The נצחון of the קדושה of יוסף in the Deep טומאה of מצרים. Explanation of the words אלמתי קמה and יוסף's נסיון in מצרים
Catalog entry: PARSHA (English) וישב no. 2 Pocket Guide p. 56 תשס"ה (2004–05) English 47 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains why the halacha that one who raises a child is considered its parent was hidden even from Yaakov Avinu: only so could Yosef face the tests of Eshes Potiphar and become Yosef HaTzaddik, whose holiness protected Klal Yisrael and stands behind Chanukah.
The Mashgiach opens with Yosef's dream of the sheaves and Rashi's reading that Yaakov's words 'your mother' meant Bilhah, who raised Yosef, and asks why Yaakov did not know that whoever raises a child counts as its parent. He then asks why Eshes Potiphar, who meant to bring Moshiach ben Yosef and did not know whether it would come through her or her daughter, did not simply have Yosef marry her daughter. He lays three foundations: Yosef alone earned the title tzaddik by guarding the bris through tests; certain halachos are revealed only in their time; and Asnas was Dinah's daughter, adopted by Potiphar's wife. A long digression applies Torah to the Arab struggle over Eretz Yisrael. The answer: the halacha of adoption stayed hidden so that Yosef would be tested, become a tzaddik, and keep Klal Yisrael pure in Mitzrayim. He closes by linking Chanukah to the holiness of Yosef.
Topics: Yosef and His Brothers · Shmiras HaBris
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Alumasi and Yaakov's 'your mother' listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the reading that 'alumasi' in Yosef's dream alludes to Rachel keeping quiet, and asks why only her silence is mentioned. He then brings Rashi that Yaakov's 'your mother' meant Bilhah who raised Yosef, and asks why Yaakov did not know that one who raises a child counts as the parent.
-
5:07 Tamar, Eshes Potiphar and the kasha listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains why the parsha of Yehuda and Tamar is placed next to Yosef and Eshes Potiphar: both meant it for the sake of Heaven, one for Moshiach ben David and one for Moshiach ben Yosef. He then asks why Eshes Potiphar, not knowing whether the offspring would come from her or her daughter, did not have Yosef marry her unmarried daughter instead of taking the risk herself.
-
10:00 Why Yosef alone is called HaTzaddik listed in the guide
In the first of three foundations, the Mashgiach explains that each of the seven shepherds has his own distinction, and Yosef's is tzaddik, the one who guards the holiness of the bris. He describes the seventeen-year-old Yosef's daily tests and threats from Eshes Potiphar, and explains that a title is earned only through tests, which is why the brothers, though holy, are not called tzaddik.
-
17:34 The Torah as the blueprint of the world
Opening the second foundation, the Mashgiach explains that Hashem looked into the Torah and created the world, like an architect with a blueprint, and brings the Kotzker that the world is the text and the Torah its commentary. He tells of a woman who asked him for his view of world events, and says he looks into the Torah to understand the world.
-
21:10 Yishmael's empty milah and Eretz Yisrael
The Mashgiach brings that the angel of Yishmael claimed Eretz Yisrael because Yishmael also has milah, and Hashem answered that their milah is empty, not a bris, so they would hold the land only while it is empty. Now that a third of Klal Yisrael has returned, the Arabs sense their end and fight like a candle flaring before it goes out.
-
29:28 Halachos revealed in their time
Returning to his point, the Mashgiach says the Avos could read the Torah out of the world, yet some matters of Torah are revealed only at their time, like the halacha of Moavi velo Moavis revealed through Boaz, Purim and Chanukah, and the prophecy of Yeshayahu. He then introduces the third foundation from Pirkei d'Rabbi Eliezer and Targum Yonasan.
-
32:42 Asnas, daughter of Dinah Story listed in the guide
The Mashgiach tells how Yaakov saved Dinah's daughter from the angry brothers, hung a charm with his name around her neck, and how the angel Gavriel brought her to the childless house of Potiphar, who adopted her. When the girls threw jewelry at Yosef, Asnas threw her charm; Yosef recognized his father's writing and asked for her.
-
37:57 The answer: a halacha hidden for Yosef's tests listed in the guide
The Mashgiach answers: Asnas was only adopted, and Eshes Potiphar did not know that an adopted daughter counts as her own. Yosef did not tell her because he did not know, and he did not know because Yaakov did not know; the halacha was hidden so that Yosef would have his tests and become the tzaddik whose merit kept Klal Yisrael pure in Mitzrayim.
-
43:20 Chanukah and the holiness of Yosef listed in the guide
Briefly, the Mashgiach says that Chanukah is the victory of the holiness of Yosef: Melech Yavan equals Yosef in gematria, and Yehudis annulled the decree against Jewish brides, which is why women are obligated in Chanukah lights and why dairy is eaten. The parshiyos of Yosef are read in Chanukah week, and he says a Jew should strengthen his own boundaries to connect with Kedushas Yosef.
