תפילה היא מלחמה גדולה' זוכים לבא בהיכלות התיבות ע”י שמחה ויגיעה. מלחמת הגוף והנשמה כל ימי חייו. טעם שהמחשבות רעות בואת דוקא כשעוסקים בעבודת ה'. כלל גדול בעבודת ה' - “אין עוד מלבדו”. לחיים יא”צ ר' שלומקע זווילער זצוקללה”ה.
Catalog entry: ספר התניא ב' כ”ח no. 14 Pocket Guide p. 48 Yiddish 41 min
Listen
About this shiur
On Tanya chapter 28, the Mashgiach explains that foreign thoughts during davening are part of the lifelong war between the two souls, and that the way to win is to dismiss them as nothing, with joy and the great rule 'ein od milvado'.
The Mashgiach opens Tanya chapter 28 by calling davening a great war: each word of tefillah is a heichal (chamber) above, and a foreign thought is a sign that one is being kept out of it, much as the cherubim guarded Gan Eden. The Tanya says not to sink into sadness but to push in. He explains that a thought is a complete spiritual entity, so a tzaddik can elevate foreign thoughts that come to him from others, but a person whose thoughts are his own must not try. Rather he should strengthen himself with joy, knowing the thought comes from the klipah fighting the G-dly soul; it attacks precisely when one strengthens himself in avodah. Because a person has two souls, such thoughts do not show that his davening is worthless. The answer is bittul: treating them as nothing, by the great rule 'ein od milvado'. He closes with the yahrzeit of Reb Shlomke of Zvil and stories about him.
Topics: Kavanah in Davening · Simcha and Lowliness (Tanya ch. 26-34)
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Davening as a war for the heichalos listed in the guide
The Mashgiach opens Tanya chapter 28 and explains that each word of davening is a heichal; angels keep a person out with foreign thoughts, like the cherubim at Gan Eden. The Tanya says not to be sad but to push one's way in, as chassidim used to.
-
4:28 Elevating thoughts: only for tzaddikim listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that every thought is a complete spiritual entity, sometimes a soul seeking a tikkun, which a tzaddik elevates to love or fear of Hashem. The Tanya warns that this is only for tzaddikim, whose foreign thoughts are not their own; someone whose thoughts are his own cannot elevate them.
-
8:56 No sadness: the klipah's war listed in the guide
The Mashgiach says a person must not despair and cry out over his thoughts, but strengthen himself with joy in davening. The thought comes from the klipah in the left chamber of the heart, which wages a lifelong war with the G-dly soul, like two wrestlers.
-
12:48 Why the thoughts come during avodah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach asks why bad thoughts come precisely when a person davens or resolves to improve, and answers that when the side of holiness strengthens itself, the other side fights back harder. He rejects the conclusion that such thoughts prove one is worthless.
-
16:05 Two souls, and the parable of the distracter listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that if a person had only one soul, a thought during davening would show something is wrong; but since he has two, the animal soul's thoughts say nothing about the davening. He brings the Tanya's parable of one who speaks with a friend while a wicked man stands opposite trying to distract him.
-
19:32 Bittul: 'you are nothing' listed in the guide
The Mashgiach teaches that the way to deal with foreign thoughts is to nullify them, treating them as utterly nothing, like something dead. He tells stories of tzaddikim on this theme.
-
25:41 The great rule: ein od milvado listed in the guide
The Mashgiach calls 'ein od milvado' a great rule in avodas Hashem: one who remembers that everything besides Hashem is nothing can win all his battles. One does not enter into conversation with the distracter, but strengthens himself in his kavanah.
-
29:57 The fly, and asking for mercy listed in the guide
After a remark about the end of the Sefirah period, the Mashgiach brings that one of the yetzer hara's names is a fly, which keeps coming back however often it is chased away. When a thought will not leave, the Tanya's advice is to pour out one's heart to Hashem and ask for mercy on the G-dly soul.
