נצחון היצר אינו אלא ע"י שמחה. ביאור “בכל עצב יהיה מותר.” עצות כנגד עצבות.

Catalog entry: ספר התניא א' כ"ו no. ⁨36⁩ Pocket Guide p. 44 Yiddish 40 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 40 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Mashgiach's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Mashgiach explains, on Tanya chapter 26, that the yetzer hara is defeated only through zerizus that comes from simcha, and that sadness over sins belongs only at set times, 'by appointment only'.

The Mashgiach learns Tanya chapter 26. A lazy, heavy fighter loses even to a weaker opponent, as a fierce lion overcomes a stronger ox; so too victory over the yetzer hara comes only through zerizus born of simcha, while atzvus, rooted in the element of earth, takes away the drive to fight. Quoting the Rebbe of Karlin, he says atzvus is no aveirah but leads to aveiros like nothing else. The passuk 'in all sadness there is profit' means only that sadness can lead to joy: regret over sins at set times, 'by appointment only', breaks the ruach hatumah and brings a joy greater than ordinary joy, like light from darkness. He roots simcha in bitachon, explains that suffering comes from the hidden, higher world and must be accepted with joy, and says that sadness during learning, davening or business is a trick of the yetzer hara.

Topics: Simcha and Lowliness (Tanya ch. 26-34) · Serving Hashem with Simcha · The Yetzer Hara and Nisyonos

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Victory needs zerizus: the lion and the ox listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach notes that the coming chapters form one subject and begins Tanya chapter 26: in a physical fight, a lazy, heavy fighter is easily beaten even by a weaker opponent. He illustrates with a lion that overcomes a stronger ox or horse through its fierceness and energy, and reads that victory over the yetzer comes only through zerizus that comes from simcha.

  2. 3:57 Atzvus: heavy as earth, the way to aveiros listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that sadness and sluggishness stem from the element of earth, so a sad person lacks the drive to fight the yetzer hara, and brings the Beis Aharon quoting the Rebbe of Karlin that atzvus is no aveirah yet leads to aveiros more than anything. He then explains that 'in all sadness there is profit' does not praise sadness: nothing is created for nothing, and its only profit is the joy that can follow it.

  3. 7:43 Regret at set times, then true joy listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that one who regrets his sins with a bitter heart at set times breaks the ruach hatumah and comes to true joy, comparing it to a businessman who takes inventory of his assets and liabilities. He brings Tehillim 51, Dovid HaMelech's chapter after Nosson HaNavi came to him, which moves from a broken heart to a plea for joy, and the Arizal's custom to say it after Tikkun Chatzos.

  4. 13:00 Tikkun Chatzos and light out of darkness listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach gives the simple reason for the custom, to learn with joy after the sadness of Tikkun Chatzos, describes how Jews once rose at midnight to mourn the Beis HaMikdash, meaning inwardly the mikdash in each Jew's heart, and says today this is not for everyone. He explains that joy after sadness is greater, like light out of darkness, brings the passuk about not serving Hashem with joy, and says that one who did teshuvah may be sure Hashem forgave him, as the bracha 'chanun hamarbeh lisloach' shows.

  5. 17:59 Sadness by appointment only listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach dwells on the Tanya's words 'at set times': like a doctor who sees patients by appointment only, sadness over sins belongs only at fixed times, such as before sleep, erev Shabbos, going to the mikveh, erev Rosh Chodesh or erev Rosh Hashanah, and must otherwise be driven out. He adds that people today are small and this is hard for them, but it is good to know it and take hold of what one can.

  6. 21:21 Bitachon, the root of simcha: the two cows listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach brings the passuk 'for in Him our heart rejoices, for in His holy Name we trusted' and tells the story of R' Shimon of Yaroslav and his 'two cows', showing that bitachon is the source of simcha. Following R' Samson Raphael Hirsch's method of related sounds, he links simcha to leaning on someone and atzvus to being forsaken, which is why idols, which give nothing to lean on, are called atzabim.

