A Lesson from יתרו - It's Never too Late
Catalog entry: PARSHA (English) יתרו no. 1 Pocket Guide p. 57 תשמ"ט (1988–89) English 1 hr 26 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach shows from Yisro, from the latecomers of Kriyas Yam Suf and Amalek, and from the Haftarah of Yeshaya that Hashem draws every Jew close and that it is never too late to come to the Torah.
The Mashgiach opens with 'va'avi eschem eilai' and the Ahavah Rabbah blessing: Hashem has declared that He wants us close. The theme of the sedra lies in its name: Yisro, the convert who was brought close, asked Moshe to come out to him because he needed courage. Rashi says Yisro heard of Kriyas Yam Suf and the war of Amalek. The Mashgiach reconciles the Targum, which calls the nechshalim latecomers, with Rashi, who says the cloud expelled them: their own tardiness put them outside, and Hashem's anger at Amalek for attacking them still burns. Dasan and Aviram, too, came late and received a private splitting of the sea. From these Yisro learned that a latecomer is welcome. Shavuos is Matan Torah for the prepared; Parshas Yisro is a rerun for latecomers, an awakening from above, as the Haftarah of Yeshaya shows against Yechezkel's. He closes: never think like Amalek, never give up.
Topics: Hashem's Love for Klal Yisroel · Matan Torah at Har Sinai
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Va'avi eschem eilai and Ahavah Rabbah
The Mashgiach opens with Hashem's words before Matan Torah, 'I brought you to Me', which the Targum renders 'I brought you close to Me'. He explains that in the Ahavah Rabbah blessing we ask for understanding of Torah on the strength of this declared wish of Hashem.
-
4:26 The sedra's theme in Yisro's name listed in the guide
The Mashgiach says the theme of a sedra is hinted in its name: Yisro was a convert brought close, and the sedra beckons those who are far. He explains that Yisro asked Moshe to come out and greet him not for honor but because he feared he would lose courage before entering.
-
10:47 What Yisro heard: Yam Suf and Amalek listed in the guide
The Mashgiach asks why Rashi says Yisro heard specifically of Kriyas Yam Suf and the war of Amalek, when the passuk lists much more. He turns to the war of Amalek and Parshas Zachor, asking why the Torah stresses 'asher karcha baderech', on the road.
-
15:00 The nechshalim: latecomers or expelled? listed in the guide
The Mashgiach contrasts the Targum, which renders nechshalim as latecomers, with Rashi, who says they were members of Shevet Dan expelled from under the Clouds of Glory. He explains that the camp under the clouds had the holiness of Yerushalayim, so a metzora such as Miriam had to leave it.
-
18:45 They expelled themselves by being late listed in the guide
The Mashgiach reconciles the Targum and Rashi: when the trumpets signaled travel, the stragglers of Dan's camp took their time and fell behind, so their own attitude, not Hashem, expelled them. He compares one who skips a minyan or a shiur, and explains that Amalek could reach them only on the road.
-
26:18 Parshas Zachor: Hashem's care for the rejected listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that Hashem's anger at Amalek for attacking these estranged Jews has not cooled after thousands of years. Parshas Zachor is the one portion Hashem commands us to read from the Torah, more than Shema or the Ten Commandments, to impress on us how He cares for those who seem expelled.
-
29:48 Dasan and Aviram's private Kriyas Yam Suf listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Targum Yonasan that Dasan and Aviram were the only Jews who stayed in Mitzrayim. According to the Midrash, when they saw the Egyptians drown they too wanted to go, and Hashem split the sea again just for these two latecomers.
-
33:40 Torah needs preparation; Yisro came after listed in the guide
The Mashgiach says Torah requires toil and preparation, which is why Hashem gave forty-nine days of counting before Matan Torah, and every year before Shavuos. Yisro missed all of it and wanted to break through the barrier of the Clouds of Glory, which no gentile could enter, as the sefarim say of a sukkah.
-
37:04 The latecomer's courage and the vav listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that Yisro first held back, feeling he was too late, but the stories of Dasan and Aviram and of Amalek showed him that Hashem welcomes latecomers. He came, added a parasha to the Torah, and received the vav, the letter of attachment shaped like a nail, in his name.
-
42:38 Two readings of Matan Torah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that Matan Torah is read on Shavuos, starting directly from the third month, for those who prepared, and again in Parshas Yisro, introduced by the latecomer Yisro. The sefarim say the same light of Shavuos comes down on Parshas Yisro, so a person who missed his preparation learns that he is never too late.
