האדם נברא ביכולת שישליט המוח על הלב. יש לכל יהודי שורש הנעלם שכולו טוב. שייכות לפורים.
Catalog entry: TANYA ENGLISH י"ב no. 27 Pocket Guide p. 75 English 54 min
Listen
About this shiur
Learning Tanya chapter 12, the Mashgiach explains that the beinoni's evil is only subdued, not killed: it is silenced during true davening and wakes again afterward, yet his mind always has the power to rule over his heart.
The Mashgiach opens Tanya chapter 12 and explains that the beinoni, whose evil never overpowers the good, is what we would call a tzaddik, yet he keeps the potential to sin. Comparing it to the Rambam's testimony of the One Who knows hidden things about a baal teshuvah, he says the term describes a present, resolute condition. An antibiotics analogy shows the difference: the tzaddik killed his yetzer hara, the beinoni only knocked it out. He explains the three judges and why the beinoni still gets full credit. During davening, when a channel is cut upward through Pesukei Dezimra and the brachos of Krias Shema, the beinoni rises like a tzaddik; afterward he falls back, like a dancer landing. Finally, an undesirable thought is no failing but a chance for the mitzvah of not straying after the heart, since the mind was created to rule the heart.
Topics: Tzaddik, Beinoni and Rasha (Tanya ch. 9-17) · Kavanah in Davening · The Yetzer Hara and Nisyonos
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Who is the beinoni of chapter 12 listed in the guide
After greeting a new listener, the Mashgiach opens chapter 12 on the beinoni, whose evil never overpowers the good, and explains that we would call him a tzaddik. The real tzaddik, like Dovid HaMelech, has killed the yetzer hara in the left chamber of his heart and replaced it with good.
-
4:28 A present state, like the Rambam's teshuvah
The Mashgiach explains that the beinoni's yetzer hara is suppressed but still there, and that being a beinoni describes his present resolute condition, as the Rambam says of a baal teshuvah that the One Who knows hidden things testifies about him. An analogy of antibiotics taken for too short a time shows the difference between knocking out the yetzer hara and killing it.
-
12:59 Rasha, tzaddik v'ra lo and the three judges
Answering a listener, the Mashgiach distinguishes the rasha and the tzaddik v'ra lo from the beinoni, then explains the judges: the yetzer hara judges the rasha, the yetzer tov the tzaddik, and both the beinoni. Hashem helps the beinoni, and with the passuk 'Hashem lo ya'azvenu' he explains that at the judgment he still gets full credit.
-
19:08 No barrier: the beinoni's davening
The Mashgiach explains that sins create a barrier between a person and his neshamah, so his thoughts wander in davening; he brings the Ba'al Shem Tov that every word of tefillah is a heichal from which the unworthy are thrown out. The beinoni has no such barrier, so while davening he feels the malachim singing and has the status of a tzaddik.
-
22:34 A person is where his thought is
On the Tanya's 'special times' of davening, the Mashgiach brings the Ba'al Shem Tov that a person is where his thought is, proves it from the halachah of designating a tree as one's Shabbos resting place, which he saw in the Satmar Rav and the Avnei Nezer, and applies it to having Yerushalayim in mind in davening.
-
27:23 The eis ratzon that moves with the sunrise
The Mashgiach asks how an eis ratzon outside Eretz Yisrael can be real when everything follows Eretz Yisrael, noting that the Ramak says those abroad miss out and the Ba'al HaTanya in his Shulchan Aruch disagrees. He explains that Above there is no time, and the eis ratzon formed at sunrise moves along with the sunrise, which is why Shacharis is the main time and needs a long davening with tallis and tefillin.
-
33:18 Cutting a channel: the order of davening
The Mashgiach explains that the air up to Shamayim is full of klipos from people's sins, and Pesukei Dezimra cut a channel through them, as the Arizal reads 'zimra' as cutting. Then the brachos of Krias Shema bring down yiras Shamayim and ahavah, preparing for Shema itself, and the bracha after Shema extends yetzias Mitzrayim, freeing oneself from everything that keeps him from Hashem.
