אמונה - A Song of Perfect Harmony
Catalog entry: PARSHA (English) בשלח no. 1 Pocket Guide p. 57 תשמ"ט (1988–89) English 1 hr 28 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains that Shabbos Shira teaches emunah: one who believes sees all of creation and history, even its empty pauses and unanswered questions, as one harmonious song to Hashem.
The Mashgiach opens with preparing for Shabbos, a sixtieth of Olam Haba, and calls Beshalach a sedra drilling emunah from start to finish. He defines shira as harmony: words, notes and colors that fit together, a whole creation singing in Perek Shira, and a history that revolves around Klal Yisrael. The pauses belong to the music too, as the shira's blank spaces in the Sefer Torah show. Belief in Hashem and Moshe brought the Jews to sing; man alone chooses whether to join, and the tzaddik conducts the symphony. The man was a forty-year exercise in not worrying about tomorrow, though each person's bitachon must fit his level. Masa uMeriva's doubt is the snake's venom, and Amalek, fought with raised hands of emunah, carries it on. He closes with the black kasha, Tu B'Shvat and Yeshayahu's song of the vineyard.
Topics: Simple Emunah, Above Reason · Niggun and Shirah · Krias Yam Suf and the Mann · Bitachon
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Preparing for Shabbos Shira
The Mashgiach introduces Shabbos Shira and says that Shabbos must be prepared for during the week. He explains the Gemara that Shabbos is a sixtieth of Olam Haba, the faintest taste, using the halachic measure of sixty.
-
5:36 Following Moshe into the desert listed in the guide
Recalling last week's mitzvah of emunah, the Mashgiach calls Beshalach a sedra full of emunah. The Jews followed Moshe into the desert without asking what they would eat, the faith Yirmiyahu later recalls in Hashem's name.
-
10:03 What song is: harmony listed in the guide
The Mashgiach asks what makes song and answers that it is harmony, the fitting together of words, notes and colors. He brings Perek Shira, where every creature sings, and explains that the whole natural world is one harmonious creation.
-
15:40 Harmony in history and Eretz Yisrael listed in the guide
The Mashgiach extends harmony to Hashem's management of history: like the Megillah, events that seem disconnected form one plan, and a fly on a painting sees only a black spot. History revolves around Klal Yisrael, as Eretz Yisrael's daily place in the headlines shows.
-
22:18 The pauses are part of the song listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that pauses lend music and poetry as much beauty as the notes, and so the empty periods in a Jew's life are part of its song. He shows it from the way the shira is written in the Sefer Torah with spaces, and from Dovid HaMelech, who saw both salvation and trouble as coming from Hashem.
-
27:49 They believed, and then they sang listed in the guide
The Jews obeyed the command to turn back toward Mitzrayim, which Rashi calls their praise, and at the sea they believed in Hashem and in Moshe His servant. The Mashgiach explains that one who believes sees everything as song and sings, and that man alone has the choice to join the song.
-
32:54 The neshama conducts the symphony listed in the guide
From the last chapter of Tehillim, where all instruments praise Hashem and the final verse speaks of the neshama, the Mashgiach explains that the neshama sums up the whole song. The tzaddik is the conductor who calls on heaven and earth to sing.
-
36:24 The man: a drill in not worrying about tomorrow listed in the guide
When hunger came, Hashem rained down man for forty years, a long exercise in emunah: gather only for today, and what was left for tomorrow rotted. The Mashgiach contrasts this with preparing for Shabbos, which symbolizes preparing in this world for Olam Haba.
-
41:03 Bitachon according to one's level listed in the guide
The Mashgiach says not every person is expected to live like the Jews in the desert, as tzaddikim like the Rebbe Reb Elimelech did. He brings the Chazon Ish's guideline, the Gemara of Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai and Rabbi Yishmael with the Ba'al Shem Tov's explanation, and distinguishes emunah, required of every Jew, from bitachon, which depends on one's level.
-
47:35 Man hu, emunah, and the flask of man listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings from sefarim that the letters of 'man hu' rearrange into emunah. He explains the flask of man kept as a remembrance, and Rashi that Yirmiyahu showed it to Jews who said they had no time to learn because of parnassah, noting the word 'at all' in his Rashi.
-
52:57 Reb Elya Lopian and the bochur Story listed in the guide
The Mashgiach tells of a gifted bochur who wanted to leave yeshiva to earn a living, and how Reb Elya Lopian showed him that he was sure of everything except that Hashem would provide.
