Lighting the Extinguished Candles
Catalog entry: ZMANIM (English) חנוכה no. 7 Pocket Guide p. 64 תשס"ח (2007–08) English 26 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains that Chanukah, a Yom Tov of the galus set in the darkest place and time, calls on every Jew to go out and relight the extinguished neshamos, while Hashem, behind the darkness, is preparing Moshiach.
The Mashgiach opens with the idea of good and less good times: Jews prefer the first half of the month, when the moon grows, and the right side, the side of chesed. Chanukah breaks every rule: it falls at the end of the month, in the long nights of Teves, its lamp stands on the left of the door, below ten tefachim, out in the public domain. He explains that Chanukah and Purim are Yomim Tovim of the galus, and that the extinguished candles stand for the many neshamos blown out in the galus; Chanukah teaches a Jew to go out into the dark and relight them. He then takes up the questions people ask about the darkness of our time and answers them from the Midrash on 'Vayehi ba'eis hahi': while everyone was busy with his own troubles, Hashem was preparing the light of Moshiach. He closes by asking each listener to prepare himself and others for Moshiach, since every mitzvah lights more than one can see.
Topics: The Chanukah Lights · The Pintele Yid: The Inner Point of Every Jew · Galus as Preparation for Geulah
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Favorable times and the right side
The Mashgiach explains that there are favorable and unfavorable times, that the first half of the month is an eis ratzon because Jews are compared to the waxing moon, and that most Yomim Tovim fall on the first or fifteenth of the month. Chanukah is the exception, at the end of the month, and Jews also always give priority to the right side.
-
5:44 Chanukah in the lowest place of the galus listed in the guide
The Mashgiach lists how Chanukah stands against the usual rules: its lamp is on the left side, at night in the long nights of Teves, in the public domain outside Hashem's 'atmosphere', and below ten tefachim where the Shechinah does not rest. He explains that Chanukah and Purim are weekday Yomim Tovim of the galus, and that Chanukah signifies the deepest galus.
-
10:10 Relighting the extinguished neshamos listed in the guide
Using 'ner Hashem nishmas adam', the Mashgiach explains that many neshamos are blown out in the galus, and that on Chanukah a Jew goes out to the public domain to relight them. He says this is the darkest hour before dawn, and lists the questions people ask about the darkness of our time.
-
15:53 The troubles of the Avos and the light of Moshiach
The Mashgiach asks why Yaakov Avinu had to bow to Esav, why Dina was taken, and why the brothers sold Yosef. He answers with the Midrash on 'Vayehi ba'eis hahi': while everyone was busy with his own matter, Hashem was preparing the light of Moshiach.
-
19:14 No free choice: everything leads to Moshiach
The Mashgiach brings that the Shevatim had no free choice in selling Yosef, citing the Ohr HaChaim, and shows how Moshiach ben Yosef came from the episode of Dina and Moshiach ben David from Yehudah and Tamar, while the galus of Mitzrayim prepared the nation. He applies this to the confusing events of today.
-
22:58 Lighting your own neshamah and others' listed in the guide
The Mashgiach tells his listeners to prepare themselves and others for Moshiach: lighting the Chanukah candle lights one's own neshamah, and like a button that lights a whole building, every mitzvah does more than one can see. He calls bringing light to the lost neshamos the task of this generation, and ends with a brachah.
The shiur, written up
Favorable times and the right side
The Mashgiach begins with the different kinds of times: some are an eis ratzon, a favorable time, and some belong to midas hadin, strict judgment. Jews try to do mitzvos and daven at a favorable time, and the first half of the month counts as one, because Jews are compared to the moon, which grows until it is full on the fifteenth.
He cites the Shulchan Aruch that a wedding is not made in the waning second half of the month, and notes that Rosh Hashanah, Sukkos and Pesach fall on the first or the fifteenth. Chanukah is the exception, on the twenty-fifth, and the lamp stands on the left, though Jews always give priority to the right. b
Chanukah in the lowest place of the galus
The Mashgiach continues: day is a time of chesed, as Tehillim 42:9 says, and night of din, yet the lights burn at night in the longest nights of Teves. The Gemara wants them in the public domain, where carrying on Shabbos is forbidden because it leaves Hashem's domain, and below ten tefachim, though the Gemara in Sukkah teaches that the Shechinah rests above ten. c,e,f
He explains that Chanukah and Purim are Yomim Tovim of the galus, weekdays with a full Shemoneh Esrei. Chanukah, at the end of the month, on the left side and in the long night, signifies the galus itself.