  7. 27:02 Suffering from the hidden world; the port wine listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach reads the Tanya's advice against sadness over worldly matters, noting that people today are small but can use it at good times. He explains that one blesses for the bad as for the good and accepts it with joy, since it comes from the hidden world, higher than the revealed one, and tells how R' Shalom of Kaminka, after losing a child, asked for port wine, an expensive wine that tastes bitter to one who does not know it.

  8. 31:33 All suffering is for one's good listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach applies the mashal: suffering comes from the hidden world and is entirely for a person's good, because Hashem loves His children and, as the Arizal writes at the start of Etz Chaim, created the world to do good. He brings the passuk 'those who love Him are like the sun going forth in its might' and the Gemara that three good gifts are acquired only through suffering, and concludes that even suffering must be accepted with joy.

  9. 35:49 Sadness during learning, davening and business listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that sadness over sins that comes during learning, davening or business must be pushed away, since it is not its time; it is the yetzer hara's trick, because sadness drives a person to taavos, as people unhappy at home console themselves with cake. Thoughts of sin belong at an appointed time, with reflection on Hashem's greatness, after which comes true joy.

The shiur, written up

Victory needs zerizus: the lion and the ox

0:50

The Mashgiach begins Tanya chapter 26, which teaches a general rule: in any physical contest, a fighter who is lazy and heavy is easily beaten, even by a weaker opponent. He illustrates with a lion facing an ox or a horse. The ox is bigger and stronger, but it is sluggish, while the lion is fierce and full of energy, so the lion wins. So too, the Tanya says, the yetzer can be overcome only with zerizus, quickness, that comes from simcha. a

Atzvus: heavy as earth

3:57

Atzvus and atzlus, sadness and laziness, both come from the element of earth, the heaviest element, so a sad person lacks the drive to fight the yetzer hara. The Mashgiach brings the Beis Aharon quoting the Rebbe of Karlin: atzvus is not an aveirah, but nothing brings to aveiros like it. b

6:11

He then explains Mishlei's 'in all sadness there is profit'. It does not praise sadness; since nothing was created for nothing, its only profit is the joy that can follow it. d

Regret at set times, then true joy

8:07

The joy the Tanya means comes after true sadness: at set times a person reflects on his sins and regrets them, as a businessman must take inventory of his assets and liabilities to keep his business running. Regret with a bitter heart breaks the ruach hatumah, the spirit of impurity.

10:29

The Mashgiach shows this in Tehillim 51, the chapter Dovid HaMelech said after Nosson HaNavi came to him. It is a cheshbon hanefesh that speaks of a broken heart and then asks for joy. This is why the Arizal had it said after Tikkun Chatzos. e,f,g

Tikkun Chatzos and light out of darkness

13:19

The simple reason for the custom is to learn with joy after the sadness of Tikkun Chatzos. Jews once went to sleep after Maariv, as the first siman of Shulchan Aruch describes, rose at midnight to mourn the Beis HaMikdash, meaning inwardly the mikdash in each Jew's heart ruined by sins, then learned until dawn. Today, the Mashgiach says, this is not for everyone. h

15:46

Joy after sadness is greater, like light out of darkness. A Jew who did teshuvah can be sure he was forgiven, as the bracha 'chanun hamarbeh lisloach' is no bracha levatala. i,k

Sadness by appointment only

18:41

The key words are 'at set times'. Like a doctor who sees patients 'by appointment only', sadness over sins belongs only at fixed times: before sleep, erev Shabbos, going to the mikveh, erev Rosh Chodesh or erev Rosh Hashanah. Otherwise it must be driven out, for a Jew who trusts in Hashem needs no sadness. People today are small, the Mashgiach adds, but it is good to take hold of what one can.