-
34:46 Yahrzeit of Reb Shlomke of Zvil Story listed in the guide
The Mashgiach marks the yahrzeit of Reb Shlomke of Zvil and tells how he said the gates of teshuvah would open before Moshiach, and how at the Kosel he pointed out houses that would be torn down, as happened in the Six Day War. He closes with l'chaim and wishes for yeshuos for Klal Yisroel.
The shiur, written up
Davening as a war for the heichalos
Opening Tanya chapter 28, the Mashgiach calls davening a great war. As the Ba'al Shem Tov teaches, each word of davening is a heichal, a chamber above; one who davens enters these chambers and makes tikkunim there. Often, however, the angels appointed over a heichal do not want to let him in, and they send him foreign thoughts, much as the cherubim were stationed to guard Gan Eden. a,b
Elevating thoughts: only for tzaddikim
The Mashgiach explains that every thought is a complete spiritual entity; it can even be a soul that needs a tikkun. A tzaddik raises such a thought: from a thought of love he makes love of Hashem, from a thought of fear, fear of Hashem.
No sadness: the klipah's war
A person may cry out, 'Why do such thoughts come to me?' The Mashgiach says he must not fall into sadness, but strengthen himself in davening with joy.
Why the thoughts come during avodah
The Mashgiach asks why such thoughts come precisely when a person davens, or resolves to improve in some area. He answers that when the side of holiness strengthens itself, the other side refuses to let go and fights harder. It is a mistake, then, to conclude from such a thought that one is worthless.
Two souls
The Mashgiach reads the Tanya: if a person had only one soul, the soul that davens would be the one that thinks, and a foreign thought would show that something is wrong. But since he has two souls, the bad thought says nothing about his davening. The Tanya compares this to one speaking with a friend while a wicked man stands opposite, talking to distract him. f,g
Bittul: 'you are nothing'
The way to treat such thoughts, the Mashgiach teaches, is to nullify them: to regard them as utterly nothing, like something dead. He illustrates this with stories of tzaddikim, among them one who declared to such forces that they are nothing.
The great rule: ein od milvado
The Mashgiach calls this a great rule in avodas Hashem: 'ein od milvado', there is nothing besides Hashem, and everything else is nothing. One who remembers this rule can win all the wars waged against him, for his opponents are nothing.
So one does not feel he must enter into conversation with the distracter. He nullifies the thought and strengthens himself in his kavanah.
The fly, and asking for mercy
After noting that these are the last days of Sefirah, the Mashgiach brings that one of the yetzer hara's names is a fly: chase it away and it comes right back, again and again. So too a thought can be very hard to push away.
Yahrzeit of Reb Shlomke of Zvil
The Mashgiach marks the yahrzeit of Reb Shlomke of Zvil. Reb Shlomke said that now, before Moshiach, the gates of teshuvah are opening. People wondered how teshuvah could come in such a world, yet a movement of teshuvah did begin, and today there are tens of thousands of baalei teshuvah, more and more.
When Reb Shlomke came to Yerushalayim, no one knew who he was for years; he sat at the Kosel among the poor. At the Kosel, then narrow and hemmed in by Arab houses, he pointed out which houses would be torn down to leave a wide place for Jews to daven. In the Six Day War exactly those houses were demolished, and a large plaza opened before the Kosel.
He closes with l'chaim and wishes that Klal Yisroel see great yeshuos.
Sources
Torah
Acharonim and Chassidus
- a Tanya ch. 28 text index In the write-up: 0:51, 3:01
- c Tanya ch. 28 text index In the write-up: 6:56
- d Tanya ch. 28 text index In the write-up: 10:57
- e Tanya (place not identified) index In the write-up: 10:57
- f Tanya ch. 28 text index In the write-up: 16:10
- g Tanya ch. 28 text index In the write-up: 16:10
- h Tanya ch. 28 text index In the write-up: 31:57
Key points
- 0:51 Each word of davening is a heichal above; a foreign thought during tefillah means one is being held back from entering it.