-
50:50 Awakening from above and from below listed in the guide
The Mashgiach introduces the terms awakening from above and awakening from below. Shavuos is an awakening from below, winding one's own alarm clock; Parshas Yisro stands for an awakening from above, and only Hashem knows whom He awakens and for whom He waits.
-
56:35 Yechezkel's barriers, Yeshaya's direct vision listed in the guide
The Mashgiach compares the Haftarah of Shavuos, where Yechezkel passes four barriers before seeing the Throne of Glory, with the Haftarah of Yisro, where Yeshaya sees Hashem on His throne in the very first passuk. Parshas Yisro, he says, needs no preparation and no counting.
-
1:02:50 Purity by the river, impurity under Uziyahu listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that Yechezkel prophesied in Bavel by a river, a place of purity, while Yeshaya's vision came in the year Uziyahu became a metzora, when impurity rested on the nation through its king. Yeshaya himself felt unworthy, being of impure lips, yet the heavens opened for him.
-
1:11:13 A gift from heaven; Amalek's cold water listed in the guide
The Mashgiach says Parshas Yisro, framed by Yisro's story and this Haftarah, teaches that one may reach heights he did not earn. He brings the Midrash in which Hashem says He brings close and does not reject, and the Midrash that Amalek 'cooled off' the stragglers by telling them they did not belong.
-
1:16:01 Think like Yisro, not like Amalek listed in the guide
The Mashgiach concludes that one should not think like Amalek but like Yisro: if one cannot enter alone, he should call someone out to pull him in, and never give up. He returns to Ahavah Rabbah: we ask for Torah not as beggars at the door, since Hashem has declared that He wants us close.
-
1:20:27 Questions on Kedusha and Shemoneh Esrei
In answer to questions, the Mashgiach agrees that Kedusha is a kind of opening of the heavens, where we stand with the angels. He then discusses whether Shemoneh Esrei was instituted by the Avos or in place of the korbanos, and why its text, set with ruach hakodesh, must be kept.
The shiur, written up
Va'avi eschem eilai and Ahavah Rabbah
Before Matan Torah, Hashem tells Moshe to remind the Jews what He did in Mitzrayim and that 'I brought you to Me' (Shemos 19:4), which the Targum renders 'I brought you close to Me', so that you should serve Me. The Mashgiach explains that Hashem is not only giving a Torah; He wants Klal Yisrael near Him. a,b
The sedra's theme in Yisro's name
The Mashgiach notes that a sedra's theme is hinted in its name. Yisro was a convert who was brought close, and the Torah describes at length how he came, how he was received and what he contributed. The sedra speaks to those near and those far: the near are fortunate, and the far are called to come near.
Yisro asked Moshe to come out from the Clouds of Glory to greet him, and Rashi adds: if not for my sake, then for your wife and children. The Mashgiach explains that he wanted no red carpet. Having served every idol, as Rashi says, he feared he would lose courage before entering a new life, and asked to be brought in. e,f
What Yisro heard
The nechshalim
Amalek attacked the nechshalim. The Targum renders this 'latecomers', while Rashi, following the Gemara, says they were members of Shevet Dan expelled from under the clouds. The Mashgiach explains that the camp under the clouds had the holiness of Yerushalayim; that is why Miriam, as a metzora, had to leave it, and why the unworthy were outside. g,h,i
They expelled themselves
To reconcile the two, the Mashgiach says Hashem rejects no Jew. When the trumpets signaled travel, the camps set out in order, and the camp of Dan went last. Some of its stragglers took their time, still packing while everyone left, and were left behind. j
Their own attitude, not a decree, expelled them. He compares people who skip a minyan or a shiur: Hashem does not throw them out, but the yetzer hara tells them it is not worthwhile. At rest the camp was protected; only on the road could Amalek reach those left behind, which is why the Torah says 'on the road'.
Parshas Zachor
This shows Hashem's attachment even to Jews who seem rejected. Thousands of years later, His anger at Amalek for attacking them has not subsided. Parshas Zachor, the Mashgiach says, is the one portion Hashem commands to be read from the Torah, not Shema and not the Ten Commandments, to impress on us how He cares for those seemingly expelled.
Dasan and Aviram
Torah needs preparation
Torah, the Mashgiach says, requires toil and conditioning. Hashem gave forty-nine days of counting before Matan Torah, and we repeat them before every Shavuos; the Zohar warns that one who does not count cannot hope for much. Yisro missed all this, yet sought to cross the barrier of the clouds, which no gentile entered. m
The latecomer's courage
Knowing he lacked the preparation, Yisro first held back, feeling he was too late. Then he heard the two episodes: Hashem split the sea for two latecomers, and declared war for all generations on Amalek for attacking the stragglers. He concluded that Hashem beckons everyone, even the late, and came.
