אין אדם חוטא אלא אם נכנס בו רוח שטות.
Catalog entry: ספר התניא ב' כ"ה no. 11 Pocket Guide p. 47 Yiddish 40 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains that a Jew sins only because a spirit of folly makes him forget that every sin cuts him off from Hashem just as idolatry does, and that the same readiness for mesirus nefesh he would show against idolatry can carry him through every daily battle with the yetzer hara.
Learning Tanya chapter 25, the Mashgiach recalls that even the simplest Jews gave their lives rather than worship idols in the persecutions of Europe, and teaches that every sin is a branch of idolatry, since it too separates a person from Hashem. A Jew sins only because a spirit of folly, as the Gemara says, makes him forget this; his hidden love for Hashem is always there. Even the plan to sin and then repent does not help, since the bond with Hashem is above time and even one moment of separation counts. The Mashgiach applies the reckoning to the daily war: getting up to daven, learning with clarity and full strength, davening with kavanah, giving tzedakah. He adds that a mitzvah creates an eternal union, warns about wasted time, and cautions that today's weaker generations must also guard their health. He closes with Rashi's reading that going against one's will is itself mesirus nefesh, and explains why the generation in the desert also needed the mitzvah of mesirus nefesh.
Topics: Ahavah Mesuteres (Tanya ch. 18-25) · Mesiras Nefesh · The Yetzer Hara and Nisyonos
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Every Jew gives his life against idolatry
The Mashgiach recalls that in the decrees and persecutions of Europe hundreds of thousands of simple Jews gave their lives rather than convert, and explains that every sin, even a light one, is a branch of idolatry. He says a person must sit and think about this again and again until it becomes part of his own knowledge.
-
6:33 The spirit of folly and the plan to repent later listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Gemara that a person sins only when a spirit of folly enters him: he forgets that the sin separates him from Hashem, while his hidden love, which includes fear, remains. He then shows that even one who plans to repent afterwards would still give his life rather than bow to an idol even for a moment, because the bond with Hashem is above time.
-
14:38 Using the reckoning in daily avodah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach applies the reckoning to the yetzer hara's daily tricks: the laziness to get up and daven in the morning, learning without clarity and full strength, davening without kavanah, and holding back from giving tzedakah. Even for one minute, he says, a Jew would give his life rather than be cut off, so he can overcome these smaller tests.
-
20:56 The eternal union of a mitzvah
The Mashgiach explains that a mitzvah done with all one's strength makes a union with Hashem that lasts forever, since above everything is eternal and the Torah never changes. Time wasted on idle talk and things that have nothing to do with Torah or avodah loses that union, and one must then ask Hashem's forgiveness.
-
24:37 Weaker generations and guarding health
The Mashgiach notes that the Ba'al HaTanya demanded unbroken Torah and avodah of people stronger than today's, and that those who strain too much break down. A person must rest, eat properly and exercise for his health, which is not bittul Torah, as long as most of the day is given to Torah and avodah and he does not indulge in foolishness.
-
31:51 Selach lanu and the meaning of nafsheichem
The Mashgiach asks why Chazal instituted the brachah of Selach lanu three times a day, and answers that it is for bittul Torah, which the daily tamid offering used to atone for and which the tefillos now replace. He then brings Rashi that nefesh means will, so that anyone who acts against his will has a measure of mesirus nefesh.
-
35:26 Mesirus nefesh in Shema and in the desert
The Mashgiach explains that when saying Shema one must have in mind readiness for mesirus nefesh at the word echad and at bechol nafshecha. He asks why the generation in the desert, whom Hashem promised the nations would fear, needed the mitzvah of mesirus nefesh, and answers that it let them make the reckoning for every mitzvah and every small sin.
The shiur, written up
Every Jew gives his life against idolatry
The Mashgiach recalls that in the decrees and persecutions of Europe, hundreds of thousands of Jews let themselves be killed rather than convert. They were simple Jews, not great servants of Hashem, some of whom had even committed serious sins, yet they would not worship idols.
From here he teaches that every sin, even a light one, is a branch of idolatry, because it too separates a person from Hashem. Knowing this is not enough: a person must sit and think about it again and again, until it becomes part of his own knowledge and he is truly convinced of it.
The spirit of folly and the plan to repent later
Why, then, does a Jew sin? The Mashgiach brings the Gemara that a person sins only when a spirit of folly enters him, alluded to in the verse of the sotah. It is folly indeed: a Jew who would let himself be killed rather than bow to an idol will not bear a much smaller sacrifice to avoid a sin, because in that moment he forgets that the sin cuts him off from Hashem. a,b
Yet every Jew, even the lowest, carries a hidden love for Hashem without any doubt. The Mashgiach compares it to a mother who fears her baby will fall on the stairs: that fear comes from love, and so this love includes fear as well.
The Tanya adds that even one who plans to sin and repent afterwards would still give his life rather than bow to an idol even for a moment. The Mashgiach cites the Mishnah that one who says he will sin and repent is not given the chance to repent, and explains that the bond with Hashem is above time, so a moment's separation is complete. c,d
Using the reckoning in daily avodah
The Mashgiach applies this reckoning to the yetzer hara's daily tricks. In the morning it tempts a person to stay in bed instead of davening; he should remind himself that he would give his life for Hashem, and this smaller test is nothing beside it.
The same holds for learning. Some learn half asleep, but the Torah must be understood clearly, and a sugya that is not yet clear should be gone over again; the Arizal says one must learn with all one's strength. So too davening with kavanah with full strength, and giving tzedakah when the yetzer wants to hold back the money. Even for one minute, the Mashgiach says, a Jew would give his life rather than be cut off.
