תשובה על “כי קרוב אליך הדבר מאד” - איך אהבת ה' ויראת ה' קרוב לבינוני. די להם אהבה ויראה שכליות' בלי הרגשים גדולים שיש לצדיקים.

Catalog entry: ספר התניא א' ט"ז no. ⁨34⁩ Pocket Guide p. 44 Yiddish 42 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 42 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Mashgiach's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Mashgiach explains, on Tanya chapter 16, how serving Hashem stays 'very near' even for a beinoni who cannot feel love and fear in his heart: love and fear understood in the mind become the wings that lift his Torah and mitzvos.

The Mashgiach opens with the title page of the Tanya, which is built on the verse 'ki karov eilecha hadavar meod', and recalls the earlier chapters: contemplating Hashem's greatness with chochmah and binah gives birth to love and fear, which comes easily to tzaddikim. For a beinoni whose heart does not catch fire, the Tanya in chapter 16 gives a great rule: love and fear that he understands with his mind are also enough. Along the way he speaks about true stories of tzaddikim, tells the Yismach Moshe's dream of tasting the Rambam's yiras shamayim, and describes the overwhelming fear of Reb Zusha, Reb Shlomo of Karlin and Reb Shmelke. He brings the Ba'al Shem Tov on why Hashem held the mountain over Klal Yisrael at Sinai, explains why Chazal say a good thought is 'joined' to the deed, and ends with the simple Jew whose hidden love lifts his mitzvos as far as olam haYetzirah.

Topics: Tzaddik, Beinoni and Rasha (Tanya ch. 9-17) · Ahavas Hashem and Dveikus · Yiras Shamayim

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 'Very near' for each according to his level listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach opens with the Tanya's title verse 'ki karov eilecha hadavar meod' and recalls how contemplation with chochmah and binah gives birth to love and fear, easily for tzaddikim. He asks what the beinoni should do, answers that understood love and fear are enough, and brings the Yismach Moshe that 'vachai bahem' means something different for each person's level. He then begins the text of chapter 16.

  2. 8:46 The Yismach Moshe tastes the Rambam's fear Story

    The Mashgiach praises true stories of tzaddikim as a way to bring a person close to Hashem, recommends the Tehilla LeMoshe, and tells the Yismach Moshe's dream in which he asked to feel the yiras shamayim of great figures and could not bear even the Rambam's fear from a time of katnus. He explains through the beat of the heart that every person goes through rising and falling.

  3. 15:12 The overwhelming feelings of tzaddikim Story listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach describes the fear of Reb Zusha, the Ba'al HaTanya's words about Reb Shlomo of Karlin's constant fear, and Reb Shmelke, who had to be shaken out of his dveikus. He explains that tzaddikim felt this because their pure souls had no insulation blocking the current.

  4. 18:56 When the heart cannot feel listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach reads the Tanya on one whose contemplation of Hashem's greatness never reaches the feeling of the heart. His mind still understands that his soul should yearn to Hashem, that the soul stays in the body like a living widow, and that Hashem is grasped only through Torah and mitzvos, like embracing a clothed king.

  5. 25:08 Understanding gives the mitzvos wings listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains why the Tanya says understood love and fear are also good: the understanding moves a person to learn and do mitzvos, and it becomes the two wings that lift them, as the Zohar says. A thinking person could busy himself with other wisdom or chess; that his mind leads him to Torah gives his learning the same aliyah.

  6. 28:50 Why Hashem held the mountain over them

    The Mashgiach brings the Ba'al Shem Tov's question why Hashem held the mountain over Klal Yisrael at Sinai after they said 'na'aseh v'nishma'. The Torah was given for all generations, including people who must force themselves to learn and serve; forcing oneself is good, and the coercion at Sinai was for them.

  7. 32:17 Hashem joins the good thought to the deed listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach asks why Chazal say 'a good thought Hashem joins to the deed' instead of the usual 'it is as if he did it', and answers that Chazal's words carry a second intention. Felt love comes from the physical heart and can lift the physical deed; a thought of the mind cannot by nature, so Hashem joins it, and the mitzvah rises to olam haBeriah.

  8. 38:21 The simple Jew's hidden love listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach describes a simple Jew who does mitzvos out of habit from his chinuch, without thought. His mitzvos still rise, because they come from the hidden love in every Jew, but only to olam haYetzirah. He closes with the idea that each mitzvah has many layers, and the inner part meant for olam haBeriah stays below.

