ביאור ענין מזל' האדם נברא תחת מזל - אבל לא צדיק או רשע. קושיא של איוב' בראת צדיקים בראת רשעים. ביאור מה זה צדיק.

Catalog entry: ספר התניא א' א no. ⁨2⁩ Pocket Guide p. 41 Yiddish 45 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 45 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Mashgiach's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Mashgiach explains that mazal decides a person's physical traits but not whether he is a tzaddik or a rasha, and uses this to explain Iyov's words and the Tanya's definition of a tzaddik as one who has no yetzer hara at all.

The Mashgiach opens with the Gemara's categories of tzaddik v'tov lo and tzaddik v'ra lo and the Ra'aya Mehemna's reading of them, then the Gemara in Berachos that the yetzer tov 'judges' the tzaddik, and Rabbah's claim to be a beinoni. He asks how Iyov could say that Hashem created tzaddikim and reshaim, when the angel announces at conception whether a person will be rich or poor, wise or foolish, but not whether he will be a tzaddik or a rasha. At length he explains what mazal is: the star and angel over each month, hour and moment of birth, and the place of birth, from which a person's physical traits flow down. Since Rabbah never sinned, a beinoni must be one who never sins; the Rosh Hashanah 'tzaddik' is a borrowed name. A true tzaddik has no yetzer hara, like Dovid HaMelech. Some are born so, and of these rare individuals Iyov spoke.

Topics: Tzaddik, Beinoni and Rasha (Tanya ch. 9-17) · The Yetzer Hara and Nisyonos

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Tzaddik v'tov lo and tzaddik v'ra lo listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach brings the Gemara's categories of tzaddik v'tov lo, tzaddik v'ra lo and their counterparts. He contrasts the plain reading (a tzaddik who fares well or badly) with the Ra'aya Mehemna's reading, that tzaddik v'ra lo is a tzaddik who has evil within him but rules over it like a master over a dog on a leash.

  2. 5:10 Rabbah the beinoni and Iyov's question listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach brings the Gemara at the end of Berachos that the yetzer tov is the tzaddik's judge, and Rabbah's statement that he is a beinoni. He then asks how Iyov could say Hashem created tzaddikim and reshaim, when the angel at conception announces a person's physical traits but not whether he will be a tzaddik or a rasha, so as not to compel his choice.

  3. 10:32 Mazal: the stars of the months listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that every person has a mazal, a star in the heavens in which an angel is clothed. Each month has its own permutation of the Name Havaya and its own mazal, which is why Cheshvan brings withering and Kislev a new light, and a person born in a month carries its traits.

  4. 17:31 Hour, place and the meaning of 'mazal' listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach adds that every hour and moment has its mazal, and that the country of birth also shapes a person, while Eretz Yisroel is above mazal. He explains that 'mazal' means flowing down, like 'nozlim', and that 'gad' also means mazal, and concludes that the angel announces everything by mazal except tzaddik and rasha.

  5. 23:59 A beinoni never sins listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach asks what a beinoni is, given that Rabbah never stopped learning and was a man of truth. He goes through the Tanya's definitions of a rasha, including one who could learn and does not, and concludes that since Rabbah had not even bitul Torah, a beinoni must be one who never sins.

  6. 28:54 The Rosh Hashanah tzaddik is a borrowed name listed in the guide

    If a beinoni never sins, the Mashgiach asks, what is a tzaddik, and how does this fit the Gemara in Rosh Hashanah where a tzaddik is one with more merits than sins? He answers that there 'tzaddik' is a borrowed name, like a litigant who wins his din Torah: he is right in that judgment, not a tzaddik in truth.

  7. 32:40 Dovid HaMelech's empty heart listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach brings Dovid HaMelech's words 'v'libi chalal b'kirbi': chalal means empty, so the left chamber of his heart had no yetzer hara, and it also means killed, since he slew it through fasting. A tzaddik is one with no yetzer hara, and such tzaddikim are few, as the Gemara says Hashem planted them in every generation.

  8. 36:25 Tzaddikim who are born complete listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach sets out the Tanya's premise: a tzaddik has no yetzer hara, either from birth or by working until he lost it, while a beinoni has two judges and chooses between them. Tzaddikim born complete come down for the sake of others, and since they have no choice they may remember earlier gilgulim, as the Yismach Moshe remembered being a sheep of Yaakov Avinu.

  9. 42:00 Iyov's answer: rare individuals listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that Iyov spoke of tzaddikim created complete, and of reshaim born to be wicked, whom Hashem also needs for His plan for creation. Dovid HaMelech instead had to repair Adam's flaw and work until he became a tzaddik; most people are neither, and have the choice to be at least a beinoni.

