שתי נשמות לישראל' טעם שהטומאה נקרא קליפה' ד' קליפות וד' יסודות.
Catalog entry: ספר התניא א' א no. 3 Pocket Guide p. 41 Yiddish 45 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains the Tanya's opening teaching that every Jew has two souls, why the side of evil is called sitra achra and klipah, and how the four klipos parallel the four elements.
The Mashgiach begins Tanya chapter one: every Jew, tzaddik or rasha, has two souls. The animal soul gives the biological life a person shares with every creature and comes from the earth; the G-dly soul comes from above and longs to cleave to Hashem. The animal soul comes from the sitra achra, 'the other side', and one cannot stand on both sides of the fence, as the Kotzker's vort about dancing at two weddings shows. It is also called klipah, a shell: it guards the fruit, but it must be broken to reach it, and breaking it is a person's purpose. The Ba'al Shem Tov's parable of the king's seven walls and stories of Rabbi Levi Yitzchak of Berditchev and Rabbi Aharon of Karlin show the sweetness waiting beyond. He then explains why the animal soul dwells in the blood, and the four klipos parallel to the four elements, illustrated by the layers of a walnut.
Topics: The Two Souls (Tanya ch. 1-8) · Kedushah and Kelipah
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Every Jew has two souls listed in the guide
The Mashgiach reads the opening of Tanya chapter one: every Jew, tzaddik or rasha, has two souls. He explains the animal soul that a person shares with every creature and the G-dly soul from above, mentions a third, intellectual soul that the Tanya does not discuss here, and describes what each of the two souls desires.
-
7:15 Sitra achra: you cannot dance at two weddings listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that the animal soul comes from the sitra achra, Aramaic for 'the other side', and that one cannot stand on both sides of the fence. He brings a vort of the Kotzker about dancing at two weddings, notes that what people say has truth in it, and explains that 'eishes chayil' means either the Torah or a physical wife, but not both together.
-
11:56 Why evil is called klipah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach gives two reasons for the name klipah: a shell only guards the fruit and is thrown away once the fruit is taken, and one must break through the shell to reach the fruit. He ties this to the keruvim and the flaming sword guarding Gan Eden and says breaking the klipah is a person's purpose.
-
16:29 The Ba'al Shem Tov's parable of seven walls Story
The Mashgiach tells the Ba'al Shem Tov's parable of a king surrounded by seven guarded walls: soldiers stop after the gifts of the first walls, but the prince breaks through all seven to reach his father, who then shows him the walls were only an illusion.
-
21:25 Wanting the King Himself
The Mashgiach applies the parable: a person must break the seven walls of the bad middos, and the one who serves Hashem out of love wants only Hashem Himself, as the Ba'al HaTanya would say in his dveikus. He brings the Gemara that the yetzer hara will look to tzaddikim like a mountain and to reshaim like a hair, and Dovid HaMelech's words that Torah is sweeter than honey.
-
24:48 The poritz's pleasures and a tzaddik's Story
The Mashgiach tells how Rabbi Levi Yitzchak of Berditchev, about to light Chanukah candles, asked a man about the poritz's food and bed and concluded that the poritz is well off but he himself is better off, and how Rabbi Aharon of Karlin dismissed a poritz sledding on sugar in midsummer next to his own pleasure in Nishmas on Shabbos. Each person feels the sweetness according to how much klipah he has broken.
-
31:03 The animal soul dwells in the blood listed in the guide
The Mashgiach notes that holiness is likened to a nut whose shell must be cracked, then returns to the Tanya's text and its source in Rabbi Chaim Vital. He explains that the animal soul is clothed in the blood, as the passuk says, while the G-dly soul is in the brain, and gives a simple reason why the Torah forbids eating blood.
-
36:25 Four elements, four klipos, and the walnut listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that the four elements come from the four letters of Hashem's Name, and that the four klipos parallel them. He brings Yechezkel's vision of the four barriers before the Kisei HaKavod, explains klipas nogah as a translucent curtain that lets light through and can be turned to holiness, and illustrates the four klipos with the four coverings of a walnut.
