קליפת יון - להכחיש בעולם הרוחני - נסיון זמננו
Catalog entry: זמנים חנוכה no. 6 Pocket Guide p. 19 תש"נ (1989–90) Yiddish 57 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains that the war of Yavan, foreshadowed by Dinah and Shechem, is a war against emunah fought through tumah and through erasing the name Yisrael, and that this is the test of the generation before Moshiach.
Opening with Vayeshev, the Mashgiach brings the Ramban's principle that the deeds of the Avos are signs for their children, and the Chasam Sofer's reading: having passed through every sign of galus, Yaakov sought a sign of the days of Moshiach, which this world cannot hold, so galus began anew with Yosef. Dinah's abduction stands for the war of Gog uMagog, the war of Yavan. Greek wisdom believes only what the intellect sees, so it fights emunah, which rests on ruach hakodesh and purity; its weapon is tumah, today the trials of arayos and forbidden foods. This explains the pure-oil miracle, and the Mashgiach shows the hidden jar lay where the sotah's dust was taken, the place guarding the purity of Jewish daughters. From Tzidkas HaTzaddik he teaches that a Jew's Jewishness lies in calling himself a Jew; the Greeks, like Shechem and Esav's kiss, sought to erase the name Yisrael. Hence Yaakov forced the angel to concede the name at once, and on Chanukah a Jew should rejoice that he is a Jew.
Topics: The Miracle of Chanukah and the Greeks · Doubts in Emunah and Amalek · Tumah, Taharah and Mikveh · Challenges of Our Generation
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Yaakov's wish for tranquility as a sign
The Mashgiach brings the Ramban's rule that the deeds of the Avos are signs for their children, traces Yaakov's life through every stage of galus up to the war of Gog uMagog, and gives the Chasam Sofer's explanation of why Yaakov sought tranquility and why galus began again with Yosef.
-
7:55 Dinah and Yaakov's struggle with the angel
The Mashgiach places the trouble of Dinah at the very end of galus, as the war of Gog uMagog, and then turns to Yaakov's struggle with the angel: Yaakov would not release him until he conceded the blessings through the name Yisrael, refusing to wait for Beis El despite the angel's tearful pleas.
-
12:01 The four kingdoms and the wisdom of Yavan listed in the guide
Dinah's trouble is the kingdom of Yavan, one of the four kingdoms of Maoz Tzur. The Mashgiach explains that each galus continues and Hashem gave a weapon against each, and that Greek wisdom, believing only what the intellect sees, fought against emunah.
-
15:49 Tumah as the weapon against emunah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that emunah above the intellect comes from ruach hakodesh present in every Jew, so the Greeks attacked it with tumah, which severs a Jew from his pure neshamah. He connects this to 'tamei'im b'yad tehorim' and to the war of Gog uMagog as a war against emunah, citing the Chafetz Chaim on why there would be no more dybbuks.
-
20:35 The trials of our time: arayos and forbidden foods listed in the guide
Weak emunah, the Mashgiach says, stems mainly from two sins that the Torah describes as defiling, arayos and forbidden foods, and these are exactly the trials of today, which earlier generations did not face. A Jew who fights for kedushah in these areas wages the war against Yavan; the Rambam opens the laws of Chanukah with the Greeks bringing tumah upon Jewish daughters.
-
24:09 The pure oil and where the jar was hidden listed in the guide
The Mashgiach asks why a miracle of pure oil was needed if tumah is permitted for the public, and answers that it symbolized the victory of the pure over the impure. He parallels Dinah's defilement with the Greeks defiling all the oils, brings Tosafos that the sealed jar was hidden in the ground, and asks how the Kohen Gadol could bury it under the Heichal's floor, answering from the Mishnah in Sotah about the loose stone from which the sotah's dust was taken.
-
32:24 Purity of Jewish daughters and the Chazon Ish Story listed in the guide
The jar was guarded in the very place that guards the purity of Jewish daughters, since its purpose was to fight the Greeks' tumah. The Mashgiach tells how the Chazon Ish asked a dentist to wash his hands before treating him, because Torah is acquired only through purity, and concludes that the Greeks attacked emunah through tumah to reach their goal.
