כל עבירה היא ע”ז ממש והעובר הוא יותר גרוע מהסטרא אחרא ממש. הסטרא אחרא נהנה מבחינת אחוריים. אם חוטא' יתוש קדמך. תרץ למה אין כל עבירה דוחה פיקוח נפש אם כל עבירה היא ע”ז ממש.

Catalog entry: ספר התניא ב' כ"ד no. ⁨10⁩ Pocket Guide p. 47 Yiddish 45 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 45 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Mashgiach's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

Learning Tanya chapter 24, the Mashgiach explains that every sin, even a small one, is truly avodah zarah, that the sinner is lower than the sitra achra itself and even than a gnat, and why pikuach nefesh nevertheless overrides most sins.

The Mashgiach announces he will now learn faster, recalls chapter 23 (anochi as the root of all mitzvos, lo yihyeh of all sins), and opens chapter 24: just as Torah and mitzvos unite a Jew with Hashem, a sin unites him with the sitra achra. Every sin is avodah zarah because the sinner makes himself a yesh who will not be batel to Hashem's will, like chametz that rises against humble matzah. He uses the very G-dly soul that animates him to power the sin, lending the sitra achra a body. The sitra achra still knows its Master and does His will; the sinner does not. It lives only from the outermost 'back' of holiness, the dregs that cannot be refined. A person sins only through a spirit of folly that hides the truth from his chochmah. Like the gnat that only takes and never gives, the sinner is lower than all creatures, and animals rule a man only when he loses his tzelem Elokim, with stories of tzaddikim and beasts. Finally the Mashgiach asks why pikuach nefesh overrides ordinary sins and answers from the Gemara and as a gezeiras hakasuv.

Topics: Ahavah Mesuteres (Tanya ch. 18-25) · Kedushah and Kelipah

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Faster pace; review of chapter 23 listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach says he will now learn faster, just to know what the text says, so as to reach the later chapters. He recalls chapter 23: anochi is the root of all mitzvos and lo yihyeh of all sins, so every sin is avodah zarah, and asks why a person who would give his life rather than worship idols does not make the same calculation for every sin.

  2. 5:37 A sin as union with the sitra achra listed in the guide

    Opening chapter 24, the Mashgiach explains that just as Torah study unites a person with Hashem, a sin unites him with the sitra achra. The sinner is a yesh who will not be batel, and a yesh is avodah zarah; he illustrates with chametz, which rises, against matzah, which stays low, and with haughtiness.

  3. 9:34 The G-dly soul harnessed to the sin listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that through thought, speech and action of a sin the soul itself is united with avodah zarah: the G-dly soul that animates the body is made into a horse pulling the wagon of the sin, and the sinner lends the sitra achra a body. He adds that the sitra achra knows its Master and does His will, so the sinner is worse than it.

  4. 13:57 The sitra achra lives from the 'back' listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that even idol-worshippers call Hashem the G-d of gods and believe He handed the world to lesser powers; their sin is that they consider themselves a yesh. Everything must draw some life from holiness, and the sitra achra draws only from the 'back', the part that cannot be refined, like the waste of food; the sinner, who goes against Hashem's will, is worse.

  5. 21:26 Dregs of this world and the spirit of folly listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that the evil of this material world is the dregs of the kelipos, like the sediment of spoiled wine, which is why the wicked are strong here. He brings the Gemara that a person sins only when a spirit of folly enters him, and explains why the woman of the parsha of sotah would give her life rather than bow to an idol yet commits a sin: the folly covers her chochmah, which is roused only by real avodah zarah.

  6. 29:31 Even the gnat preceded you listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach brings the Gemara that a gnat was created before man and explains it: every creature both receives from the world and gives to it, like the bee, but the gnat only sucks blood and gives nothing, the very mark of the sitra achra. Yet a sinner, who goes against Hashem's will, is lower still; he tells of a tzaddik who would not kill any creature except a mosquito.

