חוט הזהב של פרשה זו - אמונה (שער הבטחון של חובות הלבבות)
Catalog entry: פרשת השבוע בשלח no. 1 Pocket Guide p. 9 תש"ל (1969–70) Yiddish 1 hr 23 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach shows that emunah is the golden thread running through Parshas Beshalach, and through the Chovos HaLevavos' distinctions between one who trusts in Hashem and one who does not, he explains how bitachon shapes a person's view of mazal, parnassah and the trials of life.
The Mashgiach opens by tracing emunah through the parsha: the Midrash on 'vayaseiv' teaches leaning on Hashem, and the Song at the Sea flows from 'vaya'aminu', because only one who is content with Hashem's ways can sing. Linking the week to Tu Bishvat, he reads Yirmiyahu's two trees, the one who trusts in man and the one who trusts in Hashem, and urges learning Shaar HaBitachon. He then goes through its distinctions: the one who trusts is content with both good and bad, has peace of mind, and works without relying on the means. Along the way he explains mazal, why a tzaddik may be poor, and the manna as the lesson that each receives exactly his portion. He warns against careers that endanger the soul and against questionable earnings, tells stories of Reb Zusha, Rabbi Yisrael Salanter and the Ba'al Shem Tov, and closes with the Jewish tree that must be transplanted to its own soil.
Topics: Bitachon · Krias Yam Suf and the Mann
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Emunah, the thread of the parsha listed in the guide
The Mashgiach shows how emunah runs through Beshalach, from the Midrash on 'vayaseiv' that teaches leaning on Hashem to the Song at the Sea. He explains shirah as contentment, tells of the Chasam Sofer teaching his son to live with a question, and ties the custom of kasha on Shabbos Shirah to swallowing a kushya.
-
7:30 Tu Bishvat and Yirmiyahu's two trees listed in the guide
The Mashgiach connects the week to Tu Bishvat, when each person, a branch of the great tree, should ask which tree he belongs to. He reads Yirmiyahu's contrast between the dry shrub of one who trusts in man and the tree by the water of one who trusts in Hashem, and urges learning a chapter of Shaar HaBitachon this week.
-
14:05 First distinction: content with good and bad listed in the guide
Bringing the Chovos HaLevavos, the Mashgiach explains that one who trusts is content with whatever Hashem does and thanks Him for bad as for good, like Dovid's 'chesed umishpat ashirah', while one who does not trust credits himself for good and grows angry at bad. He stresses that bitachon is not the belief that one will get everything one wants.
-
18:19 Reb Zusha and the higher kind of person listed in the guide
The Mashgiach tells how the Maggid sent a suffering man to Reb Zusha, who did not know why he was sent since he lacked nothing, and compares bitachon to a child who trusts his father. He adds that one close to Hashem is usually granted more kindness and senses salvation, and brings sayings of the Sanzer Rav and the Kotzker that this world is not what counts.
-
24:13 Second distinction: peace of mind listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains the second distinction: one who trusts has peace of mind, knowing Hashem acts for his good, while one who does not trust has no rest even when things go well, always worrying about tomorrow. He reads the Chovos HaLevavos that Hashem brought each person into the world at a set time and withholds parnassah until its set time.
-
28:31 Mazal and why a tzaddik may be poor listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains the Gemara that the angel declares at conception whether one will be wise or foolish, rich or poor, but not righteous or wicked, and that mazal means a channel of flow. He asks why a lucky person succeeds more than a great tzaddik and answers that above mazal Hashem has accounts from earlier gilgulim and generations, citing Rabbi Akiva on why the poor are poor.
-
35:59 Exactly measured: the nursing child and the manna listed in the guide
Following the Chovos HaLevavos, the Mashgiach says a person should tell himself that Hashem knows what his soul needs, as every creature was made with its own consent. He explains that Hashem fed him as an infant exactly what he needed each day, as with the manna, 'devar yom beyomo', and that Hashem chooses the place, the person and the way through which parnassah comes, all for one's good.
-
44:32 Sefer HaYashar: trials test the strong listed in the guide
The Mashgiach reads a passage from Rabbeinu Tam's Sefer HaYashar: all the changes that come upon a person, good or bad, can distract him from serving Hashem, and they are the test of whether he is strong, unmoved like a mountain in the wind. One must prepare daily for trials, since the world is full of troubles, and then he remains b'simcha even in bad times.
