מה שמועה שמע ובא? קריאת ים סוף ומלחמת עמלק

Catalog entry: פרשת השבוע יתרו no. ⁨1⁩ Pocket Guide p. 9 תשל"ג (1972–73) Yiddish 1 hr 23 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 1 hr 23 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Mashgiach's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Mashgiach describes the signs of ikvesa d'Meshicha, the confusion and the test of emunah in the last generation, and learns from Yisro, who came to Moshe after hearing of Kriyas Yam Suf and the war of Amalek, that the only safeguard is to attach oneself to tzaddikim and to good, upright Jews.

Continuing a series on the coming of Moshiach, the Mashgiach explains why the calculated ketzin passed, and that there is a time fixed in creation when Moshiach must come. He speaks of Moshiach ben Yosef and ben David, of chevlei Moshiach and of war as a sign of redemption, bringing the Chasam Sofer that in a world war one should pray for Moshiach. From Daniel, Malachi and the Gemara in Sanhedrin he lists the signs of the last generation: great troubles, a Torah world that shrinks, the upright feeling small, and the erev rav growing strong. He answers a newspaper article that attacked the gedolei Torah, showing from the Gemara about Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai that Jews must follow the daas Torah of the tzaddikim even when a decree is sealed. He closes with Yisro, who saw that even after Kriyas Yam Suf Amalek could attack, and so came to Moshe: in such a time one stays a Jew only near the tzaddik and among good Jews.

Topics: Signs of the Generation Before Moshiach · Hiskashrus to Tzaddikim and Emunas Chachamim · The Time of the Geulah and the Ketz

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Why the calculated ketzin passed

    Continuing the talks on the coming of Moshiach, the Mashgiach asks why the ketzin calculated by Rishonim and Acharonim passed without redemption, and explains that there is a time fixed in creation when Moshiach must come. He compares it to Moshe's first appearance in Mitzrayim, after which the bondage grew harder before the redemption.

  2. 5:32 Moshiach ben Yosef, ben David and chevlei Moshiach

    The Mashgiach explains that Moshiach is a comprehensive soul, joining the soul of Moshe with that of David, and that before it is complete it can appear in parts as Moshiach ben Yosef and Moshiach ben David. He describes chevlei Moshiach and war as a sign of redemption, brings the Chasam Sofer on praying for Moshiach in a time of war, and the tzaddikim who said in the First World War that chevlei Moshiach had begun and the world would keep boiling like a pot before Shabbos.

  3. 12:02 Daniel, Malachi and the signs of the end

    The Mashgiach brings the passuk in Daniel about a time of trouble unlike any since Klal Yisrael became a nation, and Malachi's last chapter: the wicked prosper, the upright feel inferior, and then those who fear Hashem speak to one another and are written in a book of remembrance. He adds the Gemara in Sanhedrin that talmidei chachamim will diminish and new harsh decrees will come one after another.

  4. 17:00 Erev Shabbos of the world: a time of birur

    The Mashgiach compares the time before Moshiach to a kitchen on erev Shabbos, full of cleaning and cooking: a time of birur in which old accounts are settled. He explains the great tragedies through the reincarnation of souls from the time of the churban, and uses the parable of a fly on a great painting, which sees only one black spot, to show that only the great tzaddikim see the whole picture.

  5. 22:22 The Gemara's signs: a generation that shrinks

    The Mashgiach goes through more signs from the Gemara in Sanhedrin: the young shaming the old, the face of the generation, and a generation that keeps diminishing. He says that never in Jewish history has a generation shrunk steadily as it does now, when the world's population grows while assimilation and intermarriage reduce the number of Jews.

  6. 30:40 Talmidei chachamim and the erev rav

    The Mashgiach explains the sign that talmidei chachamim will be despised, and that in this time the erev rav grows stronger; he brings the Divrei Chaim, who already wrote that many rabbanim of his time were of the erev rav. He returns to Malachi: when the upright are mocked and walk in shame, they gather in small circles and strengthen one another in emunah.

  7. 35:44 An article attacking the gedolei Torah

    The Mashgiach speaks of an article in that week's Jewish Press by a rabbinic writer, who claims he does not attack the Torah, only the pretension of the gedolim to be its authorities. The Mashgiach says the writer had already written elsewhere that the Torah was written by different people, and that he blames the great rabbanim and Rebbes for Jews not having gone to Eretz Yisrael, where many could have been saved from the camps.