The shiur, written up

'Very near' for each according to his level

0:02

The Mashgiach opens with the title page of the Tanya, which says the whole sefer rests on the verse 'ki karov eilecha hadavar meod', that serving Hashem is very near. The earlier chapters taught that contemplating Hashem's greatness with chochmah and binah gives birth to love and fear, and for tzaddikim, whose hearts hold no obstacles, this comes easily. a,b

2:41

But what should beinonim do, who are no born tzaddikim? The Ba'al HaTanya's answer is that understanding with the mind that one must love and fear Hashem is also enough. The Mashgiach compares this to the Yismach Moshe's explanation of 'vachai bahem': for a simple person it means bodily life, while for a great person it means spiritual life. So too 'very near' applies to each person according to his level. e,d

The Yismach Moshe tastes the Rambam's fear

9:13

Before continuing the text, the Mashgiach stresses that nothing brings a person closer than true stories of tzaddikim from reliable sources, and he names the Tehilla LeMoshe, stories of the Yismach Moshe told by the Yitav Lev. f

12:11

There the Yismach Moshe relates that he asked in Heaven to feel the fear of Avraham Avinu, then of Dovid HaMelech, then of Rabbi Akiva, and was refused each time, until he was allowed to taste the Rambam's. At once he shook so that the table shook with him, and he begged Hashem to take it away. This, he said, was the Rambam's fear in a time of katnus. The Mashgiach explains that life is ratzo vashov, like the heart, which pumps in pulses rather than a steady flow.

The overwhelming feelings of tzaddikim

15:39

The Mashgiach describes such feelings: the vein that beats when one sees the angel at death beat constantly in Reb Zusha, and the Ba'al HaTanya likened Reb Shlomo of Karlin's fear to a man watching a bullet fly toward him. Reb Shmelke had to be shaken out of his dveikus. Their pure souls had no insulation, so the current passed through.

When the heart cannot feel

18:59

Returning to chapter 16, the Mashgiach reads about one who contemplates Hashem's greatness constantly yet never reaches a feeling in the heart, because his soul comes from such a root. The love stays hidden in his mind. Still, his mind grasps that everything is nothing before Hashem and that his soul ought to go out toward Him; it remains in the body only like a living widow, whose husband lives far away. c,h

22:07

Since Hashem cannot be grasped directly, He is reached through Torah and mitzvos, as one who embraces a king dressed in his garments embraces the king himself.

Understanding gives the mitzvos wings

25:29

The Tanya calls this good too, because the understanding moves him to learn and do mitzvos. It becomes the two wings, love and fear, that the Zohar says lift Torah and mitzvos. A thinking man could spend his mind on other wisdom or chess; since it leads him to Torah, his learning gets the same aliyah as if done with felt love and fear. g

Why Hashem held the mountain over them

28:50

The Mashgiach brings the Ba'al Shem Tov: why did Hashem hold the mountain over Klal Yisrael after they said 'na'aseh v'nishma'? That fiery generation needed no force, but the Torah was given for all generations, and Hashem knew some would have to force themselves to learn and daven. Forcing oneself is good, and the coercion was for them. j

Hashem joins the good thought to the deed

32:21

The Mashgiach asks why Chazal say 'a good thought, Hashem joins it to the deed', when their usual phrase is 'it is as if he did it'. He answers that Chazal's words carry a second intention: the love and fear in the mind are joined to the deed of the mitzvah to give it life and lift it. k

34:52

Love felt in the heart is itself physical, so it can lift a physical deed. A thought of the mind is spiritual and by nature cannot join a deed of the body. Hashem joins them nonetheless, so the thought becomes the wings, and the mitzvah rises to olam haBeriah, the place of the Kisei HaKavod.

The simple Jew's hidden love

38:26

Last, the Mashgiach describes a simple Jew who does mitzvos out of habit from his chinuch, without thinking why. His mitzvos still rise, because they come from the hidden love in every Jew, but it has wings only up to olam haYetzirah. He adds that each mitzvah has many inner layers, and the part meant for olam haBeriah stays below.

Sources

Torah

  1. a Devarim 30:14 text index In the write-up: 0:02
  2. d Vayikra 18:5 text index In the write-up: 2:41

Nevi'im

  1. h apparently Shmuel II 20:3 index In the write-up: 18:59

Talmud Bavli

  1. i apparently Berachos 11b 29:45 index
  2. j apparently Shabbos 88a index In the write-up: 28:50
  3. k apparently Kiddushin 40a index In the write-up: 32:21

Zohar and Kabbalah

  1. g Zohar (place not identified) index In the write-up: 25:29

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. b apparently Tanya, title page index In the write-up: 0:02
  2. c apparently Tanya ch. 16 index In the write-up: 18:59
  3. e Yismach Moshe (place not identified) index In the write-up: 2:41

Other

  1. f Tehilla LeMoshe (place not identified) index In the write-up: 9:13

Key points

  1. 0:02 The whole Tanya is built on the verse that serving Hashem is 'very near', and the Mashgiach shows how this holds for every person according to his level.
  2. 4:18 A beinoni who cannot bring his love and fear into the feeling of the heart still serves Hashem properly with love and fear understood in the mind.
  3. 26:00 When this understanding moves him to learn and do mitzvos, it becomes the wings that lift his Torah and mitzvos, as if he had served with felt love and fear.
  4. 34:40 By nature a thought of the mind cannot join a physical deed and lift it; Hashem joins them, and this is the meaning of 'a good thought Hashem joins to the deed'.
  5. 37:15 Mitzvos done from felt love and fear rise to olam haBeriah; those done from understanding are joined there by Hashem; those done from habit rise through hidden love only to olam haYetzirah.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 2:41 If love and fear are hard to reach for a beinoni who is no born tzaddik, how is serving Hashem 'very near'?