-
50:19 Third distinction: means without reliance listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains the third distinction: one who trusts engages in the means of parnassah without relying on them. He says the reason to work is that Hashem wants the world settled, which is why the Gemara disqualifies the dice player, and that while one may choose to devote himself entirely to Torah he cannot demand it. One should choose kosher work, and if the means fail he does not lose his trust.
-
57:01 A casualty rate for the soul listed in the guide
The Mashgiach compares the fear of the Vietnam draft, with its casualty rate, to the danger a yeshiva bachur faces in preparing for parnassah in ways not fully in Hashem's path, which has its own casualty rate for the soul. Citing the Mesilas Yesharim that man was created for the World to Come, he says people guard against physical danger but not spiritual, because they lack emunah, and consoles that even Noach was of 'ketanei amanah'.
-
1:02:33 No questionable earnings; the manna at the door listed in the guide
The Mashgiach laments that even fine Jews cut corners in parnassah, brings a teshuvah of the Chasam Sofer on a product of doubtful kashrus, and says one with true emunah does not reach for earnings with a doubt. He gives the parable of a thirsty man who drinks bad water minutes before finding a pure spring, and explains 'shatu ha'am' about the manna: those who went far for it were foolish, since those who waited found it at their door.
-
1:07:03 Stories of the Ba'al Shem Tov and Rabbi Yisrael Salanter Story listed in the guide
The Mashgiach tells a Lithuanian story of a discussion in Vilna about how much bitachon one needs, and of the Ba'al Shem Tov, before he was revealed, knocking on a door when hungry and walking on without waiting. He then tells how Rabbi Yisrael Salanter needed a watch and one arrived through a Jewish soldier back from the war.
-
1:10:25 Not to the swift: ability is also mazal listed in the guide
The Mashgiach reads Koheles' 'lo lakalim hamerotz', illustrating with his own running for a bus and slipping. He explains that the energy and aggressiveness of successful businessmen are themselves part of the mazal the angel proclaimed, so one destined for wealth will become wealthy honestly, and it is foolish to run after it at the expense of avodas Hashem.
-
1:15:21 The jar of manna and Hashem's many messengers listed in the guide
The Mashgiach turns to the jar of manna kept for the generations, which Yirmiyahu showed to those who would leave Torah to earn a living: Hashem has many messengers to bring a person's sustenance. He brings the Gemara that the Rabbanan learned the meaning of 'hashlech al Hashem yehavcha', and tells of a man who sat on a wagon yet kept his load on his shoulder.
-
1:18:48 Same omer for all; the Jewish tree transplanted listed in the guide
The Mashgiach closes with the lesson that one who gathered manna all day and one who went out for minutes each had exactly an omer. He explains 'emunas' as Seder Zera'im, since the farmer believes in Hashem and sows, says that all Jews believe deep down, and ends with Tu Bishvat: the Jewish tree needs its own soil, and he prays that Hashem transplant the Jews, as 'tevi'emo vetita'emo' in this parsha.
The shiur, written up
Emunah, the thread of the parsha
The Mashgiach opens by saying that emunah runs through Beshalach like a golden thread, from the Exodus onward. On 'vayaseiv Elokim', the Midrash teaches that even a poor man may not eat on Pesach night until he reclines. The Mashgiach explains that this is the core of the Exodus: a Jew must have Someone to lean on, the Ribono shel Olam. a,b
Shirah, he says, is the expression of contentment: one sings only when he knows that Hashem feeds him and controls everything, so he lacks nothing. Hence 'vaya'aminu' leads to 'az yashir', and the Midrash links the song to emunah. He tells that the Chasam Sofer once withheld an answer from his son so the boy would learn to live with a kushya, and suggests that this is why kasha is eaten on Shabbos Shirah: a Jew must swallow a kushya and remain a Jew. c,d
Tu Bishvat and Yirmiyahu's two trees
This is also the week of Tu Bishvat. A shevet is a branch, the Mashgiach explains, and every person is a branch of a tree, so on that day each should make a cheshbon hanefesh: to which tree does he belong?
