יוסף צדיק נסתר' בבחינת אור הגנוז שמאיר בחושך מצרים
Catalog entry: פרשת השבוע וישב no. 6 Pocket Guide p. 7 תשנ"ג (1992–93) Yiddish 1 hr 21 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains why the law that raising a child counts as bearing it stayed hidden from Yaakov, Yosef and Potiphar's wife, so that Yosef would pass his trials in Egypt and become the hidden tzaddik, the concealed light (or haganuz) that shines in the darkness of exile like the Chanukah lights.
The Mashgiach opens with Yosef's dream and the merit of Rachel's silence, then Yaakov's objection that Yosef's mother had died, answered by Rashi: Bilhah raised him, and one who raises an orphan is as if he bore him. He asks why Yaakov, who learned all of Torah, did not know this, and why Potiphar's wife tried to sin rather than wait for her daughter Asenath. He lays three foundations: the tzaddik yesod olam earns his place through trials in guarding the bris; chiddushim in Torah are revealed in their time; and the Pirkei d'Rabbi Eliezer account of Asenath. The law stayed hidden so that Yosef would face his trials and earn kingship. The Mashgiach then ties Yosef, first of the hidden tzaddikim, to the hidden light of Chanukah, and closes with the Lubliner story and Chanukah as a final sealing.
Topics: Yosef and His Brothers · The Hidden Light · The Chanukah Lights
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Yosef's sheaf and Rachel's silence
The Mashgiach reads Yosef's dream of his sheaf standing up as an allusion to the merit of his mother's silence, and asks why silence is cited when Rachel actively gave Leah the signs. He brings the Midrash that Rachel's plea for the Jewish people was accepted because she was not jealous of her sister.
-
4:49 Bilhah as Yosef's mother
Yaakov asks how Yosef's mother could bow when she had died, and Rashi answers that it means Bilhah, who raised him. The Mashgiach brings the Gemara that raising an orphan counts as bearing him, and asks how Yaakov, who learned all of Torah, did not know this. He then brings Rashi on the juxtaposition of Tamar and Potiphar's wife.
-
9:32 Two Moshiachs and Potiphar's wife's intent
The Mashgiach explains that every parsha holds Moshiach, and that the parshiyos of Yehuda and Yosef correspond to Moshiach ben David and Moshiach ben Yosef; both Tamar and Potiphar's wife acted for the sake of Heaven. He asks why Potiphar's wife sought to sin instead of waiting for Yosef to marry her daughter.
-
12:41 First foundation: the tzaddik yesod olam
The Mashgiach lays the first of three foundations: in every generation there is a tzaddik yesod olam, sometimes revealed and sometimes hidden, who sustains the world and reaches his level through trials in guarding the bris. Yosef is the tzaddik of this kind, and this merit leads to kingship.
-
15:59 Second foundation: chiddushim revealed in their time
The Mashgiach explains that new insights in Torah bring renewal into creation, and that rulings can change between generations, illustrated by measurements for a future korban. Some chiddushim are concealed until their time, like the law permitting a Moabite woman, revealed in Boaz's day and hidden earlier so that the Satan would not interfere with the line of Moshiach.
-
24:08 Third foundation: the story of Asenath
The Mashgiach brings Pirkei d'Rabbi Eliezer: Asenath, Dinah's daughter from Shechem, was sent away by Yaakov with an amulet, carried to Egypt and adopted by Potiphar's childless wife; she threw the amulet to Yosef, who recognized his father's writing and married her. Rabbeinu Bachya explains that she is called Potiphera's daughter because she was raised there.
-
28:53 Why the law stayed hidden: Yosef's trials
The Mashgiach answers the questions: Potiphar's wife did not know that a raised daughter counts as her own, and Yaakov did not know it either, because the chiddush had to stay hidden. Yosef had to become king through trials in guarding the bris, alone and young in Egypt; had Yaakov known, he would have taught Yosef, who could have simply offered to marry her daughter. The law was revealed only when Yosef became king.
-
39:00 The bris of the tongue and Yosef's kingship
The Mashgiach brings Sefer Yetzirah and the Toldos Yaakov Yosef that the bris of the tongue parallels the bris of the flesh, and the Chasam Sofer's reading of 'ein yisron l'baal halashon'. The brothers argued that one who speaks lashon hara cannot be king; Yosef answered with the merit of his mother's silence, which earns kingship. The Mashgiach stresses that Yosef did not speak lashon hara and that the dispute is beyond us.
