האור של מגילת אסתר יותר נעלה מאור של תורת משה (חתם סופר)

Catalog entry: זמנים סעודת פורים קטן no. ⁨3⁩ Pocket Guide p. 22 תשס"ה (2004–05) Yiddish 35 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 35 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Mashgiach's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Mashgiach explains that the Megillah has two faces, the level of Kesuvim all year and on Purim a light higher even than Toras Moshe, and that through it Klal Yisroel, even in its lowest state, is revealed as Hashem's kallah.

The Mashgiach opens with the Gemara that a Megillah written among the other books of Kesuvim is not valid, and with Esther's place among the prophetesses. He explains that certain parts of Torah have two faces: the Aseres HaDibros read with the upper or lower cantillation, and the song of David in Navi and in Tehillim. So too the Megillah: all year it is Kesuvim, but on Purim a higher world comes down and, as the Chasam Sofer writes, its light is greater than that of Toras Moshe. For this Esther had to be a prophetess. He then explains that Purim is for those who have fallen far: 'lechalosam' in the days of Haman means 'to His kallah', like a king who goes to his bride in a disgraceful place. 'Al mikra megillah' equals 'chosson v'kallah'. He applies this to Purim Katan, to the small avodah of today, and ends with joy and brachos for the chosson and kallah.

Topics: Megillas Esther · Hashem's Love for Klal Yisroel · Purim

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 A Megillah among the Kesuvim; Esther the prophetess

    The Mashgiach opens with the Gemara that a Megillah written among the other books of Kesuvim is not valid, and asks how this fits the bracha 'al mikra megillah'. He brings the Gemara's count of prophets and prophetesses, Rashi on why Daniel is not counted, and Esther's place among the prophetesses, and mentions how Haman's decree bound all Jews together.

  2. 4:59 Two faces in Torah; the Chasam Sofer on the Megillah listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that the Aseres HaDibros read in public with the upper cantillation are on a higher level than when read alone, and that the song of David stands higher in Navi than in Tehillim. He brings the Yerushalmi that the Megillah will remain when other books are annulled, and the Chasam Sofer that the Megillah's greatness is higher than the light of Toras Moshe.

  3. 11:12 The Megillah's new light on Purim listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that the Megillah is Kesuvim all year but on Purim receives a new light, which is why one written among the Kesuvim is invalid. To write it above the Kesuvim, Esther had to be a prophetess; he connects 'vatilbash Esther malchus' and the inner court of the king to the world where all Jews are bound together at the root of their souls.

  4. 16:22 Purim for the fallen; 'lechalosam' as His kallah

    The Mashgiach says Purim is for those who have fallen far, and that the hidden love of Hashem, which many waters cannot extinguish, is revealed through the Megillah. He reads the Gemara's 'lechalosam' in the days of Haman as 'to His kallah', with a mashal of a king who goes to his bride in a disgraceful place to bring her back.

  5. 22:02 Esther cries out; 'al mikra megillah' as chosson v'kallah

    The Mashgiach describes Esther crying out to Hashem from the lowest place, and says the joy of Purim is that Jews know that in whatever state they are, even outside the camp, they are Hashem's kallah. Therefore the bracha 'al mikra megillah' equals 'chosson v'kallah' in gematria.

  6. 26:12 Purim Katan and the heavenly yeshiva

    The Mashgiach explains that although the Megillah is read in the second Adar, the joy belongs to Purim Katan too, and that in Heaven there is a yeshiva that follows Rabbi Eliezer b'Rabbi Yosi, where the Megillah is read today. He adds that on Purim a Jew may enter the heichal of whichever tanna he wishes, and that a small avodah of today, such as negel vasser, is precious in Heaven.

  7. 30:04 Joy of chosson and kallah; brachos

    The Mashgiach says Jews gather to strengthen the emunah that they are Hashem's kallah, connects 'vaye'ehav hamelech es Esther' to the joy of chosson and kallah, and blesses the chosson, kallah and families. He closes with 'tov lev mishteh tamid' and the hope that the joy may help bring Moshiach.

The shiur, written up

A Megillah among the Kesuvim; Esther the prophetess

0:28

The Mashgiach opens with the Gemara that a Megillah written together with the other books of Kesuvim is not valid; it must stand on its own. He asks how this fits with the bracha 'al mikra megillah', which treats the reading as more than ordinary learning. a

2:06

He brings the Gemara's list of the prophets and prophetesses of Israel, with Esther among them, and Rashi's explanation that Daniel is not counted, since he was not a prophet and his book is among the Kesuvim. b,c

Two faces in Torah; the Chasam Sofer

6:28

The Mashgiach explains that certain parts of Torah have two faces. The Aseres HaDibros read in public with the upper cantillation are on a very high level, while read alone with the lower cantillation they are on a lower one. Likewise the song of David appears in Navi and again, with small changes, in Tehillim, and in Navi it is on a higher level. f

7:24

He brings the Yerushalmi that the Megillah will remain even when other books are annulled, and the Chasam Sofer, who writes that the greatness of the Megillah is higher than the light of Toras Moshe, and that this is why it will remain. d,g

The Megillah's new light on Purim

11:15

From here the Mashgiach answers the opening question. The Megillah has two faces: all year it is Kesuvim, but on Purim a higher world comes down into it, a new light, and it is raised far above the level of Kesuvim. Written among the Kesuvim, it cannot receive this light.