He answers from Yirmiyahu. One who trusts in man is like a dry shrub in the desert, surrounded by neighbors that take away even the little moisture he has. One who trusts in Hashem is a tree planted by water, its roots reaching the stream, its leaves fresh even in a year of drought. He therefore urges everyone to learn a part of a chapter of Shaar HaBitachon in the Chovos HaLevavos this week. e,f
First distinction: content with good and bad
The Chovos HaLevavos lists seven distinctions between one who trusts and one who does not. In the first, the one who trusts is content with whatever Hashem does and thanks Him for good and bad alike, as Dovid sang of both chesed and mishpat, and as Chazal require a blessing for the bad as for the good. The other credits himself in good times and, as Yeshayahu describes, grows angry at Hashem in bad times. f,g,h,i,j
The Mashgiach stresses that bitachon is not the belief that Hashem will give one everything; great tzaddikim suffered. It means knowing that whatever Hashem does is good for oneself.
Reb Zusha and the higher kind of person
The Mashgiach tells how a man who complained to the Maggid that things were bad for him was sent to Reb Zusha, who said he did not know why he was sent, since he lacked nothing. Bitachon is like a child who trusts that his father knows what is good for him, even when it does not seem so.
Usually, he adds, one who trusts and feels close to Hashem is granted more kindness and senses salvation coming. Yet the essence remains contentment; for such a person this world is not his world, as the Sanzer Rav said that nothing can be taken from him because he has nothing, and as the Kotzker answered a wealthy man who boasted of his comforts by pointing to the World to Come.
Second distinction: peace of mind
Mazal and why a tzaddik may be poor
The Mashgiach brings the Gemara that before birth an angel proclaims whether one will be wise or foolish, rich or poor, but not whether he will be a tzaddik or a rasha. Mazal, he explains, means a flow, a channel through which each person's blessing comes down. Children, life and sustenance depend on mazal, though great merit can break it, as Hashem lifted Avraham above his mazal. m,n
Why, then, should one born under a lucky star succeed more than a greater tzaddik? From the side of mazal it is a question, the Mashgiach answers, but above mazal Hashem has accounts from earlier gilgulim and earlier generations. As Rabbi Akiva said, the poor are poor so that others may merit through them, and a person may be born into poverty to repay an old debt. p
Exactly measured: the nursing child and the manna
Therefore, says the Chovos HaLevavos, one without parnassah should tell himself that Hashem knows what his soul needs. The Mashgiach explains that before birth every soul agrees to its mazal, as Chazal say all creatures were made with their own consent; only once clothed in the body does a person stop seeing what is good for him. f,q
The one who provides little now is the One who fed him as an infant exactly what he needed each day, and it did him no harm. That, the Mashgiach says, is bitachon, and it is the lesson of the manna, 'devar yom beyomo', given daily and spoiling if left over. Yirmiyahu praises the generation that followed Hashem into the desert without worrying what they would eat. r,s
Sefer HaYashar: trials test the strong
The Mashgiach reads from Rabbeinu Tam's Sefer HaYashar: all that comes upon a person, good or bad, riches or captivity, can distract his heart from serving Hashem, and this is the test of his strength. One whose emunah is strong is not moved, as the strongest winds cannot uproot a great mountain. v
When a trial comes, he says, a person should know that this is the time for which he made his covenant with Hashem. He must prepare every day, since troubles that do not come today will come tomorrow and the world is full of them. Then even in bad times he remains b'simcha, knowing all is what Hashem decreed. v
Third distinction: means without reliance
In the third distinction, one who trusts engages in the means of parnassah without leaning on them. The Mashgiach explains the doctrine behind this: one works not because work brings parnassah but because Hashem wants the world settled. That is why the Gemara disqualifies the dice player, who contributes nothing to the world, and why Adam was placed in the garden 'to work it'. f,w,x
One may cut himself off entirely to rely on Hashem and learn, but one cannot demand that of everyone. A person who goes to work should choose kosher work free of danger, and thank Hashem alone for the result. If the means fail, he does not lose his trust, since Hashem can send parnassah through any means He wishes.
A casualty rate for the soul
The Mashgiach points to the war in Vietnam: everyone seeks a way out of the draft, though the casualty rate was about one in ten and most casualties survived. In a yeshiva setting, he says, entering certain paths of parnassah, or preparations for them, also has a casualty rate, for the soul. The Mesilas Yesharim teaches that man was created for the World to Come, so that danger should be feared more. y
No questionable earnings; the manna at the door
Even fine Jews, the Mashgiach laments, are lenient in parnassah. He mentions a teshuvah of the Chasam Sofer about a product of doubtful kashrus, and says that one with true emunah does not reach for earnings that carry a doubt. He compares him to a thirsty man who drinks bad water minutes before finding a pure spring. aa
Stories of the Ba'al Shem Tov and Rabbi Yisrael Salanter
The Mashgiach tells that before he was revealed, the hungry Ba'al Shem Tov knocked on a door and walked on; he had been told to do something for parnassah, but he need not wait for the householder. He also tells how Rabbi Yisrael Salanter, discussing bitachon in Vilna, said he needed a watch, and a Jewish soldier soon brought a gold watch from a dying comrade to be given to a talmid chacham.