-
56:12 Masa uMeriva, the snake and Amalek listed in the guide
At Masa uMeriva the Jews asked whether Hashem was among them; the Mashgiach explains this doubt as the venom the snake injected into Adam and Chava, citing the Megaleh Amukos that 'hayesh' and 'ayin' form 'hishiani'. Amalek, the seat of disbelief, came next, and Moshe's raised hands teach that Amalek is fought with emunah.
-
1:03:45 Swallowing a black kasha listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains the custom of eating kasha and feeding the birds on Shabbos Shira, and the black kasha brought in the name of Reb Pinchas of Koretz. He tells how the Chasam Sofer waited three days to answer his son's kasha, and concludes that an unanswered question never refutes the Torah given at Sinai.
-
1:11:00 Tu B'Shvat: davening for the trees
The Mashgiach explains Tu B'Shvat as the Rosh Hashanah of the trees, a day to daven for a good esrog, and the minhag of eating fruit. Barren trees will bear fruit when Moshiach comes, the Bnei Yissaschar ties the day to the geulah forty days later, and he says one should daven that every tree bear fruit.
-
1:17:31 Man is a tree: the song of the vineyard
Man is a tree of the field, whose fruit is his mitzvos, and a person may fear he is a barren tree. The Mashgiach reads Yeshayahu's song of Hashem's vineyard, which yielded spoiled grapes despite all His care, and says that we are that vineyard.
-
1:23:39 Replant us: the closing of the shira
If our fruit is sour, the Mashgiach says, perhaps the soil is at fault and not the tree, which is why the shira ends with the plea to plant Klal Yisrael in the Beis HaMikdash. He adds that at the sea the Jews reached prophecy, pointing and saying 'this is my G-d', and closes with a listener's question about counting the forty days.
The shiur, written up
Preparing for Shabbos Shira
The Mashgiach opens by calling this Shabbos Shira a very special Shabbos, one that must be prepared for: a person cannot fall into Shabbos, and the Shabbos he has depends on how acceptable his service of Hashem was during the week. He brings the Gemara in Berachos that Shabbos is a sixtieth of Olam Haba. a
A sixtieth, he explains, is the faintest taste there is: a drop of milk in sixty times as much soup is nullified, while any perceptible taste is forbidden like the substance itself. So Shabbos gives a faint taste of the Olam Haba a person earned during the week. The Gemara learns from this sedra that Shabbos needs preparation, and one who has a dull Shabbos has himself to blame. b,c
Following Moshe into the desert
Recalling last week's talk on the mitzvah of emunah, the first mitzvah given to Moshe Rabbeinu, the Mashgiach calls Beshalach a sedra that drills emunah from beginning to end. Hashem led the Jews into the desert, and millions followed Moshe without asking what they would eat or drink.
What song is: harmony
The whole sedra is a song, so the Mashgiach asks what song is. His answer is harmony. A single word of a poem has no beauty; the beauty is in the matching of words, the rhyme between lines. A random key on a piano is noise, and notes become music only when they fit together, as colors do in a painting.
Harmony in history
Beyond the physical world, the Mashgiach says, there is harmony in how Hashem manages history, which is what Purim is about. While the events of the Megillah unfolded, Vashti's execution, Esther's rise and Bigsan and Teresh's plot looked unconnected; one who finishes the Megillah with the Midrash sees one plan. f
We miss the beauty because we do not see the whole picture, like a fly on a great painting that sees only a black spot. Viewed through Torah glasses, history revolves around Klal Yisrael: tiny Eretz Yisrael is in the headlines every day while Brazil is not, and from the first Rashi in Bereishis onward everyone has fought over it. g
A Jew who learns Beshalach on Shabbos Shira, he concludes, learns to go through life singing, as part of one symphony describing Hashem's glory.
The pauses are part of the song
In music and poetry, the Mashgiach explains, the pauses lend as much beauty as the notes. So too in Jewish history and in every life there are empty periods when a person thinks nothing is happening, and with emunah he knows these are part of the music.