  7. 35:44 Beasts and the tzelem Elokim: stories Story

    The Mashgiach brings Chazal that a wild beast rules over a man only when he looks to it like an animal, having lost his tzelem Elokim. He tells how lions bowed before the Divrei Chaim, how a pack of wolves left a family of the Komarna Rebbe's descendants unharmed, and of a gadol who saw a leader without a tzelem Elokim; and he mentions Daniel among the lions.

  8. 40:31 Why pikuach nefesh overrides other sins listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach asks: if every sin is avodah zarah, why does pikuach nefesh override all sins but avodah zarah? He answers with the Gemara's reasoning, desecrate one Shabbos so he can keep many, and that it is a gezeiras hakasuv, not because Shabbos is lighter; he shows from the law of shechitah that a mumar for Shabbos is like an idolater. He closes with a word about the coming week.

The shiur, written up

Faster pace; review of chapter 23

0:57

The Mashgiach says he will now learn faster, simply to know what the text says, since the earlier chapters were only a preparation for the later ones. He recalls chapter 23: anochi is the root of all the mitzvos and lo yihyeh the root of all sins, so a sin cuts a person off from bittul to Hashem and makes him batel to the sitra achra, which is avodah zarah. b

4:00

If a person understood this, the Mashgiach says, he would never sin. One who would give his life rather than worship idols should reason that a small sin is no different, and conquering his desire is far easier than mesirus nefesh.

A sin as union with the sitra achra

5:40

Opening chapter 24, the Mashgiach explains that just as Torah study unites a person with Hashem, a sin unites him with the sitra achra. The sinner will not be batel; he is a yesh, a self, and a yesh is avodah zarah. Chametz and matzah are the same flour and water, he notes, but matzah stays low and carries holy lights, while chametz rises; that rising is avodah zarah. He adds Chazal's teaching that haughtiness is like idol worship. a,d

The G-dly soul harnessed to the sin

9:55

A sinful thought, word or deed, the Mashgiach continues, unites the soul itself with avodah zarah. The G-dly soul gives the body its life, so in sinning a person harnesses it like a horse to the wagon of his sin. The sitra achra cannot sin without a physical body; the sinner lends it his.

12:48

The sitra achra knows its Master: the Satan entices people because Hashem commands it, so he does Hashem's will. The person who lets himself be enticed acts against that will and is worse than the Satan.

The sitra achra lives from the 'back'

14:22

Even idol-worshippers, the Mashgiach explains, call Hashem the G-d of gods; they believe He handed the running of the world to the angels and the stars because it is beneath His honor. Their fault is the yesh: they think the powers they received are their own. f

17:08

Everything Hashem created has a purpose, and everything must draw life from holiness or it would cease to exist. The sitra achra draws only from the part that cannot be refined, like the part of food the body cannot absorb and expels; this is the 'back', with Hashem's will hovering above it but not descending into it. A Jew who sins against Hashem's will, the Mashgiach concludes, is worse than all of it.

Dregs of this world and the spirit of folly

21:45

Citing the Etz Chaim, the Mashgiach explains that the evil of this material world is the dregs of the kelipos, like the thick sediment of wine left too long. Since Adam's sin good and evil are mixed, and a Jew's work is to sift out the good; this world is the waste left over, which is why its wicked are strong, as the Al HaNisim speaks of the wicked given into the hands of the righteous. h,i

23:52

Hence the Gemara reads the word for the straying wife as folly: a person sins only when a spirit of folly enters him. Such a woman, the Mashgiach notes, would give her life rather than bow to an idol even outwardly, yet she sins. Were she to understand that her sin binds her to the lowest kelipah, she would resist. The folly covers the G-dly soul's chochmah, which is roused only by outright idol worship; an ordinary sin reaches toward chochmah but not into it. j,k

Even the gnat preceded you

30:24

The Mashgiach brings the Gemara that if a man grows proud he is told that a gnat preceded him in creation. Every creature receives from the world and gives to it, like the bee that stings yet gathers sweetness and makes honey. The gnat only sucks blood and gives nothing. Holiness is giving, so the gnat is the extreme of the sitra achra; yet the sinner is lower than it. l

32:30

He relates what he was told of a tzaddik who would let no creature be killed, even mice, allowing only traps that catch them alive; a mosquito, the tzaddik said, may be killed.

