סעודת "טוב להודות לה'"
Catalog entry: זמנים סעודת פורים קטן no. 4 Pocket Guide p. 22 תשמ"ט (1988–89) Yiddish 51 min
Listen
About this shiur
At a Purim Katan seudah the Mashgiach explains why the fourteenth of Adar I still calls for a commemoration of the miracle, and why Purim's high light needs to be repeated and strengthened, ending with 'Tov lehodos laShem', the good of praising Hashem.
The Mashgiach opens with the Mishnah that Adar I and Adar II differ only in Megillah reading and gifts to the poor, and the dispute whether feasting is required on Adar I, which the Rema settles with 'increase the meal a little'. With the Magen Avraham's rule on commemorating a miracle, he asks how such a commemoration could be pushed off entirely. He brings the Chasam Sofer, who says the Torah-level duty to commemorate a miracle is met in Adar I by refraining from eulogy and fasting, and questions it. He weighs zerizus against doing a mitzvah in its finest way, and explains 'igeres haPurim hashenis'. From Pharaoh's doubled dream and the Maharal he explains that Purim's light comes from so high that it must be repeated to stay in the world, and that a leap year needs two Purims. He closes with 'Tov lehodos laShem' and brachos.
Topics: Purim Katan and the Leap Year · Purim · Thanks and Praise to Hashem
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Feasting on Adar I and the Rema
The Mashgiach brings the Mishnah on Adar I and II and the dispute over feasting on Adar I, settled by the Rema. With the Magen Avraham's rule on commemorating a miracle, he asks how Adar I can be left empty, and explains the Rema's 'increase a little' as adding wine.
-
7:19 The Chasam Sofer and the Mashgiach's question
The Mashgiach brings a Chasam Sofer close to what he once said: commemorating a miracle is a Torah duty, fulfilled in Adar I by refraining from eulogy and fasting. He then asks how refraining can be a commemoration, when a positive act is needed.
-
11:47 Zerizus, mitzvah min hamuvchar and 'hashenis'
The Mashgiach suggests the dispute may follow Rav Nachman and Rava on Hallel, then weighs zerizus against a mitzvah in its finest form, with the Chacham Tzvi and the Terumas HaDeshen. He explains how zerizus applies to Purim and how 'igeres haPurim hashenis' refers to reading the Megillah a second time.
-
18:18 Purim's high light must be repeated
From a case of mistaken Kiddush the Mashgiach shows that Adar I holds some holiness of Purim. With Pharaoh's doubled dream and the Maharal he explains that Purim's light comes from so high that it must be strengthened by repetition, as in reading the Megillah twice and Esther's two feasts.
-
24:04 Two Purims, 'Tov lehodos' and brachos listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that the thirteenth month is a deeper darkness that needs a double Purim, and that the seudah is a commemoration and a preparation for the next Purim. He speaks on 'Tov lehodos laShem' and the taste of good davening, and closes with brachos for salvation and the final redemption.
The shiur, written up
Feasting on Adar I and the Rema
The Mashgiach opens with the Mishnah that Adar I and Adar II differ only in the reading of the Megillah and gifts to the poor, which implies that feasting and joy apply on the fourteenth of Adar I as well. Tosafos disagree, and the Rema rules that the custom is not to require it, yet one should increase the meal a little to satisfy the stringent, since 'a good heart is a constant feast'. a,b,c,v
He then brings the Magen Avraham, that a community or an individual may fix a day on which a miracle happened as a day of joy, a 'Purim'. The Megillah too was instituted because of a miracle, and the Gemara learns from Pesach, through a kal vachomer, that one must say Hallel for being saved from death to life. The Purim halachos of the Anshei Knesses HaGedolah can be moved to Adar II, but the Mashgiach asks how the Magen Avraham's general duty to commemorate a miracle can be pushed off entirely. d,e
On the view that does not follow Tosafos, Mordechai and Esther instituted some mitzvos even for Adar I; on Tosafos' view only the general commemoration remains. This, the Mashgiach explains, is the Rema's 'increase a little': the Purim seudah requires wine, while a plain commemoration does not, so to satisfy the stringent one drinks some wine. b,c,d
The Chasam Sofer and the Mashgiach's question
The Mashgiach relates that after he once said this, he was shown a gloss of the Chasam Sofer, printed in the Vilna Shas, close to his idea. Based on the Ramban at the end of Sefer HaMitzvos, the Chasam Sofer holds that marking a miracle is a Torah duty learned by kal vachomer, and any remembrance of the miracle suffices; the Rabbanan only set how to fulfil it. Citing the Chacham Tzvi, brought in the Mishneh LaMelech, that zerizus overrides doing a mitzvah in its finest way, he concludes that in Adar I the Torah duty is met by refraining from eulogy and fasting, while the mitzvos of divrei kabbalah wait for Adar II. f,g,h,i
The Mashgiach offers remarks for lomdim to look into. He does not understand how refraining fulfils the duty: a commemoration must be a positive act. On an ordinary day, thank G-d, there is also no eulogy and no fast, so what is the remembrance of the miracle?