He shows it from the way the shira must be written in the Sefer Torah, with set spaces, which the Gemara describes as a half brick over a whole brick: the empty spaces are part of the shira. This is Dovid HaMelech's meaning in Tehillim: both the cup of salvation and trouble and sorrow come from Hashem. h,i
They believed, and then they sang
Hashem then told the Jews to turn back toward Mitzrayim so that Mitzrayim would know He is Hashem, and they obeyed. Rashi says this is their praise: they did not ask why they should approach their pursuers, but listened to Moshe. At the sea they believed in Hashem and in Moshe His servant, and Chazal say that believing in the shepherds of Yisrael is like believing in Hashem. j,k,l,m
The neshama conducts the symphony
The last chapter of Tehillim praises Hashem with every instrument, but its final verse speaks of the neshama, the instrument that sums up the whole song. The Mashgiach explains that the tzaddik holds the conductor's baton and, as in Tehillim, calls first on the heavens and then on the earth to sing. o,p
The man: not worrying about tomorrow
In the desert the expected problem came: the Jews were hungry and asked for food, and Hashem rained bread from heaven for forty years. The Mashgiach calls this one long exercise in emunah. They were to gather only for that day; what was left for tomorrow became wormy. The Gemara says one who worries about tomorrow is lacking in emunah. q,r
Yet they had to prepare for Shabbos. The Mashgiach explains the symbolism: life in this world is preparation for the day that is all Shabbos, so for Olam Haba one should save mitzvos for a rainy day, but not worry about tomorrow in this world.
Bitachon according to one's level
The Mashgiach does not say this lesson binds everyone. Tzaddikim like the Rebbe Reb Elimelech lived like the Jews in the desert: once he could not sleep, searched the house, found money and rushed it to a poor man. Most people must know which rung of the ladder they stand on, and the Chazon Ish's guideline was to prepare for tomorrow or next week but not to worry about a year from now.
The Gemara records that Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai held one should only learn while Rabbi Yishmael held one should also work, and many who followed Rabbi Shimon did not succeed. The Ba'al Shem Tov explains that they imitated him without being like him in every respect. Emunah is required of every Jew; bitachon depends on one's level, and at minimum each must set aside time to learn and give tzedakah without ruining himself. s
Man hu, emunah, and the flask of man
Bread grows from toil in the earth, the Mashgiach says, yet Hashem expected the Jews to see it fall from heaven, asking 'man hu'. The sefarim note that the letters of 'man hu' rearrange into emunah. t
Moshe was told to keep a flask of man as a remembrance. Rashi relates that when Yirmiyahu rebuked the people for not learning, and they asked where their parnassah would come from, he brought out the flask: see how your forefathers were fed. The Mashgiach notes that his Chumash's Rashi says they did not learn 'at all', showing Yirmiyahu only asked them to set aside some time, not to give up work. u,v
Reb Elya Lopian and the bochur
A talented bochur told Reb Elya Lopian he was leaving yeshiva to earn a living. To each reason, that he must live, marry, raise children and pay doctors, Reb Elya replied that maybe he would not, and the bochur protested that he was being cursed. Reb Elya explained: you are sure of all of these, and the only thing you are not sure of is that Hashem will provide for a talmid chacham. This, the Mashgiach says, is what Yirmiyahu told the Jews.
Masa uMeriva, the snake and Amalek
When thirst came, the Jews quarreled with Moshe at Masa uMeriva and tested Hashem, asking whether He was among them. The Mashgiach explains that they surely knew Hashem exists; they doubted whether He was with them to help. Such doubt comes from the snake, of whom Chava said 'the snake enticed me': it injected doubt whether Hashem's command was for their good. w,x
Swallowing a black kasha
There is a custom to eat kasha on Shabbos Shira and throw some to the birds. The Midrash tells that Dasan and Aviram spread man before Shabbos to prove Moshe wrong, and the birds ate it, so they are rewarded. The Mashgiach saw in sefarim, in the name of Reb Pinchas of Koretz, that the custom is black kasha with its shell. ad
He tells how a young son of the Chasam Sofer asked a philosophical question against the Chumash. His father waited three days before answering, to teach him that one can carry a kasha for three days and still be a believing Jew. The Mashgiach says there never was a real kasha on Hashem, the Torah or His running of the world.
So on Shabbos Shira, he muses, one eats kasha to learn to swallow a kasha, even a black one. The Torah was given at Sinai to every Jew directly, and an unanswered question no more refutes it than a calculation that water should flow upward stops it from flowing down. If one attains this emunah, his whole life becomes a song.
