חילוק בין עצבות ומרירות. כשמחשבות רעות באות - אז יש אפשרות לקיים מצוות ולא תתורו. שני מטעמים שהשכינה נהנות מהם. לחיים יא”צ.
Catalog entry: ספר התניא ב' כ"ז no. 13 Pocket Guide p. 48 Yiddish 43 min
Listen
About this shiur
On Tanya chapter 27, the Mashgiach explains that a bad thought pushed away is not a reason for sadness but a chance to fulfill 'velo sasuru', and that the beinoni's struggle with his yetzer gives Hashem a nachas ruach of its own.
The Mashgiach opens by distinguishing atzvus (dejection that makes a person withdraw and sleep) from merirus (bitterness that drives him to act), and two sources of atzvus: sins and worldly troubles. Turning to Tanya chapter 27, he explains that a person troubled by bad thoughts should not see them as a sign of distance from Hashem: pushing them out fulfills the mitzvah of 'velo sasuru', which speaks to beinonim, not tzaddikim. With the Bnei Yissaschar he shows that the sin lies only in letting the thought stay. In a long digression he explains that the Torah speaks to every Jew on his level, with examples of pride, anger, 'vachai bahem' and Korach. He then brings the Zohar on the nachas ruach when the sitra achra is subdued, the two kinds of 'matamim', 'leyom ra'ah', iskafya in permitted things such as delaying a meal, and 'kadesh atzmecha'. He closes with a lechayim for the yahrzeit of Rabbi Naftali of Ropshitz and two stories about him.
Topics: Simcha and Lowliness (Tanya ch. 26-34) · The Yetzer Hara and Nisyonos · Tzaddik, Beinoni and Rasha (Tanya ch. 9-17)
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Atzvus versus merirus listed in the guide
The Mashgiach defines atzvus as dejection that makes a person sleep and avoid reality, and merirus as bitterness that drives him to act. He distinguishes atzvus over sins from atzvus over worldly troubles such as business, children and health.
-
3:42 Bad thoughts as a chance for a mitzvah listed in the guide
Reading Tanya chapter 27, the Mashgiach explains that a person who is pained by bad thoughts, thinking they show he is far from Hashem, is mistaken: when he pushes them away he fulfills 'velo sasuru acharei levavchem'. He asks whether one should then want such thoughts, and begins to answer that the pasuk does not speak to tzaddikim.
-
8:10 The beinoni's mitzvah of driving thoughts out listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that 'velo sasuru' speaks to beinonim, each with his own nisyonos, and brings Chazal that one who refrains from a sin that came his way is rewarded as for a mitzvah. With the Bnei Yissaschar he shows the sin is only in keeping the thought, calls distress over such thoughts a form of gasus haruach, and says pushing them out is a person's avodah.
-
14:23 The Torah speaks to each Jew on his level listed in the guide
Pausing to explain the Tanya's claim that the pasuk does not speak to tzaddikim, the Mashgiach says every word of the Torah concerns every Jew: pshat binds everyone, while great tzaddikim keep the Torah on deeper levels. He illustrates with pride and anger, 'vachai bahem', Korach's subtle jealousy, and Moshe's sin at Mei Merivah.
-
23:55 Subduing the sitra achra raises Hashem's glory listed in the guide
Back to the Tanya, the Mashgiach gives the example of a person in the street who remembers not to look and does not look: his mitzvah rises above and the sitra achra is knocked down. He brings the Zohar on the great nachas ruach when the sitra achra is subdued, and says a person plagued all his life by such thoughts should not be broken, since this may be why his soul came down.
-
28:13 Why a beinoni is created, and two kinds of nachas listed in the guide
The Mashgiach recalls the question from Tanya chapter 1 on free choice and explains the answer here: a beinoni is created to fight the sitra achra without nullifying it, and his war brings a second kind of nachas ruach beside that of tzaddikim. He connects this to the plural 'matamim' of Yitzchak and Rivkah.
-
31:44 Sweet and sharp delicacies; iskafya in permitted things listed in the guide
The Mashgiach compares the two kinds of nachas ruach to sweet dishes and sharp ones like horseradish made tasty with fish. He reads 'vegam rasha leyom ra'ah' as making day out of the bad, and explains that iskafya applies even in permitted things, such as delaying a meal for a while when one is hungry.
-
36:35 A little sanctity below, much from above listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Gemara on the hours when people and talmidei chachamim eat, explaining that the talmid chacham waited to subdue his yetzer, and extends this to holding back from idle talk. He explains that even a little iskafya draws great kedushah from above, citing 'adam mekadesh atzmo me'at' and 'kadesh atzmecha bemutar lach', and the Tanya that true kedushah comes only through subduing the sitra achra.
