מדריגת יראה ואהבה בדרך 'לעשותו' - יכולים הכל לעשותו' חוץ רשעים עד שיעשו תשובה.

Catalog entry: ספר התניא א' י"ז no. ⁨35⁩ Pocket Guide p. 44 Yiddish 41 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 41 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Mashgiach's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

On Tanya chapter 17, the Mashgiach explains that the Torah's promise that serving Hashem is 'close, in your mouth and your heart, to do it' is kept through a love and fear born in the mind that lead to action, open to every Jew except a rasha until he does teshuvah.

The Mashgiach opens with the difficulty Tanya chapter 17 resolves: the Torah says the matter is close 'in your heart', yet only tzaddikim rule their hearts. The answer, he explains, lies in the word 'la'asoso', to do it: a love and fear that the mind grasps through contemplating Hashem's greatness and that bring a person to act, even without feeling. He shows how the order of davening is built on this. The mind is in a person's control; only a rasha, whose heart rules him, cannot begin lasting avodah until he does the lower teshuvah, breaking the kelipah with a broken heart and raising the fallen lower hei. This leads to the exile of the Shechinah, the tale of Reb Zusha and the hay, and the Jew's inner exile. He then applies the chapter: when feeling is closed, as with the meraglim and Avraham's tenth trial at the akeidah, one must go with the mind. He ends with Tamuz and Av.

Topics: Tzaddik, Beinoni and Rasha (Tanya ch. 9-17) · Ahavas Hashem and Dveikus · Teshuvah

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 How can the heart be 'close'? listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach raises the difficulty with the passuk 'ki karov eilecha hadavar me'od, beficha uvilvavcha la'asoso': the Gemara calls fear of Heaven a small thing only for Moshe, yet the Torah is eternal, and only tzaddikim rule their hearts. He recalls that the previous chapter began the answer.

  2. 3:13 Love and fear in the mind; the order of davening listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach reviews chapter 16: one who cannot arouse feeling in his heart still achieves enough when his mind understands, through contemplating Hashem's greatness, that one must love and fear Him. He shows how davening follows this path, from korbanos and ketores through the greatness of creation and the angels in birchos krias shema, up to ahavah rabbah and Shema.

  3. 7:34 'La'asoso': the mind rules, except for resha'im listed in the guide

    Reading chapter 17, the Mashgiach explains that 'la'asoso' means a love that brings to action: the mind is in a person's control, so anyone can contemplate Hashem's greatness and reach an intellectual love that drives the mitzvos. Resha'im are different: they are in the power of their hearts, unlike tzaddikim whose hearts are in their power, so the Torah's words speak of living Jews.

  4. 12:34 A rasha needs teshuvah first; the fallen hei listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that a rasha may do a mitzvah, even a great one, but it flares and goes out; to begin lasting avodah he must first break the kelipah through the lower teshuvah, the 'broken spirit' of the passuk as the Zohar reads it, which raises the fallen lower hei. He tells of Reb Zusha and the peasant's fallen hay, and distinguishes the lower teshuvah from the higher one.

  5. 17:49 The Shechinah in exile with the Jew listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains the exile of the Shechinah through Chazal's 'galu le'Edom, Shechinah imahem' and the passuk 'veshav Hashem Elokecha es shevuscha', which says Hashem Himself returns. On the level of remez, a Jew who acts like Edom drags the spark of G-dliness within him into exile in the kelipah; when he does teshuvah with a broken heart the kelipah breaks like a nutshell and the Shechinah rises from her fall.

  6. 23:33 When feeling is absent: Eretz Yisrael and the meraglim listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach ties the chapter back to the previous one: intellectual love and fear, without feeling, is also good, and one cannot always feel. He brings R' Avraham of Kalisk's warning to those traveling to Eretz Yisrael that they may feel nothing and must toil, and the Chasam Sofer's explanation of the meraglim's complaint that they had not felt the land's holiness, which they should have answered with tefillah.