-
46:23 Asenath's name and the hidden light of Chanukah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach asks why Asenath was hidden in a thornbush and named after it, and turns to Chanukah: Vayeshev and Mikeitz are the Chanukah parshiyos, and the Chanukah lights reveal the or haganuz, the light of Moshiach that will show the world in a new light. That light is hidden in the Torah, and one who toils in Torah sees it according to his level.
-
53:07 Inferior oils: souls Shabbos cannot kindle
The Mashgiach brings the tzaddikim's reading of the Gemara that wicks and oils unfit for Shabbos may be used for Chanukah: 'pesoles' hints at souls, since a soul is a candle. There are souls that even Shabbos cannot kindle, but the Chanukah light can.
-
56:33 Chanukah light in the public domain
The Mashgiach explains that Shabbos means staying in the reshus hayachid, the domain of the One, while reshus harabim is the domain of the other side. The Chanukah light is placed facing the public domain, on the left, below ten handbreadths, on weekdays and in the longest nights, like an oasis in the desert.
-
1:00:44 Thirty-six lights, thirty-six hidden tzaddikim listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Bnei Yissaschar that the thirty-six Chanukah lights correspond to the thirty-six hours Adam enjoyed the hidden light, and links them to the thirty-six hidden tzaddikim. The first of them is Yosef, a tzaddik nistar whom his brothers did not recognize, who kept the Torah in secret in Egypt and is a sign for Jews in exile.
-
1:05:22 The One who dwells in the thornbush listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the blessing to Yosef of 'the One who dwells in the thornbush' and the reason Hashem appeared in a thornbush: He is with the Jewish people in their distress. Yosef stayed holy in Egypt, the most impure land, and Asenath, carried there as a baby with only an amulet, also kept herself noble there, so she bears the name of the thornbush.
-
1:08:40 Asenath learned from Yosef; Yosef in today's Egypt listed in the guide
The Mashgiach suggests Asenath kept her holiness by watching Yosef in the same house. He then says today's bochurim are in an Egypt worse than before, recalling how much more modest the street once was, and brings the Ohr HaChaim that before Moshiach one can fall into the fiftieth gate of impurity but the Torah protects. He calls on them to be like Yosef and refuse the yetzer hara.
-
1:13:09 Chanukah as final sealing; the Lubliner's story
The Mashgiach notes that the idea of Chanukah as the final sealing of judgment was revealed only by the disciples of the Ba'al Shem Tov, a further chance for weaker generations. He tells how the Lubliner Rebbe saw an informer shining in all worlds as he lit Chanukah candles, explains that every Jew is good inside, and urges holding on to that light after Chanukah, when Hashem gives strength beyond one's own.
The shiur, written up
Yosef's sheaf and Rachel's silence
The Mashgiach opens with Yosef's dream that his sheaf stood up, and reads it as an allusion to the merit of his mother's silence. He asks why silence is the merit cited, when Rachel did far more than keep quiet: she actively handed Leah the signs so that her sister would not be shamed. He then brings the Midrash that when Rachel pleaded for the Jewish people, saying she had not been jealous of her sister, Hashem answered her, 'there is reward for your deed.' a,b,c
Bilhah as Yosef's mother
Yaakov objected to the dream: how could Yosef's mother bow, when Rachel had already died? Rashi answers that it refers to Bilhah, who raised him, and the Gemara teaches that one who raises an orphan in his home is as if he bore him. The Mashgiach asks how Yaakov, who learned all of Torah from Shem and Ever, did not know this. He then brings Rashi that Potiphar's wife, like Tamar, meant it for Heaven: she saw in the stars that she would have descendants from Yosef. d,e,f,i
Two Moshiachs and Potiphar's wife's intent
Every parsha carries Moshiach, the Mashgiach explains, and here the parshiyos of Yehuda and Yosef stand for Moshiach ben David and Moshiach ben Yosef. Yet he asks: if Potiphar's wife did not know whether the children would come from her or from her daughter, why risk a sin rather than wait for Yosef to marry her daughter?
First foundation: the tzaddik yesod olam
To answer, the Mashgiach lays three foundations. The first: in every generation there is a tzaddik yesod olam, the foundation of the world, sometimes revealed and sometimes hidden, in whose merit the world is sustained. He reaches this level through trials in guarding the bris, and Yosef is the tzaddik in this sense; this merit leads to kingship.
