What the Sea Saw that it Split; Secrets of Music. (ט”ו בשבט)
Catalog entry: PARSHA (English) בשלח no. 4 Pocket Guide p. 57 תשס"א (2000–01) English 51 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains that the sea split into twelve paths because the redemption from Mitzrayim was only a half, mixing weeping and song like the seven white and five black notes of music, while the future splitting into seven will be pure song.
The Mashgiach opens with the Midrash that had Klal Yisrael said 'Hashem Melech' instead of 'Yimloch', there would have been no further golus, and asks why the sea split into twelve paths while in the future it will split into seven. He brings the Midrash that the sea refused to split until it saw the coffin of Yosef, and explains with the Rama MiPano and the Chida that the redemption from Mitzrayim came early and is only half of the geulah, like Yachatz; Yosef's name hinted that Hashem will redeem a second time, so the sea agreed. On Shabbos Shirah he turns to the inner meaning of music: seven notes, harmony as a shidduch made in Heaven, the sevens of creation, the Shabbos, and David HaMelech. The five black keys are broken notes of sadness, so twelve paths meant weeping and song together, while Moshiach brings seven paths and an eighth string. He closes with Tu B'Shvat as a time of chesed and new Torah.
Topics: Krias Yam Suf and the Mann · Niggun and Shirah
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Twelve paths now, seven in the future listed in the guide
The Mashgiach opens with the Midrash on 'Hashem Yimloch' and the twelve paths in the sea, notes that in the future the sea will split again into seven channels, and asks why. He brings the Midrash that the names of the Shvatim allude to the geulah, with Yosef standing for 'Yosif Hashem shenis yado'.
-
3:49 The sea's condition and its refusal listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Midrash that the sea refused to split until it saw Yosef's coffin, because Yosef fled from Potiphar's wife. He asks why it refused if Hashem had made a condition with it at creation, and asks why Rashi's mention of the condition comes only after the sea returned to its place.
-
6:57 A half geulah, like Yachatz listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Rama MiPano that Klal Yisrael left Mitzrayim after 210 years instead of 400, and the Chida that this is why the matzah is broken at Yachatz. He answers that the sea refused because the time of full joy had not come, and split only when Yosef's coffin showed it there would be a second splitting.
-
12:15 Shabbos Shirah: the inner side of music listed in the guide
For Shabbos Shirah the Mashgiach turns to music: Moshe Rabbeinu was taught it and taught the Leviim, and musicians know its science but not its inner meaning. He explains the seven notes and the octave, and that harmony is pleasant like a good shidduch while clashing sounds irritate.
-
18:24 Music as a key to Torah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Gra, through the Pe'as HaShulchan, that the secrets of Torah require the wisdom of music, and the Tikkunei Zohar that some heavenly chambers open only through niggun, which is why piano keys are called keys. He tells the Chabad tradition that the Ba'al HaTanya answered the scholars of Shklov with a niggun.
-
21:39 The sevens of creation and Shabbos listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that Hashem created seven days with seven middos, and brings Pirkei d'Rabbi Eliezer that of every seven the seventh is chosen. The seven notes correspond to all these sevens; only with the seventh is the harp complete, which is Shabbos, and David, the seventh of the Ushpizin, ends Tehillim with ten instruments and gave the seven voices of Mizmor l'David.
-
26:16 Seven is unity; music is a shidduch listed in the guide
The Mashgiach contrasts the seven Ushpizin, who are unity and culminate in David, with the twelve Nesi'im, who are division. Creation is harmonious and beautiful like music, a shidduch made in Heaven, while today's music is noise without harmony that stirs up lust.
-
30:24 Black keys, white keys and the twelve paths listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains the five black keys as broken half-notes, like the shevarim of the shofar: white keys alone make a joyful niggun and black keys alone a sad one. With the passuk 'bakosharos' read as weeping and song, he answers that the sea split into twelve, seven white and five black, because the geulah from Mitzrayim was joy mixed with weeping.
-
36:02 Seven paths and an eighth string listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that when Moshiach comes there will be only joy, so the sea will split into seven; to the question how music can exist without the black notes he brings the Gemara that the harp will then have eight strings. This also explains why they said 'Yimloch', and why the sea's condition is mentioned after it returned: it still owes the second splitting.
-
40:45 Tu B'Shvat: the union called Ilan listed in the guide
After reporting that day's news of bombs in Meah She'arim with one person lightly hurt, the Mashgiach explains Tu B'Shvat as the day of the Ilan: Hashem's written name joined with the name as it is read is the union of Hashem and Knesses Yisrael, equal in gematria to 'ilan'. He brings the Bnei Yissaschar and the Chiddushei HaRim that new Torah comes down from this day.
-
45:25 A flow of chesed: use the keys listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Sanzer Rav that from Tu B'Shvat until Shavuos every two weeks brings a special day, a continuous flow of chesed, and urges learning, davening, tzedakah and good middos now. He brings the Zohar on saying Shiras HaYam daily, the passuk 'Adam bikar', and closes with the trees' awakening and the tenth, future song of eight notes.