  8. 40:00 Daas Torah: the counsel of those who learn day and night

    The Mashgiach addresses the claim that Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai erred, and shows from the Gemara in Megillah that in every exile Hashem set up great Torah leaders, Chananya, Mishael and Azarya, Mordechai and others, who led the Jewish people also in public affairs. From the passuk that one who toils in Torah day and night succeeds in all he does, he explains that their counsel succeeds, and brings Rav Chaim's words on the authority of a Rishon who rules without a proof.

  9. 48:00 When the decree is sealed: Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai, Yosef and Mordechai

    The Mashgiach explains that the Gemara itself says Hashem turned Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai's wisdom back because the destruction was already decreed, yet Jews were right to follow him, and a churban that comes while following the tzaddik is far better. He compares it to the sale of Yosef, which brought Yaakov down to Mitzrayim with honor, and to Mordechai asking whether the decree was sealed in blood or in clay, and applies this to the decree of the recent destruction, which the tzaddikim saw could not be averted.

  10. 56:54 The fox and the fish, and the burned house

    The Mashgiach brings Rabbi Akiva's parable of the fox who invites the fish onto dry land: Torah is our water of life, and leaving it to escape danger is certain death. He tells a parable of a thief who set fire to the house he robbed and was then praised for saving people, and applies it to the Zionist leaders who claim to have rescued Jews; he adds Rav Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld's words when the chief rabbinate was founded.

  11. 1:05:29 The final test: a generation of confusion

    The Mashgiach brings the Rizhiner that the last test before Moshiach will be chachamim from both sides bringing proofs from the Torah, and that one must hold to those who keep the old Torah until Eliyahu comes. He answers the writer's mockery of following a Rebbe blindly, brings the Gemara that one who turns from evil will be considered mad, Rabbi Pinchas of Koretz that people will gather in small groups and whisper, and the Lechovitcher's blessing that his chassidim be healthy, fresh and 'meshuga'.

  12. 1:12:09 What did Yisro hear? Kriyas Yam Suf and Amalek listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach asks why Yisro had to come to Moshe in the desert after hearing of Kriyas Yam Suf and the war of Amalek, when he could have asked for instructions and learned Torah in Midian. He answers that Yisro saw that even after the greatest miracle Amalek could still attack, so in a world of scoffing one can stay a Jew only near the tzaddik and among upright Jews; he adds that it is better to believe what one need not believe than not to believe what one must.

  13. 1:16:23 Leitzanus, and holding on to the old faith

    In closing, the Mashgiach speaks of leitzanus, which can dismiss any truth by making it absurd, and of Dovid HaMelech, who was mocked yet did not turn from the Torah. He ends by urging faith in the chachamim and gedolim of the generation and holding on to the old way of emunah.

The shiur, written up

Why the calculated ketzin passed

0:37

Continuing his talks on the coming of Moshiach, the Mashgiach asks why all the ketzin, the dates for the redemption calculated by the Rishonim and Acharonim, passed with nothing. He explains that those dates depended on the merit of the generation, but there is also a time set into the purpose of creation itself. When Hashem sees that this moment has come, Moshiach must come even if the whole world argued otherwise, because the plan of creation cannot be changed.

4:46

He compares this to Mitzrayim: after Moshe Rabbeinu first appeared and told the Jews they would be redeemed, the bondage only grew harder before the redemption came, in Nisan.

Moshiach ben Yosef, ben David and chevlei Moshiach

5:36

The Mashgiach explains that Moshiach is a comprehensive soul: the soul of Moshe joins with the soul of Dovid HaMelech. In every generation there is a tzaddik of the house of David who, if the generation merits it, becomes Moshiach, even if he himself does not know it. Until then it can appear in parts, first Moshiach ben Yosef, who fights Hashem's war, and afterwards Moshiach ben David.

8:03

Before Moshiach come chevlei Moshiach, the birth pangs, and a great war is a sign of redemption. The Mashgiach brings the Chasam Sofer, who wrote in a time of war that one should pray for Moshiach rather than only for peace. In the First World War the tzaddikim said chevlei Moshiach had begun and quiet would not last; the world boils like a pot preparing the cholent for Shabbos.

Daniel, Malachi and the signs of the end

12:06

The Mashgiach brings the passuk in Daniel 12:1 about a time of trouble such as Jews have not had since they became a nation. In Malachi's last chapter, the prophet describes the final days: the wicked prosper, and those who hold to Hashem feel small and walk in shame. Then those who fear Hashem speak to one another, Hashem listens and writes them in a book of remembrance. The Gemara in Sanhedrin adds that talmidei chachamim will diminish and new harsh decrees will keep coming. a,b,c

Erev Shabbos of the world

17:00

The Mashgiach compares this time to a kitchen on erev Shabbos, when everything is swept, scrubbed and cooked: it is a time of birur, when Hashem settles accounts going back a thousand years. He explains that souls from the time of the churban, the biryonim who stood against Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai and the chachamim, were reincarnated to repair what they had caused.

