“ויצא יצחק לשוח בשדה” - לבטל הקטרוגים הגדולים על זיווגו
Catalog entry: פרשת השבוע חיי שרה no. 4 Pocket Guide p. 5 תשל"ח (1977–78) Yiddish 1 hr 8 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains that Yitzchak's going out 'lasuach basadeh' was a Mincha prayer at Har HaMoriah that broke through the great accusations of Lavan-Bilam against his match with Rivkah.
The Mashgiach opens with Eliezer, Avraham's devoted disciple, who had a personal interest in marrying his own daughter to Yitzchak yet carried out the mission faithfully and even prayed against his own interest. Avraham rejected him as a mechutan because of lineage, and Lavan's words 'come in, blessed of Hashem' show that Eliezer had become blessed. The great novelty is that Lavan, identified with Bilam, the head of the forces of impurity, consented to that blessing. Lavan and Besuel schemed to kill Eliezer and keep Yitzchak from ever marrying; Besuel died of his own poison, and Rivkah's courageous 'I will go' broke Lavan's sorcery, like the Exodus from Egypt. To overcome these accusations Yitzchak prayed Mincha at Har HaMoriah, the source of all matches, hidden in ordinary conversation as the Ramban and Kedushas Levi explain. The Mashgiach closes with Avraham finding Me'aras HaMachpelah through his self-sacrificing hospitality, and urges yeshiva students to give time to bring others close.
Topics: Chayei Sarah and Me'aras HaMachpelah · Shidduchim and Chasunah · The Power of Tefilah
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Eliezer's interest and the plot of Besuel and Lavan
The Mashgiach describes Eliezer as Avraham's disciple who wanted his own daughter for Yitzchak and only noticed his interest on retelling the events. He then tells the Midrash that Besuel tried to poison Eliezer to block Yitzchak's marriage, and identifies Lavan with Bilam.
-
6:13 Why Avraham refused Eliezer as mechutan
Bringing the Tzidkas Hatzaddik, the Mashgiach explains that in a shidduch one avoids a family descended from a non-Jew without conversion, so Avraham refused Eliezer, who was of Canaan. Lavan's 'come in, blessed of Hashem' shows Eliezer became blessed by overcoming his personal interests.
-
10:05 Eliezer's prayer against his own interest
The Mashgiach stresses that Eliezer prayed wholeheartedly for the success of a mission against his own interest, something extraordinary since prayer can only come from the heart. He explains why Eliezer chose chesed as the sign: middos are inherited, and chesed was Avraham's essence.
-
13:59 The head of impurity agrees to the blessing
The Mashgiach explains that usually something must be given to the 'other side', but here Lavan-Bilam, the head of the chariot of impurity, himself said 'blessed of Hashem'. He compares this to the Gemara's two angels on Erev Shabbos, where even the bad angel answers amen.
-
17:53 'Let the girl stay with us' and Besuel's death
The Mashgiach reads the request that Rivkah stay 'days or ten' as the Midrash's seven days of mourning or twelve months, since Besuel had just died of his own poison, and asks what kind of answer 'do not delay me' is. He explains that Lavan, being Bilam, held Yaakov for twenty years with sorcery and wanted to hold Eliezer the same way.
-
24:05 Lavan's diplomacy and Rivkah's 'I will go'
The Mashgiach brings the Midrash that in the merit of Rivkah's 'I will go' the Jews left Egypt. He explains Lavan's request as diplomatic speech hiding Besuel's death, Eliezer's veiled reply showing he knew, and Rivkah standing up against her brother's sorcery.
-
28:43 A new creation, and leaving like Egypt
The Mashgiach explains that Avraham was a new creation with no ties to Terach, and Rivkah likewise owed her father nothing, so she could refuse to stay. He compares her last-minute departure with self-sacrifice to the haste of the Exodus, breaking a sorcery that kept anyone from leaving.
-
33:41 'From Hashem' means from Har HaMoriah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains 'the matter came from Hashem' as coming from Har HaMoriah, where Rivkah's birth was announced, and brings Tosafos that Yitzchak's 'sadeh' was Har HaMoriah. In the frightening twenty-four hours when Lavan-Bilam sought to swallow Klal Yisroel, Yitzchak prayed there, at the place where all matches originate.
-
40:08 Prayer hidden in conversation listed in the guide
The Mashgiach asks why the Ramban explains 'lasuach' as Yitzchak strolling with friends, and answers with the Kedushas Levi that tzaddikim clothe prayer in ordinary talk so it can pass the accusing angels. He tells of the Kedushas Levi talking in the kitchen at Mezritch and of a tzaddik's complaint about milk.