The shiur, written up
Twelve paths now, seven in the future
The sea's condition and its refusal
The Midrash says the sea refused to split until it saw Yosef's coffin, for Yosef had fled from Potiphar's wife. Yet another Midrash says Hashem made a condition with the sea at creation, when He said 'Yikavu hamayim' (Bereishis 1:9), so why did it refuse? The Mashgiach adds a second difficulty: Rashi on Shemos 14:27 mentions the sea keeping its condition only after it returned to normal, which was never the condition. g,h,i,j,k
A half geulah, like Yachatz
The Mashgiach brings Rabbi Menachem Azariah of Fano: Klal Yisrael was meant to stay 400 years, as Avraham was told (Bereishis 15:13), but Hashem took them out after 210 lest they sink into the fiftieth gate of impurity. Their mission in golus was left unfinished, and after so many years of this golus it is still not made up. The Chida says this is why the matzah is broken at Yachatz: the geulah comes in two parts, and the larger half is Pesach of the future. l
Now the Mashgiach answers. When Moshiach comes the whole world, even the sea, will sing; the sea felt no such joy and refused, since the 400 years were not complete. Seeing Yosef's coffin, it understood that this was only a first splitting, a Yachatz, and split.
Shabbos Shirah: the inner side of music
Since it is Shabbos Shirah, the Mashgiach turns to music. A Midrash says Hashem taught Moshe Rabbeinu music to teach the Leviim, who studied it five years. Musicians know its science but not its inner meaning, as the Rebbe Maharash of Lubavitch said: science cannot explain why a hard knife cuts soft challah rather than the reverse. m
There are seven notes, the octave repeating the first. Every sound, even a rusty door, is made of them, yet only notes that suit each other give pleasure, like a good shidduch; a bad match irritates, like a hammer's banging.
Music as a key to Torah
In the introduction to the Pe'as HaShulchan, the Gra is quoted that the secrets of Torah require the wisdom of music, and the Tikkunei Zohar says some heavenly chambers open only through niggun. That, says the Mashgiach, is why piano bars are called keys. He holds that the nations received this wisdom from tzaddikim, citing Rashi that Tuval Kayin first played music. n,o,p
He relates that when the scholars of Shklov asked the Ba'al HaTanya their questions, he sang a niggun instead of answering.
The sevens of creation and Shabbos
Seven is unity; music is a shidduch
The seven Ushpizin are unity, culminating in David HaMelech, while the twelve Nesi'im are division, each over his own shevet. Shabbos is unity, and in true unity all will be under Moshiach.
Finished creation is harmonious, a shidduch made in Heaven, which is what music is. Today's music is noise without harmony, the opposite of a shidduch, and stirs up desire.
Black keys, white keys and the twelve paths
Seven paths and an eighth string
With Moshiach there will be only joy, so the sea will split into seven. Without black notes, how can there be music? The Mashgiach brings the Gemara (Arachin 13b) that the harp of seven strings will have eight; as an added digit multiplies the combinations, one more note will make a song never yet heard. v
Tu B'Shvat: the union called Ilan
The Mashgiach reports that two hours earlier two bombs exploded in Meah She'arim and only one person was slightly hurt, open miracles; Klal Yisrael needs much mercy.
Tu B'Shvat is the day of the Ilan. Hashem's name as written and as read is the union of Hashem and Knesses Yisrael, like kri and ksiv, and together they equal 'ilan' in gematria, as the Bnei Yissaschar explains. The Chiddushei HaRim says one can see a difference in one's Torah after Tu B'Shvat; the Mashgiach adds that what he said about music he wrote down the night before, on Tu B'Shvat. x
A flow of chesed: use the keys
The Sanzer Rav said that from Tu B'Shvat to Shavuos no two weeks pass without a special day: Rosh Chodesh Adar, Purim, Rosh Chodesh Nisan, Pesach, Rosh Chodesh Iyar, Pesach Sheni, Rosh Chodesh Sivan. It is a continuous flow of chesed, and the Mashgiach urges learning, davening, giving tzedakah and working on good middos now, while the iron is hot.
The Zohar promises great yeshuos to one who says Shiras HaYam daily with kavanah. Citing 'Adam bikar' (Tehillim 49:21), the Mashgiach says one who wastes a good time is like an animal. On Shabbos Shirah the keys are in hand, nature awakens from its winter shrouds, and the tenth song will be the new song of eight notes. y,z
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Targum
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
- b Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 0:00
- f Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 1:13
- g Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 3:49
- i Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 3:49
- m Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 12:48
- q Pirkei d'Rabbi Eliezer (place not identified) index In the write-up: 21:44
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 0:11 Klal Yisrael said 'Yimloch' rather than 'Melech' at the sea because they felt that the time of the full geulah had not yet come.
- 7:08 The redemption from Mitzrayim came after 210 instead of 400 years and is only the first half of the geulah, as the Chida explains the breaking of the matzah at Yachatz.
