דרוש בענין "ואין נוהגין כן וכו' וטוב לב משתה תמיד" (סיום שו”ע או”ח רמ"א)
Catalog entry: זמנים פורים קטן no. 8 Pocket Guide p. 22 תשנ"ב (1991–92) Yiddish 38 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains the Rema's closing words on Purim Katan, why he tells us to eat a little more at a meal though the custom does not follow the Ran, and how 'vetov lev mishteh tamid' lets one satisfy the stringent view without breaking the minhag.
The Mashgiach reads the last siman of Shulchan Aruch Orach Chaim, where the Rema brings the Ran's view that Purim Katan requires feasting, notes that the custom follows Tosfos, yet says to eat a little more 'to satisfy the stringent', closing with 'vetov lev mishteh tamid'. Since the Rema guards every minhag, why add this? The Mashgiach brings the Magen Avraham that one who experienced a miracle should make that day a yom tov, which the Chasam Sofer derives from the Gemara's kal vachomer about Hallel, and the Magen Avraham that a yahrzeit is kept in both Adars. Purim's own mishteh is a special din tied to wine, because the miracle came through wine. So even Tosfos agrees one should rejoice on Purim Katan; the dispute is only about wine. The Rema's answer is that Jews always say l'chaim. The Mashgiach closes with Rav Shmuel bar Shilas, a descendant of Haman.
Topics: Purim Katan and the Leap Year · Purim
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 The last siman of Orach Chaim listed in the guide
The Mashgiach reads the last siman of Shulchan Aruch Orach Chaim on the 14th and 15th of Adar Rishon, the Mishnah that the two Adars differ only in Megillah and gifts to the poor, and the Rema's gloss ending with 'vetov lev mishteh tamid'. He says every word of the Rema is ruach hakodesh and deserves closer thought.
-
3:32 The Rema's strictness about minhag listed in the guide
The Mashgiach lays out the dispute between the Ran, who requires feasting on Purim Katan, and Tosfos, whom the custom follows. He shows the Rema's zeal for minhag with the example of shevarim-teruah blown in two breaths, and asks why the Rema then tells us to eat a little more at a meal.
-
7:53 A private Purim and a yahrzeit in Adar listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Magen Avraham that a community or individual who experienced a miracle should make that day a yom tov, like Purim Krakow, and the Chasam Sofer who derives this mitzvah from the Gemara's kal vachomer about Hallel. He then brings the Magen Avraham that a yahrzeit is kept in both Adars, since only the Megillah is limited to the second Adar by the word 'hasheinis'.
-
13:46 Why Purim's feast needs wine listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains the Ran's view that Purim Katan requires a feast, and asks why Chanukah has no din of mishteh vesimcha despite the kal vachomer. He answers that the mishteh of Purim is a special din, a remembrance of a miracle that came through wine, so by the Ran one must drink wine on Purim Katan too.
-
19:00 Even Tosfos agrees to rejoice listed in the guide
The Mashgiach asks why Tosfos does not require rejoicing on Purim Katan by the Magen Avraham's din, and answers that Tosfos too would agree to that. The difference is that a self-made yom tov like Purim Krakow can be celebrated in any way, even a parade, while Purim Gadol has halachos from Chazal that require wine.
-
24:56 Rereading the Rema: a l'chaim listed in the guide
The Mashgiach rereads the Rema phrase by phrase and points to the change of wording from 'mishteh vesimcha' to 'yarbeh ketzas biseudah'. He asks how a meal without wine satisfies the stringent view, and answers from 'vetov lev mishteh tamid': Jews always say l'chaim with a little wine, so one fulfills the Ran's view without visibly going against the minhag.
-
29:35 Wine or any strong drink? listed in the guide
The Mashgiach wonders whether the Purim drinking must be wine or any intoxicating drink, since the custom is to drink bronfen. He notes that wine is named at Vashti's feast while Esther's feasts mention only 'mishteh', contrasts kiddush where wine is required, mentions Rabbi Avraham of Tshechanov drinking a revi'is of wine on Purim, and remarks that bronfen is a newer drink.