-
46:46 The greatness of Mincha listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that the Ramban hints at how great the accusation was, and that Yitzchak's talk with his friends was his Mincha. Mincha's greatness is stopping in the middle of work to speak to Hashem, at a time of strict judgment, and this prayer broke the kitrug; he then urges preparing for the blessing of Shabbos.
-
51:44 How Avraham found Me'aras HaMachpelah
The Mashgiach brings Pirkei d'Rabbi Eliezer that Avraham found Me'aras HaMachpelah while chasing the calf for his guests, and asks why it was revealed then, decades before he needed it. He brings a Midrash that Adam and Chava did not want Avraham there, and the halacha that one may not make a neighbor uncomfortable.
-
58:06 Hospitality beyond one's own comfort
The Mashgiach describes Avraham, ninety-nine years old on the third day after his milah on a hot day, running after guests with no thought for his comfort, so Adam and Chava had to yield their comfort for him. He explains that Avraham's hospitality brought people under the wings of the Shechinah, out of gratitude that Hashem had brought him close.
-
1:03:33 Giving time to bring others close
The Mashgiach notes the many children in yeshivos and the far greater number without Torah education, and says every yeshiva student should feel Avraham's gratitude and give at least a half hour a week to learn with others. He explains that giving time, like giving tzedakah, causes no loss but brings more.
The shiur, written up
Eliezer's interest and the plot of Besuel and Lavan
The Mashgiach opens with Eliezer, whom Chazal describe as an elder who sat in yeshiva, a true disciple of Avraham. Yet Eliezer had a personal interest: he hoped Yitzchak would marry his own daughter. Citing the Kotzker Rebbe, the Mashgiach notes that Eliezer only recognized this interest when he retold the events and reviewed them in his mind. a
Why Avraham refused Eliezer as mechutan
To explain why Avraham would not take Eliezer as a mechutan, the Mashgiach brings an introduction from the Tzidkas Hatzaddik: in a shidduch one avoids a family descended from a non-Jew without conversion, for even if the man himself is great, it shows up in the children. Eliezer was of Canaan, yet once he carried out his mission faithfully despite his interests, Lavan greeted him, 'Come in, blessed of Hashem.' e,f
Eliezer's prayer against his own interest
The Mashgiach stresses that Eliezer even prayed for the mission's success against his own interest. Prayer, he says, can only come from the heart: a person can act against his heart, but he cannot daven against it. He says a person should consider honestly whether he could pray wholeheartedly for another's success against his own interests.
He adds that Eliezer chose kindness as the sign because middos pass down by inheritance, and chesed was Avraham's essence.
The head of impurity agrees to the blessing
The Mashgiach explains that usually, even in the family of Dovid HaMelech, something must be thrown to the 'other side' so that it does not accuse. Here instead Lavan, who is Bilam, the head of the chariot of impurity, himself said 'blessed of Hashem.' This resembles the Gemara's two angels on Erev Shabbos, where even the bad angel must answer amen to the blessing. f,g
'Let the girl stay with us' and Besuel's death
After the match was agreed with 'the matter came from Hashem', they asked that Rivkah stay 'days or ten'. The Mashgiach brings the Midrash that this meant the seven days of mourning or twelve months, for Besuel had just died of his own poison. He asks what kind of reply Eliezer's 'do not delay me' is to that. h,i,j,k
He explains that Lavan, being Bilam himself, was the whole chariot of impurity, and with sorcery held Yaakov for twenty years; only a miracle let Yaakov free. Lavan wanted to hold Eliezer back in the same way.
Lavan's diplomacy and Rivkah's 'I will go'
The Mashgiach brings the Midrash that in the merit of Rivkah's 'I will go' the Jews left Egypt. Lavan's request, he explains, was diplomatic language hiding Besuel's death; Eliezer hinted back that he knew, and that Hashem had given him success. Rivkah, knowing her brother's great power of sorcery, nevertheless stood up against him and said, 'I will go.' l,m
A new creation, and leaving like Egypt
The Mashgiach explains that Avraham was a new creation with no tie to Terach, which is why he was at first childless, so that a new power of birth would begin with him. Rivkah likewise understood that she owed her father nothing and could refuse to stay.
Her departure resembled the Exodus: when the moment comes that one can no longer remain in impurity, one leaves in haste. Eliezer needed kefitzas haderech, and with self-sacrifice Rivkah broke a sorcery that held that no one could leave, as in Egypt.
