ביאור איך הבינוני מנצח נסיונות בין אדם לחבירו. אהבת ה' ואהבת ישראל אחד. פורים וי"ג יו"ט של לך כנוס וכו'.
Catalog entry: TANYA ENGLISH י"ב no. 28 Pocket Guide p. 75 English 58 min
Listen
About this shiur
Learning Tanya chapter 12, the Mashgiach explains that the Beinoni's mind rules his heart while his hidden love for Hashem lies dormant, shows through the 'tip of the yud' how this innermost point is revealed on Yom Kippur and even more on Purim, and ends with how the Beinoni overcomes ill will toward his fellow Jew.
The Mashgiach reviews that in the Beinoni the evil inclination is knocked out but still speaks, and that the mind rules the heart by nature, so even Haman could restrain himself. Since light pushes away darkness, bad thoughts are best displaced with holiness. The Beinoni is still not a tzaddik: his advantage is only in function, while in his core lies a hidden love. Through the Gemara on the Purim decree, the forty lashes reduced to thirty-nine, the Rambam on a forced get and the 'tip of the yud', the Mashgiach shows that sin never reaches the fortieth level, revealed on Yom Kippur, on Purim, and through Mordechai's self-sacrifice. He returns to the Beinoni, whose love sleeps after davening, explains why Tanya omits avak lashon hara, how the Beinoni repels thoughts, and how he answers hostility toward a fellow Jew with kindness, closing with a Chassidic story.
Topics: Tzaddik, Beinoni and Rasha (Tanya ch. 9-17) · Purim · Ahavah Mesuteres (Tanya ch. 18-25) · Yom Kippur
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 The mind rules the heart, even in Haman
The Mashgiach reviews that the Beinoni's evil inclination is knocked out but still speaks, reads that the mind rules the heart by nature, and shows it from Haman restraining himself before Mordechai. Bad thoughts are best displaced with holiness.
-
7:54 Light over darkness; why only a Beinoni
With the candle that drives darkness from a whole room, the Mashgiach explains how holiness pushes away the folly of sin. He then asks why so perfect a person is only called a Beinoni, and answers that his advantage is only in function, not essence, like a dancer who must come down.
-
14:06 The hidden love and the Purim decree
The Mashgiach explains that in the Beinoni's heart lies a hidden, natural love of the G-dly soul. He brings the Gemara where Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai says the Jews bowed only outwardly, asks how he knew this, and answers that every Jew has a hidden chamber that protests against sin.
-
19:53 Forty levels and the tip of the yud
The Mashgiach explains that creation and man consist of forty forces, the fortieth being the 'tip of the yud' of Hashem's Name, where no sin reaches. With the Rambam on a get given under duress, he shows that the inner will remains good, so lashes are only thirty-nine.
-
24:42 Yom Kippur, Amalek and Purim listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Ba'al HaTanya on 'before Hashem you shall be purified': Yom Kippur atones from the Holy of Holies, above the yud. Amalek is the 'first' of impurity set against it. Purim, he says, is even higher than Yom Kippur, and its intoxication is like anesthesia for those who reach it.
-
31:12 Esther's fear and Mordechai ben Kish listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains Esther's fear that the Jews had sinned even against the innermost point, which Amalek sought to occupy. Hashem Himself judged by the inner point, and Mordechai, 'ben Kish' who knocked on the gates of mercy, sparked the self-sacrifice that opened them.
-
35:43 Self-sacrifice opens the hidden chamber listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that the gates of the Holy of Holies open on Yom Kippur through the fast, which is self-sacrifice, and on Purim through the Jews' self-sacrifice. This hidden love is why even sinners gave their lives rather than worship idols, and why the Jews did not abandon their Jewishness to escape Haman's decree.
-
39:11 The tzaddik's open love, the Beinoni's dormant love
The Mashgiach contrasts the tzaddik, who is himself a Holy of Holies like Aharon, with the Beinoni, whose love glows openly only while davening and lies dormant afterward. He may still feel worldly desires, but never acts on them.
-
44:00 Thoughts of sin and avak lashon hara
The Mashgiach explains why thoughts of sin are worse than the sin, that a passing thought is no sin for the Beinoni who repels it, and why the Tanya mentions only two of the three sins no one escapes daily, leaving out avak lashon hara.
-
48:07 The imprint of davening repels thoughts
The Mashgiach explains that being a Beinoni is a great level, that the imprint of davening and the hidden fear and love help him rule over the heart, and that he pushes a bad thought away with both hands. Impurity rises from heart to mind, but without lingering it bears nothing and dissipates.