21:08

A person looking at this is like a fly on a great painting, who sees only the black spot under him. Only the great chachamim with ruach hakodesh see the whole picture and understand why the tzaddikim had to suffer.

A generation that shrinks

24:17

The Mashgiach continues with the signs in the Gemara in Sanhedrin: in the generation in which Moshiach comes, the young will shame the old, and a generation that keeps diminishing is a sign to wait for him. c

29:14

He points out that never before in Jewish history has a generation shrunk steadily. There were lean periods, but now, while the world's population grows, the Jewish people grows smaller, with close to half lost to assimilation and to marriages with non-Jews whose children are counted as gentiles. This, he says, is the sign the Gemara describes.

Talmidei chachamim and the erev rav

30:52

Another sign is that talmidei chachamim will be despised, and in this time the erev rav grows stronger. The Mashgiach brings the Divrei Chaim, who already wrote that many rabbanim of his time were of the erev rav. d

33:53

He returns to Malachi: when those who go in Hashem's ways are mocked for following the earlier tzaddikim instead of being cleverer than them, a few upright Jews gather in a small house and strengthen one another in emunah. b

An article attacking the gedolei Torah

36:03

The Mashgiach speaks of an article in that week's Jewish Press by a rabbinic writer who says he does not attack the Torah, only the claim of the gedolim to be its authorities. The Mashgiach notes that the same writer had already written that the Torah was written by different people, and that he blames the great rabbanim and Rebbes because Jews did not go to Eretz Yisrael, where many could have been saved from the camps.

Daas Torah

40:00

The writer argued that, as the Gemara in Gittin 56b shows, even Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai could err when he asked for Yavneh and not for Jerusalem. The Mashgiach answers first from the Gemara in Megillah 11a: in every exile Hashem set up leaders, Chananya, Mishael and Azarya, the Chashmona'im, Mordechai, who guided Klal Yisrael also in public and political matters. In every generation it was the chachamim who kept the Jewish people from being wiped out. e,f

44:32

Why should such leaders understand affairs of state? The Mashgiach brings the passuk in Tehillim 1: one whose desire is in Hashem's Torah and who toils in it day and night succeeds in all he does. From this he explains that the counsel of one who learns Torah lishmah succeeds, and he should lead the Jewish people. g

46:53

He adds Rav Chaim's words: when the Rosh brings a proof, others may argue with the proof; but when he rules without one, it is pure Torah strength, untouched by outside interests, and one can rely on it.

When the decree is sealed

48:52

The Mashgiach shows that the Gemara itself explains Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai's mistake: Hashem turned back the wisdom of the wise, because the decree that Jerusalem be destroyed was already sealed in Heaven. Still, Jews had to follow him, and it is heresy to say the biryonim were right. If Jerusalem had to fall, it was far better that it fell while Jews followed Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai; in Heaven things are judged differently, and through a tzaddik fewer are harmed and more are saved. e

52:37

So too with Yosef: the Gemara says Yaakov had to go down to Mitzrayim anyway, and the sale of Yosef only brought him there with honor, not in chains. When Mordechai learned from Eliyahu, as a Midrash relates, that the decree was sealed in clay and not in blood, he knew prayer could help, and the fast was made. h,i

54:49

The Mashgiach says the tzaddikim saw that the decree in Poland in the time of the camps could not be helped, and the sign was that Jews could not be roused to pray. Like Rabbi Chanina ben Dosa, who knew from whether his tefillah flowed whether it was accepted, the tzaddikim knew when to pray and when a decree was already sealed. j

The fox and the fish, and the burned house

57:04

The Mashgiach brings the Gemara in Berachos 61b. In the time of the Roman decree, Rabbi Akiva was asked why he still taught Torah, and he answered with a parable: a fox invited the fish onto dry land to escape the bigger fish, and they answered that if they fear in the water, their life, how much more outside it. Torah is the source of Jewish life, and leaving it, or those who teach it, to follow other counsel is certain death. k

1:00:16

He then tells of a robber who was let into a house on a cold night, stole in the middle of the night and set the house on fire to hide it, then ran shouting through the rooms. Afterwards he was praised for saving the people, until someone who knew him said he had started the fire. The Mashgiach applies this to those who now claim that they rescued the Jews.