Tu B'Shvat: davening for the trees
Tu B'Shvat is the Rosh Hashanah of the trees, the Mashgiach says; the Chachamim explain that their roots then begin absorbing the moisture for spring fruit, and the sefarim call it a day to daven for a good esrog. The Shulchan Aruch mentions eating fruit then, and with the brachah one can have a beautiful esrog in mind. ae,af
Rashi in Bereishis says every tree bore fruit before Adam's curse, and Rashi explains that when Moshiach comes the barren trees will bear fruit. The Bnei Yissaschar counts forty days from Tu B'Shvat to the geulah of Rosh Chodesh Nisan, like forty days of forming a fetus. So, the Mashgiach says, one should daven that every oak and fir bear fruit. ah,ai,ag
Man is a tree: the song of the vineyard
Beyond all the trees in the encyclopedia, the Mashgiach says, there is another tree: man is like the tree of the field, an inverted tree with roots in heaven. Because of galus, rooted in the snake and Amalek, there are many fruitless trees among us, and a person examining himself may ask where his mitzvos, his fruit, are, and whether Hashem accepts them. aj
Yeshayahu sings for Hashem the song of His vineyard: He planted it on fertile land, cleared it, built a tower and dug a winepress, hoped for grapes, and it gave spoiled fruit. What more could He have done? We are that vineyard, the Mashgiach says, and Hashem wants good fruit, so this is the day to daven that our tree produces it. ak
Replant us: the end of the shira
Sources
Torah
- c apparently Shemos 16:5 index In the write-up: 2:44
- j Shemos 14:4 text index In the write-up: 28:12
- l Shemos 14:31 text index In the write-up: 28:12
- q Shemos 16:4 text index In the write-up: 36:43
- t Shemos 16:15 text index In the write-up: 48:18
- u Shemos 16:33 text index In the write-up: 49:27
- w Shemos 17:7 text index In the write-up: 56:15
- x Bereishis 3:13 text index In the write-up: 56:15
- z Shemos 17:8 text index In the write-up: 59:21
- ab Shemos 17:12 text index In the write-up: 1:02:08
- ac Shemos 17:16 text index In the write-up: 1:02:08
- aj Devarim 20:19 text index In the write-up: 1:17:31
- al Shemos 15:17 text index In the write-up: 1:23:47
- am Shemos 15:2 text index In the write-up: 1:25:24
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
- a Berachos 57b text index In the write-up: 0:30
- b apparently Pesachim 44b index In the write-up: 2:44
- h Megillah 16b text index In the write-up: 25:05
- r Sotah 48b text index In the write-up: 36:43
- s Berachos 35b text index In the write-up: 43:17
- ae apparently Rosh Hashanah 14a index In the write-up: 1:11:17
Midrash
Rishonim
- g Rashi, Bereishis 1:1 text index In the write-up: 18:09
- k apparently Rashi, Shemos 14:4 index In the write-up: 28:12
- v apparently Rashi, Shemos 16:32 index In the write-up: 49:27
- ah Rashi (place not identified) index In the write-up: 1:12:56
- ai apparently Rashi, Vayikra 26:4 index In the write-up: 1:12:56
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 10:30 Shira is harmony: the beauty of a poem, a melody or a painting lies not in each part but in how the parts fit together.
- 14:07 All of creation sings to Hashem, and history too is one harmonious plan centered on Klal Yisrael, even when people see only disconnected events.
- 23:38 The empty periods in a life are part of its song, like the pauses in music and the blank spaces in the shira of the Sefer Torah.
- 31:28 Only one who believes can sing; man alone has the choice to join creation's song, and the tzaddik conducts it.
- 37:58 The man was a forty-year drill in emunah, not to worry about tomorrow; but each person's bitachon must fit his own level.
- 58:35 Doubt in Hashem is the venom of the original snake, carried on by Amalek, and it is fought with emunah.
- 1:06:59 A kasha one cannot answer does not refute the Torah; one sets it aside and remains a believing Jew.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 10:23 What is song: what makes music or poetry?
Answer: 10:30 Harmony: no single word or note is beautiful by itself; the beauty is in how they match and fit together.
-
Question: 39:26 Why were the Jews told to prepare for Shabbos but not to gather man for tomorrow?
Answer: 39:40 Shabbos symbolizes Olam Haba: one should prepare and save mitzvos for the world to come, but not worry about tomorrow in this world.
-
Question: 57:06 How could the Jews ask 'is Hashem among us', when they surely knew Hashem exists?