-
53:11 Between man and his fellow: doing the opposite listed in the guide
Reading the Tanya on matters between man and his fellow, the Mashgiach explains that the Beinoni dismisses hostility and does the opposite, as Yosef did with his brothers. He tells of the Lechovitcher Rebbe and a Chassid whose competitor opened a store across the street, and answers a listener's objection.
The shiur, written up
The mind rules the heart, even in Haman
The Mashgiach reviews that in the Beinoni, the intermediate person, the evil inclination is knocked out, yet not like a fighter who can revive: it still voices its opinion but is never listened to. During davening the Beinoni is like a tzaddik, but only until the tefillah ends. The Tanya explains why: the mind by nature rules over the heart, since Hashem created in the mind the power to overpower passion. a
Light over darkness; why only a Beinoni
The Mashgiach brings the passuk in Koheles that wisdom excels folly as light excels darkness: one candle pushes away a whole dark room. So holiness drives out the folly of the kelipah, for, as the Gemara in Sotah says, a person sins only when a spirit of folly enters him. c,d
He then asks why so perfect a person is only called a Beinoni. The answer is that his advantage lies only in his thought, speech and action, not in his essence. Like a dancer lifted off the ground who must come down, after davening his animal soul speaks again.
The hidden love and the Purim decree
The Beinoni lacks the open flames of love in the heart's right chamber; he only knows he must obey the Torah. Yet within him is a hidden, natural love of the G-dly soul. a
To show this, the Mashgiach brings the Gemara where Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai answers that the Jews of Haman's time bowed to the image only outwardly, so the decree was only outward. He asks how Rabbi Shimon knew this, and answers that every Jew has a hidden love; even when his whole being sins, a tiny chamber in his heart protests. e,f
Forty levels and the tip of the yud
Yom Kippur, Amalek and Purim
The Ba'al HaTanya, in Likkutei Torah, explains the passuk 'before Hashem you shall be purified' to mean that Yom Kippur's atonement comes from above the yud, the Holy of Holies. Against this stands Amalek, the 'first' of the nations and the root of evil. The Arizal teaches that four books of the Torah correspond to the letters of the Name and Bereishis to the tip of the yud, where Jews are rooted and sin does not reach. j,k
Esther's fear and Mordechai ben Kish
Self-sacrifice opens the hidden chamber
Normally the gates of the Holy of Holies are closed; on Yom Kippur the fast, which the Gemara in Yoma treats as self-sacrifice, opens them. Mordechai opened them on an ordinary day. This hidden love is why even sinners gave their lives rather than worship idols, and why the Jews, called Yehudim for rejecting idolatry, did not abandon their Jewishness to escape the decree. q,s
The tzaddik's open love, the Beinoni's dormant love
Thoughts of sin and avak lashon hara
Thoughts of sin are worse than sin, since thought reaches a higher level than speech and action. Yet a passing thought is no sin for the Beinoni; pushing it away is a mitzvah.
The imprint of davening repels thoughts
One who learns the Chofetz Chaim will not stumble even there; being a Beinoni is a high level. The imprint of davening and the concealed fear and love help him rule the heart, so he repels a bad thought with both hands. w,a
In holiness the mind gives birth to love and fear in the heart; in impurity desire rises from heart to mind. Unless it lingers, it gives birth to nothing and dissipates.
Between man and his fellow: doing the opposite
Turning to matters between man and his fellow, the Tanya says that when hostility toward a fellow rises, the Beinoni dismisses it and does the very opposite, treating kindly one who mistreated him, as Yosef did with his brothers. a,x
A Chassid complained to the Lechovitcher Rebbe about a competitor across the street. The Rebbe sent him to work on himself; when he returned untroubled, the Rebbe said he must work until he is happy when customers go there. The Mashgiach adds that this is the Beinoni's lifelong task, and to a listener's objection he answers that opening the store was wrong, but so is bearing a grudge.
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
- b Esther 5:10 text index In the write-up: 6:14
- c Koheles 2:13 text index In the write-up: 7:54
- f apparently Daniel ch. 3 index In the write-up: 15:20
- n Esther 2:5 text index In the write-up: 34:39
- p Esther 3:2 text index In the write-up: 34:39
- t apparently I Divrei HaYamim 23:13 index In the write-up: 39:26
Talmud Bavli
- d Sotah 3a text index In the write-up: 7:54
- e apparently Megillah 12a index In the write-up: 15:20, 32:42
- h Rosh Hashanah 32a text index In the write-up: 20:00
- m apparently Megillah 15a index In the write-up: 32:42
- o apparently Megillah 12b index In the write-up: 34:39
- q Gemara Yoma (place not identified) index In the write-up: 35:46
- s apparently Megillah 13a index In the write-up: 35:46
- v apparently Bava Basra 164b index In the write-up: 46:56
Midrash
- u Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 39:26
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 4:45 In the Beinoni the evil inclination still voices its opinion but is never listened to, because by nature the mind rules over the heart.