The shiur, written up
Every Jew has two souls
Having raised his questions, the Ba'al HaTanya now begins to answer them. The Mashgiach reads the opening of Tanya chapter one, based on Rabbi Chaim Vital in Sha'ar HaKedushah and Eitz Chaim: every Jew, tzaddik or rasha, has two souls. He shows this in the passuk in Yeshayahu, which opens with 'ruach' in the singular and ends with 'neshamos' in the plural. a,b,c,d
The animal soul is the biological life a person shares with every creature: eating, drinking, sleeping. It comes from the earth and returns to it, as the passuk says of dust. The G-dly soul, a part of G-d above, comes from the Kisei HaKavod and longs to learn, daven, do mitzvos and fly back to its source. The Mashgiach adds that there is also an intellectual soul, which the Tanya does not discuss here. e
Sitra achra: you cannot dance at two weddings
The animal soul comes from the sitra achra, an Aramaic term the Targum uses for 'side': the other side of the fence. One cannot stand on both sides at once. The Mashgiach brings the Kotzker's reading that 'eishes chayil' means either the Torah, to which a talmid chacham is wedded, or a physical wife, and one cannot dance at both weddings. f,i
Why evil is called klipah
Why is the sitra achra called klipah? A shell guards the fruit, a shomer lapri as the Gemara calls it, and is thrown away once the fruit is taken; so too the physical is needed only while the soul is in the body. A deeper reason: one cannot eat an orange without cutting through its peel. Klipah is the barrier, the yetzer hara, that must be broken. j
The Ba'al Shem Tov's parable of seven walls
The Mashgiach tells the Ba'al Shem Tov's parable. A king surrounded himself with seven walls, each higher and guarded by fiercer beasts, with gifts for every soldier who broke through. Most soldiers took gold and diamonds after a few walls and stopped. The prince went on, saying he wanted the king himself, and reached his father. When he asked why it was so hard, the king waved a handkerchief and the walls vanished: they had been an illusion.
Wanting the King Himself
A person must break the seven walls of the bad middos. Each stops at his level, but one who serves Hashem from love wants Hashem Himself, as the Ba'al HaTanya would say in dveikus that he wants neither Gan Eden nor Olam Haba. As the Gemara in Sukkah says, the yetzer hara will look to tzaddikim like a mountain, yet in the end it is a hair. Dovid HaMelech calls Torah sweeter than honey; tzaddikim feel this. l,m
The poritz's pleasures and a tzaddik's
Rabbi Levi Yitzchak of Berditchev, about to light Chanukah candles, asked a man who worked for the poritz how he fares: golden vessels, fine cooks, a soft bed, while the Rebbe slept on straw. Did the poritz light Chanukah candles? He is a goy. The poritz has it good, said Rabbi Levi Yitzchak, but I have it better, and lit with great feeling.
Rabbi Aharon of Karlin was told of a poritz who sledded over sacks of costly sugar in midsummer, and asked what that pleasure has to do with his own when saying Nishmas on Shabbos morning. Each person feels this according to how much klipah he has broken.
The animal soul dwells in the blood
Holiness is called a nut, as in Shir HaShirim, whose shell must be cracked. Returning to the Tanya, the Mashgiach explains that the animal soul is clothed in the blood, for the passuk says the soul of flesh is in the blood. Scientists cannot say what life is; a slaughtered animal is the same, only dead, because the life force sits in the blood. The tefillin prayer speaks of the soul in the brain: two different souls. n,a,o
Meat eaten becomes part of a person; blood carries the animal soul, and Hashem does not want a person to strengthen his own animal soul by eating it.
Four elements, four klipos, and the walnut
Hashem created the world through the four letters of His Name, and from them come four elements: fire, air, water and earth. Scientists, the Mashgiach notes, call them energy, gas, liquid and solid. Since even klipah comes from the Name, there are four klipos.
Yechezkel, in the haftarah of Shavuos, passed four barriers before seeing the Kisei HaKavod; the last is nogah. Hashem's light reaches this world through curtains, and the klipos hide it. Klipas nogah is like a translucent curtain: the sun is not seen clearly but its light comes through, and it can be turned to holiness, which the other three cannot. p
A walnut shows all four: the green husk removed on the farm, the hard shell, a brittle membrane dividing the nut, and the thin brown skin eaten with the nut. That last is nogah, which becomes part of the eating.
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Targum
Talmud Bavli
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Other
Key points
- 0:57 Every Jew, whether tzaddik or rasha, has two souls: an animal soul from the side of klipah and a G-dly soul that is a part of G-d above.
- 2:13 The animal soul is the life force a person shares with every living creature, and its seat is the blood.
- 7:23 The source of evil is called sitra achra, 'the other side', because one cannot be on both sides of the fence at once.
- 12:01 It is called klipah because, like a shell, it is needed only to guard the fruit, and because it must be broken through to reach the fruit; breaking it is a person's purpose in the world.
- 36:29 There are four klipos, parallel to the four elements that come from the four letters of Hashem's Name; the finest, klipas nogah, lets light through and can be turned to holiness.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 7:23 Why is the source of the animal soul called sitra achra?
Answer: 7:28 It means 'the other side', as in the Targum's word for side; one cannot stand on both sides of the fence at once.
-
Question: 11:56 Why is the sitra achra called klipah?
