift to Moshiach: all the animals Yaakov sent to Esav will be returned. Rabbi Hoshaya called it a good piece of Torah and said it in his name, and it is still learned in the Midrash.
In the story: Rabbi Hoshaya
Insights
- 12:47 The Midrash's piece of Torah from the am ha'aretz, that Esav will return Yaakov's animals to Moshiach, was his own portion in the Torah: the souls given over to Esav, like him, will ultimately return to Yaakov and become tzaddikim.
- 15:38 Just as the tzaddik never even thinks of sinning, the rasha v'ra lo is his exact counterpart who never even thinks of teshuvah.
- 28:55 The surplus half-shekels of the Jews beyond six hundred thousand became the silver hooks that protruded outside the holiness of the Mishkan; Haman did not bother to counter them, thinking those outcast Jews mattered to no one, and that was his mistake.
- 33:23 The thirteenth month has no combination of the four letters of Hashem's Name, which allow only twelve, so it stands outside the camp; the Purim miracle happening in Adar Sheni shows it was made for the Jews outside the camp.
- 37:00 Korach's flaw of division reached Yitzhar, Kehas and Levi but could not reach Yisrael, because the Yechidah that unites all of Klal Yisrael is untouchable.
- 43:23 Ordinary Purim is for the rasha v'tov lo who still has regret, while Shushan Purim of Yerushalayim, the walled city surrounded like a makif, is a higher level, for those who have nothing within themselves but the makif.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 50:16 The Mashgiach says one makes safeguards not to bring in those who can be a bad influence, because rishus is contagious, but a rasha remains a living being whom one must still take care of.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Esav, Esther HaMalkah, Haman, Korach, Mordechai HaTzaddik, Rabbi Hoshaya, Rashi, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Chasam Sofer, the Divrei Shmuel (Rabbi Shmuel of Slonim), the Slonimer Rebbe, Yaakov Avinu
Terms אדר שני, הרהורי תשובה, ווי העמודים, יחידה, מוקפין חומה, מחצית השקל, מקיף, ענני הכבוד, צדיק ורע לו, צירוף, צלם אלקים, קדושת ישראל