-
39:06 Rising in davening, falling back after
The Mashgiach explains that during genuine davening the beinoni's evil becomes subservient to the good and powerless, since even the body sees its root, as the chayos rise to the level of the serafim. After davening the motor shuts off and he falls back, like Chassidim who dance and rise off the ground only for a moment; the evil wakes again but remains only one judge.
-
45:39 Undesirable thoughts and 'machshavah mamash' listed in the guide
The Mashgiach teaches that an undesirable thought comes from the yetzer hara, not from the person's essence, and is no reason to feel guilty; it is an opportunity for the mitzvah of 'v'lo sasuru', which is transgressed only by letting the thought linger. He explains that the beinoni never lets in a 'machshavah mamash', a fully developed thought.
-
50:04 The mind rules the heart; Reb Shmelke's dveikus listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that the mind is the ruler over the heart and every person was created able to hold himself back. He tells of the Rebbe Reb Shmelke, who asked his students to tap him if he lost his dveikus while learning, and explains that Torah learned with dveikus is like tefillah, but the Tanya speaks of tefillah. He ends answering a question about Pesukei Dezimra and the eis ratzon.
The shiur, written up
Who is the beinoni of chapter 12
After greeting a new listener, the Mashgiach opens Tanya chapter 12: having described the tzaddik and the rasha, the Ba'al HaTanya now defines the beinoni, the 'intermediate' person whose evil never overpowers the good. Such a person, the Mashgiach says, is what we would call a tzaddik; he is called a beinoni only because he still has the potential to be a rasha. a
A present state, like the Rambam's teshuvah
The beinoni's yetzer hara still lives in him but is always suppressed and never gets a chance to speak up. Must someone who once sinned lose this title forever? No, the Mashgiach answers: teshuvah helps for everything. The title describes his present condition, in which his willpower suppresses the yetzer hara so that it cannot breathe.
He compares this to the Rambam's statement that after true teshuvah the One Who knows hidden things testifies that the person will not return to his sin. If he sins again after Yom Kippur, that does not show his teshuvah was false; it means that in his resolute state he would not have sinned. So too the beinoni: later on, who knows what changes may come. d
He illustrates with someone who stops antibiotics a little early: the symptoms vanish, but knocked-out microbes may revive. The beinoni's yetzer hara is knocked out and could rise again; the tzaddik's was killed and will never get up.
Rasha, tzaddik v'ra lo and the three judges
A listener asks how the rasha differs from the beinoni, since a rasha can also do mitzvos. The Mashgiach answers that the rasha's yetzer hara is at full power and he is in real danger of sinning whenever he meets a temptation. The tzaddik v'ra lo may go years without sinning, but his yetzer hara is alive and kicking, so he stands below the beinoni.
He then brings the Gemara: the yetzer hara judges the rasha, the yetzer tov judges the tzaddik, and both judge the beinoni. Hashem helps the beinoni prevail, as the passuk says 'Hashem lo ya'azvenu'. When the accuser argues he deserves no credit since Hashem helped, the answer is 'v'lo yarshi'enu b'hishafto': at the judgment he is credited as if he did it all himself. e,f
No barrier: the beinoni's davening
Sins, the Mashgiach explains, create an insulation between a person and his neshamah, which is why his thoughts wander in davening. He brings the Ba'al Shem Tov that every word of tefillah is a heichal, and malachim throw out one who is unworthy. The beinoni, who never sins, has no barrier: he feels the malachim singing and sings with them, holding the status of a tzaddik while he davens.
A person is where his thought is
The Tanya says the beinoni's G-dly soul rules him only at special times, such as when he puts on tallis and tefillin. To explain how davening raises him, the Mashgiach brings the Ba'al Shem Tov: a person is where his thought is, in holiness or in filth.