The final test: a generation of confusion

1:05:29

The Mashgiach brings the Rizhiner: the last test before Moshiach will be that there are chachamim on the side of holiness and chachamim on the side of the erev rav, and both bring proofs from the Torah. One must hold to those who keep the old Torah and not listen to anyone coming with new things. It will be a generation of confusion, until Eliyahu HaNavi comes and decides who is right.

1:07:52

The writer also mocked chassidim and now yeshiva bnei Torah for following a Rebbe blindly. The Mashgiach answers that the Gemara in Sotah already foretells that one who turns from evil will be considered mad. Rabbi Pinchas of Koretz said that before Moshiach people will gather in small groups to strengthen emunah and will look around to see that no scoffer is listening. The Lechovitcher blessed his chassidim to be healthy, fresh and 'meshuga'. l

What did Yisro hear?

1:12:20

The parsha opens 'Vayishma Yisro', and Chazal, as Rashi brings, ask what news he heard that made him come: Kriyas Yam Suf and the war of Amalek. The Mashgiach asks why Yisro had to come to Moshe in the desert at all. He could have sat in Midian, sent a message to Moshe for instructions and learned Torah there. m,n

1:13:04

He answers that the whole world saw Kriyas Yam Suf, and still Amalek had the brazenness to attack Klal Yisrael. This showed Yisro that even after the greatest miracle a person can fall into kefirah, so to stay a Jew one must come to the tzaddik and live among upright Jews. In a world of scoffing, the Mashgiach says, this is the only counsel.

1:15:22

He adds that it is better to believe in something one need not believe than not to believe in what one must, and that attaching oneself to tzaddikim, chachamim and good friends is the best guarantee of keeping emunah.

Leitzanus

1:16:49

In closing, the Mashgiach speaks of leitzanus: by making a thing look absurd, one can dismiss any truth without answering it. Dovid HaMelech says that scoffers mocked him greatly, yet he did not turn from the Torah. He ends by calling for faith in the chachamim of the generation. o

Sources

Torah

  1. m Shemos 18:1 text index In the write-up: 1:12:20

Nevi'im

  1. b apparently Malachi 3:13-16 index In the write-up: 12:06, 33:53

Kesuvim

  1. a Daniel 12:1 text index In the write-up: 12:06
  2. g apparently Tehillim 1:2-3 index In the write-up: 44:32
  3. o apparently Tehillim 119:51 index In the write-up: 1:16:49

Talmud Bavli

  1. c apparently Sanhedrin 97a index In the write-up: 12:06, 24:17
  2. e Gittin 56b text index In the write-up: 40:00, 48:52
  3. f apparently Megillah 11a index In the write-up: 40:00
  4. h apparently Shabbos 89b index In the write-up: 52:37
  5. j apparently Berachos 34b index In the write-up: 54:49
  6. k Berachos 61b text index In the write-up: 57:04
  7. l Gemara Sotah (place not identified) index In the write-up: 1:07:52

Midrash

  1. i Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 52:37

Rishonim

  1. n apparently Rashi on Shemos 18:1 index In the write-up: 1:12:20

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. d Divrei Chaim (place not identified) index In the write-up: 30:52

Key points

  1. 1:39 The Mashgiach explains that besides the ketzin that depend on merit, there is a time fixed in creation when Moshiach must come even if the generation is not worthy.
  2. 8:10 A world war is a sign that redemption may be near, so the Chasam Sofer wrote that at such a time one should pray for Moshiach rather than only for peace.
  3. 14:04 Malachi foretells that in the last time the wicked will prosper and the upright will feel small, and then those who fear Hashem will gather and strengthen one another, and Hashem records it in a book of remembrance.
  4. 44:32 The Mashgiach holds that Jews must follow the daas Torah of the gedolim, whose counsel succeeds because they learn Torah day and night, and rejects the claim that they lack insight into public affairs.
  5. 48:52 Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai's mistake came from Hashem because the decree of the churban was sealed, yet it was still far better that Jerusalem fell while Jews followed him.
  6. 1:06:12 The final test before Moshiach will be a generation of confusion, with chachamim on the side of holiness and on the side of the erev rav both bringing proofs from the Torah.
  7. 1:13:56 From Yisro the Mashgiach learns that after seeing that Amalek could attack even after Kriyas Yam Suf, one can stay a Jew only by coming to the tzaddik and living among upright Jews.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 0:37 Why did all the ketzin calculated by the Rishonim and Acharonim pass without the redemption?