The shiur, written up

Tzaddik v'tov lo and tzaddik v'ra lo

0:49

The Mashgiach opens with the Gemara's categories: tzaddik v'tov lo, tzaddik v'ra lo, rasha v'tov lo, rasha v'ra lo, and elsewhere the beinoni. In plain terms, tzaddik v'ra lo is a tzaddik who fares badly, and the Gemara asks how that can be. a

2:11

The Ra'aya Mehemna reads it differently: the evil is 'his'. It is inside him, yet he rules over it, like a man leading a dog on a leash that does what its master wants. b

Rabbah the beinoni and Iyov's question

5:10

The Gemara at the end of Berachos says the yetzer tov judges tzaddikim and the yetzer hara judges reshaim, while beinonim are judged by both. Rabbah said he was a beinoni, and Abaye answered that he left no one room to live. c

7:58

The Mashgiach then asks how Iyov could say that Hashem created tzaddikim and reshaim. Before a child is formed, an angel announces whether he will be rich or poor, wise or foolish, strong or weak, but not tzaddik or rasha. Hashem's knowledge, discussed by the Rambam, leaves choice intact; an angel's announcement would compel it. d,e,f

Mazal: the stars of the months

10:52

This, the Mashgiach says, is a person's mazal. People call mazal luck, but every person truly has a star in the heavens in which an angel is clothed, as the Gemara in Shabbos speaks of a person's mazal, and his health depends on it. g

13:04

Each month has a different conduct. The Name Havaya, having a doubled letter, has twelve permutations rather than twenty-four, one for each month. So Cheshvan brings withering and cold, while Kislev already brings light; Nissan brings bloom, in nature and in the Jewish people, and Tishrei begins the decline.

15:53

Parallel to these are the twelve mazalos, pictured in the piyutim for rain. A person born in Tishrei falls under its angel and has its traits. This is ancient wisdom, which the nations inherited from Noach.

Hour, place and the meaning of 'mazal'

17:32

Every hour and every moment also has a mazal, and the angel over the moment of birth announces whether a person will be wise or foolish, rich or poor, strong or weak. Even the country of birth shapes his character, though Eretz Yisroel stands above mazal.

19:58

The word mazal means flowing, as in 'nozlim': it is a channel through which bounty runs down from above, like New York's water flowing from the mountains. Similarly, at Gad's birth Leah said 'ba gad', which Rashi explains as mazal. h

22:40

The Ibn Ezra wrote a poem about his bad mazal: had he been an undertaker, nobody would have died. Yet tzaddik and rasha have nothing to do with mazal; that is given over to the person, which sharpens the question on Iyov.

A beinoni never sins

24:16

What is a beinoni? If he does some merits and some sins, how could Rabbah call himself one? Rabbah never stopped learning, so the Angel of Death had no hold on him, and he was a man of truth who would not misstate his level.

26:27

The Tanya calls a rasha anyone with even a light sin, even one who could learn and does not. Rabbah had not even bitul Torah, so a beinoni must be one who never sins. m

The Rosh Hashanah tzaddik is a borrowed name

29:31

If so, what more is a tzaddik? And the Gemara in Rosh Hashanah calls one with more merits than sins a tzaddik. The Mashgiach answers that this is a borrowed name: like a litigant who wins his din Torah even if he is a great sinner, the one inscribed as a tzaddik on Rosh Hashanah is right in that judgment, not a tzaddik in truth. i

Dovid HaMelech's empty heart

32:59

The true definition follows from Dovid HaMelech's words 'v'libi chalal b'kirbi'. Chalal means empty: the left chamber of his heart, the seat of the yetzer hara, was empty. It also means slain, for he killed his yetzer hara through fasting. j

34:52

A tzaddik, then, has no yetzer hara at all. Such tzaddikim are few, so, as the Gemara in Yoma says, Hashem planted them in every generation, and the tzaddik is the 'yesod olam', the foundation of the world. k,l

Tzaddikim who are born complete

36:31

Here the Tanya's true premise begins: a tzaddik has no yetzer hara, either because he was born without one, of which Iyov spoke, or because he worked until he lost it. A beinoni has two judges in his heart, the yetzer tov and the yetzer hara, and he chooses which to obey. m

38:32

Tzaddikim born complete come down for others. The Yismach Moshe remembered being a sheep of Yaakov Avinu and showed a mark from his stick. Such tzaddikim remember earlier gilgulim because they have no choice; ordinary people would be unable to sin if they remembered.

Iyov's answer: rare individuals

42:13

Iyov meant these ready-made tzaddikim. Dovid HaMelech, by contrast, had to repair Adam's flaw, as the sefarim teach that Adam, David, Moshiach are one soul. Some reshaim are likewise born to be wicked, because Hashem needs them for His plan. These are individuals; most people can choose at least to be a beinoni.