-
33:03 Haman's descendant and the joy of Adar
Short of time, the Mashgiach brings the Gemara that 'mishenichnas Adar marbin besimcha' was said by Rav Yehuda the son of Rav Shmuel bar Shilas. From the Gemara that Haman's descendants taught Torah in Bnei Brak, he identifies Rav Shmuel bar Shilas as a descendant of Haman who would not have been a Jew without the Purim miracle, and so had special joy in Adar; he closes with blessings.
The shiur, written up
The last siman of Orach Chaim
The Mashgiach opens with the last siman of Shulchan Aruch Orach Chaim, on the 14th and 15th of Adar Rishon. The Mishnah teaches that the two Adars differ only in the Megillah and gifts to the poor. The Rema then brings a view requiring feasting, notes that the custom differs, and ends with 'vetov lev mishteh tamid'. Every word of the Rema, the Mashgiach says, is ruach hakodesh and deserves thought. a,c,b,d
The Rema's strictness about minhag
The view requiring feasting is the Ran's; Tosfos disagrees, and the custom follows Tosfos. The Mashgiach stresses that all Ashkenazi customs come from the Rema, who guards every minhag. For example, some Rishonim require shevarim-teruah in one breath, yet the Ashkenazi custom is two breaths, and the Rema says to follow the custom. e,f
So why does the Rema, after stating that the custom is otherwise, tell us to eat a little more at a meal?
A private Purim and a yahrzeit in Adar
The Mashgiach brings the Magen Avraham that when a community or even an individual experiences a miracle, that day should be made a yom tov. Many towns had their own Purim, like Purim Krakow, when the Jews were saved from a priest who hated them. The Chasam Sofer calls this a mitzvah, learned from the Gemara's kal vachomer: if Hallel is said for leaving slavery, surely for being saved from death. g,h,i
Why Purim's feast needs wine
Even Tosfos agrees to rejoice
Why, then, does Tosfos not require rejoicing on Purim Katan by the Magen Avraham's din? The Mashgiach answers that Tosfos would indeed agree to rejoice. A self-made yom tov like Purim Krakow needs no wine; one rejoices with Hashem, 'zeh hayom asah Hashem', in any way, even with a parade and balloons. f,m
Rereading the Rema: a l'chaim
Wine or any strong drink?
The Mashgiach wonders whether wine is required, since the custom is bronfen. Wine is named by Vashti, but Esther's feasts say only 'mishteh'; the miracle was drunkenness, which bronfen also brings. Kiddush, by contrast, requires wine. Rabbi Avraham of Tshechanov drank a revi'is of wine on Purim. Bronfen, the Mashgiach adds, is newer than the Rema. n,o,p
Haman's descendant and the joy of Adar
Though late, the Mashgiach brings the Gemara that 'mishenichnas Adar marbin besimcha' was said by Rav Yehuda the son of Rav Shmuel bar Shilas. Rav Shmuel bar Shilas taught children, and the Gemara says Haman's descendants taught Torah in Bnei Brak; the Ein Yaakov reads that they taught children there. q,r,s,t
So Rav Shmuel bar Shilas was Haman's descendant, who would never have been a Jew without the Purim miracle. That is why his family felt a special joy when Adar came. The Mashgiach closes with blessings.
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
- a Shulchan Aruch Orach Chaim 697:1 text index In the write-up: 0:01
- b Rema, Shulchan Aruch Orach Chaim 697:1 text index In the write-up: 0:01, 26:15
- g apparently Magen Avraham, Orach Chaim 686 index In the write-up: 8:21
- h Shu"t Chasam Sofer (place not identified) index In the write-up: 8:21
- j apparently Magen Avraham, Orach Chaim 568 index In the write-up: 11:44
Other
Key points
- 4:28 The Mashgiach says the Rema guards every minhag, so his instruction to eat a little more on Purim Katan, against the custom he himself records, needs an explanation.
- 8:21 According to the Magen Avraham, anyone who experiences a miracle should make that day a yom tov, as with Purim Krakow, and the Chasam Sofer calls this a mitzvah learned by kal vachomer from Pesach.
- 16:25 The mishteh of Purim is not the general din of celebrating a miracle but a special halachah requiring wine, because the Purim miracle came about through wine.