    Answer: 1:39 Those ketzin depended on merit, but there is also a time set in creation when Moshiach must come regardless, and no one can change it.

  2. Question: 40:00 If Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai erred in not asking to spare Jerusalem, how can one rely on the gedolim?

    Answer: 49:03 The Gemara itself says Hashem turned his wisdom back because the destruction was decreed; Jews were still right to follow him, and a churban that comes that way is far better.

  3. Question: 1:12:42 Why did Yisro have to come to Moshe in the desert, when he could have asked for instructions and learned Torah in Midian?

    Answer: 1:13:56 He saw that even after Kriyas Yam Suf Amalek could attack; so one can stay a Jew only by coming to the tzaddik and living among upright Jews.

  4. Question: 53:02 Was the sale of Yosef the cause of the exile in Mitzrayim?

    Answer: 52:37 No; the exile was already decreed, and the sale only brought Yaakov down with honor.

Stories

  1. 57:04 The fox and the fish

    In the time of the Roman decree against learning Torah, Rabbi Akiva was asked why he still taught, and he answered with a parable. A fox stood by a river and told the fish to come up onto dry land and live with him in friendship, safe from the bigger fish that swallow them. The fish answered that if they are afraid in the water, which is their life, how much more will they die if they leave it. The Mashgiach says the same holds for Jews and the Torah, the source of their life.

    In the story: Rabbi Akiva

  2. 1:00:16 The thief who set the house on fire

    A lowly man, a robber, came to a place on a cold night and asked to be let in; the family gave him food and a bed. In the middle of the night he took their things and, so no one would know, set the house on fire, then ran through the rooms shouting while the people ran out. Afterwards people praised him for saving them, until someone who knew him said that he was the one who had started the fire. The Mashgiach applies this to those who claim to have rescued the Jews.

Insights

  1. 5:36 The Mashgiach explains that Moshiach is one comprehensive soul joining Moshe and David, and that until the generation merits its full revelation it can appear in parts, as Moshiach ben Yosef and Moshiach ben David.
  2. 10:26 The upheavals before Moshiach are like the cleaning and cooking in a kitchen on erev Shabbos: the noise of preparation for the great Shabbos.
  3. 21:08 A person looking at a tragedy is like a fly on a great painting that sees only the black spot beneath it; only the great tzaddikim see the whole picture and the old accounts being settled.
  4. 50:37 Even when a decree is sealed and the tzaddik's counsel seems to fail, a churban that comes while Jews follow the tzaddik is far better, and more are saved, than one that comes through those who rejected him.
  5. 52:37 The sale of Yosef did not cause the exile, which was already decreed; it only made Yaakov go down to Mitzrayim with honor instead of in chains.
  6. 1:13:44 Yisro's question teaches that even the greatest open miracle does not protect from Amalek's coldness; therefore he left Midian to live near Moshe and among the Jews.
  7. 1:16:49 Leitzanus is the strongest weapon against truth, because by making something absurd it can dismiss anything without answering it.

What the Mashgiach says to take from it

  1. 8:45 Citing the Chasam Sofer, the Mashgiach says that in a time of world war one should pray that Moshiach come, not only for peace.
  2. 35:14 The Mashgiach says upright Jews should gather in small groups, talk about emunah and strengthen one another.
  3. 1:13:06 The Mashgiach says one should attach oneself to tzaddikim, chachamim and good, upright friends, the best guarantee of staying with emunah in ikvesa d'Meshicha.
  4. 1:06:22 The Mashgiach says one must hold to the chachamim who keep the old Torah and not listen to those who come with new things.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Azaryah, Chananyah, Daniel, Dovid HaMelech, Eliyahu HaNavi, Malachi, Mishael, Mordechai HaTzaddik, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabban Yochanan ben Zakkai, Rabbi Akiva, Rabbi Chanina ben Dosa, Rabbi Mordechai of Lechovitch, Rabbi Pinchas of Koretz, Rabbi Yisrael of Ruzhin (the Ruzhiner), Rabbi Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld, Rashi, Rav Kook, the Chasam Sofer, the Divrei Chaim (Rabbi Chaim of Sanz), Theodor Herzl, Yaakov Avinu, Yisro, Yosef HaTzaddik

Terms דעת תורה, חבלי משיח, ליצנות, מחיית עמלק, משיח בן יוסף, עקבתא דמשיחא, ערב רב, קריעת ים סוף, תלמיד חכם

Report an error on this page