Not to the swift: ability is also mazal
Koheles says the race is not to the swift, and the Mashgiach tells of running for a bus and slipping. Nor is wealth to the clever: some people are quick, aggressive and good at business, yet those qualities are themselves the mazal of wealth the angel proclaimed, just as the decree of wisdom brings a better mind. ac
One destined to be rich will become rich even dealing honestly, so it is foolish to run after money at the expense of avodas Hashem.
The jar of manna and Hashem's many messengers
At the end of the parsha a jar of manna is kept for the generations, and Yirmiyahu showed it to those who would leave Torah for parnassah: Hashem has many messengers to provide. If one check does not come, another will, and one who prepared for years for a profession can lose the ability in a moment. ad,ae
Same omer for all; the Jewish tree transplanted
Sources
Torah
- a Shemos 13:18 text index In the write-up: 0:41
- c Shemos 14:31 text index In the write-up: 5:03
- r Shemos 16:4 text index In the write-up: 38:41
- u Devarim 8:3 43:59 text index
- x Bereishis 2:15 text index In the write-up: 50:30
- ab Bamidbar 11:8 text index In the write-up: 1:04:56
- ad Shemos 16:33 text index In the write-up: 1:15:31
- ag apparently Shemos 16:18 index In the write-up: 1:18:53
- ai apparently Shemos 15:17 index In the write-up: 1:21:47
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
- h apparently Berachos 60b index In the write-up: 14:37
- m Niddah 16b text index In the write-up: 28:46
- n Moed Katan 28a text index In the write-up: 28:46
- p Bava Basra 10a text index In the write-up: 32:41
- q apparently Chullin 60a index In the write-up: 35:59
- w apparently Sanhedrin 24b index In the write-up: 50:30
- af apparently Rosh Hashanah 26b index In the write-up: 1:16:50
- ah Shabbos 31a text index In the write-up: 1:18:53
Midrash
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Other
Key points
- 0:41 Emunah is the thread that runs through the whole parsha, from the Exodus through the Song at the Sea, the manna and Amalek.
- 5:03 Shirah is the expression of contentment, and only one who trusts that Hashem controls everything can sing.
- 16:47 True bitachon is not the belief that Hashem will give one everything one wants, but being content with whatever Hashem does, knowing it is for one's good.
- 30:20 A person's mazal is the channel through which his flow of blessing comes, and Hashem places each soul in the mazal it needs for its tikkun.
- 40:34 The manna teaches that each person receives exactly his portion, whether he toils for it or not.
- 51:06 One works because Hashem wants the world settled, not because the work brings the parnassah, so one must never compromise on Yiddishkeit or honesty for a living.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 6:43 Why is it the custom to eat kasha on Shabbos Shirah?
Answer: 6:51 Because the parsha of shirah and emunah teaches that a Jew must be able to swallow a kushya and remain a Jew.
-
Question: 32:32 Why should one born under a lucky star succeed more than a greater tzaddik?
Answer: 32:52 From the side of mazal it is a question, but above mazal Hashem has accounts from earlier gilgulim and earlier generations that the soul must rectify.
-
Question: 51:43 Why is a dice player disqualified?
Answer: 51:53 Because he is not engaged in settling the world, and every person is obligated to be productive in it.
-
Question: 1:00:57 Why do people take care against physical dangers but make no reckoning about spiritual ones?
Answer: 1:01:27 Because people lack emunah.
-
Question: 1:20:31 Why is Seder Zera'im called 'emunas'?
Answer: 1:20:35 Because the farmer believes in Hashem and sows; even when he sees and feels, he must believe that Hashem makes it grow.
Stories
-
5:51 The Chasam Sofer and his son's question
The Chasam Sofer's son asked him a strong question in learning, and his father did not answer. Later the father gave him an answer and told him that he had had it all along, but he wanted him to become used to living for a while with a question unanswered.
In the story: the Chasam Sofer
-
18:19 The Maggid sends a man to Reb Zusha
A man came to the Maggid complaining that things were bad for him and asked how one can strengthen oneself. The Maggid sent him to the beis medrash to ask Reb Zusha. Reb Zusha answered that he did not know why the Rebbe had sent him, since nothing was lacking to him.