-
40:02 Lechayim for the Ropshitzer's yahrzeit Story listed in the guide
The Mashgiach calls for a lechayim for the yahrzeit of Rabbi Naftali of Ropshitz and tells of him: a man who wore sackcloth with his shirt open so it would be seen, of whom the Ropshitzer said the Satan had caught him in the sack, and the Ropshitzer's own last words about the yetzer hara.
The shiur, written up
Atzvus versus merirus
The Mashgiach distinguishes atzvus from merirus. Atzvus is dejection: a person feels beaten down, goes to sleep and does not want to face the world. Merirus is bitterness that sees how far one is and sets out, with energy, to act; atzvus, he says, must not be. He then separates atzvus over sins, feeling far from Hashem, from atzvus over worldly troubles such as business, children and health.
Bad thoughts as a chance for a mitzvah
Tanya chapter 27 addresses a person pained by bad thoughts that fall into his mind while he is busy with business, who takes them as a sign that he is far from Hashem. People err, the Mashgiach says: it is the opposite. Pushing the thought away fulfills 'velo sasuru acharei levavchem', one of the great mitzvos, and he should rejoice in his portion. Had the thought not come, he would not have done this mitzvah. b,c
The beinoni's mitzvah of driving thoughts out
The pasuk, the Mashgiach explains, does not speak to tzaddikim, whose thoughts are always pure, but to beinonim: in the Tanya's terms, one who never sins yet still has a yetzer hara. Each has his own nisyonos, some in emunah, some in other desires. Chazal say that one who refrains from a sin that came his way is rewarded as for a mitzvah. c,d
The Torah speaks to each Jew on his level
The Mashgiach pauses to explain why the pasuk is said not to address tzaddikim. Every word of the Torah concerns every Jew. Pshat, the lowest level, binds everyone, while great tzaddikim keep the Torah in its inner depths too. So the Gemara in Sotah likens the proud to one who serves avodah zarah: for a great tzaddik even anger is truly like avodah zarah, though a simple Jew who becomes angry is not judged as an idolater. f
Likewise, 'vachai bahem' permits desecrating Shabbos for a sick child, yet the Mashgiach brings from the Shulchan Aruch that a great tzaddik may give up his life even over other aveiros. The answer given is that for a tzaddik who cannot be separated from Torah, 'life' means a spiritual life. g,h
Subduing the sitra achra raises Hashem's glory
Returning to the Tanya, the Mashgiach gives the example of a man in the street who remembers he must not look, and does not: his mitzvah rises above and the sitra achra is knocked down. The Zohar describes the great nachas ruach when the sitra achra is subdued. So one plagued all his life by such thoughts should not be broken; perhaps this tikkun is why he came down. j
Why a beinoni is created
The Mashgiach recalls the question in the first perek of Tanya: how can tzaddikim and reshaim be created, if man has free choice? The answer: the beinoni, created as such, fights the sitra achra without nullifying it, and this brings a second kind of nachas ruach. Hence 'matamim' (delicacies) is in the plural. k,l
Sweet and sharp delicacies
The Mashgiach compares the two kinds of nachas to sweet dishes and sharp ones, like horseradish made tasty with fish. He reads 'vegam rasha leyom ra'ah' as making day out of the bad. Iskafya (breaking one's desire) applies even to permitted things: a hungry person can decide to eat a little later, or pause in the middle of a meal, privately between himself and Hashem. m
A little sanctity below, much from above
The Gemara in Shabbos says a talmid chacham eats later than others; the Mashgiach explains that he waited in order to subdue his yetzer. Even a little such holiness below, as 'adam mekadesh atzmo me'at' and 'kadesh atzmecha bemutar lach' teach, draws great kedushah from above, and with it learning and davening with more fervor. n,o,p
Lechayim for the Ropshitzer's yahrzeit
The Mashgiach calls for a lechayim for the yahrzeit of Rabbi Naftali of Ropshitz. In Ropshitz a man wore sackcloth with his shirt left open so it would be seen; the Ropshitzer said the Satan had caught him in the sack. At his own passing the Ropshitzer snapped his fingers, saying the yetzer hara had all his life thought he belonged to it.