Second foundation: chiddushim revealed in their time
The second foundation is that Torah is constantly renewed: new insights in Torah, accepted in Heaven, bring renewal into creation, and rulings can change between generations. As an example, the Mashgiach explains that one who eats cheilev today should record how much he ate, since in the time of the Beis Hamikdash the measure for a korban might be ruled differently.
Some chiddushim stay hidden until their time. Ruth was a Moabite, and only in Boaz's day was it revealed that the verse barring Moabites applies to men and not to women. Why not earlier? Because Moshiach would come from that union, and the Satan, who works to hold Moshiach back, would have obstructed it; so the matter was concealed. m
Third foundation: the story of Asenath
The third foundation comes from Pirkei d'Rabbi Eliezer. Dinah had a daughter from Shechem, and to save her from the brothers Yaakov wrote on an amulet that she was of his family and placed her in a thornbush. She was brought to Egypt and adopted by Potiphar's childless wife. When the girls of Egypt threw ornaments so that Yosef would look at them, she threw the amulet; Yosef recognized his father's writing and married Asenath. Rabbeinu Bachya explains that the verse calls her Potiphera's daughter because she was raised there. o,q,p
Why the law stayed hidden: Yosef's trials
Now the questions resolve. Potiphar's wife saw correctly that her household would have children from Yosef, since a raised daughter truly counts as one's own; but she did not know that chiddush, so she pursued him herself. Yaakov did not know it either, which is why he objected to the dream. The Mashgiach explains that it was hidden on purpose: Yosef had to become king of Egypt, and kingship comes through guarding the bris.
The other brothers were tzaddikim, but only Yosef had such trials. Day after day she pressured him, a seventeen-year-old alone in Egypt, the most corrupt place, with no father, brother or rebbe to strengthen him. Had Yaakov known the law, he would have taught it to Yosef, to whom he passed all his learning, and Yosef would simply have offered to marry her daughter and avoided the trials. So it stayed hidden until Yosef became king.
The bris of the tongue and Yosef's kingship
The Mashgiach brings Sefer Yetzirah, cited by the Toldos Yaakov Yosef, that the bris of the tongue parallels the bris of the flesh: one who defiles his mouth defiles the bris. The Chasam Sofer reads the verse about the 'master of the tongue' as an acronym of mila. t,u,w
From here he explains the brothers' retort, 'will you reign over us?': kingship requires guarding the bris, and they held that Yosef spoke lashon hara. Yosef answered that he would reign in the merit of his mother, who guarded her mouth and revealed nothing; that is why he cited her silence and not her giving the signs. The Mashgiach stresses that Yosef did not speak lashon hara, and that what passed between him and the holy tribes is beyond our grasp. x
Asenath's name and the hidden light of Chanukah
The Mashgiach asks why so much happened to Asenath, and why she was hidden in a thornbush and named for it. He turns to Chanukah: Vayeshev and Mikeitz are read then, and the Bnei Yissaschar brings that the Chanukah lights reveal the or haganuz, the light of Moshiach. When Moshiach comes the world will be seen in another light, as a green or red lamp colors everything, and all the questions of exile will be answered. j
Inferior oils: souls Shabbos cannot kindle
Chanukah light in the public domain
Shabbos, the Mashgiach explains, means staying in the reshus hayachid, the domain of the One, and not going out to the reshus harabim, the place of the other side. The Chanukah light, by contrast, is placed facing the public domain, on the left, below ten handbreadths, on weekdays and in the longest nights, like an oasis found in the middle of a desert.