-
36:19 Jewishness rests on calling oneself a Jew listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings Tzidkas HaTzaddik that a Jew's whole Jewishness lies in calling himself a Jew, with the passuk 'uveshem Yisrael yechaneh', the Radvaz on denying one's Jewishness, and an incident from the Toras Chaim about a Jew in Germany asked 'Bist du ein Jude?'.
-
40:42 Erasing the name Yisrael: Esav's kiss and Shechem listed in the guide
The Greeks wanted Jews to deny their portion in the G-d of Israel. The Mashgiach brings the Midrash and the Sfas Emes on Esav, who could not bite Yaakov and so kissed him, as the tactic of today's nations and churches seeking togetherness, and shows the same aim in Shechem's offer to become one people, which the brothers called 'nevalah asah b'Yisrael'.
-
45:54 The breached soreg and the 25 letters of Shema Yisrael listed in the guide
The Mashgiach asks why the Greeks breached specifically the soreg, and answers that it was the wall separating Jew from gentile and pure from impure. He then explains Chanukah as chaf-heh, the 25 letters of Shema Yisrael: emunah includes believing that one is Yisrael as well as that Hashem is One.
-
49:10 Why Yaakov insisted on the name Yisrael now listed in the guide
Returning to the angel, the Mashgiach explains that both the angel and Yaakov knew Shechem, standing for Yavan, lay ahead; the name Yisrael was the weapon for that war, so the angel wept and Yaakov stood firm. With it Yaakov built the altar 'Kel Elokei Yisrael'. The Mashgiach then says that on Chanukah a Jew should rejoice in being a Jew and accept upon himself strengthening in Torah, mitzvos and purity.
-
53:18 Chanukah: holiness in the weekday, gifts from Above
The Mashgiach describes Chanukah as holiness brought into the weekday and into the darkness of Teves, and as a free gift from Above even to the unworthy. He suggests this is why children receive Chanukah gifts: Hashem gives His children gifts, and the vessels to receive them are a resolution in Torah, mitzvos and joy in being a Jew.
The shiur, written up
Yaakov's wish for tranquility as a sign
The Mashgiach opens with Rashi's words on Vayeshev, that Yaakov sought to dwell in tranquility, and brings the Ramban's rule that the deeds of the Avos are signs for their children: Avraham's descent to Egypt in a famine, Sarah taken by Pharaoh and released with gifts, foretold the exile in Egypt and the leaving with great wealth. c,a
Yaakov's life traced the last galus: Lavan pursuing him after he left is the birth pangs of Moshiach, Dinah is the war of Gog uMagog, and Rachel's death is the killing of Moshiach ben Yosef. Having lived through all of it, Yaakov wanted to be a sign of the days of Moshiach.
Dinah and the angel
The four kingdoms and the wisdom of Yavan
Tumah as the weapon against emunah
The trials of our time
Weak emunah comes chiefly from arayos and forbidden foods, which the Torah calls defiling, as in Shemini. These are today's trials, which earlier generations never faced. A Jew who fights for kedushas einayim and fully kosher food wages the war against Yavan; the Rambam opens the laws of Chanukah with the Greeks defiling Jewish daughters. j,k
The pure oil and the hidden jar
The commentators ask why a miracle was needed when tumah is permitted for the public. The Mashgiach answers that since the whole war was tamei against tahor, the beauty of the miracle was pure oil, the victory of the pure.
Dinah's episode parallels this: the Greeks defiled every oil, and the Gemara in Kesubos tells of their decree against Jewish brides. Following the Gemara in Shabbos, one sealed jar remained; Tosafos asks why it was not defiled by being moved, and answers that it was hidden in the ground for many years. n,l,m
How could the Kohen Gadol bury it under the paved Heichal without breaking a stone? The Mishnah in Sotah, explaining the passuk about dust from the floor of the Mishkan, tells of one loose stone with a ring from beneath which that dust was taken; there, the Mashgiach says, the jar was likely hidden. o,p
Purity of Jewish daughters and the Chazon Ish
Thus the jar was guarded in the very place that guards the purity of Jewish daughters, for its purpose was to defeat the tumah the Greeks brought.