  7. 28:16 Avraham's tenth trial and the meraglim listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach links the meraglim, the tenth trial of the generation of the desert, to Avraham's tenth trial. The akeidah's test was not self-sacrifice, which Avraham had shown long before, but a closed heart: he saw the Place 'from afar', full of questions and assailed by the Satan. The meraglim faced the same test in the land and did not know to break through the shell.

  8. 33:31 Serving with the mind when the heart is closed listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach draws the lesson of the two chapters: when the heart and feelings will not cooperate, one must go with the mind. Even at Ne'ilah or the height of Shabbos the heart may close, and that is Avraham's trial; every honest Jew who is not a rasha can serve this way, and one who finds himself in a rasha's state must break himself through teshuvah.

  9. 36:44 Tamuz and Av: the two eyes

    The Mashgiach connects parshas Shelach to blessing Rosh Chodesh Tamuz: Tamuz and Av, the 'days of the first grapes', are under the dominion of the sitra achra, given to Esav while Yaakov took the other months. They correspond to the two eyes, and are the months for breaking the sitra achra with a broken spirit.

The shiur, written up

How can the heart be 'close'?

0:30

The Mashgiach opens with the passuk 'beficha uvilvavcha la'asoso'. The Gemara in Berachos says fear of Heaven, which Moshe asked for in 'ma Hashem Elokecha sho'el', was a small thing only for Moshe. But the Torah is eternal, and only tzaddikim rule their hearts; how can the heart be 'close' for everyone? Tanya's previous chapter, he recalls, began the answer. a,b,c,d

Love and fear in the mind; the order of davening

3:38

Not everyone can arouse love and fear in the heart. Tanya chapter 16 teaches that it is enough when the mind, contemplating Hashem's greatness, understands that one must love and fear Him. d

4:52

Davening is built this way: korbanos and ketores clear away the kelipos, as seen with Korach; birchos krias shema describe the sun, the spheres and the angels, before whom the world is like a drop; only then come ahavah rabbah and Shema. f

'La'asoso': the mind rules, except for resha'im

7:59

Tanya chapter 17 reads 'la'asoso' as a love that brings to action. A person's heart is not in his control, the Mashgiach explains, but his mind is: anyone can think about Hashem's greatness and reach an intellectual love, not a felt one, that leads him to the mitzvos, whose sweetness the soul will taste in the World to Come. e

11:01

Resha'im are excluded: as Chazal say, they are in the power of their hearts, while of tzaddikim it says 'vayomer Hashem el libo'. The Torah's words speak of living Jews. h,i

A rasha needs teshuvah first; the fallen hei

12:35

A rasha may do a great mitzvah, but it flares and goes out. To begin lasting avodah he must first break the kelipah by the lower teshuvah, the 'broken spirit' that the Zohar reads into 'zivchei Elokim ruach nishbarah'. This raises the lower hei of Hashem's Name, which fell into exile. j,k

15:33

A bundle of hay fell from a peasant's wagon, and he called on Reb Zusha to help. 'I cannot,' said Reb Zusha. 'You can, you just do not want to,' replied the peasant. Reb Zusha took it to heart: raising the fallen hei is the avodah of Jews in exile. A higher teshuvah also exists, reaching the Throne of Glory.

The Shechinah in exile with the Jew

18:07

The fallen hei, fear of Heaven, is the exile of the Shechinah. The Gemara in Megillah says that when Jews went into exile in Edom the Shechinah went with them, learning it from 'veshav Hashem Elokecha es shevuscha': it says Hashem Himself will return, since He is in exile with them. l,m

20:15

By remez, the Mashgiach explains, 'galu le'Edom' means a Jew falling to Edom's conduct, and this inner exile brings the outer one. Such a Jew drags his spark of G-dliness into exile in the kelipah. When he does teshuvah with a broken heart, the kelipah breaks like a nutshell and the Shechinah rises from her fall. l

When feeling is absent: Eretz Yisrael and the meraglim

23:43

This completes the previous chapter: an intellectual love and fear, without feeling, is also good, and one cannot always feel. R' Avraham of Kalisk warned those going to Eretz Yisrael that they would not feel its holiness at once and must toil for it. d