Thirty-six lights, thirty-six hidden tzaddikim
The Bnei Yissaschar, citing Rabbi Pinchas of Koretz, links the thirty-six Chanukah lights to the thirty-six hours Adam enjoyed the hidden light. So too there are thirty-six hidden tzaddikim, and the first is Yosef, a tzaddik nistar: his brothers did not recognize him, and Targum Onkelos says he kept the Torah in secret. He was set in Egypt, the reshus harabim, as a sign for Jews kindling Chanukah lights in exile. af,ah
The One who dwells in the thornbush
Yosef was blessed by 'the One who dwells in the thornbush'. Hashem appeared in a thornbush to show that He is with the Jewish people in distress. Egypt was so impure that hardly anyone stayed pure there, yet Yosef remained holy, and Asenath, brought there as a baby, also kept herself noble, so her name recalls the thornbush. ak
Asenath learned from Yosef; Yosef in today's Egypt
How did Asenath keep her holiness? Perhaps, the Mashgiach suggests, by watching Yosef in the same house and learning from his conduct. He then says today's bochurim are in an Egypt worse than ever, recalling how decent the street once was. Bringing the Ohr HaChaim, he says the Torah protects even near the fiftieth gate of impurity, and when the yetzer hara comes one should refuse like Yosef. al
Chanukah as final sealing; the Lubliner's story
That Chanukah is the final sealing of judgment was revealed only by the disciples of the Ba'al Shem Tov; earlier generations knew of Yom Kippur. Weaker generations, the Mashgiach explains, were given another chance.
He tells of an informer whose name disciples brought to the Lubliner Rebbe on a kvittel. The Rebbe spoke of a light, and explained that at that moment the man was lighting Chanukah candles, when a Jew shines in all worlds. Every Jew is good inside, and at Chanukah his hidden light shines; one must not let it go but carry it past Chanukah. Then Hashem gives strength beyond one's own, as 'many in the hands of the few'. an
Sources
Torah
- a Bereishis 37:7 text index In the write-up: 1:48
- d Bereishis 37:10 text index In the write-up: 5:02
- m apparently Devarim 23:4 index In the write-up: 20:58
- q Bereishis 41:45 text index In the write-up: 24:29
- r apparently Bereishis 39:10 33:04 index
- x Bereishis 37:8 text index In the write-up: 41:14
- y apparently Bereishis 37:2 41:44 index
- ag apparently Bereishis 42:8 1:03:05 index
- ak apparently Devarim 33:16 index In the write-up: 1:05:37
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Targum
Talmud Bavli
Talmud Yerushalmi
Midrash
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
- e Rashi on Bereishis 37:10 text index In the write-up: 5:02
- i Rashi on Bereishis 39:1 text index In the write-up: 5:02
- p apparently Rabbeinu Bachya on Bereishis 41:45 index In the write-up: 24:29
- s apparently Rashi on Bereishis 37:3 37:09 index
- ai apparently Rashi on Bereishis 39:11 1:04:22 index
- am apparently Rambam, Hilchos Geirushin 2:20 1:17:18 index
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 5:02 Rashi answers Yaakov's question about Yosef's dead mother: Bilhah raised Yosef, and one who raises an orphan in his home is regarded as having given birth to him.
- 20:37 Not every chiddush in Torah is revealed in every generation; some are concealed until their time, as with the law permitting a Moabite woman, revealed only in Boaz's day.
- 31:31 The law that a raised child counts as one's own stayed hidden from Yaakov, Yosef and Potiphar's wife so that Yosef would have to face his trials in Egypt and so become the tzaddik yesod olam and king.
- 41:36 Kingship is earned through guarding the bris, and guarding the mouth is its parallel; this is why Yosef invoked his mother's silence rather than her act of giving the signs.
- 48:28 The Chanukah lights reveal the or haganuz, the hidden light that is the light of Moshiach, which today is found concealed in the Torah.
- 1:02:22 Yosef was the first of the thirty-six hidden tzaddikim, a hidden light set in Egypt, the most impure place, and a sign for Jews kindling Chanukah lights in exile.
- 1:13:43 Chanukah is the final sealing of judgment, because at Chanukah even weak people receive strength beyond their own, as 'many in the hands of the few'.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 5:00 How could Yaakov say 'I and your mother' would bow, when Rachel had already died?
Answer: 5:08 Rashi explains it refers to Bilhah, who raised Yosef, and one who raises an orphan is as if he bore him.
-
Question: 11:57 Why did Potiphar's wife seek to sin rather than wait for Yosef to marry her daughter?
Answer: 29:37 Asenath was not her natural daughter, and she did not know the chiddush that a raised child counts as one's own.
-
Question: 22:20 Why was the permission of a Moabite woman revealed only in Boaz's time?
Answer: 22:26 Because Moshiach would come from that union, and had the Satan known he would have done everything to obstruct it; so the matter was concealed until its time.
-
Question: 7:53 How could Yaakov, who learned all of Torah from Shem and Ever, not know that raising a child counts as bearing it?