'From Hashem' means from Har HaMoriah
The Mashgiach explains 'the matter came from Hashem' as coming from Har HaMoriah. Rashi brings that right after the Akeidah Rivkah's birth was announced, and there Yitzchak's match was determined. Tosafos explains that the 'field' where Yitzchak prayed Mincha was Har HaMoriah. h,n,o
Those twenty-four hours, until Eliezer returned, were frightful: Lavan-Bilam sought to swallow Klal Yisroel, kill Eliezer and leave Yitzchak unmarried. Eliezer succeeded through Yitzchak's prayer at Har HaMoriah, the source of all matches, since, as Chazal say, Adam and Chava were created from the earth of the place of the Mikdash.
Prayer hidden in conversation
The Gemara learns from 'lasuach basadeh' that Yitzchak prayed, yet the Ramban explains that he went strolling with his friends. The Mashgiach asks what compelled the Ramban to say this. He answers with the Kedushas Levi: tzaddikim can clothe prayer in ordinary talk, so that it passes the accusing angels that block certain prayers. p,q,r,s
When the Kedushas Levi came to Mezritch, he went into the kitchen in tallis and tefillin and spoke with the Rebbetzin about cooking; the Maggid said that tzaddikim speak to Hashem through such talk. Similarly, a tzaddik's complaint about weak milk turned out to be a prayer for a nursing mother. s
The greatness of Mincha
The Mashgiach says the Ramban hints at how great the accusation was, so that Yitzchak's Mincha was hidden in conversation with his friends. The greatness of Mincha, which the Gemara stresses, is stopping in the middle of work to speak to Hashem. It is a time of strict judgment, and Yitzchak's prayer broke through it. He concludes that one should prepare before Shabbos to receive its blessing. r,t
How Avraham found Me'aras HaMachpelah
The Mashgiach brings Pirkei d'Rabbi Eliezer: when the guests came, Avraham chased the calf until it entered Me'aras HaMachpelah, where he saw Adam and Chava and a place full of fragrance. He asks why it was revealed then, thirty-eight years before Sarah's death, while he was busy with guests. u
Hospitality beyond one's own comfort
Here, though, Avraham, ninety-nine years old on the third day after his milah, on a day as hot as the verse describes, ran after guests with no thought of his own comfort. Measure for measure, Adam and Chava had to set aside their comfort for him. x
Avraham's hospitality brought people under the wings of the Shechinah, teaching them to serve Hashem, out of gratitude that Hashem had brought him close.
Giving time to bring others close
The Mashgiach notes that while many children learn in yeshivos and Bais Yaakovs, millions of Jewish children do not. He says every yeshiva student should feel Avraham's gratitude and give at least half an hour a week to learn with others. Giving time, like tzedakah, causes no loss but brings more; a busy student must calculate how much, but everyone has some time to give.
Sources
Torah
- d Devarim 26:5 text index In the write-up: 3:19
- f Bereishis 24:31 text index In the write-up: 6:13, 14:25
- h Bereishis 24:50 text index In the write-up: 18:15, 33:55
- i Bereishis 24:55 text index In the write-up: 18:15
- k Bereishis 24:56 text index In the write-up: 18:15
- m Bereishis 24:58 text index In the write-up: 24:07
- p Bereishis 24:63 text index In the write-up: 40:11
- x Bereishis 18:1 text index In the write-up: 58:11
Targum
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
- b Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 3:19
- j Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 18:15
- l Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 24:07
- u apparently Pirkei d'Rabbi Eliezer ch. 36 index In the write-up: 52:35
- v Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 55:10
- y Midrash (place not identified) 1:02:31
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 9:37 Eliezer had a personal interest against the match, yet he fulfilled Avraham's mission completely and even prayed for its success against his own interest.
- 15:28 The novelty of 'come in, blessed of Hashem' is that Lavan, who is Bilam, the head of the forces of impurity, himself consented to Eliezer's blessing, as the bad angel answers amen on Erev Shabbos.
- 24:07 Rivkah's courageous 'I will go', said against her powerful brother, broke Lavan's sorcery, and in that merit the Jews left Egypt.
- 37:52 Yitzchak's 'lasuach basadeh' was his Mincha prayer at Har HaMoriah, the place from which all matches come, needed to break the accusations against his match.
- 48:31 The greatness of Mincha is that a person stops in the middle of his work and occupations to speak to Hashem.
- 54:42 Avraham was shown Me'aras HaMachpelah only after he disregarded his own comfort for his guests, which meant Adam and Chava too had to set aside their comfort for him.
- 1:03:19 Just as Avraham, out of gratitude for being brought close to Hashem, brought others close, every yeshiva student should give some of his time to bring others close.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 2:44 Why was Avraham not satisfied with Eliezer as a mechutan, though he was great and devoted?
Answer: 6:13 In a shidduch one avoids a family descended from a non-Jew without conversion, since traits pass to the children; Eliezer was of Canaan.