- 22:18 Even Tosfos agrees one should rejoice on Purim Katan by the Magen Avraham's din; the difference is that only by the Ran's view must one drink wine.
- 28:07 The Rema's closing words 'vetov lev mishteh tamid' show how to satisfy the stringent view: Jews always say l'chaim at a gathering, so drinking a little wine does not look like going against the minhag.
- 33:38 Rav Shmuel bar Shilas, a descendant of Haman whose family became Jews through the Purim miracle, had special reason for joy, which is why his son taught 'mishenichnas Adar marbin besimcha'.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 7:25 The Rema is so strict about minhag and himself records that the custom is not like the Ran; why does he introduce eating a little more at a meal on Purim Katan?
Answer: 25:55 Even by Tosfos, the Magen Avraham's din of celebrating a day of miracle applies to Purim Katan as to a yahrzeit in both Adars, so some feast is fitting.
-
Question: 15:05 If one must make a yom tov for a miracle by kal vachomer, why is there no din of mishteh vesimcha on Chanukah?
Answer: 16:10 Purim's mishteh is not from that din; it is a special remembrance of a miracle that came through wine.
-
Question: 19:00 Why does Tosfos not require rejoicing on Purim Katan, given the Magen Avraham's din and his ruling that both Adars are alike?
Answer: 20:08 Tosfos would agree to rejoice; they only hold there is no obligation of wine, which belongs to the halachos of Purim Gadol.
-
Question: 26:53 How does 'yarbeh ketzas biseudah' satisfy the stringent view, which requires wine, if the minhag does not follow it?
Answer: 28:06 'Vetov lev mishteh tamid': at every gathering Jews drink a little wine to say l'chaim, so they fulfill the Ran without going against the minhag.
-
Question: 33:38 Why was it Rav Yehuda the son of Rav Shmuel bar Shilas who said 'mishenichnas Adar marbin besimcha'?
Answer: 35:06 Rav Shmuel bar Shilas was a descendant of Haman and would not have been a Jew without the Purim miracle, so his family had special joy in Adar.
Stories
-
8:35 Purim Krakow
The Mashgiach mentions that many towns in Europe, and especially Sephardic communities, had their own Purim for a miracle that happened to them. In Krakow there was a great miracle when the Jews were saved from a priest who was an enemy of the Jews. The day of his downfall was called Purim Krakow, and they used to rejoice and make a seudah on it.
-
31:59 Rabbi Avraham of Tshechanov's revi'is
The Mashgiach relates that Rabbi Avraham of Tshechanov was careful on Purim to pour a revi'is of wine and drink it, and with that he fulfilled the obligation. The Mashgiach adds that the Polish revi'is cups were very small.
In the story: Rabbi Avraham of Ciechanow
Insights
- 26:28 The Mashgiach reads the Rema's switch from 'mishteh vesimcha' to 'yarbeh ketzas biseudah' as deliberate: the Rema is not adopting the Ran's obligation but the feast every view agrees to.
- 17:53 The Mashgiach distinguishes two dinim of joy: the Magen Avraham's general yom tov for a miracle, which can be kept in any way, and Purim's own mishteh, a remembrance of a miracle that came through wine, which requires wine.
- 15:26 Chanukah has no din of mishteh vesimcha despite the kal vachomer of Hallel, which shows that Purim's feasting is not derived from that kal vachomer.
- 28:17 The Rema's rule not to go against a minhag applies where one visibly opposes it; since Jews always drink l'chaim, a little wine at the meal does not visibly break the custom.
- 35:06 The joy of Adar was taught by the son of Rav Shmuel bar Shilas because his family, descended from Haman, became Jews only through the Purim miracle.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Achashverosh, Esther HaMalkah, Haman, Rabbi Avraham of Ciechanow, Rabbi Yosef Karo (the Beis Yosef), Rav Shmuel bar Shilas, Rav Yehuda son of Rav Shmuel bar Shilas, Rebbe Elimelech of Lizhensk (the Noam Elimelech), the Baalei Tosafos, the Chasam Sofer, the Magen Avraham, the Ran, the Rema, Vashti
Terms זכר לנס, משתה ושמחה, פורים קטן, קל וחומר, רביעית