The eternal union of a mitzvah
A mitzvah done with all one's strength, the Mashgiach explains, makes a union with Hashem that is eternal. One who ate matzah has eaten it forever, since above there is nothing that exists only now. Torah too is eternal, as Yeshayahu says that the word of Hashem stands forever. But time spent on idle matters that have no connection to Torah or avodah loses that union, and one must then ask Hashem's forgiveness. e
Weaker generations and guarding health
The Mashgiach notes that the Ba'al HaTanya, who demanded unbroken Torah and avodah, spoke to people stronger than today's. Today's generations have weaker nerves; those who strain too much break down and for months cannot learn. It is impossible now to go from dawn to night without a minute's rest. c
The seforim bring that a tzaddik took a walk every day for his health. This is not bittul Torah but the opposite, since it lets a person learn. Bochurim in camp may exercise part of the day, and one should eat what he needs but not overeat; what matters is to measure honestly whether it is needed. The great majority of the day must still belong to Torah and avodah, for Hashem is in camp too.
Selach lanu and the meaning of nafsheichem
The Mashgiach asks why Chazal instituted Selach lanu three times a day, if one already asked forgiveness earlier. It is for bittul Torah, which no one fully escapes. Once the daily tamid atoned for it, as the Midrash says that no one in Yerushalayim remained with sin; today the tefillos stand in place of the tamid, as the Gemara teaches. f,g,h
Mesirus nefesh in Shema and in the desert
When saying Shema, the Mashgiach says, one must have in mind at echad, and again at bechol nafshecha, the readiness to give one's life for Hashem. j
He asks why the generation in the desert needed the mitzvah of mesirus nefesh, when Hashem promised that all nations would fear them. He answers that it let them make the reckoning: one ready to die rather than be cut off from Hashem must accept every mitzvah, and resist even a smaller sin, with the same readiness. k
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
- g Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 31:51
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 3:43 Every sin, even a light one, is a branch of idolatry, because it too separates a Jew from Hashem.
- 6:56 A Jew sins only because a spirit of folly enters him and he forgets that the sin cuts him off from Hashem; his hidden love stays intact.
- 13:10 The bond with Hashem is above time, so even a single moment of separation is real separation, and the plan to sin and repent later changes nothing.
- 14:52 The same reckoning of mesirus nefesh should be used against the yetzer hara in getting up to daven, learning Torah with clarity and full strength, davening with kavanah and giving tzedakah.
- 21:59 A mitzvah or Torah learning creates a union with Hashem that is eternal, while time spent on idle things loses that union.
- 24:51 Today's generations are weaker than in the Ba'al HaTanya's time, so a person must also look after his health, as long as most of the day is given to Torah and avodah.
- 34:45 Going against one's own will is itself a form of mesirus nefesh, and the readiness to give one's life should be applied to all the mitzvos.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 7:39 Why does a Jew who would give his life rather than worship idols commit other sins?
Answer: 7:04 A spirit of folly enters him and he forgets that every sin separates him from Hashem like idolatry.
-
Question: 13:10 If he can repent afterwards, why should he refuse to sin even for a moment?
Answer: 12:18 One who sins planning to repent is not helped to repent, and the bond with Hashem is above time, so even a moment's separation is complete.
-
Question: 31:51 Why did Chazal institute Selach lanu three times a day, if a person already asked forgiveness earlier?
Answer: 32:03 For bittul Torah, which no one avoids; the tamid used to atone for it, and the tefillos now stand in its place.
-
Question: 36:08 Why did the generation in the desert need the mitzvah of mesirus nefesh, when Hashem promised that the nations would fear them?
Answer: 37:12 So that they could make the reckoning that one who is ready to die rather than be cut off from Hashem must accept every mitzvah with the same readiness.
Insights
- 3:43 Even a light sin is a branch of idolatry, not because of its severity but because any act against Hashem's will separates a Jew from Him just as idolatry does.
- 7:07 The 'folly' of sin is that a Jew who would let himself be killed rather than bow to an idol will not bear a far smaller sacrifice to avoid a sin that cuts him off just the same.
- 13:17 Because Hashem and the bond with Him are above time, a separation 'just for a moment' is not small: in that moment the person is fully cut off.
- 22:05 A mitzvah done in a moment is eternal, like matzah eaten once that remains forever, because above there is nothing that exists only now.
- 31:51 Selach lanu is said three times daily for bittul Torah, which the tamid once atoned for; the tefillos that replace the tamid carry that atonement.
- 36:19 The generation in the desert, who faced no idolatrous oppressor, still needed the mitzvah of mesirus nefesh, so that the reckoning of readiness to die could strengthen them in every mitzvah.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 5:36 The Mashgiach says one must sit and think about readiness for mesirus nefesh again and again until it becomes part of one's own knowledge.
- 16:02 The Mashgiach says one should learn with full strength and understand the sugya clearly, going over it again if it is not yet clear.
- 17:29 The Mashgiach says one should daven with kavanah with all one's strength.
- 27:09 The Mashgiach says that resting, eating properly and exercise for one's health are not bittul Torah, as long as most of the day is spent in Torah and avodah.
- 35:29 The Mashgiach says that when saying Shema one should think, at the word echad, of readiness for mesirus nefesh.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Moshe Rabbeinu, Rashi, the Arizal, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi)
Terms אהבה מסותרת, ביטול תורה, חשבון הנפש, למעלה מן הזמן, מסירות נפש, עבודה זרה, קבלת עול מלכות שמים, רוח שטות