Answer: 31:31 The chiddush was hidden from him, because had he known he would have taught Yosef, and Yosef would have avoided his trials, which he needed in order to become king.
-
Question: 2:54 Why did Yosef cite his mother's silence rather than her giving the signs to Leah, which was the greater merit?
Answer: 44:04 Because kingship is earned specifically through guarding the mouth, the parallel of guarding the bris.
Stories
-
24:29 Asenath and the amulet
According to Pirkei d'Rabbi Eliezer as the Mashgiach tells it, Dinah had a daughter from Shechem, and the brothers wanted to harm her. Yaakov wrote on an amulet that she was of his children, placed her in a thornbush, and she was carried to Egypt and given to Potiphar's wife, who had no children and adopted her. When Yosef rode through Egypt and the girls threw ornaments to make him look, Asenath threw the amulet; Yosef recognized his father's writing and married her.
In the story: Shechem ben Chamor, Yaakov Avinu, Yosef HaTzaddik, Dinah, Osnas, Potiphar, the angel Michael, the angel Gavriel, Potiphar's wife, Ephraim, Menashe, Potiphera
-
1:15:23 The Lubliner and the informer
In a certain town an informer caused many troubles, informing on Jews to the government. Disciples of the Rebbe of Lublin wrote a kvittel with his name and gave it to the Rebbe, who looked at it and spoke of a light; they wondered how this could be said of such a wicked man. When they asked, the Lubliner explained that at the moment they handed him the kvittel the man was lighting Chanukah candles, and when a Jew lights Chanukah candles he shines in all worlds.
In the story: the Chozeh of Lublin, the Imrei Emes (Rabbi Avraham Mordechai of Ger), the Chiddushei HaRim, the Sfas Emes, the Shem MiShmuel of Sochatchov, the Avnei Nezer of Sochatchov
Insights
- 31:31 The Mashgiach reads Yaakov's ignorance of a simple Gemara as deliberate concealment from Above: the law had to stay hidden so that Yosef would face his trials and earn kingship, and it was revealed only once he became king.
- 30:05 Potiphar's wife was right in her astrology, since Asenath, whom she raised, truly counts as her daughter; her error came only from not knowing that chiddush.
- 41:30 The brothers' retort 'will you reign over us' meant that one who speaks lashon hara has broken the bris of the tongue and cannot be king; Yosef answered that he would reign in the merit of his mother's silence.
- 58:42 Yosef as the hidden light was placed specifically in Egypt, the reshus harabim and place of the other side, just as the Chanukah light is placed facing the public domain, low, on the left and in the darkest nights.
- 1:07:32 Asenath's name comes from the thornbush (sneh): like Hashem in the thornbush and like Yosef, she remained noble and holy in Egypt, which matched her to Yosef, blessed by 'the One who dwells in the thornbush'.
- 54:40 The Chanukah lights can kindle souls that even Shabbos cannot, the 'inferior oils', because the Chanukah light was made to shine into places that are otherwise unfit.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 1:11:27 The Mashgiach says that bochurim today, in an Egypt with great trials, must hold on through Torah, which keeps them holy.
- 1:12:38 The Mashgiach says that when the yetzer hara tempts one to look, speak or act where one may not, one should refuse firmly, like Yosef in Egypt.
- 1:18:34 The Mashgiach says one should not let go of the light kindled at Chanukah but take it along afterward and begin serving Hashem from then on.
- 52:18 The Mashgiach mentions that it is a great segulah to look at the Chanukah lights, since the eyes are permeated with the hidden light.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Adam HaRishon, Bilhah, Boaz, Dinah, Dovid HaMelech, Ever, Leah Imeinu, Naomi, Osnas, Potiphar's wife, Potiphera, Rabbeinu Bachya, Rabbi Pinchas of Koretz, Rabbi Yaakov Yosef of Polnoye (the Toldos), Rachel Imeinu, Rus, Shechem ben Chamor, Shem, Tamar, the angel Michael, the Arizal, the Baal Shem Tov, the Bnei Yissaschar (Rabbi Tzvi Elimelech of Dinov), the Chasam Sofer, the Chozeh of Lublin, the Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh, Yaakov Avinu, Yehudah (son of Yaakov), Yosef HaTzaddik
Terms אור הגנוז, גמר חתימה, מואבי ולא מואבית, משיח בן יוסף, פסולת, צדיק, צדיק נסתר, קדושת הברית, רשות הרבים, שטן