Answer: 57:11 They doubted whether Hashem was with them to help them, a doubt that stems from the snake.
-
Question: 1:03:45 Why is kasha eaten and fed to the birds on Shabbos Shira?
Answer: 1:04:36 The birds ate the man that Dasan and Aviram spread, so they are rewarded; and the Mashgiach adds that eating kasha teaches one to swallow a kasha and remain a Jew.
Stories
-
41:31 The Rebbe Reb Elimelech could not sleep
Tzaddikim like the Rebbe Reb Elimelech would not go to sleep while they still had something put away for tomorrow. Once he could not fall asleep and understood that something must be left in the house. He searched, found some money, rushed it off to a poor person, and was then able to sleep.
In the story: Rebbe Elimelech of Lizhensk (the Noam Elimelech)
-
53:04 Reb Elya Lopian and the bochur who wanted to leave yeshiva
A talented bochur in the yeshiva where Reb Elya Lopian was mashgiach told him he was leaving to earn a living. To each reason he gave, that he needed to live, to marry, to support children and to pay medical bills, Reb Elya answered: maybe you won't live, maybe you won't marry, maybe you won't have children, and the bochur protested that he was cursing him. Reb Elya explained that he was not cursing him: the bochur was certain of all these things, and the only thing he was not sure of was that Hashem would provide parnassah to a talmid chacham.
In the story: Rav Elya Lopian
-
1:05:25 The Chasam Sofer's son and his kasha
A son of the Chasam Sofer, the Mashgiach is not sure which one, asked his father as a boy a philosophical question that seemed to contradict the Chumash, and his father did not answer. Three days later he called the boy and gave him a splendid answer. He told him that he had known the answer all along, but wanted to teach him that one can go around three days with a kasha and still be a Jew who believes in Hashem.
In the story: the Chasam Sofer
Insights
- 23:38 The pauses in music and the blank spaces of the shira in the Sefer Torah show that a person's empty periods are themselves part of his song, not interruptions of it.
- 32:22 Every creature sings by being what it is, but man alone chooses whether to sing along; the tzaddik, the neshama of the last verse of Tehillim, conducts the whole orchestra of creation.
- 39:26 Preparing on Friday for Shabbos while gathering no man for tomorrow mirrors life: one should worry about the 'tomorrow' of Olam Haba and store up mitzvos, not about tomorrow in this world.
- 57:33 The Israelites' doubt at Masa uMeriva is the snake's original venom: following the Megaleh Amukos, the letters of 'hayesh' and 'ayin' make up 'hishiani', the word Chava used for the snake's enticement.
- 1:07:42 The kasha eaten on Shabbos Shira is a lesson in emunah: learn to 'swallow a kasha', even a black one, and remain a believing Jew.
- 1:24:35 If the Jewish tree yields sour fruit, perhaps the fault is in the soil and not the tree; replanted in the Beis HaMikdash, as the shira ends, it will yield golden fruit.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 1:17 The Mashgiach says one must prepare for Shabbos during the week, since the Shabbos one has depends on that preparation.
- 45:01 According to the Mashgiach, every Jew should set aside time each day to learn and give tzedakah, with a sensible reckoning, without overreaching beyond his level of bitachon.
- 1:07:05 The Mashgiach says that with a question one cannot answer, one should put it on a back burner and keep believing.
- 1:11:48 On Tu B'Shvat, the Mashgiach says, one should daven for a beautiful esrog, having it in mind with the brachah on fruit, and daven that every barren tree bear fruit.
- 1:24:29 The Mashgiach says that on Shabbos Shira one should daven that the Jewish tree be replanted in the Beis HaMikdash.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Achashverosh, Adam HaRishon, Aviram, Bigsan and Teresh, Chava, Dasan, Dovid HaMelech, Esther HaMalkah, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbi Pinchas of Koretz, Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, Rabbi Yishmael ben Elisha, Rashi, Rav Elya Lopian, Rebbe Elimelech of Lizhensk (the Noam Elimelech), the Baal Shem Tov, the Chasam Sofer, the Chazon Ish, Vashti, Yechezkel HaNavi, Yeshayahu HaNavi, Yirmiyahu HaNavi
Terms אילני סרק, אמונה, אתרוג, בטחון, מדריגה, מן, נבואה, ספק, עץ הדעת, פרק שירה, קריעת ים סוף, רבונו של עולם, שבת שירה