Beasts and the tzelem Elokim

36:02

Chazal teach that a wild beast rules over a man only when he looks to it like an animal, having lost his tzelem Elokim. The Mashgiach tells how the lions bowed their heads before the Divrei Chaim, and how a pack of wolves stopped a family of the Komarna Rebbe's descendants in a forest; the chief wolf jumped onto the wagon, sniffed each of them, and led the pack away. m

39:29

By contrast, a gadol once saw a leader coming to visit and said an ox was coming up the stairs; the man had lost his tzelem Elokim. Tzaddikim, the Mashgiach adds, are feared by beasts, as with Daniel among the lions. p

Why pikuach nefesh overrides other sins

40:39

The Mashgiach asks: if every sin is avodah zarah, why does pikuach nefesh override all other sins? The Tanya answers with Chazal's reasoning, desecrate one Shabbos so he can keep many, not because Shabbos is lighter. Shabbos is like avodah zarah: the shechitah of a mumar for Shabbos is invalid. It is a gezeiras hakasuv; the Torah wants no mesirus nefesh for Shabbos. a,q,r

Sources

Torah

  1. c apparently Devarim 11:16 3:13 index
  2. e Shemos (place not identified) 8:04 index
  3. j Bamidbar 5:12 text index In the write-up: 23:52
  4. n apparently Bereishis 9:2 35:55 index
  5. o Vayikra 20:25 37:01 text index

Kesuvim

  1. p apparently Daniel ch. 6 index In the write-up: 39:29

Talmud Bavli

  1. d apparently Sotah 4b index In the write-up: 5:40
  2. f Gemara (place not identified) index In the write-up: 14:22
  3. g apparently Gittin 57a 18:20 index
  4. k Sotah 3a text index In the write-up: 23:52
  5. l Sanhedrin 38a text index In the write-up: 30:24
  6. m Shabbos 151b text index In the write-up: 36:02
  7. q Yoma 85b text index In the write-up: 40:39
  8. r apparently Chullin 5a index In the write-up: 40:39

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. a Tanya ch. 24 text index In the write-up: 5:40, 40:39
  2. b apparently Tanya ch. 23 index In the write-up: 0:57

Tefillah and Piyut

  1. i apparently Al HaNisim (Chanukah) index In the write-up: 21:45

Other

  1. h Etz Chaim (place not identified) index In the write-up: 21:45

Key points

  1. 3:24 Every sin, even a rabbinic one, is truly avodah zarah, because the sinner detaches himself from bittul to Hashem and binds himself to the sitra achra.
  2. 7:00 A sin is a yesh, a self that will not be batel to Hashem's will, and the yesh itself is avodah zarah, as chametz rises while matzah stays low.
  3. 10:50 When sinning, a Jew harnesses his G-dly soul, which gives his body life, to the sitra achra, and lends it a body with which to sin.
  4. 13:11 The sitra achra itself recognizes its Master and carries out His will, so a person who sins is worse than it.
  5. 24:13 A person sins only because a spirit of folly covers his chochmah; were it uncovered, he would give his life rather than sin, as he would for avodah zarah.
  6. 40:39 Pikuach nefesh overrides other sins not because they are lighter than avodah zarah but because of the Gemara's reasoning and a decree of the Torah.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 4:13 If every sin is avodah zarah, why does a person who would give his life for avodah zarah not do so for other sins, when merely conquering his desire is far easier?

    Answer: 25:16 Because a spirit of folly covers the chochmah of the soul; ordinary sin reaches close to chochmah but not into it, so the soul's readiness for mesirus nefesh is not roused.

  2. Question: 7:30 What is the difference between chametz and matzah, if both are flour and water?

    Answer: 7:38 Matzah is bittul and stays low, while chametz rises and is a yesh, which is avodah zarah.

  3. Question: 13:36 Why is a person who lets the Satan entice him worse than the Satan himself?

    Answer: 13:23 Because the Satan entices people at Hashem's command and so does His will, while the sinner acts against His will.

  4. Question: 30:24 Why do Chazal say a gnat preceded man in creation?

    Answer: 31:20 Every creature both takes and gives, but the gnat only takes; the sinner, who goes against Hashem's will, is lower even than it.