- 11:04 The Beinoni's advantage is only in his functioning, his thought, speech and action, not in his essence, which is why he is not called a tzaddik.
- 18:53 Every Jew has a hidden love for Hashem in the depths of his heart, a fortieth level, the 'tip of the yud', that sin never reaches.
- 25:52 The atonement of Yom Kippur, and even more the salvation of Purim, come from this innermost place, opened by self-sacrifice.
- 45:27 A passing thought of sin is not a sin for the Beinoni; pushing it away immediately is a mitzvah.
- 53:26 Between man and his fellow, the Beinoni dismisses any feeling of hostility and does the very opposite, treating the other kindly.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 10:42 If the Beinoni never sins and silences his evil inclination, why is he not called a tzaddik?
Answer: 12:06 His advantage is only in his functioning, his thought, speech and action, not in his essence; his animal soul is not driven out.
-
Question: 17:57 How did Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai know that the Jews bowed to the image only outwardly?
Answer: 18:53 Every Jew has a hidden love for Hashem; even when his whole being sins, a hidden chamber in his heart protests.
-
Question: 31:12 What did Esther fear when she asked about the decree?
Answer: 32:50 That the impurity of sin had penetrated even the innermost point, the 'tip of the yud', where Amalek sought to enter; Hashem, judging by that inner point, saw it had not.
-
Question: 46:50 Why does the Tanya leave out avak lashon hara from the three sins no one escapes daily?
Answer: 47:28 A thought can be repelled before it becomes a sin, but one who speaks even avak lashon hara has sinned and is no longer a Beinoni; the Beinoni is saved from it.
-
Question: 56:57 A listener asks: is it not wrong to open the same store across the street, and is one not entitled to be upset?
Answer: 57:17 The Mashgiach answers that the Ba'al HaTanya would say: it was wrong to open the store, but it is wrong to bear a grudge; where is the bitachon and the love of Jews?
Stories
-
54:50 The Lechovitcher Rebbe and the competing store
A Chassid complained to the Lechovitcher Rebbe that someone had opened a store across the street selling the same merchandise. The Rebbe asked him where his emunah and his love of Jews were, and told him to work on himself until the resentment left his heart. The Chassid returned and said that it no longer bothered him when customers went to the competitor. The Rebbe answered that this was not enough: he must work until he is happy when a customer goes to the other store.
In the story: Rabbi Mordechai of Lechovitch
Insights
- 18:43 Man, like the world created with ten utterances in four letters, has forty powers; sin involves only thirty-nine, which is why the Sages read 'forty lashes' as thirty-nine: the fortieth level, the 'tip of the yud', is never touched by sin.
- 25:05 The atonement of Yom Kippur, 'before Hashem', comes from above the yud of Hashem's Name, the Holy of Holies within the Jew, where sin never entered.
- 26:34 Amalek is the 'first' of impurity, its own 'tip of the yud', set against the innermost point of holiness; Esther feared he had penetrated even there.
- 34:47 Mordechai is called 'ben Kish' because he knocked on the gates of mercy, opening the Holy of Holies on an ordinary day; a tzaddik's great act affects all Jewish souls.
- 46:56 The Tanya omits avak lashon hara from the three daily sins because a thought can be repelled before it is a sin, but words once spoken are already a sin, and a Beinoni does not speak them.
- 51:34 In holiness the mind gives birth to love and fear in the heart; in impurity desire rises from the heart to the mind, and if not allowed to linger it gives birth to nothing and dissipates.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 7:08 The Mashgiach says it is easier to neutralize bad thoughts by displacing them with holiness, with words of Torah, than by fighting them directly.
- 45:57 When a thought of sin comes, the Beinoni immediately declares war on it and pushes it away with both hands, which is a mitzvah.
- 48:07 The Mashgiach says that one who learns the Chofetz Chaim and stays conscious of it will not stumble even in avak lashon hara.
- 54:06 If one feels a grudge because a fellow mistreated him, the Mashgiach says he should treat him very nicely in return.
- 56:07 The Mashgiach says the Beinoni's task is constant work on his middos, both between man and Hashem and between man and his fellow.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Aharon HaKohen, Esther HaMalkah, Haman, Mordechai HaTzaddik, Nevuchadnetzar, Rabbi Mordechai of Lechovitch, Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, the Arizal, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Chofetz Chaim, the Rambam, Yosef HaTzaddik
Terms אהבה מסותרת, בינוני, חלל השמאלי, מוח שליט על הלב, מחשבות זרות, מסירות נפש, נפש הבהמית, קודש הקדשים, קוצו של יו"ד, רוח שטות, רשימו