Two readings of Matan Torah
Matan Torah, the Mashgiach explains, is read twice a year. On Shavuos, after forty-nine days of preparation, we begin directly with 'in the third month'. But someone who missed the boat, who never had a Jewish upbringing from birth, may feel he is too late. o
For such latecomers there is another Matan Torah, Parshas Yisro. The sefarim say the same light that comes down on Shavuos comes down when it is read, and tzaddikim saw the thunder and lightning then. That is why it opens with Yisro, who never counted sefirah, and is read long after the doors have closed.
The Mashgiach adds that this is also symbolic: Parshas Yisro can be any day, teaching that one who wants to be accepted by Hashem is never too late.
Awakening from above and from below
The Mashgiach brings two terms from the Chassidic sefarim: an awakening from above, when Hashem lifts a person, and an awakening from below, through his own toil and desire. When the yetzer hara has the upper hand, Hashem may send events that wake him, an inner voice asking how long he will sleep. p
Shavuos is the awakening from below, winding one's own alarm clock to be ready in time. Parshas Yisro stands for the awakening from above. Only Hashem, who knows every soul's background, decides whom to wake and for whom to wait.
Yechezkel's barriers, Yeshaya's direct vision
The two Haftaros show the difference. On Shavuos we read Yechezkel, who saw the heavens open, but only after passing four barriers: storm wind, cloud, fire and a translucent glow. In the Haftarah of Yisro, Yeshaya sees Hashem on His throne in the very first passuk, with no barriers at all. q,r
Parshas Yisro, the Mashgiach says, is when one may receive clarity without counting sefirah or toiling; on Shavuos one must prepare.
Purity by the river, impurity under Uziyahu
A second difference is the setting. Yechezkel says he was by the river Kevar. The Mashgiach brings the Gemara that prophecy is limited to Eretz Yisrael because of the impurity outside it, unless the prophet already prophesied there or is in a pure place; a river, where one immerses, is such a place. q,t
A gift; Amalek's cold water
Think like Yisro, not like Amalek
Last week's sedra ends with Amalek, and this one opens with Yisro. The Mashgiach says one should not think like Amalek, that one is rejected, but like Yisro: one who lacks the courage to enter should call someone out to pull him in, as Yisro did with Moshe, and never give up.
Questions on Kedusha and Shemoneh Esrei
Asked whether Kedusha is also an opening of the heavens, the Mashgiach agrees: in the blessing before Shema we relate what the angels say, and in Shemoneh Esrei we say it together with them, as if standing in their place.
On the origin of Shemoneh Esrei, he says the Gemara's two views, that the Avos instituted the prayers or that they correspond to the korbanos, are both true. People davened even in the Beis HaMikdash, as with the maamados, but the fixed text, set with ruach hakodesh, holds meanings the Arizal reveals and must be kept. z,aa
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Targum
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 5:08 The theme of Parshas Yisro is hinted in its name: Yisro was a convert brought close, and the sedra tells those who are far to come near.
- 18:48 The nechshalim were expelled from under the Clouds of Glory, but Hashem did not reject them; their own lateness and lack of eagerness put them outside the camp.
- 37:48 Yisro felt he had come too late, and the two episodes he heard about, Kriyas Yam Suf and the war of Amalek, gave him the courage to come anyway.
- 45:03 Matan Torah is read twice a year: on Shavuos for those who prepared with sefirah, and in Parshas Yisro as a rerun for latecomers, so one is never too late.
- 51:41 Shavuos stands for an awakening from below that a person earns, while Parshas Yisro stands for an awakening from above that Hashem gives as a gift.
- 57:58 The Haftarah of Shavuos has Yechezkel pass through barriers in a place of purity, while the Haftarah of Yisro has Yeshaya see Hashem at once in a time of impurity.
- 1:14:37 The Mashgiach says no one should let Amalek convince him that he does not belong; one should think like Yisro and, if needed, call someone out to pull him in.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 7:50 Why did Yisro ask Moshe to come out and greet him, as if he wanted honor?
Answer: 8:28 He was not seeking honor; coming from idolatry he feared he would lose courage before entering, and wanted to be taken in.
-
Question: 11:24 The passuk lists much that Yisro heard; why does Rashi say he heard specifically Kriyas Yam Suf and the war of Amalek?