Answer: 11:59 Like a shell, it is needed only to guard the fruit, and once the fruit is taken it is thrown away; it is not the purpose.
-
Question: 13:14 Is there a deeper reason for the name klipah?
Answer: 13:24 To reach the fruit one must break through the shell; the klipah is the barrier, the yetzer hara, that must be broken.
-
Question: 14:41 After Adam was sent out, why could he not simply walk back into Gan Eden?
Answer: 14:46 Hashem placed the keruvim and the flaming sword around it, a guard like a hard shell around a nut.
-
Question: 20:20 Why did the king make it so hard to reach him?
Answer: 20:30 The walls were never real, only an illusion; they showed who was content with gifts and who, like the prince, truly loved his father.
-
Question: 34:55 Why may one eat meat but not blood?
Answer: 35:06 The blood is the vessel of the animal soul, and eating it would draw the animal's animal soul into a person and strengthen his own.
Stories
-
16:53 The king's seven walls
The Ba'al Shem Tov told of a king who surrounded himself with seven walls, each guarded by beasts on top and each harder than the one before, with gifts for every soldier who broke through. Soldiers who broke through the first walls received gold, silver and diamonds and went no further. The prince kept going, answered those who asked why he risked himself that he wanted the king himself, broke through all seven and embraced his father. When he asked why it was so hard to reach him, the father waved a handkerchief and the walls disappeared: they had only been an illusion.
In the story: the Baal Shem Tov
-
24:58 Rabbi Levi Yitzchak and the poritz's comforts
Rabbi Levi Yitzchak of Berditchev stood holding the shamash, ready to light the Chanukah candles with his chassidim gathered, when a man named Chatzkel came in from working for the poritz. Instead of making the brachah, he asked how the poritz fares, and heard of golden vessels, fine dishes from cooks trained abroad, and a soft bed, while the Rebbe himself slept on straw. Then he asked whether the poritz had lit Chanukah candles; the man answered that he is a goy. Rabbi Levi Yitzchak said the poritz is well off, but he himself is better off, and lit the candles with great feeling, as if he were the luckiest man alive.
In the story: Rabbi Levi Yitzchak of Berditchev
-
28:14 The poritz who sledded on sugar
People ran to Rabbi Aharon of Karlin to tell him that a poritz had gone mad from pleasures: in the middle of summer he wanted to ride a sled. Sugar was very expensive in Russia then, yet his workers spread hundreds of sacks of sugar over the field, and the poritz went sledding on it. Rabbi Aharon dismissed the poritz's pleasure, asking what connection it has to the pleasure he feels on Shabbos morning when he says Nishmas.
In the story: the Beis Aharon (Rabbi Aharon II of Karlin-Stolin), Reb Eliyahu Shalom (the Mashgiach's father), Rabbi Moshe Leib of Sassov
Insights
- 13:24 Beyond guarding the fruit, the klipah is called a shell because it is a barrier that must be cracked to reach the fruit, and breaking it, like getting past the keruvim guarding Gan Eden, is the purpose of a person's life.
- 11:04 The Kotzker read 'eishes chayil' as either the Torah, to which a talmid chacham is wedded, or a physical wife: a person cannot dance at both weddings, just as one cannot stand on both sides of the fence of the sitra achra.
- 20:30 In the Ba'al Shem Tov's parable the walls were never real; so too, the tzaddik who breaks through finds at the end that the klipah that looked like a mountain was no more than a hair.
- 35:06 Eating meat makes it part of a person, but blood is the vessel of the animal's own animal soul, so eating it would strengthen his own animal soul; this, the Mashgiach says, is why Hashem does not want it eaten.
- 38:09 Even the klipos come from Hashem's four-letter Name, so there are four of them, parallel to the four elements; the four coverings of a walnut picture them, with the thin skin eaten together with the nut standing for klipas nogah, which can become part of holiness.
- 40:10 Klipas nogah is like a translucent curtain on a window: one does not see the sun clearly, but its light comes through, unlike the other klipos, which make only darkness.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
Mentioned in this shiur
People Adam HaRishon, Dovid HaMelech, Leah Imeinu, Rabbi Chaim Vital, Rabbi Levi Yitzchak of Berditchev, Shlomo HaMelech, the Arizal, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Baal Shem Tov, the Beis Aharon (Rabbi Aharon II of Karlin-Stolin), the Kotzker Rebbe (Rabbi Menachem Mendel of Kotzk), Yechezkel HaNavi
Terms ארבע יסודות, חלק אלוק ממעל, כסא הכבוד, נפש האלקית, נפש הבהמית, סטרא אחרא, קליפה, קליפת נוגה, שם הוי"ה