Sources

Kesuvim

  1. j Tehillim 109:22 text index In the write-up: 32:59
  2. l apparently Mishlei 10:25 index In the write-up: 34:52

Talmud Bavli

  1. a apparently Berachos 7a index In the write-up: 0:49
  2. c apparently Berachos 61b index In the write-up: 5:10
  3. d apparently Bava Basra 16a index In the write-up: 7:58
  4. e apparently Niddah 16b index In the write-up: 7:58
  5. g Gemara Shabbos (place not identified) index In the write-up: 10:52
  6. i apparently Rosh Hashanah 16b index In the write-up: 29:31
  7. k apparently Yoma 38b index In the write-up: 34:52

Zohar and Kabbalah

  1. b apparently Zohar, Ra'aya Mehemna, Parshas Mishpatim index In the write-up: 2:11

Rishonim

  1. f apparently Rambam, Hilchos Teshuvah index In the write-up: 7:58
  2. h apparently Rashi, Bereishis 30:11 index In the write-up: 19:58

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. m apparently Tanya ch. 1 index In the write-up: 26:27, 36:31

Key points

  1. 8:22 The angel at conception announces a person's physical lot (rich or poor, wise or foolish, strong or weak) but not whether he will be a tzaddik or a rasha, since that is left to his free choice.
  2. 15:58 Mazal is the star and its angel over the month, hour and moment of birth, and even the country of birth shapes a person; his physical bounty flows down to him through it.
  3. 24:39 Because Rabbah never sinned and was truthful, his calling himself a beinoni shows that a beinoni is one who never commits a sin.
  4. 29:31 The 'tzaddik' of the Rosh Hashanah judgment, one with more merits than sins, is only a borrowed name, meaning one who is found right in that judgment.
  5. 32:49 A true tzaddik has no yetzer hara at all, as Dovid HaMelech said that his heart was 'chalal', empty of it.
  6. 37:00 Some tzaddikim are born without a yetzer hara and some, like Dovid HaMelech, worked until they lost it; Iyov's words refer to the first kind, who are rare individuals.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 7:58 How could Iyov say that Hashem created tzaddikim and reshaim, when the angel does not announce whether a person will be a tzaddik or a rasha?

    Answer: 37:05 Some tzaddikim are born without a yetzer hara and some reshaim are born to be wicked; Iyov spoke of these, who are rare individuals, while most people have free choice.

  2. Question: 24:16 How could Rabbah, who never stopped learning and was a man of truth, call himself a beinoni?

    Answer: 28:09 A beinoni is one who never commits a sin, which is why Rabbah could say it of himself.

  3. Question: 28:43 If a beinoni never sins, what is a tzaddik, and how does this fit the Gemara in Rosh Hashanah that a tzaddik has more merits than sins?

    Answer: 32:06 In Rosh Hashanah 'tzaddik' is a borrowed name for one found right in judgment; a true tzaddik is one with no yetzer hara.

  4. Question: 40:13 Why do great tzaddikim remember their earlier gilgulim while ordinary people do not?

    Answer: 40:22 The great tzaddikim came down for others and have no free choice, so memory does them no harm; ordinary people would be unable to sin if they remembered.

Stories

  1. 22:56 Ibn Ezra's poem about his bad luck

    The Mashgiach mentions that things went badly for the Ibn Ezra all his days and he had to wander. He wrote a poem about his bad mazal, saying that had he dealt in shrouds or been an undertaker, nobody would have died. The Mashgiach brings it to show how mazal governs a person's physical lot.

    In the story: the Ibn Ezra

  2. 38:35 The Yismach Moshe remembered being a sheep

    The Yismach Moshe said that he remembered being one of the sheep of Yaakov Avinu, since all Jewish souls were once sheep with Yaakov Avinu. He showed a mark on his back and said it came from Yaakov Avinu striking him with a stick when he was a sheep. He also remembered other earlier lives, and even sang the niggun Yaakov Avinu played on his flute, a niggun known among Chassidim.

    In the story: the Yismach Moshe, Yaakov Avinu, the Yetev Lev, the Apter Rav (the Ohev Yisrael)

    told in 3 other shiurim →

Insights

  1. 3:56 The Ra'aya Mehemna reads tzaddik v'ra lo not as a tzaddik who suffers but as a tzaddik whose evil belongs to him: it is inside him, yet he is its master, like a man leading a dog on a leash.
  2. 9:44 The angel cannot announce tzaddik or rasha because, unlike Hashem's knowledge, a decree spoken through an angel or written in the Torah would compel the outcome and take away free choice.
  3. 19:58 'Mazal' comes from flowing down, like 'nozlim': it is the channel through which a person's physical bounty descends from above, and 'gad', said at Gad's birth, means mazal for the same reason.
  4. 24:39 Rabbah, a man of truth who never interrupted his learning, could not have called himself a beinoni if a beinoni sometimes sins; this forces the definition that a beinoni never sins at all.
  5. 33:10 'Chalal' in Dovid's verse carries both meanings, empty and slain: he slew his yetzer hara through fasting, and so his heart was left empty of it.
  6. 40:13 Great tzaddikim can remember their earlier gilgulim because they have no free choice to lose; ordinary people do not remember, because such memory would make it impossible for them to sin.
  7. 43:57 Just as Hashem creates some tzaddikim complete, He also has reshaim born to be wicked, because He needs them to carry out His plan for creation.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Abaye, Adam HaRishon, Dovid HaMelech, Iyov, Leah Imeinu, Moshe Rabbeinu, Noach, Rabbah (bar Nachmani), Rashi, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Ibn Ezra, the Rambam, the Yismach Moshe, Yaakov Avinu

Terms בחירה, בינוני, גלגול, יצר הרע, יצר טוב, מזל, פגם, צדיק ורע לו, צירופי שם הוי"ה, רעיא מהימנא

Report an error on this page