-
Question: 8:47 Why does one need Lavan's words to know that Eliezer became blessed?
Answer: 8:57 The novelty is that Lavan, the root of Bilam and the head of impurity, himself consented to the blessing, so the evil can no longer accuse.
-
Question: 20:05 What kind of answer is 'do not delay me' to the request that Rivkah stay a while?
Answer: 25:08 Lavan spoke diplomatically, hiding that Besuel had died of the poison meant for Eliezer; Eliezer hinted that he knew and that Hashem had given him success.
-
Question: 37:40 With what power did Eliezer succeed against the forces trying to cut off Klal Yisroel in those twenty-four hours?
Answer: 37:46 Through Yitzchak's prayer at Har HaMoriah, the place from which all matches come, where he prayed that Eliezer succeed.
-
Question: 40:51 Why does the Ramban explain 'lasuach' as Yitzchak walking and chatting with his friends?
Answer: 41:41 Following the Kedushas Levi, tzaddikim clothe prayer in ordinary talk to pass the accusers; Yitzchak's conversation was his Mincha in a time of great accusation.
-
Question: 54:04 Why was Me'aras HaMachpelah revealed to Avraham exactly then, long before he needed it?
Answer: 57:31 Adam and Chava did not want to be disturbed, but once Avraham ignored his own comfort for his guests, they too had to set aside their comfort for him.
Stories
-
41:48 The Kedushas Levi in the kitchen at Mezritch
When the Kedushas Levi came to the Maggid of Mezritch, where the students were very strict about prayer, he put on tallis and tefillin, went into the kitchen and began talking with the Rebbetzin about cooking. The students were upset at this. At the meal they told the Maggid, who said the Kedushas Levi understood his own conduct: tzaddikim can speak what seems like ordinary talk while speaking to Hashem.
In the story: Rabbi Levi Yitzchak of Berditchev, the Maggid of Mezritch
-
45:15 A tzaddik's complaint about milk
A tzaddik once went into the kitchen and complained angrily that he was not given a little milk, and the next day that the milk was weak and not nourishing. His disciple, who was present, wondered at such talk. A few minutes later a woman came home who had a baby and no milk, and said she had obtained milk but it was weak. Then the disciple understood that the tzaddik's words had been a prayer for her.
In the story: Rabbi Naftali of Ropshitz (the Zera Kodesh)
Insights
- 1:38 Eliezer's negiah went unnoticed even by him until he retold the events and reflected on them; only on review did he realize he had a personal interest.
- 12:33 Eliezer chose kindness as the sign rather than piety or long davening, because middos pass down by inheritance while other virtues he himself also had.
- 16:08 The greatest success is when the force of evil itself consents to the blessing, so that it can no longer accuse; this happened when Lavan-Bilam said 'blessed of Hashem'.
- 31:57 Rivkah's leaving Lavan's house was a model of the Exodus: a sorcery held that none could leave, and when the moment came that she could no longer remain in impurity, she left in haste with self-sacrifice.
- 41:41 The Ramban's plain reading that Yitzchak went to chat with friends hints at the Kedushas Levi's idea: in a time of great accusation, a tzaddik's prayer is hidden in ordinary speech so the accusing angels let it through.
- 1:00:11 Avraham was granted Me'aras HaMachpelah measure for measure: because he ignored his own comfort for his guests, Adam and Chava had to give up their comfort for him.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 10:57 The Mashgiach says a person should consider honestly how he himself would act, since true prayer for another's success against one's own interest must come from the whole heart.
- 48:59 The Mashgiach says that by Mincha a person should stop in the middle of his work and occupations to speak to Hashem, not forgetting Him even when busy with his livelihood.
- 1:04:17 The Mashgiach says every yeshiva student should feel gratitude to Hashem for being brought close and give at least a half hour a week to learn with others and bring them close.
- 1:06:29 The Mashgiach says one should know that giving time to others, like giving tzedakah, does not cause a loss but brings more.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Adam HaRishon, Avraham Avinu, Besuel, Bilaam, Chava, Eliezer, servant of Avraham, Lavan, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbi Levi Yitzchak of Berditchev, Rabbi Tzadok HaKohen of Lublin, Rashi, Rivka Imeinu, Terach, the Kotzker Rebbe (Rabbi Menachem Mendel of Kotzk), the Maggid of Mezritch, the Ramban, Yaakov Avinu, Yitzchak Avinu
Terms הכנסת אורחים, הכרת הטוב, כישוף, מסירות נפש, מערת המכפלה, מקום המקדש, סטרא אחרא, קטרוג, קפיצת הדרך, תחת כנפי השכינה