  5. Question: 40:31 If every sin is truly avodah zarah, why does pikuach nefesh override all other sins?

    Answer: 41:33 Not because they are lighter: Chazal reason that one Shabbos is desecrated so he can keep many, and it is a gezeiras hakasuv that the Torah wants no mesirus nefesh for Shabbos.

Stories

  1. 32:30 The tzaddik who would not kill a creature

    The Mashgiach relates what he was told about a tzaddik who was very careful not to kill any living creature, even harmful ones. When his home had mice and people brought traps that kill, he had them removed and allowed only traps that catch the mice alive so they could be set free in the field. A mosquito, however, he said may be killed, as the Tanya explains.

  2. 36:41 The lions bowed to the Divrei Chaim

    The Mashgiach tells the well-known story that the Divrei Chaim of Sanz once went to look at the animals, perhaps with a holy intention, for the mitzvah to distinguish between pure and impure animals. When he came to the cage of the lions, they bowed their heads before him, because they saw in him the tzelem Elokim.

    In the story: the Divrei Chaim (Rabbi Chaim of Sanz)

  3. 38:01 The wolves and the Komarna family

    A descendant of Rabbi Yitzchak Eizik of Komarna traveled with her family by wagon through a forest to visit their grandfather. Suddenly the horses stopped and reared up, a sign that wolves were coming, and a whole pack arrived. The chief wolf jumped onto the wagon, went around the whole family sniffing them, climbed down and led all the wolves away. The Mashgiach explains: they saw that these people had a tzelem Elokim; he heard the story as told by a Rebbe who had it from his grandmother.

    In the story: the Skulener Rebbe, Rabbi Yitzchak Eizik of Komarna (the Heichal HaBrachah)

    told in 1 other shiur →

  4. 39:22 The gadol and the leader who lost his tzelem Elokim

    The Mashgiach recalls that a leader came to visit one of the great gedolim. At that moment the gadol looked out at the staircase, ran in to the rebbetzin and said that an ox was coming up the stairs. The Mashgiach explains that he saw that this man had lost his tzelem Elokim.

Insights

  1. 7:30 The Mashgiach reads the difference between chametz and matzah as the difference between avodah zarah and bittul: both are the same flour and water, but chametz rises, a yesh, while matzah stays low and becomes a vehicle for holy names and lights.
  2. 11:38 The sitra achra itself cannot sin, since sin needs a physical body in this world; a Jew who sins lends it his body, and harnesses his G-dly soul like a horse to the wagon of his sin.
  3. 14:47 Even idol-worshippers call Hashem the G-d of gods and believe He delegated the world; their sin is the yesh, thinking their powers are their own, and a Jew who sins against Hashem's will is worse than them.
  4. 32:11 The gnat, the creature that only takes and gives nothing, is the extreme of the sitra achra, since holiness is defined by giving; yet the sinner is lower than it.
  5. 28:58 The difference between mesirus nefesh for avodah zarah and not for other sins lies in chochmah: only outright idol worship reaches the chochmah of the soul and rouses it, while an ordinary sin reaches close to chochmah but not into it.
  6. 36:02 A wild beast attacks a man only when it sees him as an animal; a person who keeps his tzelem Elokim is feared by the beasts.

What the Mashgiach says to take from it

  1. 3:46 The Mashgiach says that if a person understood that every sin binds him to avodah zarah, he would never commit a sin.
  2. 4:28 The Mashgiach says a person should make the reckoning: if he would give his life rather than worship idols, he should surely conquer his desire for a small sin, which is far easier than mesirus nefesh.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Daniel, Haman, Rabbi Yitzchak Eizik of Komarna (the Heichal HaBrachah), the Arizal, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Baal Shem Tov, the Divrei Chaim (Rabbi Chaim of Sanz), the Rambam

Terms אחוריים, אנכי ה' אלקיך, מסירות נפש, נפש האלקית, סטרא אחרא, עבודה זרה, פיקוח נפש, צלם אלקים, קליפה, רבונו של עולם, רוח שטות

Report an error on this page