The Mashgiach tells that the Chazon Ish, suffering gum pain, had a neighbor dentist massage his gums, and asked him to wash negel vasser first, since Torah comes only through purity. When he once came without washing, the Chazon Ish sensed it disturbed his learning. Through tumah, the Greeks sought to uproot emunah.
Jewishness rests on calling oneself a Jew
Tzidkas HaTzaddik teaches that a Jew's whole Jewishness lies in calling himself a Jew, as the passuk says of those far from Torah before Moshiach, 'uveshem Yisrael yechaneh'. The Radvaz rules that one may not save himself by declaring he is a gentile, as the Shulchan Aruch also holds, for that denies being a Jew. q,r,s,t
Esav's kiss and Shechem
The Greeks wanted Jews to deny any portion in the G-d of Israel. The Midrash explains the dots over 'vayishakehu': Esav wanted to bite Yaakov and, unable to, kissed him, which the Sfas Emes also discusses. v,w,x
Today's nations, the Mashgiach says, adopt this tactic: no more persecution, only togetherness, joint ceremonies of priest and rabbi. Shechem likewise proposed that the Jews become one people with them, and the brothers called it 'nevalah asah b'Yisrael', an attempt to erase the name Yisrael. y,z
The breached soreg and Shema Yisrael
Why Yaakov needed the name Yisrael now
Holiness in the weekday, gifts from Above
Chanukah, the Mashgiach says, is holiness within the weekday, kindled even in the dark of Teves, a fight against tumah until the redemption. Its holiness is a gift from Above even to the unworthy.
He suggests this is why children get Chanukah gifts: Hashem loves His children and gives them gifts, and the vessels to receive them are a resolution, learning, and joy in having a portion in the G-d of Israel.
Sources
Torah
- d Bereishis 32:27 text index In the write-up: 8:24
- f Bereishis 32:29 text index In the write-up: 10:11
- j apparently Vayikra 11:43 index In the write-up: 20:56
- p Bamidbar 5:17 text index In the write-up: 29:54
- v Bereishis 33:4 text index In the write-up: 40:45
- y apparently Bereishis 34:22 index In the write-up: 42:53
- z Bereishis 34:7 text index In the write-up: 42:53
- ac Devarim 6:4 text index In the write-up: 48:17
- ad Bereishis 33:20 text index In the write-up: 49:22
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Rishonim
- a apparently Ramban on Bereishis 12:6 index In the write-up: 0:07
- c apparently Rashi on Bereishis 37:2 index In the write-up: 0:07
- e apparently Rashi on Bereishis 32:27 index In the write-up: 10:11
- k apparently Rambam, Hilchos Chanukah 3:1 index In the write-up: 20:56
- m apparently Tosafos, Shabbos 21b index In the write-up: 25:30
- ab apparently Rashi on Bamidbar 19:9 index In the write-up: 46:19
Acharonim and Chassidus
- b Chasam Sofer (place not identified) index In the write-up: 6:08
- q Tzidkas HaTzaddik (place not identified) index In the write-up: 36:51, 38:12
- s Teshuvos Radvaz (place not identified) index In the write-up: 36:51
- t Shulchan Aruch (place not identified) index In the write-up: 36:51
- x Sfas Emes (place not identified) index In the write-up: 40:45
- af Divrei Chaim (place not identified) index In the write-up: 15:49
Tefillah and Piyut
Other
Key points
- 0:36 The Mashgiach brings the Ramban's principle that what happened to the Avos is a sign of what will happen to their children, and applies it to Yaakov's life as a map of the whole galus.
- 8:37 The episode of Dinah and Shechem is the sign of the war of Gog uMagog at the end of galus, which is the war of Yavan.
- 14:09 Greek wisdom accepts only what the intellect grasps, and so it wars against emunah; its chief weapon is tumah, which cuts a Jew off from his pure neshamah.
- 36:51 According to Tzidkas HaTzaddik, a Jew's Jewishness rests on his calling himself a Jew, and the Greeks' decree aimed to make Jews deny any portion in the G-d of Israel.
- 50:09 Yaakov refused to wait until Beis El for the angel's concession because the name Yisrael was his weapon for the coming struggle with Shechem, which stands for Yavan.
- 52:03 The Mashgiach says that on Chanukah every Jew should rejoice in having a portion in the G-d of Israel and resolve to strengthen himself in Torah, mitzvos and purity.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 0:23 What does it mean that Yaakov sought to dwell in tranquility?