    Answer: 2:54 The Ba'al HaTanya teaches that understanding with the mind that one must love and fear Hashem is also enough.

  2. Question: 5:30 How may a chassid give up his life for any mitzvah, when the Torah says 'vachai bahem'?

    Answer: 5:51 The Yismach Moshe answers that each person's Torah is according to his level: for a great person 'life' means spiritual life, and an aveirah would contradict it.

  3. Question: 28:50 Why did Hashem hold the mountain over Klal Yisrael at Sinai after they had already accepted the Torah?

    Answer: 29:09 The Torah was given for all generations, and the coercion was for those who would have to force themselves to serve.

  4. Question: 32:08 Why do Chazal say a good thought is 'joined' to the deed instead of 'it is as if he did it'?

    Answer: 32:21 By a second intention, they hint that the mind's love and fear are joined to the deed of the mitzvah to give it life and lift it.

  5. Question: 34:52 How can a spiritual thought of the mind lift a mitzvah done with the physical limbs?

    Answer: 36:10 By nature it cannot; Hashem joins them, so the thought becomes wings in place of the heart's love and fear.

  6. Question: 38:23 Where does the motivation of a simple Jew who does mitzvos by habit come from?

    Answer: 39:50 From the hidden love and fear in every Jew; it lifts his mitzvos, but only to olam haYetzirah.

Stories

  1. 11:55 The Yismach Moshe asks to feel the yirah of the great

    The Yismach Moshe, a great dreamer of dreams, told the Yitav Lev that he asked in Heaven to feel the yiras shamayim of Avraham Avinu and was told it was too much for him. He asked for that of Dovid HaMelech, then the nevi'im and Tannaim down to Rabbi Akiva, and each time was refused, until he reached the Rambam and was allowed to taste it. Suddenly he began to tremble and shake so that the table shook with him, and he cried to Hashem to take it away because he could not bear it. He concluded that this had been the Rambam's yirah in a time of katnus.

    In the story: the Yismach Moshe, the Rambam, the Yetev Lev, Avraham Avinu, Dovid HaMelech, Rabbi Akiva, the Baal Shem Tov

  2. 15:22 Reb Zusha's fear

    One who saw Reb Zusha's great yiras shamayim said that there is a vein that begins to beat when a person's soul departs, out of terror at seeing the angel with a thousand eyes. By Reb Zusha, that vein beat constantly.

    In the story: Reb Zusha of Anipoli

  3. 16:01 Reb Shlomo of Karlin before the firing squad

    The Ba'al HaTanya said of Reb Shlomo of Karlin that his yiras shamayim was like that of a man standing before a squad of soldiers who have already fired, who sees the fire leaving the barrel and the bullet flying toward him. This was his fear of Hashem constantly.

    In the story: the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), Rabbi Shlomo of Karlin

  4. 17:41 Reb Shmelke's dveikus

    Reb Shmelke, brother of the Hafla'ah and like him a talmid of the Maggid, needed people to watch over him constantly. When he went into dveikus they would give him a push so that he would wake and know where he was, because his soul was in danger of leaving him through his dveikus to Hashem.

    In the story: Rabbi Shmelke of Nikolsburg, the Haflaah (Rabbi Pinchas Horowitz), the Maggid of Mezritch

    told in 1 other shiur →

Insights

  1. 5:51 Following the Yismach Moshe, the Mashgiach explains that 'vachai bahem' means biological life for a simple person but spiritual life for a great one, so the same Torah demands different things according to each person's level, just as 'very near' does.
  2. 13:59 Spiritual life, like the heart's beat, is a pulse rather than a steady flow: every person must go up and fall back, and this explains how the Yismach Moshe could taste the Rambam's fear from a moment of katnus.
  3. 17:02 The tzaddikim felt intense love and fear because their pure souls had no 'insulation': like an electric current, it passes through only where nothing blocks it.
  4. 29:09 According to the Ba'al Shem Tov, the mountain held over Klal Yisrael at Sinai was not for that fiery generation but for later generations, who would have to force themselves to learn and serve.
  5. 32:55 Chazal chose the word 'metzarfah', joins, rather than 'it is as if he did it' as a second intention: it hints that Hashem joins the intellectual love of the mind to the physical deed, which by nature cannot be joined.

What the Mashgiach says to take from it

  1. 8:39 The Mashgiach says that true stories of tzaddikim, from reliable sources, are among the strongest ways to bring a person close to serving Hashem.
  2. 29:53 The Mashgiach says that one who does not want to learn and forces himself to learn, daven and do mitzvos because he understands he must serve Hashem is doing well.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Avraham Avinu, Dovid HaMelech, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbi Akiva, Rabbi Shlomo of Karlin, Rabbi Shmelke of Nikolsburg, Reb Zusha of Anipoli, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Baal Shem Tov, the Haflaah (Rabbi Pinchas Horowitz), the Maggid of Mezritch, the Rambam, the Yetev Lev, the Yismach Moshe

Terms אהבה ויראה, אהבה מסותרת, בינוני, דביקות, כי קרוב אליך הדבר מאד, עולם הבריאה, עולם היצירה, קטנות, רצוא ושוב

Report an error on this page