היצר מנצח כשאדם בעצבות' קשר עצבות לעצלות. בכל עצב יהיה מותר. עצה להיות בשמחה אפ' כשבאות צרות.
Catalog entry: ספר התניא ב' כ"ו no. 12 Pocket Guide p. 47 Yiddish 45 min
Listen
About this shiur
On Tanya chapter 26, the Mashgiach explains why sadness lets the yetzer hara win, how a set time of broken-heartedness leads to a greater joy, and why sadness that comes in the middle of business or avodah is a trick of the yetzer.
The Mashgiach learns the opening of Tanya chapter 26: just as a sluggish wrestler loses even to a weaker opponent, a person in sadness cannot defeat the yetzer, because sadness and laziness both come from the element of earth. One must be joyful, free of worry about the future and of dissatisfaction with the present. He then explains the verse 'in every sadness there is an advantage': a broken heart at a set time, as in the Arizal's order of Tikkun Chatzos followed by Tehillim 51, leads to a joy greater than before, like light after darkness. Along the way he discusses the four tefillos and four Shabbos meals, staying awake on leil shishi and Shavuos night, and the hidden chassadim that come clothed in suffering. He closes with the Tanya's warning that sadness during business or davening is a ploy of the yetzer, which leads to cravings.
Topics: Simcha and Lowliness (Tanya ch. 26-34) · Serving Hashem with Simcha · The Yetzer Hara and Nisyonos
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Sadness and laziness lose the battle listed in the guide
The Mashgiach reads the opening of Tanya chapter 26 and its mashal of two wrestlers, adding the example of the lion and the ox. He explains that sadness and laziness both come from the element of earth, so a depressed person moves slowly and cannot defeat the yetzer.
-
4:04 Joy, zerizus and waking up early listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains the Tanya's call to be free of worry and sadness, distinguishing worry about the future from dissatisfaction with the present. He shows that people who wake up late are escaping life, while on a day they expect something good they rise early, as a Jew who looks forward to serving Hashem does.
-
7:17 In every sadness there is an advantage listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the verse 'in every sadness there is an advantage' and explains with the Tanya that the advantage is the joy that follows true regret over one's avodah. A broken heart breaks the sitra achra and the wall between a person and Hashem, as the verse 'the offerings of G-d are a broken spirit' teaches.
-
11:16 A set time for sadness: Tikkun Chatzos listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that sadness may enter only at an appointed time, for a few minutes. He shows this in the Arizal's order to say Tehillim 51, Dovid HaMelech's chapter of teshuvah, after Tikkun Chatzos, where one mourns the destruction of his own inner Beis HaMikdash and then learns in joy.
-
14:35 Four tefillos, four meals, and leil shishi
The Mashgiach digresses to the four tefillos: Shacharis and Mincha are obligations, Maariv was a choice that Jews accepted like a vow, and Dovid HaMelech's midnight tefillah remained for tzaddikim. He parallels them to the four Shabbos meals, and criticizes staying up on Thursday night only to sleep through Shabbos.
-
20:19 Shavuos night and serving with sense
The Mashgiach explains that staying awake on Shavuos night is meant to prepare for the morning, so one who will doze through davening and Kerias HaTorah gains nothing, like a chasan who arranged everything and then went to sleep at the chuppah. Since the generations have weakened, one must serve Hashem with sense, and on Shabbos rise early, learn and daven with strength.
-
24:14 Light after darkness; sorrows of this world listed in the guide
Returning to the Tanya, the Mashgiach explains with 'as light excels over darkness' that joy after sadness is greater, and brings the Arizal's reading of 'because you did not serve Hashem with joy'. He lists other set times for a reckoning, then turns to sadness over children, health and livelihood, which the Tanya rejects, since one blesses Hashem for bad as for good.
-
29:37 Hidden chassadim clothed in suffering listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that rejoicing in suffering is a high level reached through years of work. The first two letters of Hashem's name stand for the hidden worlds, whose greater chassadim come down covered in suffering, as he shows in the word 'mitzvah', and he brings 'fortunate is the man whom Hashem chastises' and Chazal on those who rejoice in suffering.
-
34:30 Tzaddikim who rejoiced in suffering listed in the guide
The Mashgiach tells of tzaddikim who rejoiced in suffering, including a Rav named Eliyahu who put his hand into fire, because closeness to Hashem is better than life. He explains that the hidden chassadim will one day be revealed like the sun leaving its sheath, and that in worldly troubles one should bind himself to Hashem.
-
38:23 Sadness in business and avodah is the yetzer listed in the guide
The Mashgiach says simpler people should meet worldly troubles with bitachon. He then brings the Tanya that even sadness over spiritual matters, when it comes during business or davening, is a trick of the yetzer that leads to cravings, as seen in people who overeat, and that true bitterness belongs only at a fixed time such as chatzos or Krias Shema before sleep.