26:07

The Chasam Sofer explains the meraglim's 'eretz ocheles yoshveha' as: we passed through and felt nothing. Instead, the Mashgiach says, they should have davened at the kevarim for feeling. Moshe had told them to take of the fruit of the land, which would have raised them. n,o

Avraham's tenth trial and the meraglim

28:34

'Vayenasu osi zeh eser pe'amim' makes the meraglim the tenth trial in the desert, matching Avraham's tenth trial in Avos. Yet the furnace was harder: there Avraham gave himself up with his mind alone, before any prophecy. q,r,s

30:10

The akeidah's trial, the Mashgiach answers, was a closed heart: 'vayar es hamakom merachok', he saw Hashem from afar. He was full of questions, since he had been told 'ki veYitzchak', and the Satan came as a prophet; Avraham replied that a liar is not believed even when truthful. The meraglim faced the same test and did not know to crack the shell. t,u,v

Serving with the mind when the heart is closed

33:52

When the heart will not cooperate, the Mashgiach concludes, one goes with the mind. Even at Ne'ilah or the height of Shabbos the heart may close; this is Avraham's trial, not a decree. Every honest Jew who is not a rasha can serve this way, and one who sees himself as a rasha must break himself and do teshuvah.

Tamuz and Av: the two eyes

36:50

Shelach comes before blessing Rosh Chodesh Tamuz. Tamuz and Av, the 'days of the first grapes', are under the sitra achra; the Zohar says Hashem gave them to Esav, and Yaakov took the other months. x,y

39:42

They correspond to the two eyes, as in 'eini eini yordah mayim', and the Bnei Yissaschar ties Tamuz to sight. They are months for breaking the sitra achra with a broken spirit. z,aa

Sources

Torah

  1. a Devarim 30:14 text index In the write-up: 0:30
  2. c Devarim 10:12 text index In the write-up: 0:30
  3. f apparently Bamidbar 17:11-13 index In the write-up: 4:52
  4. g Devarim 30:12 10:47 text index
  5. i Bereishis 8:21 text index In the write-up: 11:01
  6. m Devarim 30:3 text index In the write-up: 18:07
  7. n Bamidbar 13:32 text index In the write-up: 26:07
  8. o Bamidbar 13:20 text index In the write-up: 26:07
  9. p Bamidbar 15:19 27:55 text index
  10. q Bamidbar 14:22 text index In the write-up: 28:34
  11. t Bereishis 22:4 text index In the write-up: 30:10
  12. u Bereishis 21:12 text index In the write-up: 30:10
  13. w Bamidbar 14:8 35:04 text index
  14. x Bamidbar 13:20 text index In the write-up: 36:50

Kesuvim

  1. k Tehillim 51:19 text index In the write-up: 12:35
  2. z Eichah 1:16 text index In the write-up: 39:42

Mishnah

  1. r Avos 5:4 text index In the write-up: 28:34
  2. s Avos 5:3 text index In the write-up: 28:34

Talmud Bavli

  1. b Berachos 33b text index In the write-up: 0:30
  2. l Megillah 29a text index In the write-up: 18:07, 20:15
  3. v Sanhedrin 89b text index In the write-up: 30:10

Midrash

  1. h apparently Bereishis Rabbah 34:10 index In the write-up: 11:01

Zohar and Kabbalah

  1. j Zohar (place not identified) index In the write-up: 12:35
  2. y Zohar (place not identified) index In the write-up: 36:50

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. d apparently Tanya ch. 16 index In the write-up: 0:30, 3:38, 23:43
  2. e apparently Tanya ch. 17 index In the write-up: 7:59
  3. aa Bnei Yissaschar (place not identified) index In the write-up: 39:42

Key points

  1. 7:59 The Torah's 'close in your heart, to do it' refers to a love and fear that the mind grasps and that bring a person to keep the mitzvos, even when the heart feels nothing.
  2. 8:41 A person's mind is in his control even when his heart is not, so contemplating Hashem's greatness is within everyone's reach.
  3. 12:35 A rasha, whose heart rules him, cannot begin avodah that lasts until he first does the lower teshuvah, breaking the kelipah with a broken heart.
  4. 14:35 The lower teshuvah raises the fallen lower hei of Hashem's Name, which is the exile of the Shechinah.
  5. 31:58 When the heart is closed, even in the holiest place or moment, one must serve with the mind; this was Avraham's tenth trial and the trial the meraglim failed.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 1:51 How can the Torah, which is eternal, say that the matter is close 'in your heart' for everyone, when only tzaddikim rule their hearts and the Gemara calls fear of Heaven a small thing only for Moshe?