- 6:56 Elevating foreign thoughts is only for tzaddikim, whose foreign thoughts come from others; a person whose thoughts are his own must not engage with them.
- 10:08 One must not fall into sadness over such thoughts, but strengthen himself all the more in davening with joy.
- 10:57 The foreign thought comes from the klipah fighting the G-dly soul in the beinoni, a lifelong war in which each side strengthens itself when the other does.
- 16:25 Because a person has two souls, foreign thoughts in davening are not a sign that his davening is worthless.
- 25:41 The way to deal with them is bittul: to treat them as nothing, by the great rule 'ein od milvado', that besides Hashem everything is nothing.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 8:12 Why may a tzaddik elevate foreign thoughts, while an ordinary person may not?
Answer: 8:32 A tzaddik's foreign thoughts come from others, souls seeking a tikkun; an ordinary person's thoughts are his own, and one who has not yet elevated himself cannot elevate them.
-
Question: 12:48 Why do bad thoughts come precisely when a person davens or works on himself?
Answer: 12:08 Because it is a war: when the side of holiness strengthens itself, the klipah strengthens itself to resist, as wrestlers do.
-
Question: 14:42 Do foreign thoughts during davening show that something is wrong with the person's davening?
Answer: 16:25 No. That would be so if he had one soul; since he has two, the thoughts come from the animal soul and do not reflect on the davening.
Stories
-
35:44 Reb Shlomke and the gates of teshuvah
Reb Shlomke of Zvil said that now, before Moshiach, the gates of teshuvah are opening. When this was repeated, people wondered how teshuvah could come in such a world. The Mashgiach notes that afterwards a movement of teshuvah did begin, and today there are tens of thousands of baalei teshuvah, more and more.
In the story: Reb Shlomke of Zvhil
-
37:14 The houses by the Kosel
Reb Shlomke came to Yerushalayim and for some years no one knew who he was; he sat at the Kosel among the poor. Standing at the Kosel, which was then narrow and hemmed in by Arab houses, he pointed out which houses would be torn down so that a wide place would open where Jews could daven. In the Six Day War, the Mashgiach relates, exactly those houses were demolished and a large plaza opened in front of the Kosel.
In the story: Reb Shlomke of Zvhil
Insights
- 1:26 The Mashgiach compares the angels who keep a person out of a heichal of tefillah with foreign thoughts to the cherubim and flaming sword that guard Gan Eden.
- 4:31 A thought is not empty: it is a complete spiritual entity, possibly a soul that needs a tikkun, and that is why a tzaddik can raise it.
- 13:25 The very fact that bad thoughts come exactly when a person strengthens himself in avodah shows that a real battle is under way, not that the avodah is worthless.
- 16:25 If a person had only one soul, a foreign thought would show that his davening is flawed; since he has two, the thought belongs to the other soul and says nothing about his davening.
- 25:41 The Mashgiach ties the dismissal of foreign thoughts to 'ein od milvado': the same awareness that nothing exists besides Hashem is what lets a person treat the thoughts as nothing.
- 32:12 The yetzer hara is called a fly because, like a fly, it keeps coming back no matter how often it is driven away.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 8:32 The Mashgiach says one who is not a tzaddik should not try to elevate his foreign thoughts, but put them out of mind.
- 10:08 He says one must not become depressed over foreign thoughts, but strengthen oneself in davening with joy.
- 25:41 He teaches to nullify such thoughts and regard them as nothing, remembering that there is nothing besides Hashem.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Rabbi Yechiel Michel of Zlotchov (the Zlotchover Maggid), Reb Shlomke of Zvhil, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Baal Shem Tov
Terms ביטול, בינוני, היכל, חלל השמאלי, כותל המערבי, כרובים, מחשבות זרות, נפש האלקית, נפש הבהמית, עצבות