The shiur, written up
Sadness and laziness lose the battle
The Mashgiach opens Tanya chapter 26: when two people wrestle, the one who is lazy and heavy loses easily, even to a weaker opponent. He adds that an ox may be stronger than a lion, yet the lion wins through speed. So too against the yetzer, sadness brings heaviness, since sadness and laziness both come from the element of earth, and a depressed person moves slowly. a
Joy, zerizus and waking up early
The Tanya asks for joy and freedom from worry, which the Mashgiach defines as concern for the future, and sadness, dissatisfaction with the present. People who sleep late, he says, are escaping a day they expect nothing from; on a vacation day they rise early. A Jew who looks forward to Torah and tefillah gets up eagerly. b
In every sadness there is an advantage
Yet the verse in Mishlei 14:23 says every sadness has an advantage. The Tanya explains that this is the joy that follows true regret: one who feels he should learn and daven better becomes broken, and that brokenness breaks the sitra achra and the iron wall between him and Hashem. This is the meaning of Tehillim 51:19, a broken heart is Hashem's offering, and the verse before it, Tehillim 51:10, speaks of crushed bones rejoicing. c,d,e,f
A set time for sadness: Tikkun Chatzos
After Tehillim 51:14, asking Hashem to restore joy, the Mashgiach stresses that sadness may enter only at an appointed time, for a few minutes. Thus the Arizal ordered this chapter of Dovid HaMelech's teshuvah said after Tikkun Chatzos, where one mourns his own inner Beis HaMikdash, and then one learns in joy. g
Four tefillos, four meals
This leads the Mashgiach to the four tefillos. Avraham's Shacharis and Yitzchak's Mincha are obligations; Yaakov's Maariv was optional, but Jews accepted it like a vow, and it is the greatest. The fourth, Dovid HaMelech's midnight tefillah, as in Tehillim 119:62, was never made an obligation and only tzaddikim keep it. h
The Shabbos meals match: the first two are obligations, shalosh seudos is Yaakov's, and melave malka is Dovid's. He adds that staying up Thursday night only to sleep through Shabbos defeats its purpose; it is better to be awake on Shabbos.
Shavuos night and serving with sense
Staying awake on Shavuos night, the Mashgiach explains, prepares for the morning. One who will doze through davening and Kerias HaTorah is like a chasan who ordered everything, then went to sleep at the chuppah. Since the generations have weakened, Mishlei 13:16 applies: serve with sense, and on Shabbos rise early, learn and daven with strength. j
Light after darkness
Returning to the Tanya, the Mashgiach explains with Koheles 2:13 that light which follows darkness is valued more, like dawn after a night awake, and joy after sadness is greater. On Devarim 28:47 he cites the Arizal: the joy of serving Hashem must exceed all that this world offers. Those who do not rise at chatzos can make a reckoning at Krias Shema before sleep, erev Shabbos or erev Rosh Chodesh. k,l
Hidden chassadim clothed in suffering
Rejoicing in suffering is a level reached through years of work. The first letters of Hashem's name, Yud-Heh, are the hidden worlds, and their greater chassadim come down covered in suffering, as the hidden first letters of 'mitzvah' show. Hence Tehillim 94:12 praises the man chastised by Yud-Heh, and Shabbos 88b praises those who rejoice in suffering. o,p
Tzaddikim who rejoiced in suffering
Great tzaddikim rejoiced in suffering, the Mashgiach says, and some took it on themselves, like Rav Eliyahu, who put his hand into fire for atonement and later had a white hand. Being bound to Hashem is better than life, as Tehillim 63:4 says, and Hashem dwells in the hidden, as in Tehillim 91:1. In worldly troubles, one should bind himself to Hashem. q,r
Sadness in business is the yetzer
Simpler people, the Mashgiach says, should meet such troubles with bitachon. Then he brings the Tanya: even sadness over spiritual matters, if it falls on a businessman during his work, is a trick of the yetzer. If the yetzer wants a person to forget Hashem, why would it remind him of his failings? Because sadness leads to cravings, as seen in depressed people who overeat. s
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
- c Mishlei 14:23 text index In the write-up: 7:21
- e Tehillim 51:19 text index In the write-up: 7:21
- f Tehillim 51:10 text index In the write-up: 7:21
- g Tehillim 51:14 text index In the write-up: 11:21
- h Tehillim 119:62 text index In the write-up: 14:43
- j Mishlei 13:16 text index In the write-up: 20:45
- k Koheles 2:13 text index In the write-up: 24:46
- o Tehillim 94:12 text index In the write-up: 29:46
- q Tehillim 63:4 text index In the write-up: 34:39
- r Tehillim 91:1 text index In the write-up: 34:39
Talmud Bavli
Zohar and Kabbalah
Acharonim and Chassidus
- a apparently Tanya ch. 26 index In the write-up: 0:20
- b apparently Tanya ch. 26 index In the write-up: 4:15
- d apparently Tanya ch. 26 index In the write-up: 7:21
- m apparently Tanya ch. 26 index In the write-up: 28:09
- s apparently Tanya ch. 26 index In the write-up: 38:28
- t apparently Tanya ch. 26 index In the write-up: 43:12
Key points
- 0:44 Like a sluggish wrestler who loses to a weaker opponent, a person in sadness and heaviness cannot overcome the yetzer hara.