In the story: the Maggid of Mezritch, Reb Zusha of Anipoli
-
22:54 A wealthy man boasts before the Kotzker
A man who had become wealthy and left avodas Hashem boasted before the Kotzker Rebbe of his comfortable life and his possessions. The Kotzker answered him that such a this-world is not what counts, pointing him to the World to Come.
In the story: the Kotzker Rebbe (Rabbi Menachem Mendel of Kotzk)
-
1:07:52 The Ba'al Shem Tov knocks and walks on
Before he was revealed, the Ba'al Shem Tov was once hungry, knocked on a door and walked on. When the owner opened and saw him far away, he called after him and asked why he had not waited. The Ba'al Shem Tov answered that his teacher had told him one must do something for parnassah, so he knocked, but he did not need to wait for the man, since it is not he who provides.
In the story: the Baal Shem Tov
-
1:07:15 Rabbi Yisrael Salanter's watch
In a discussion in Vilna about how strong one's bitachon must be, Rabbi Yisrael Salanter gave the example that he had lost his watch and needed one. While they were speaking a Jewish soldier came in from the war: a fatally wounded comrade had given him a gold watch, asking that it be brought to the Rav of Vilna to give to a Jewish talmid chacham, and the watch reached Rabbi Yisrael.
In the story: Rabbi Yisrael Salanter, the Rashash (Rabbi Shmuel Strashun)
-
1:10:54 Running for the bus
The Mashgiach relates that the day before he had run after a bus, fearing he would be late as had happened the previous day, slipped and fell hard. He applied to himself Koheles' words that the race is not to the swift.
-
1:17:30 The man who kept his load on his shoulder
A man was walking with a heavy box of scrap, and a wagon owner offered him a ride. He climbed onto the wagon but kept holding the box on his shoulder, saying he did not want to make it heavy for the horses. The owner told him the horses carry it anyway, so he may as well put it down on the wagon.
Insights
- 3:00 The Mashgiach reads the Midrash that even a poor man may not eat on Pesach night until he reclines as teaching the essence of the Exodus: a Jew must have Someone to lean on, the Ribono shel Olam.
- 6:43 Playing on the custom of eating kasha on Shabbos Shirah, the Mashgiach says the parsha of shirah and emunah teaches a Jew to swallow a kushya and remain a Jew.
- 30:20 The word mazal means a flow or channel: each person has a particular channel through which his flow of blessing comes down.
- 36:48 Before birth every soul agrees to the mazal it is given, since it knows that this is what its tikkun requires; only once clothed in the body does it no longer see what is good for it.
- 1:12:10 The drive, energy and aggressiveness of successful businessmen are not the cause of their wealth but part of the mazal of wealth they were created with, so dishonesty adds nothing.
- 58:42 The career choices of a yeshiva bachur carry a 'casualty rate' for the soul just as a war carries one for the body, and people fear the second far more only for lack of emunah.
- 1:21:47 The Jewish tree, like a citrus tree, cannot grow in foreign soil; the Mashgiach sees 'tevi'emo vetita'emo' in this parsha as a prayer that Hashem transplant the Jews to where they truly belong.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 9:16 On Tu Bishvat each person should make a cheshbon hanefesh about which tree he belongs to.
- 13:33 The Mashgiach suggests learning at least a part of a chapter of Shaar HaBitachon in the Chovos HaLevavos this week.
- 47:36 The Mashgiach says a person must prepare himself every day to withstand trials, since they will surely come.
- 1:00:28 The Mashgiach says the cheshbon hanefesh about the spiritual danger of a path of parnassah must be made before setting out on it.
- 1:03:21 The Mashgiach says one with true emunah does not reach for earnings that carry a doubt of wrongdoing.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Dovid HaMelech, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbeinu Tam, Rabbi Akiva, Rabbi Yisrael Salanter, Rashi, Reb Zusha of Anipoli, the Baal Shem Tov, the Chasam Sofer, the Divrei Chaim (Rabbi Chaim of Sanz), the Kotzker Rebbe (Rabbi Menachem Mendel of Kotzk), the Maggid of Mezritch, Yeshayahu HaNavi, Yirmiyahu HaNavi
Terms אמונה, בטחון, חשבון הנפש, ט"ו בשבט, מזל, מן, רבונו של עולם, שירה