Relighting the extinguished neshamos
In the galus, the Mashgiach says, many neshamos are caught in its whirlpool. Shlomo HaMelech calls the soul a candle, 'ner Hashem nishmas adam', and there are candles that have been blown out; he estimates that ninety percent of the nation today does not know Shema Yisrael. g
On Chanukah, he explains, a Jew goes out into the public domain, conquers territory from the Satan, and with a shamash lights these neshamos and makes them sparkle again; they are the lights of which one says 'haneiros halalu kodesh hem'. Now is the darkest part of the night, right before Moshiach, and people ask: why the Holocaust, why so much heresy, why the temptations of the internet that cut so many off from the Torah? h
The troubles of the Avos and the light of Moshiach
The parshiyos read before Chanukah, the Mashgiach says, raise the same questions: why must Yaakov Avinu bow seven times to Esav, why was Dina taken by Shechem, why did the holy brothers sell Yosef? The Midrash answers from 'Vayehi ba'eis hahi': everyone was busy with his own matter, and Hashem was creating the light of Moshiach. i,j,k,l
No free choice: everything leads to Moshiach
The Mashgiach adds that the Shevatim had no free choice: Yosef had to be sold so that he would rule Mitzrayim and prepare for his family. The Ohr HaChaim explains that Hashem sometimes takes away a great tzaddik's choice. From Dina came Asnas, mother of Moshiach ben Yosef; from Yehudah and Tamar, Moshiach ben David; and the galus of Mitzrayim purified the nation for the Torah. n
So too today, with frightening headlines, he says one sees only darkness, but at dawn it will be clear that Hashem was preparing Moshiach.
Lighting your own neshamah and others'
The Mashgiach tells his listeners to prepare themselves and others for Moshiach. Lighting the Chanukah candle lights one's own neshamah; like a button that lights a whole skyscraper, every mitzvah, one of 248 matching the limbs, brings light or the opposite. Bringing light to lost neshamos, he says, is this generation's task.
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 2:35 Jews prefer the first half of the month, when the moon waxes, and the right side of chesed, yet Chanukah falls at the end of the month and its lamp stands on the left side of the door.
- 8:17 Chanukah and Purim are Yomim Tovim of the galus, weekdays with a full Shemoneh Esrei, and Chanukah sits in the lowest place of the galus: end of the month, left side, the darkest nights of the year.
- 10:39 The extinguished candles are the neshamos blown out in the galus, and Chanukah teaches a Jew to go out into the public domain and relight them.
- 17:33 Behind the dark events of the parsha, and of our own time, Hashem is preparing Moshiach.
- 24:05 Every mitzvah is like a button whose effect a person cannot see, and lighting the Chanukah candle lights one's own neshamah and those of others.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 4:48 Why does Chanukah fall at the end of the month, on the left side, in the darkest nights, when Jews prefer the waxing moon and the right side?
Answer: 9:27 Chanukah is a Yom Tov of the galus; it signifies the deepest galus, where Jews must go out and relight the extinguished neshamos.
-
Question: 16:23 Why did Hashem let the tzaddikim suffer: Yaakov bowing to Esav, Dina taken by Shechem, the brothers selling Yosef?
Answer: 17:33 The Midrash on 'Vayehi ba'eis hahi' says that while each was busy with his own matter, Hashem was preparing the light of Moshiach.
-
Question: 17:13 How could the holy Shevatim sell Yosef?
Answer: 19:27 They had no free choice; it was Hashem's plan, so that Yosef would become king in Mitzrayim and prepare the way for Yaakov's family, as the Ohr HaChaim explains that Hashem sometimes takes away great tzaddikim's choice.
Insights
- 4:48 Every feature of Chanukah breaks the Jewish preference for favorable times and places: end of the month instead of its first half, left instead of right, night in Teves, the public domain, below ten tefachim. The Mashgiach reads this as Chanukah being the Yom Tov of the deepest galus.
- 6:50 Going out to the public domain is going out of Hashem's 'atmosphere', which is why carrying out on Shabbos is forbidden; lighting there means conquering territory from the Satan and bringing back neshamos that fell to the side of the yetzer hara.
- 10:39 The candle is the neshamah ('ner Hashem nishmas adam'), so the Chanukah lights kindled in the dark stand for blown-out neshamos given a new sparkle, and the words 'haneiros halalu kodesh hem' refer to them.
- 15:26 The Mashgiach reads the Midrash on 'Vayehi ba'eis hahi' as the answer to the questions of our own dark time: each of the Avos and Shevatim was busy with his own trouble, and Hashem was preparing Moshiach.
- 20:22 The dark episodes of the parsha produced both Mashiachs: from Dina and Shechem came Asnas, Yosef's wife and the source of Moshiach ben Yosef, and from Yehudah and Tamar came Moshiach ben David.
- 24:25 A mitzvah is like a button at the bottom of the Empire State Building that turns on every light: our 248 limbs correspond to 248 mitzvos, and each movement brings light or the opposite into the world without our seeing how.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 23:29 The Mashgiach says each listener must prepare himself and others for Moshiach.
- 23:53 He says that when one makes the brachah and lights the Chanukah candle, one should know that one is lighting one's own neshamah.
- 25:19 He calls on the listeners to bring light to the many neshamos in the public domain, in the grip of the Satan, calling this the task of this generation.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Dinah, Esav, Osnas, Shechem ben Chamor, Shlomo HaMelech, Tamar, the Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh, Yaakov Avinu, Yehudah (son of Yaakov), Yosef HaTzaddik
Terms בחירה, גלות, טבת, למטה מעשרה, מדת הדין, מדת החסד, מיעוט הירח, משיח בן דוד, משיח בן יוסף, נר ה' נשמת אדם, עת רצון, רבונו של עולם, רשות הרבים, שכינה