- 2:38 Sadness and laziness come from the same element of earth; a sad person lacks the joy of life and moves slowly, while zerizus comes from joy.
- 7:21 'In every sadness there is an advantage': the joy that comes after a true broken heart at a set time is greater, like light that comes after darkness.
- 11:50 Regret over one's avodah belongs only at a fixed time, such as after Tikkun Chatzos or at Krias Shema before sleep, not all day.
- 30:55 Suffering that comes from the hidden world is a greater kindness, and great tzaddikim rejoiced in suffering because it bound them to Hashem.
- 40:34 Sadness about one's spiritual standing that falls on a person in the middle of business or davening comes from the yetzer hara, which uses it to lead him to cravings.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 8:03 If sadness is bad, how can the verse say that every sadness has an advantage?
Answer: 8:29 The advantage is the joy that follows a true broken heart; it is greater, like light after darkness.
-
Question: 13:10 Why did the Arizal order Tehillim 51 to be said after Tikkun Chatzos?
Answer: 14:13 So that after mourning, the learning that follows would be in the joy that comes after sadness.
-
Question: 4:57 Why do people sleep late?
Answer: 5:05 They are escaping life because they expect nothing from the new day; it is a sign of sadness.
-
Question: 21:42 What does one gain from staying up Shavuos night if he dozes through davening and Kerias HaTorah?
Answer: 20:45 Nothing; the purpose is the morning, so it is like a chasan who sleeps at his own chuppah.
-
Question: 42:49 If the yetzer hara wants a person to forget Hashem, why would it bring sadness about avodas Hashem in the middle of business?
Answer: 41:15 Because sadness leads to cravings, which is what the yetzer is after.
Stories
-
34:45 Rav Eliyahu's white hand
The Mashgiach tells of a Rav named Eliyahu who had a white hand. He had once put his hand into fire, wanting to burn it as an atonement for something he had done as a small child. Afterward he was given a new, white hand, and he took suffering upon himself because through it he was bound to Hashem.
-
22:25 The chasan who slept at his wedding
As a mashal for one who stays up Shavuos night and then sleeps through the morning, the Mashgiach describes a chasan who prepared for his wedding, ordering whiskey, a photographer and every good thing. When it came time for the chuppah, he said he was very tired and went to sleep. The Mashgiach says this makes no sense.
Insights
- 2:38 Sadness and laziness share one root in the heaviest element, earth, which is why a depressed person is also a slow one.
- 4:57 Sleeping late is a sign of sadness, a flight from life by someone who expects nothing of the new day; the same person rises early on a day he looks forward to.
- 13:10 The Arizal placed Tehillim 51 after Tikkun Chatzos so that the mourning over one's own inner Beis HaMikdash would lead straight into learning with the joy that follows sadness.
- 14:43 The four tefillos parallel the four Shabbos meals: the first two are obligations, Yaakov's third is a choice and the greatest, and Dovid HaMelech's fourth is kept only by the few.
- 30:18 Suffering comes from the hidden letters Yud-Heh of Hashem's name, so it is a greater kindness than revealed blessing, just as the first letters of 'mitzvah' are hidden by the at-bash exchange.
- 41:15 The proof that spiritual sadness during business is from the yetzer is that the yetzer otherwise wants a person to forget Hashem; it sends such sadness only to drag him into cravings.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 11:50 The Mashgiach says one should set a specific time, such as chatzos, Krias Shema before sleep, erev Shabbos or erev Rosh Chodesh, to let in some sadness and make a reckoning, and not be sad the rest of the day.
- 40:17 The Mashgiach says that when sadness about one's avodah falls on a person in the middle of business, he should know it is from the yetzer and push it away.
- 38:23 The Mashgiach says simpler people facing worldly troubles should strengthen themselves with bitachon that Hashem provides all they need.
- 20:10 The Mashgiach says one should rather be awake on Shabbos itself: rise early, learn before davening and daven with strength.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Dovid HaMelech, Nasan HaNavi, the Arizal, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), Yaakov Avinu, Yitzchak Avinu
Terms ארבע יסודות, את"ב"ש, זריזות, מלוה מלכה, סטרא אחרא, עלמא דאתגליא, עלמא דאתכסיא, עצבות, עצלות, תיקון חצות