Answer: 38:33 Both showed that Hashem welcomes latecomers, which gave Yisro, who felt late, the courage to come.
-
Question: 15:50 The Targum renders nechshalim as latecomers, while Rashi says they were expelled from the cloud; how do these fit together?
Answer: 21:23 They lagged behind when the camp traveled, so their own behavior expelled them; Hashem did not reject them.
-
Question: 14:25 Why does the Torah stress that Amalek attacked 'on the road'?
Answer: 24:57 At rest the whole camp was protected by the cloud; only while traveling were the stragglers exposed to Amalek.
-
Question: 45:03 Why is Matan Torah read again in Parshas Yisro, and why is Yisro not read on Shavuos?
Answer: 48:14 Shavuos is for those who prepared; Parshas Yisro, opening with a latecomer, is a rerun for latecomers, read after the doors have closed.
-
Question: 1:10:46 Why did Yeshaya merit to see Hashem on His throne without preparation, in a time of impurity?
Answer: 1:11:08 That is the nature of Parshas Yisro: a gift from heaven that one did not earn.
Stories
-
31:44 Dasan and Aviram's private splitting of the sea
According to the Targum Yonasan the Mashgiach cites, Dasan and Aviram were the only Jews who stayed behind in Mitzrayim. When the Egyptians who remained were shown the drowning of their army at the sea, Dasan and Aviram decided they too wanted to go and ran to join the Jewish camp. It was already after Kriyas Yam Suf, so Hashem parted the sea again, a private splitting just for these two latecomers.
-
7:32 Yisro asks Moshe to come out to him
Yisro sent word to Moshe that he, his father-in-law, was arriving with Moshe's wife and two sons, and asked Moshe to come out from under the Clouds of Glory to greet him. Rashi adds that he said: if not for my sake, come out for your wife and your children. The Mashgiach explains that Yisro, who had tried every idol, was not seeking honor; he feared he would lose his courage before entering and wanted to be brought in.
In the story: Yisro, Moshe Rabbeinu
Insights
- 19:20 The Mashgiach reconciles the Targum's 'latecomers' with Rashi's 'expelled by the cloud': both are true, since Hashem rejects no Jew, but their own tardiness at the call to travel left them outside the camp's protection.
- 38:33 Rashi chose Kriyas Yam Suf and the war of Amalek because each showed Hashem's love for latecomers: a private splitting of the sea for Dasan and Aviram, and eternal anger at Amalek for attacking the stragglers. This is what gave Yisro the courage to come late.
- 28:43 Parshas Zachor is the one portion Hashem Himself requires to be read from the Torah, not Shema and not the Ten Commandments, and its message is how much Hashem cares for Jews who seem rejected.
- 45:55 Parshas Yisro is a second Matan Torah for latecomers: it is read long after Shavuos, opens with the story of a convert who came late, and the sefarim say the light of Shavuos comes down on it.
- 57:58 The two Haftaros mirror the two paths: Yechezkel, on Shavuos, reaches the vision through four barriers and in a place of purity by a river; Yeshaya, on Yisro, sees Hashem in the first passuk, in a year of impurity when King Uziyahu was a metzora.
- 40:50 The vav added to Yeser's name, which forms Yisro, is the vav of attachment: a vav is a nail, shaped like one, and like the hooks of the Mishkan's pillars it joins two things into one.
- 1:14:51 According to the Midrash the Mashgiach brings, Amalek's 'karcha' means he cooled them off: he got into the stragglers' hearts and told them they did not deserve to be Jews, killing their fervor before killing them.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 49:49 The Mashgiach says that a person who wants to be accepted by Hashem is never too late, even if he missed Shavuos.
- 1:16:23 He says one should not think like Amalek, that one is rejected, but like Yisro.
- 1:17:31 He says that if one feels he cannot enter on his own, he should call someone out to pull him in, and never give up.
- 1:20:00 He says that when asking for Torah in Ahavah Rabbah one need not feel like a poor man at the door, since Hashem has declared He wants us close, and one should act accordingly this Shabbos and after.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Aviram, Dasan, Miriam, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbi Elazar (ben Pedas), Rashi, the Arizal, the Rambam, Uziyahu HaMelech, Yechezkel HaNavi, Yeshayahu HaNavi, Yisro
Terms אתערותא דלתתא, ו' החיבור, ווי העמודים, כסא הכבוד, מחיית עמלק, מצורע, מתן תורה, נחשלים, ספירת העומר, ענני הכבוד, קדושה, קריעת ים סוף, רבונו של עולם