He proves it from a halachah he saw in the Satmar Rav and, he thinks, the Avnei Nezer: one nearing a town before Shabbos may set his eyes on a tree and make it his resting place. By thinking he is there, he is there. Likewise the Shulchan Aruch requires having Yerushalayim in mind in davening, and so his tefillos go up. g,h
The eis ratzon that moves with the sunrise
The Mashgiach asks: everything follows Eretz Yisrael, yet when we sit at Shalosh Seudos it is already Sunday there, so where is the eis ratzon, the time of Divine favor? The Ramak says those abroad miss out, but the Ba'al HaTanya in his Shulchan Aruch disagrees. Shacharis is a special eis ratzon, the time of the tamid, as the halachah follows both views that the tefillos correspond to the korbanos and that the Avos instituted them. i,j
He answers that Above there is no time or space, but the eis ratzon formed at sunrise keeps moving with the sunrise, so we receive Eretz Yisrael's original eis ratzon hours later. That is why Shacharis is long and needs tallis and tefillin: it brings down the eis ratzon, which Mincha and Maariv then fortify.
Cutting a channel: the order of davening
The Mashgiach explains, while noting that he applies physical terms to spiritual things, that the air up to Shamayim is full of klipos from people's sins. Pesukei Dezimra cut a channel through them; the Arizal reads 'zimra' as cutting, as in 'karmecha lo sizmor', do not prune your vineyard. Once the road is free, the neshamah sees the malachim singing shira, and this fills him with yiras Shamayim. k
Rising in davening, falling back after
During genuine davening the beinoni's evil becomes subservient to the good, and he becomes like a tzaddik, even beyond the tzaddik v'ra lo. No foreign thought can reach him, because even his body and animal soul see their root, and his bad inclinations are rendered useless. The Mashgiach likens this to the chayos rising to the level of the serafim in davening.
After davening the motor shuts off and he falls back to his real self. The Mashgiach compares it to Chassidim dancing on Shabbos: a dancer rises above his height, but only briefly. The tzaddik really is that high; the beinoni only jumps. Then his evil reawakens in the left chamber, yet it is only one judge, so it stays potential.
Undesirable thoughts and 'machshavah mamash'
The Mashgiach says an undesirable thought is no reason to feel inferior: it comes from an alien source, the yetzer hara, not from the G-dly soul. One should chase it out by replacing it with thoughts of Torah and Hashem, since two thoughts cannot share the mind.
The mind rules the heart; Reb Shmelke's dveikus
The mind, the Mashgiach explains, rules the heart, and every person was created able to keep the heart's thoughts from settling in his mind, so no one may say he cannot control his thoughts. He tells that the Rebbe Reb Shmelke asked his students to tap him if he lost his dveikus while learning; once they did, and he said he had not lost it.
Every mitzvah has its peak, and tefillah's is a dveikus that leaves the yetzer hara no rule; Torah learned with dveikus is like tefillah.
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
- a apparently Tanya ch. 12 index In the write-up: 1:03
- g Avnei Nezer (place not identified) index In the write-up: 23:57
- h Shulchan Aruch (place not identified) index In the write-up: 23:57
- i Shulchan Aruch HaRav (place not identified) index In the write-up: 27:24
- n apparently Tanya ch. 12 index In the write-up: 47:22
Key points
- 2:23 The beinoni of Tanya never sins and would seem a tzaddik to us, but his yetzer hara is still alive within him.
- 8:18 Being a beinoni describes a present resolute state, so a later sin does not mean he never was one, and teshuvah restores it.
- 12:23 The tzaddik has killed his yetzer hara, while the beinoni has only knocked it out, so it may revive.
- 39:51 During true davening the beinoni's evil is rendered powerless and he is like a tzaddik, but after davening it awakens again.
- 34:42 Pesukei Dezimra cut a channel up through the obstructions, and the brachos of Krias Shema bring down yiras Shamayim and ahavah.
- 47:15 An undesirable thought is not a failing but a chance for the mitzvah of not straying after one's heart; the sin is only letting it linger.
- 50:15 Every person was created with a mind that can rule his heart, so there is no excuse to say he cannot control his thoughts.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 7:30 If a beinoni is one who never sins, does someone who sinned once lose that distinction forever?
Answer: 8:23 No; teshuvah helps for everything, and the term describes his present resolute condition, as the Rambam says the One Who knows hidden things testifies about a baal teshuvah even if he later changes.