Zerizus, mitzvah min hamuvchar and 'hashenis'
The Mashgiach suggests that the dispute about Adar I may follow the Gemara's dispute on Hallel: Rav Nachman holds that the reading of the Megillah is Purim's Hallel, while Rava holds no Hallel is required, since 'we are still servants of Achashverosh'. Tosafos may follow Rava, though he says he does not know. l,b
The Chasam Sofer argues that, because of zerizus, Purim should really have been in Adar I. Others disagree: the Terumas HaDeshen, brought in the Shulchan Aruch on Kiddush Levanah, waits until Motzaei Shabbos when one is still dressed for Shabbos, since a mitzvah in its finest form outweighs zerizus. On that view the celebration belongs only in Adar II. f,h,j,k
The Mashgiach asks what zerizus has to do with Purim, when eating matzah before Pesach is no zerizus. The Chasam Sofer answers that the Gemara means the first year, when the Anshei Knesses HaGedolah chose the month. On the source 'igeres haPurim hashenis', which Rashi reads as 'in the second month', the Mashgiach asks that 'hashenis' describes the letter, and explains it of a case like the Mishnah's: the Megillah was read in Adar I, the year was then made a leap year, and it is read a second time. f,m,n,a
Purim's high light must be repeated
If someone mistook Sunday for Shabbos and made Kiddush, he certainly says Tachanun at Minchah; a mistake is nothing. Yet Adar I is different: Purim Katan holds some of Purim's holiness, so once the Megillah was read there is a hold of holiness and joy on the day. The Mashgiach compares Pharaoh's dream: the second dream did not add, but confirmed the first. p
Citing the Maharal, the Mashgiach explains that the Jews had fallen so low that the miracle had to come from a hidden place far above understanding, as a man fallen into a deep pit needs a longer rope; the Kedushas Levi says similar things. Such a light has no connection to this world, which is why one drinks 'ad delo yada'. Like fire, which according to the Shaar HaKedushah rises because it does not belong to the world, these lights tend to go back up and must be held with 'iron grips'. q,r
Two Purims, 'Tov lehodos' and brachos
Adar, the twelfth month, is a time of darkness and concealment; a thirteenth month is deeper still, and only a great Purim can lift Jews from such a fall. So a leap year needs two Purims, Purim Katan with the great Purim. The Mashgiach says that gathering now to praise Hashem and sing, even beyond the letter of the law, is a commemoration and an 'investment' in the next Purim.
Today's seudah, he says, is 'Tov lehodos laShem': it is good to praise Hashem. When Hashem helps a person not follow the yetzer hara's calculations and resolve to daven well every morning, even on an ordinary Wednesday, he finds that 'ki tov zamrah' and that a taste in davening changes his learning, his honesty and his business. u,w
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Rishonim
- b apparently Tosafos, Megillah 6b index In the write-up: 1:41, 5:49, 11:53
- g apparently Ramban, end of Sefer HaMitzvos index In the write-up: 7:31
- n apparently Rashi, Megillah 6b index In the write-up: 14:40
- o Rosh (place not identified) 17:39 index
- y Rashi (place not identified) index In the write-up: 27:46
Acharonim and Chassidus
- c Shulchan Aruch Orach Chaim 697:1, Rema text index In the write-up: 1:41, 5:49
- d Magen Avraham (place not identified) index In the write-up: 3:32, 5:49
- f Chasam Sofer (place not identified) index In the write-up: 7:31, 12:57, 14:40
- i Mishneh LaMelech (place not identified) index In the write-up: 7:31
- k apparently Shulchan Aruch Orach Chaim 426:2 index In the write-up: 12:57
- q Kedushas Levi (place not identified) index In the write-up: 20:24
- r Shaar HaKedushah (place not identified) index In the write-up: 20:24
Other
Key points
- 3:32 According to the Mashgiach, beyond the Purim that Mordechai and Esther instituted, there is a general duty, as the Magen Avraham writes, to commemorate a miracle, and this is why something of Purim remains on Adar I.