Bitachon, the root of simcha

21:31

Where does simcha come from? The Mashgiach brings 'for in Him our heart rejoices, for in His holy Name we trusted', and tells of R' Shimon of Yaroslav, who learned all day. Asked how he made a living, he said he had two cows. His rebbetzin told the questioner they had nothing; R' Shimon answered that his two cows were in the Tehillim, the two words 'ki' of this passuk. l

23:51

Bitachon is the root of simcha. Using R' Samson Raphael Hirsch's method of related sounds, the Mashgiach links simcha to leaning on someone and atzvus to being forsaken. Idols are called atzabim because one who relies on them has nothing to lean on.

Suffering from the hidden world

28:00

The Tanya also advises against sadness over worldly matters. One blesses for the bad as for the good and accepts it with joy, since it comes from the hidden world, which in Kabbalah is higher than the revealed one. n,o

30:07

The Mashgiach tells how R' Shalom of Kaminka, after losing a child, asked for port, an expensive wine that tastes bitter to one who does not know it. He said port is costly and bitter.

All suffering is for one's good

32:04

Suffering, the Mashgiach explains, is like that costly wine: it comes from a very high world, and only one who does not understand it finds it bitter, like a child given fine brandy. Everything is for a person's good, since, as the Arizal writes at the start of Etz Chaim, the world was created to do good. q

34:32

He brings the Gemara that three gifts come only through suffering: Torah, Olam Haba and Eretz Yisrael, and concludes that even suffering must be accepted with joy. s

Sadness during learning, davening and business

36:12

Sadness over sins that comes during learning, davening or business must be pushed away; it is not its time. It is the yetzer hara's trick, for sadness drives a person to taavos: people unhappy at home console themselves with another piece of cake. Thoughts of sin belong at an appointed time, with reflection on Hashem's greatness, and then true joy follows.

Sources

Torah

  1. j Devarim 28:47 16:09 text index
  2. p Devarim 29:28 29:05 text index

Nevi'im

  1. r Shoftim 5:31 33:21 text index

Kesuvim

  1. c apparently Tehillim 115:4 6:01 index
  2. d Mishlei 14:23 text index In the write-up: 6:11
  3. e Tehillim 51:19 text index In the write-up: 10:29
  4. f Tehillim 51:10 text index In the write-up: 10:29
  5. g Tehillim 51:14 text index In the write-up: 10:29
  6. i Koheles 2:13 text index In the write-up: 15:46
  7. l Tehillim 33:21 text index In the write-up: 21:31
  8. t apparently Koheles 7:12 35:25 index

Mishnah

  1. n Mishnah Berachos 9:5 text index In the write-up: 28:00

Talmud Bavli

  1. o apparently Berachos 60b index In the write-up: 28:00
  2. s Berachos 5a text index In the write-up: 34:32

Rishonim

  1. m apparently Chovos HaLevavos, Shaar HaBitachon 24:04 index

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. a apparently Tanya ch. 26 index In the write-up: 0:50
  2. b Beis Aharon (place not identified) index In the write-up: 3:57
  3. h Shulchan Aruch Orach Chaim 1 text index In the write-up: 13:19
  4. k apparently Tanya, Iggeres HaTeshuvah ch. 11 index In the write-up: 15:46

Other

  1. q apparently Etz Chaim, beginning index In the write-up: 32:04

Key points

  1. 3:06 Victory over the yetzer hara comes only through zerizus that flows from simcha; atzvus makes a person heavy and lazy.
  2. 5:26 Atzvus is not itself an aveirah, but nothing brings a person to aveiros as much as atzvus does.
  3. 7:34 Sadness over one's sins has value only at set times, and only because it leads to the joy that follows it.
  4. 15:31 Joy that comes after true sadness over sins is greater than other joy, like light that comes out of darkness.
  5. 23:51 Bitachon is the root of simcha: one who has someone to lean on rejoices, one who is forsaken is sad.
  6. 31:38 All suffering comes from the hidden world, higher than the revealed one, and is entirely for a person's good, so it is to be accepted with joy.
  7. 36:12 Sadness over sins that comes during learning, davening or business is a trick of the yetzer hara and must be pushed away.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 6:17 The passuk 'in all sadness there is profit' seems to say that sadness has some value; is that so?