    Answer: 7:59 'La'asoso' refers to a love and fear grasped in the mind, which is in every person's control, and which bring him to do the mitzvos even without feeling.

  2. Question: 18:07 Why did the Shechinah go into exile?

    Answer: 18:10 Because the lower hei of Hashem's Name, which is fear of Heaven, fell; that fall is the exile of the Shechinah.

  3. Question: 19:19 Why does the passuk say 'veshav Hashem', Hashem will return, rather than that He will bring back the captivity?

    Answer: 19:27 Because Hashem is in exile together with the Jews, so He Himself returns with them.

  4. Question: 29:23 What was Avraham's tenth trial at the akeidah, if being thrown into the furnace with only his mind to go on was already harder?

    Answer: 30:10 The trial was the closing of the heart: he saw the Place 'from afar', felt distant from Hashem, and was full of questions, yet went on.

Stories

  1. 15:33 Reb Zusha and the fallen hay

    Reb Zusha was traveling with a peasant who carried hay on his wagon, and a bundle fell off. The peasant called to him to help lift it, and Reb Zusha answered that he could not. The peasant replied that he could, he just did not want to. Reb Zusha took this to heart, saying the peasant had understood him: he could lift the hei but did not want to, since that is the avodah of Jews in exile.

    In the story: Reb Zusha of Anipoli

    told in 2 other shiurim →

Insights

  1. 4:44 The order of davening follows Tanya's path: korbanos and ketores clear away the kelipos, birchos krias shema contemplate the greatness of creation and the angels, and only then can one say ahavah rabbah and accept the yoke of Heaven in Shema.
  2. 16:02 Reb Zusha took the peasant's words about the hay, 'you can but you do not want to', as a rebuke to himself, since raising the fallen hei is the avodah of Jews in exile.
  3. 20:15 On the level of remez, 'galu le'Edom' means Jews fell to the conduct of Edom, and the inner exile draws the outer one; the Shechinah in exile is the spark of G-dliness in a Jew held captive by his kelipah.
  4. 29:32 Avraham's tenth trial was not the self-sacrifice of the akeidah, since he had already let himself be thrown into the furnace on the strength of his mind alone, but the closing of his heart, seeing Hashem 'from afar'.
  5. 32:31 The meraglim's trial was the same as Avraham's tenth: their lack of feeling in Eretz Yisrael was a shell to be broken like a nut, not a sign against the land.
  6. 39:42 Tamuz and Av correspond to the two eyes, and as months given over to the sitra achra they are the time to break it with a broken spirit.

What the Mashgiach says to take from it

  1. 33:47 The Mashgiach says that when the heart and feelings do not cooperate, one must go with the mind and understand that serving Hashem is good.
  2. 34:03 The Mashgiach says that if the heart closes even at Ne'ilah or the height of Shabbos, one should see it as Avraham's trial rather than a decree against oneself.
  3. 35:55 The Mashgiach says that one who finds himself in the state of a rasha must break himself through the ways Chazal give, crying out against the yetzer hara and doing teshuvah with a broken heart.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Avraham Avinu, Kalev ben Yefuneh, Moshe Rabbeinu, Pharaoh, Rabbi Avraham of Kalisk, Reb Zusha of Anipoli, the Chasam Sofer, Yaakov Avinu, Yitzchak Avinu

Terms גלות השכינה, התבוננות, טמטום הלב, ימי בכורי ענבים, לב נשבר ונדכה, מרגלים, סטרא אחרא, קליפה, רבונו של עולם

Report an error on this page