The shiur, written up
Alumasi and Yaakov's 'your mother'
Tamar, Eshes Potiphar and the kasha
The Mashgiach brings Rashi that the parsha of Yehuda and Tamar stands beside that of Yosef and Eshes Potiphar because both women acted for the sake of Heaven. Tamar knew Moshiach ben David would come from Yehuda; Eshes Potiphar saw in her stargazing that she would have offspring from Yosef, but not whether from herself or her daughter. She was seeking Moshiach ben Yosef, the Mashgiach adds. g
Hence his kasha: if she did not know, why not have Yosef marry her unmarried daughter, with no risk at all, and be the grandmother, instead of endangering herself and Yosef?
Why Yosef alone is called HaTzaddik
Before answering, the Mashgiach lays three foundations. First, each of the seven shepherds has his own distinction: Avraham is the lover of Hashem, Yitzchak is marked by fear, and only Yosef is called HaTzaddik, the title of one who guards the holiness of the bris. h,i,j
Yosef was seventeen, torn from his family and sold as a slave with no idea whether he would remain one. For a whole year Eshes Potiphar tempted him daily, and the Midrash says she threatened to blind and imprison him; each time he answered by pointing to Hashem. k,l
A title, the Mashgiach explains, is earned only through tests, as Avraham earned his through ten. The brothers were also holy in Mitzrayim, but without tests they were not called tzaddik.
The Torah as the blueprint of the world
The second foundation: Hashem looked into the Torah and created the world, so the Torah is its blueprint. The Mashgiach brings the Kotzker that the world is the text and the Torah its commentary. A woman called him this week for his view of the Arab terror, and he explains that he looks into the Torah to understand the world. m
Yishmael's empty milah and Eretz Yisrael
The angel of Yishmael, the Mashgiach brings, complained that Yishmael also keeps milah and deserves Eretz Yisrael. Hashem answered that a Jew's milah is a bris, while theirs is mere surgery. The Mashgiach cites the Rambam that milah weakens desire and the Gemara that Arabia took most of the world's immorality: their milah does not curb them. This was also the brothers' claim against Shechem. o,p,q
Because their milah is empty, they were given the land while it is empty, through the long galus. Since the war a third of Klal Yisrael has returned, and the Arabs sense their end. Like a Chanukah candle that flares as its wax runs out, they fight back with all their strength.
Halachos revealed in their time
Returning, the Mashgiach says the Avos could read the Torah from the world, as an architect reads the blueprint from a building. Yet some halachos are revealed only in their time: Moavi velo Moavis was unknown until Boaz derived it from the pesukim, which is why Doeg challenged David's lineage. s
Asnas, daughter of Dinah
The third foundation comes from Pirkei d'Rabbi Eliezer and Targum Yonasan. Dinah had a daughter from Shechem, and to protect her from the angry brothers Yaakov hung a charm bearing his name on her neck and left her on a thorn bush. The angel Gavriel brought her to the childless Potiphar, who adopted her. t,u
Later, when girls threw jewelry at Yosef to catch his eye, Asnas threw her charm. Yosef recognized his father's handwriting, looked up, and asked Pharaoh for her.
The answer: a halacha hidden for Yosef's tests
Chanukah and the holiness of Yosef
Chanukah, the Mashgiach says, is the victory of the holiness of Yosef; Melech Yavan equals Yosef in gematria. Yehudis annulled the decree against brides, the reason the Rema gives for eating dairy and the Gemara in Shabbos for women's obligation in the lights. Yosef's parshiyos fall in Chanukah week, and a Jew, he says, should build boundaries in himself to connect to that holiness. aa,ab
Sources
Torah
- a apparently Bereishis 37:7 index In the write-up: 0:24
- b apparently Bereishis 37:10 index In the write-up: 2:18
- i apparently Bereishis 31:42 index In the write-up: 10:24
- k apparently Bereishis 39:10 index In the write-up: 13:19
- q apparently Bereishis ch. 34 index In the write-up: 21:39
- v apparently Bereishis 49:22 34:47 index
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Targum
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
- c apparently Rashi on Bereishis 37:10 index In the write-up: 2:18, 38:34
- g apparently Rashi on Bereishis 39:1 index In the write-up: 5:36
- o apparently Moreh Nevuchim 3:49 index In the write-up: 21:39
- w apparently Rashi on Bereishis 37:3 index In the write-up: 38:34
- y apparently Rashi on Vayikra 24:11 index In the write-up: 41:24
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 2:28 Following Rashi, Yaakov's 'your mother' referred to Bilhah who raised Yosef, which raises the question why Yaakov did not know that one who raises a child counts as the parent.
- 11:26 The title tzaddik belongs specifically to Yosef, because he guarded the holiness of the bris through a year of daily tests in Potiphar's house.
- 30:44 Certain halachos given at Sinai remain hidden until their proper time, such as Moavi velo Moavis, revealed only through Boaz.
- 34:26 Asnas was not Eshes Potiphar's natural daughter but Dinah's daughter whom she adopted, so she did not know that Asnas counted as her own.