12:58

For this reason, he says, the Megillah was written with ruach hakodesh, and Esther had to be one of the seven prophetesses. He connects 'vatilbash Esther malchus' and her standing in the king's inner court to the high world where all Jews are bound together at the root of their souls. h,i

Purim for the fallen; 'lechalosam'

16:26

The Mashgiach says Purim is for those who have fallen far. In every Jew there is a hidden love for Hashem that, as the passuk says, many waters cannot extinguish, and the reading of the Megillah brings it into the open, so that the Jews accept it with joy. j

19:15

He brings the Gemara that 'lechalosam' refers to the days of Haman and reads it as 'to His kallah'. He gives a mashal of a king whose bride is in a disgraceful place, and the king goes to her there to bring her back. k

'Al mikra megillah' as chosson v'kallah

22:40

The Mashgiach describes Esther crying out to Hashem from the lowest place. The joy of Purim, he says, is that Jews should know that in whatever state they find themselves, even outside the camp, they are Hashem's kallah. Therefore the bracha 'al mikra megillah' equals 'chosson v'kallah' in gematria.

Purim Katan and the heavenly yeshiva

26:22

Turning to Purim Katan, the Mashgiach explains that although the Megillah is read in the second Adar, the joy belongs here too. In Heaven there is a yeshiva that follows Rabbi Eliezer b'Rabbi Yosi, where the Megillah is read today. Citing the Klausenburger Rebbe, he says that on Purim a Jew can enter the heichal of whichever tanna he wishes. l

29:21

He adds that a small avodah of today, such as washing negel vasser, may bring Hashem more nachas than the great mesiras nefesh of earlier generations.

Joy of chosson and kallah

30:20

The Mashgiach says Jews gather to strengthen their emunah that they are Hashem's kallah, and connects 'vaye'ehav hamelech es Esther' to the joy of chosson and kallah. He blesses the chosson, the kallah and their families, and hopes this joy may help bring Moshiach. m

34:15

He closes with 'tov lev mishteh tamid', saying that all the festivals are contained in Purim. n

Sources

Nevi'im

  1. f apparently II Shmuel 22; Tehillim 18 index In the write-up: 6:28

Kesuvim

  1. i Esther 5:1 text index In the write-up: 12:58
  2. j Shir HaShirim 8:7 text index In the write-up: 16:26
  3. m Esther 2:17 text index In the write-up: 30:20
  4. n Mishlei 15:15 text index In the write-up: 34:15

Talmud Bavli

  1. a Gemara Megillah (place not identified) index In the write-up: 0:28
  2. b Megillah 14a text index In the write-up: 2:06
  3. h apparently Megillah 7a index In the write-up: 12:58
  4. k Megillah 11a text index In the write-up: 19:15
  5. l apparently Megillah 6b index In the write-up: 26:22

Talmud Yerushalmi

  1. d apparently Yerushalmi Megillah 1:5 index In the write-up: 7:24

Rishonim

  1. c apparently Rashi on Megillah 14a index In the write-up: 2:06

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. e Tanya (place not identified) 8:59 index
  2. g Chasam Sofer (place not identified) index In the write-up: 7:24

Key points

  1. 0:28 A Megillah written among the other books of Kesuvim is not valid, because on Purim the Megillah rises above the level of Kesuvim.
  2. 6:28 Some parts of Torah have two faces, a higher and a lower level, such as the Aseres HaDibros with the upper and lower cantillation.
  3. 10:42 Citing the Chasam Sofer, the Mashgiach says the greatness of the Megillah on Purim is higher than the light of Toras Moshe.
  4. 16:26 Purim belongs to the Jews who have fallen far; even there they remain Hashem's kallah.
  5. 25:38 The words 'al mikra megillah' in the bracha equal 'chosson v'kallah' in gematria.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 0:28 Why is a Megillah written among the other books of Kesuvim not valid?

    Answer: 12:23 Because on Purim the Megillah receives a new light and rises above the level of Kesuvim; joined to the Kesuvim it stays on their level.

  2. Question: 19:27 What does 'lechalosam' in the days of Haman mean?

    Answer: 19:39 It is read as 'to His kallah': Hashem goes to Klal Yisroel, His bride, even in a lowly place, as a king goes to his bride to bring her back.

  3. Question: 2:49 Why is Daniel not counted among the prophets?

    Answer: 2:55 According to Rashi, Daniel was not a prophet; what he wrote is among the Kesuvim.

Insights

  1. 11:15 The Megillah has two faces: all year it is on the level of Kesuvim, and on Purim it receives a new light; this is why a Megillah written among the Kesuvim is invalid.
  2. 13:15 For the Megillah to be written above the level of Kesuvim, Esther had to be one of the seven prophetesses.
  3. 19:39 The Mashgiach reads 'lechalosam' in the days of Haman as 'to His kallah': like a king who goes to his bride in a disgraceful place, Hashem comes to Klal Yisroel even in its lowest state.
  4. 25:22 The bracha 'al mikra megillah' equals 'chosson v'kallah' in gematria, because the Megillah reveals Klal Yisroel as Hashem's kallah.
  5. 26:56 On Purim Katan the Megillah is read in the heavenly yeshiva that follows Rabbi Eliezer b'Rabbi Yosi, and on Purim a Jew can enter the heichal of whichever tanna he wishes.
  6. 29:21 A small avodah of a Jew today, such as washing negel vasser, may bring Hashem more nachas than the great mesiras nefesh of earlier generations.

What the Mashgiach says to take from it

  1. 24:10 The Mashgiach says the joy of Purim is that Jews should know that in whatever state they find themselves, they are Hashem's kallah.
  2. 28:31 The Mashgiach says Purim is a great day that must be used.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Daniel, Dovid HaMelech, Esther HaMalkah, Haman, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbi Eliezer ben Rabbi Yossi, Rashi, the Chasam Sofer, the Klausenburger Rebbe

Terms חתן וכלה, כנסת ישראל, מחוץ למחנה, עשרת הדברות, פורים קטן, רוח הקודש

Report an error on this page