    Answer: 6:46 The opposite: the passuk shows that sadness in itself is worthless, but since nothing was created for nothing, the good that can come from it is its opposite, joy.

  2. Question: 15:28 Why does joy that follows sadness over sins surpass other joy?

    Answer: 15:46 Because it is light that comes out of darkness, which is greater light.

  3. Question: 29:45 How can a person accept suffering with joy when it seems bad?

    Answer: 31:06 Suffering comes from the hidden world, higher than the revealed one, and is all for his good; like a costly wine it only tastes bitter to one who does not understand it.

Stories

  1. 21:37 R' Shimon of Yaroslav's two cows

    R' Shimon of Yaroslav sat and learned all day in the beis medrash, relying on Hashem for his parnassah. A Jew who saw his holiness asked how he made a living, and he answered that he had two cows. The man asked the rebbetzin, who said they had no cows and often had nothing to eat, so he came back and asked why such an honest Jew had told a lie. R' Shimon answered that his two cows were not in a stable but in the Tehillim, and showed him the passuk 'for in Him our heart rejoices, for in His holy Name we trusted', with its two words 'ki'.

    In the story: Rabbi Shimon of Yaroslav

    told in 1 other shiur →

  2. 30:07 R' Shalom of Kaminka and the port wine

    After R' Shalom of Kaminka lost a child, he asked that port wine be brought to him. Port is a very expensive wine that tastes bitter to one who is not used to it, and only connoisseurs appreciate it. He drank it and remarked that port is a costly wine and it is bitter.

    In the story: Rabbi Shalom of Kaminka

Insights

  1. 3:57 Atzvus and atzlus (sadness and laziness) are the same thing at root: both come from the element of earth, the heaviest element, which is why a sad person has no drive to fight the yetzer hara.
  2. 18:22 The Tanya's 'at set times' is like a doctor's sign 'by appointment only': sadness over sins may come in only at its appointed time, never as a guest with its own key.
  3. 24:28 Following the method of related sounds, simcha is linked to leaning on someone and atzvus to being forsaken; idols are called atzabim because one who relies on them has nothing to lean on.
  4. 14:06 Mourning the Beis HaMikdash at Tikkun Chatzos means, inwardly, mourning the mikdash in each Jew's heart that was ruined by his sins, which is regret over them.
  5. 30:32 Suffering is like a costly wine such as port: it comes from a very high world, but it tastes bitter to one who is not a connoisseur, as the finest brandy tastes bitter to a child.
  6. 36:49 Atzvus pushes a person into taavos, because he cannot bear being dissatisfied and looks for some satisfaction, such as a piece of cake; this is why the yetzer hara brings on sadness in the middle of one's work.

What the Mashgiach says to take from it

  1. 19:01 The Mashgiach says to set fixed times for regret over one's sins, such as before sleep at Krias Shema, erev Shabbos, going to the mikveh, erev Rosh Chodesh or erev Rosh Hashanah.
  2. 36:12 The Mashgiach says that sadness which comes during learning, davening or business must be pushed away, since it is not its time.
  3. 20:28 The Mashgiach says that even if these levels are hard for people today, it is good to learn them and take hold of what one can, at least in part.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Bas Sheva, Dovid HaMelech, Nasan HaNavi, Rabbi Aharon of Karlin (Rabbi Aharon HaGadol), Rabbi Samson Raphael Hirsch, Rabbi Shalom of Kaminka, Rabbi Shimon of Yaroslav, the Arizal, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi)

Terms ארבע יסודות, בטחון, זריזות, יסורים, עלמא דאתגליא, עלמא דאתכסיא, עצבות, עצלות, רוח הטומאה, תאוה, תיקון חצות

Report an error on this page