- 6:37 The Mashgiach explains the Rema's 'increase the meal a little' as adding wine, since the Purim seudah requires wine while a general commemoration of a miracle does not.
- 10:29 The Mashgiach questions the Chasam Sofer's view that refraining from eulogy and fasting fulfils the commemoration, since a commemoration must be a positive act, and on an ordinary day too there is no eulogy or fast.
- 20:58 Purim's miracle came from so high a place, beyond nature and beyond understanding, that its light tends to rise back up, so it must be held and strengthened by repetition.
- 22:43 This repetition, the Mashgiach suggests, is behind reading the Megillah at night and again by day, and behind Esther's making two feasts.
- 24:04 In a leap year the lowliness of the thirteenth month is deeper still, so two Purims are needed, Purim Katan together with the great Purim.
- 25:43 The Purim Katan seudah is an expression of 'Tov lehodos laShem': it is good to praise Hashem, and a person who has a taste in davening finds that all of his life changes.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 4:54 How can Adar I be left entirely without the Purim celebration, when the Magen Avraham's general duty to commemorate a miracle applies to it?
Answer: 5:49 One view holds that Mordechai and Esther instituted some mitzvos for Adar I; Tosafos hold they instituted nothing, so what remains is the general commemoration, which the Rema meets by increasing the meal a little.
-
Question: 14:33 What does zerizus have to do with Purim, when the time for a mitzvah has not yet come, just as eating matzah before Pesach is no zerizus?
Answer: 15:08 The Chasam Sofer answers that the Gemara speaks of the first year after the miracle, when the Anshei Knesses HaGedolah were deciding which Adar to fix; for us the time is already fixed.
-
Question: 15:43 How can 'igeres haPurim hazos hashenis' teach that Purim is in the second Adar, when 'hashenis' describes the letter and not the month?
Answer: 16:11 It speaks of a case like the Mishnah's, where the Megillah was read in Adar I and the year was then made a leap year, so it is read a second time in Adar II.
-
Question: 18:22 Someone who mistook Sunday for Shabbos and made Kiddush may still say Tachanun at Minchah, since it was a mistake; why then does a Megillah reading in Adar I, later found mistaken, affect the day?
Answer: 18:43 Because Adar I is different: Purim Katan holds a measure of the holiness of Purim, so once the Megillah was read there is a hold of holiness and joy on the day.
-
Question: 23:23 Why did Esther, at the first feast, put off her request until the next day instead of asking at once?
Answer: 23:34 She knew she was creating a Purim and that one feast was not enough; it needed a repetition, so she made two feasts.
Insights
- 4:54 The Mashgiach reads the dispute about feasting on Adar I in light of the Magen Avraham: even if Mordechai and Esther instituted nothing for Adar I, the general duty to commemorate a miracle remains, and so cannot simply be pushed off to Adar II.
- 11:47 He suggests that the dispute over Adar I may parallel the dispute between Rav Nachman and Rava on whether Hallel is required on Purim: if no Hallel is required, as Rava holds, there may also be no duty to commemorate.
- 19:55 He explains Pharaoh's doubled dream as the model for Purim: a second time does not add a new thing but fixes and strengthens the first.
- 22:04 Like fire, which rises because it does not belong to this world, Purim's lights belong to a place above this world and tend to go back up, so they must be held with 'iron grips' through repetition.
- 23:23 Esther's delay to a second feast is explained as her understanding that the Purim she was creating needed a repetition to take hold.
- 24:12 Because the thirteenth month is a deeper darkness than the twelfth, a leap year's Purim must lift Jews from a greater lowliness, which is why it needs two Purims together.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 25:12 The Mashgiach says that gathering on Purim Katan to praise Hashem and sing is a commemoration of the miracle, beyond the strict letter of the law, and a preparation and 'investment' for the coming Purim.
- 26:14 The Mashgiach speaks of resolving to come to good davening every morning, even on an ordinary Wednesday, and to daven with some calm of mind and understanding.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Esther HaMalkah, Mordechai HaTzaddik, Pharaoh, Rashi, Rav Nachman, Rava, the Chacham Tzvi, the Chasam Sofer, the Magen Avraham, the Maharal of Prague, the Ramban, the Rema, the Rosh
Terms אנשי כנסת הגדולה, זכר לנס, זריזות, לפנים משורת הדין, משתה ושמחה, עד דלא ידע, פורים קטן, קל וחומר, שנה מעוברת, שפלות