-
Question: 12:59 A listener asks: since a rasha can also do mitzvos, what separates him from the beinoni, and where is the tzaddik v'ra lo?
Answer: 13:18 The rasha's yetzer hara is in full power and he is in real danger of sinning; the tzaddik v'ra lo usually overcomes it, but his yetzer hara is alive, so he stands below the beinoni.
-
Question: 17:16 Why should the beinoni get credit for subduing his yetzer hara if Hashem helped him?
Answer: 17:33 From 'v'lo yarshi'enu b'hishafto': at the time of judgment Hashem gives him credit as if he did it all himself.
-
Question: 27:24 If everything follows Eretz Yisrael, how can there be an eis ratzon at Shalosh Seudos or Shacharis outside it, when there it is already a different time?
Answer: 30:10 Above there is no time; the eis ratzon formed at sunrise keeps moving with the sunrise, so the original eis ratzon of Eretz Yisrael reaches each place in its own morning.
-
Question: 52:39 Why does the Tanya speak only of tefillah, when Torah also has a special quality?
Answer: 52:46 Every mitzvah has its own peak; tefillah's is dveikus with Hashem that leaves the yetzer hara no rule, and Torah learned with dveikus is like tefillah too.
Stories
-
51:47 Reb Shmelke asks to be reminded of his dveikus
The Mashgiach tells that the Rebbe Reb Shmelke, a brother of the Hafla'ah, told his students that if they saw him lose his dveikus with Hashem while delving into a sugya, they should tap him on the shoulder to remind him. Once they tapped him, and he answered that he had not lost his dveikus.
In the story: Rabbi Shmelke of Nikolsburg, the Haflaah (Rabbi Pinchas Horowitz), the Maggid of Mezritch
Insights
- 2:23 The Mashgiach stresses that the Tanya's beinoni, who never sins even in thought, is what we would call a virtual tzaddik; he is called a beinoni only because the potential for sin still lives in him.
- 10:01 He reads the beinoni's 'never will sin' like the Rambam's testimony of the One Who knows hidden things about a baal teshuvah: it describes how resolute he is now, not a guarantee about the future.
- 11:37 With an analogy of antibiotics stopped too early, he explains that the beinoni's yetzer hara is knocked out like dormant microbes that can revive, whereas the tzaddik's is dead.
- 30:10 He explains that since Above there is no time, the eis ratzon formed at sunrise in Eretz Yisrael travels with the sunrise, so each place has the original eis ratzon in its own morning.
- 34:30 He describes the air up to Shamayim as full of klipos from people's sins, so Pesukei Dezimra must cut a channel through them, matching the Arizal's reading of 'zimra' as cutting.
- 43:04 He compares the beinoni in davening to a Chassid dancing on Shabbos: he rises above his normal height but lands again, while the tzaddik truly stands that high.
- 47:22 He says an intruding thought is an opportunity: a person was sent down to wage this war, and if the enemy never came he could never fight it.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 45:58 The Mashgiach says a person should not feel inferior or guilty when an undesirable thought comes; it is not from his neshamah.
- 46:42 He says to chase such a thought out immediately by replacing it with thoughts of Torah and Hashem, since two thoughts cannot be in the mind together.
- 50:35 He says there is no excuse for a person to claim he cannot control his thoughts, for every person's mind was given the power to rule.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Dovid HaMelech, Rabbi Shmelke of Nikolsburg, the Arizal, the Avnei Nezer of Sochatchov, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Baal Shem Tov, the Haflaah (Rabbi Pinchas Horowitz), the Ramak (Rabbi Moshe Cordovero), the Rambam, the Satmar Rav (Rabbi Yoel Teitelbaum)
Terms בינוני, דביקות, ולא תתורו, חציצה, יציאת מצרים, יצר הרע, יצר טוב, מוח שליט על הלב, מחשבות זרות, נפש האלקית, נפש הבהמית, עת רצון, פסוקי דזמרה, צדיק ורע לו, קליפה, קריאת שמע, רבונו של עולם, תחום שבת