- 43:26 The whole matter of Chanukah is the victory of the holiness of Yosef, which is why his parshiyos are read in the week of Chanukah.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 3:03 Why did Yaakov say Yosef's mother was already dead, when he surely knew that one who raises a child is considered its parent and Bilhah raised Yosef?
Answer: 41:22 That halacha was among those not revealed until their time; it stayed hidden so that Yosef would face his tests and become a tzaddik.
-
Question: 8:21 If Eshes Potiphar did not know whether the offspring would come from her or her daughter, why did she not have Yosef marry her unmarried daughter instead of risking herself?
Answer: 38:34 Asnas was only adopted, and she did not know that an adopted daughter counts as her own before Heaven.
-
Question: 40:00 Why did Yosef, who learned everything from Yaakov, not tell her that Asnas counts as her daughter?
Answer: 40:42 Yosef did not know it, because Yaakov did not know it.
-
Question: 11:26 Why is only Yosef called HaTzaddik, and not Avraham, Yitzchak, Yaakov or Moshe?
Answer: 11:43 Tzaddik is the title of one who guards the holiness of the bris through tests, which Yosef did in Potiphar's house.
-
Question: 21:59 If Yishmael also keeps milah, why should they not have a claim on Eretz Yisrael?
Answer: 22:26 Their milah is surgery, not a bris with Hashem, so it is empty, and they were given the land only while it is empty.
Stories
-
32:52 Asnas and the charm
Dinah had a baby girl fathered by Shechem, and the brothers were angry and wanted to harm her. Yaakov took the baby, hung a charm around her neck on which he wrote that she was from the family of Yaakov and signed his name, and set her down on a thorn bush. The angel Gavriel brought her to Mitzrayim to the childless house of Potiphar, who adopted her. Years later, when girls on the rooftops threw jewelry at Yosef to catch his eye, Asnas threw her charm; Yosef saw his father's handwriting, looked up, and asked Pharaoh for her.
In the story: Shechem ben Chamor, Yaakov Avinu, Yosef HaTzaddik, Dinah, Osnas, Potiphar, the angel Michael, the angel Gavriel, Potiphar's wife, Ephraim, Menashe, Potiphera
-
19:53 A woman asks the Mashgiach about world events
The Mashgiach relates that a woman who had asked him two years earlier for his explanation of the Twin Towers, and had printed it in a book that became a bestseller, called again that week. She wanted his explanation of why the Arabs were being roused to such terror now. He told her his explanation and left it to her whether to print it.
-
44:05 Yehudis and the decree
The Mashgiach brings from the Midrashim that the Greeks decreed against Jewish brides before their weddings. Yehudis, daughter of Yochanan Kohen Gadol, fed the king dairy, put him to sleep, and cut off his head, and the decree was annulled.
In the story: Yehudis, Yochanan Kohen Gadol
Insights
- 41:24 The halacha that a raiser counts as a parent was hidden even from Yaakov by design: had it been known, Eshes Potiphar would have sent Asnas to Yosef, and Yosef would never have had the tests that made him a tzaddik.
- 16:28 A title like tzaddik is earned only through tests; Yosef's brothers were also holy, but without tests they did not earn the name.
- 7:58 Eshes Potiphar sought Moshiach ben Yosef just as Tamar sought Moshiach ben David, which is a further reason the two parshiyos stand side by side.
- 22:53 Yishmael's milah, being surgery rather than a bris, is empty, so they were given Eretz Yisrael only while it is empty; as the land fills with Jews they sense their end and resist like a candle flaring before it dies.
- 29:54 The Avos could read the Torah from the world, as an architect can read the blueprint from a finished building.
- 43:37 Melech Yavan equals Yosef in gematria (156), showing that the war of Chanukah was a battle of the holiness of Yosef.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 46:31 The Mashgiach says that on Chanukah a Jew should make boundaries in himself so as to have more connection with the holiness of Yosef, and thereby merit the gifts from Heaven that Chanukah brings.
- 19:31 The Mashgiach says every Jew has a share in the Torah, and he himself looks into the Torah to understand what happens in the world.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Aharon HaKohen, Avraham Avinu, Bilhah, Boaz, Dinah, Doeg HaAdomi, Dovid HaMelech, Ever, Leah Imeinu, Moshe Rabbeinu, Osnas, Potiphar, Potiphar's wife, Rabbi Eliezer (ben Hurkenos), Rachel Imeinu, Shaul HaMelech, Shechem ben Chamor, Shem, Shlomis bas Divri, Tamar, the angel Gavriel, the Kotzker Rebbe (Rabbi Menachem Mendel of Kotzk), the Rambam, the Rema, Yaakov Avinu, Yehudah (son of Yaakov), Yehudis, Yeshayahu HaNavi, Yishmael, Yitzchak Avinu, Yochanan Kohen Gadol, Yonasan ben Uziel, Yosef HaTzaddik
Terms אושפיזין, לשם שמים, מואבי ולא מואבית, מזל, משיח בן דוד, משיח בן יוסף, נסיון, פחד יצחק, קדושת הברית, שבעה רועים, שר של מעלה