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Zohar and Kabbalah
Acharonim and Chassidus
- a apparently Tanya ch. 26 3:48 index
- b apparently Tanya ch. 27 index In the write-up: 3:48
- e Bnei Yissaschar (place not identified) index In the write-up: 11:35
- h Shulchan Aruch (place not identified) index In the write-up: 19:19
- i Ohr HaChaim (place not identified) index In the write-up: 21:29
- k apparently Tanya ch. 1 index In the write-up: 28:17
Key points
- 0:39 Atzvus is dejection that makes a person withdraw from life, while merirus is bitterness that pushes him to act; the Mashgiach says atzvus must be avoided.
- 5:15 A bad thought that enters a person's mind is no sign of distance from Hashem; pushing it out fulfills the mitzvah of 'velo sasuru', and he should rejoice in it.
- 11:35 The sin is not that the thought came, but letting it stay and following it; the mitzvah is to drive it out.
- 26:35 When a beinoni subdues the sitra achra, Hashem has a great nachas ruach, a different kind from the nachas of tzaddikim who nullify it entirely.
- 34:41 Iskafya applies even in permitted things, such as holding back from eating for a while when one is hungry, and a little sanctification below brings great kedushah from above.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 4:18 Should a person be saddened when bad thoughts enter his mind during his business?
Answer: 5:15 No; he should rejoice, since by pushing them away he fulfills 'velo sasuru'.
-
Question: 8:58 How can the pasuk 'velo sasuru' address tzaddikim, who have no such thoughts at all?
Answer: 9:17 It speaks to beinonim, each of whom has his own nisyonos.
-
Question: 11:35 Where is the sin, if the thought simply came into his head uninvited?
Answer: 11:50 Following the Bnei Yissaschar, the sin is only when he lets it stay and does not drive it out.
-
Question: 29:26 If a beinoni was created a beinoni and cannot nullify the sitra achra, what is the point of his lifelong war?
Answer: 29:38 There are two kinds of nachas ruach above, and subduing the sitra achra while it is still strong brings its own nachas.
-
Question: 19:42 Given 'vachai bahem', how may a great tzaddik give up his life even for other aveiros?
Answer: 20:09 Each Jew has his own pshat in the Torah; for a tzaddik who cannot be separated from Torah, 'life' means a spiritual life.
Stories
-
42:14 The man in sackcloth
In Ropshitz there was a Jew who wore sackcloth as a self-affliction, and left his shirt a little open so that people would see he was wearing a sack. The Ropshitzer said of him that the Satan had caught him in the sack.
In the story: Rabbi Naftali of Ropshitz (the Zera Kodesh)
-
42:53 The Ropshitzer's last words
The Ropshitzer asked that no titles be written on his matzeivah. When he passed away he snapped his fingers and said that all his life the yetzer hara had thought he belonged to it.
In the story: Rabbi Naftali of Ropshitz (the Zera Kodesh)
Insights
- 6:44 The very fact that a bad thought comes is what gives a beinoni the chance to fulfill 'velo sasuru'; had it not come, he would not have done the mitzvah.
- 12:44 Being shaken by bad thoughts comes from hidden gasus haruach: the person imagines he is a tzaddik to whom such thoughts should not occur, when even the Tanya's beinoni is a lofty level.
- 16:23 The same mitzvah binds every Jew by its pshat, yet for a great tzaddik it reaches further: for him anger is truly like avodah zarah, and 'vachai bahem' means a spiritual life.
- 21:29 Korach was a very great man, and his jealousy of Moshe Rabbeinu was so subtle that for ordinary people it would be a mitzvah.
- 31:17 The plural 'matamim' points to two kinds of nachas: the sweet dish of tzaddikim who nullify evil, and the sharp dish, like horseradish made tasty, of beinonim who subdue it.
- 33:34 'Vegam rasha leyom ra'ah' is read not as the wicked being made for a day of punishment, but as a person making day out of the bad, turning darkness into light.
- 27:32 A person's lifelong struggle with a particular kind of thought may be the very tikkun for which his soul came down into this gilgul.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 11:57 The Mashgiach says that when a bad thought comes one should not keep thinking about it but push it out at once, as with a broom.
- 5:15 The Mashgiach says that a person who fulfills 'velo sasuru' should rejoice as with any mitzvah, rather than fall into atzvus.
- 34:53 The Mashgiach suggests breaking one's desire even in permitted things, such as waiting a little before eating when hungry or holding back from idle talk.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Korach, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbi Naftali of Ropshitz (the Zera Kodesh), Rivka Imeinu, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh, Yitzchak Avinu
Terms אתכפיא, בינוני, היסח הדעת, ולא תתורו, יצר הרע, מטעמים, מרירות, נחת רוח, סטרא אחרא, עצבות