- 10:17 The sea refused to split because the true time had not come, and agreed only when Yosef's coffin reminded it that Hashem will redeem a second time.
- 17:43 Music is a shidduch: notes that belong together give pleasure, while sounds that do not fit are noise, and creation itself is harmonious like music.
- 21:44 The seven notes correspond to the seven days of creation and the other sevens Hashem made, each culminating in the seventh: Shabbos, Eretz Yisrael, the Kinneres and David HaMelech.
- 30:48 The seven white keys are complete notes of joy and the five black keys are broken half-notes of sadness, so the twelve paths of the sea were weeping and song together.
- 36:11 When Moshiach comes there will be only joy, the sea will split into seven, and the harp will have an eighth string, a new song the world has never heard.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 2:32 Why did the sea split into twelve paths at the Exodus, while in the future it will split into seven?
Answer: 35:44 Twelve are the seven white and five black notes: the first geulah was song mixed with weeping, while the future one will be only joy, the seven pure notes.
-
Question: 5:31 If Hashem made a condition with the sea at creation that it would split for Klal Yisrael, why did it refuse?
Answer: 10:17 It sensed that the time of complete joy had not come, since the 400 years were not complete, until Yosef's coffin showed it that this was only the first of two splittings.
-
Question: 6:08 Why does Rashi mention the sea keeping its condition only after it returned to its normal state, which is not the condition?
Answer: 40:11 Because the sea had not yet fulfilled its condition; it still owes Klal Yisrael the second, future splitting.
-
Question: 0:11 Why did Klal Yisrael say 'Hashem Yimloch' rather than 'Hashem Melech'?
Answer: 0:48 They felt that the splitting was only part one, a temporary geulah with golus still to come.
-
Question: 19:30 Why are the bars of a piano called keys?
Answer: 19:38 Because, according to the Tikkunei Zohar, niggun opens heavenly chambers; they are keys that open.
-
Question: 32:53 Why are the full notes white and the half notes black?
Answer: 33:15 White is chesed and black is din; the black notes are broken, sighing notes.
Stories
-
20:45 The Ba'al HaTanya answers with a niggun
The Mashgiach relates a tradition of the Chabad chassidim that the Ba'al HaTanya once came to Shklov, where there were great scholars. They asked him to come because they had many questions in Torah for him to answer. They gathered and he told each one to ask his question; when they had all finished, instead of answering he sang a niggun.
In the story: the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi)
-
40:47 Bombs in Meah She'arim
The Mashgiach reports that shortly before the shiur he heard news that was both bad and good. About two hours earlier two pipe bombs set by Arabs had exploded in a street of Meah She'arim, and only one person was slightly wounded. He calls it open miracles, like in the Gulf War, and says Klal Yisrael needs much mercy.
Insights
- 11:09 The sea's refusal to split was not defiance of its condition: it sensed that this was not yet the time of universal joy, and Yosef's coffin, recalling 'Yosif Hashem shenis', told it that this splitting was only the first of two.
- 35:32 The twelve paths of the sea match the twelve notes of the octave, seven white and five black, because the splitting held both song for leaving Mitzrayim and weeping for the golus still ahead; the future seven paths match the seven pure notes.
- 19:04 Piano keys are called 'keys' because, as the Tikkunei Zohar teaches, niggun is what opens certain heavenly chambers.
- 17:43 Musical harmony is a shidduch made in Heaven: notes that belong together give pleasure as a good match does, and today's noisy music is the opposite of a shidduch, an expression of promiscuity.
- 31:45 The white keys are chesed and the black keys are din; the black notes are broken like the shevarim of the shofar, and only they can produce a sad niggun.
- 37:32 An eighth string on the future harp is not a small addition: as adding a digit multiplies the possible numbers, one more note will multiply music many times over into a song never yet heard.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 46:46 The Mashgiach urges using the period beginning with Tu B'Shvat, a flow of chesed, to learn, daven, give tzedakah and work on good middos and love of Klal Yisrael, Torah and Hashem.
- 47:57 Citing the Zohar, the Mashgiach says one should say Shiras HaYam every day with kavanah, for which the Zohar promises great yeshuos.
- 49:03 The Mashgiach says that on Shabbos Shirah the keys are in one's hands, and one should sing shirah to Hashem together with all of creation.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Dovid HaMelech, Moshe Rabbeinu, Potiphar, Rabbi Yisrael of Shklov, Shlomo HaMelech, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Bnei Yissaschar (Rabbi Tzvi Elimelech of Dinov), the Chida, the Chiddushei HaRim, the Divrei Chaim (Rabbi Chaim of Sanz), the Rebbe Maharash of Lubavitch, the Rema MiPano, the Vilna Gaon, Tuval Kayin, Yosef HaTzaddik
Terms אושפיזין, אילן, אפיקומן, היכל, יחץ, נ' שערי טומאה, פנימיות, קרי וכתיב, קריעת ים סוף, רבונו של עולם, שבעה רועים, תחיית המתים