Answer: 5:18 Having passed through all the signs of galus, he sought to be a sign of the days of Moshiach; since this world cannot hold such a sign, galus began anew with Yosef.
-
Question: 11:38 Why could Yaakov not wait until Beis El for the angel's concession?
Answer: 50:09 Because Shechem, standing for Yavan, came first, and the name Yisrael was the weapon for that war.
-
Question: 24:12 Why was a miracle of pure oil needed if tumah is permitted for the public?
Answer: 24:33 The whole war with Yavan was tamei'im against tehorim, so the beauty of the miracle was pure oil, symbolizing the victory of the pure.
-
Question: 27:22 How was it known that the sealed jar had not been defiled by the Greeks moving it?
Answer: 28:13 Tosafos answers that it was hidden in the ground, with signs that it had lain there untouched for many years.
-
Question: 29:54 How could the Kohen Gadol bury the jar under the paved floor of the Heichal without breaking a stone of the Mikdash?
Answer: 31:24 The Mishnah in Sotah tells of one loose stone with a ring, from under which the dust for the sotah was taken; the jar was most likely hidden there.
-
Question: 47:05 Why did the Greeks breach specifically the soreg and not the wall of the Temple Mount?
Answer: 47:15 The soreg was the boundary beyond which a gentile could not enter, the wall between Jew and gentile and between impure and pure, and that is what bothered them.
Stories
-
33:23 The Chazon Ish and the dentist's hands
The Chazon Ish suffered pain in his gums, and a dentist living nearby would come and massage them. Once, early in the morning, the pain was so great that he could not learn, and he sent for the dentist. Afterwards he told him that he wants to merit Torah, which comes only through purity, and asked that next time he first wash negel vasser. Once the dentist came in a hurry without washing; the Chazon Ish sensed it and said it disturbed his learning.
In the story: the Chazon Ish
-
38:19 'Kein Jude' in Germany
The Mashgiach brings from the Toras Chaim that during a decree against Jews in Germany, soldiers stopped a Jew, a talmid chacham, and asked him whether he was a Jew. He answered 'kein Jude', which in German means 'not a Jew', while he intended it in loshon hakodesh as 'kein Yehudah', 'yes, a Jew'.
Insights
- 5:04 Following the Chasam Sofer, Yaakov's wish to dwell in tranquility was not a desire for ease: having lived out every sign of galus through Gog uMagog, he sought to be the sign of the days of Moshiach, but this world has no vessel for such a sign, so instead galus began anew with Yosef.
- 16:34 Emunah in what is beyond the intellect is real because every Jew has some measure of ruach hakodesh, and that is why the Greeks, who wanted to uproot it, attacked through tumah, which cuts a Jew off from his pure neshamah.
- 24:19 Though impure oil could have been used, the beauty of the miracle was that the oil was pure, symbolizing the victory of 'tamei'im b'yad tehorim'.
- 31:58 The jar of oil was most likely hidden under the loose stone from which the sotah's dust was taken, so it was guarded in the very place that guards the purity of Jewish daughters, which was what the Greeks sought to destroy.
- 42:45 Esav, unable to bite Yaakov, kissed him; the Mashgiach sees this as the tactic of the nations before Moshiach, who seek to destroy Jews through embrace and togetherness rather than persecution.
- 48:17 Chanukah, read as chaf-heh, alludes to the 25 letters of Shema Yisrael, because emunah includes not only that Hashem is One but also that one is Yisrael, the very point the Greeks attacked.
- 49:22 Yaakov's insistence on the angel's concession at once, rather than at Beis El, is explained by the coming encounter with Shechem: the name Yisrael was the weapon against Yavan, which is why the angel fought so hard against conceding it.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 23:03 The Mashgiach says that a Jew who struggles for kedushas einayim and insists on fully kosher food, at whatever cost, is waging the war against Yavan.
- 35:01 The Mashgiach says that one who wishes to merit Torah must be careful about purity, such as washing after touching covered parts of the body.
- 52:03 The Mashgiach says that on Chanukah every Jew should rejoice that he has a portion in the G-d of Israel, kindle the lights with that awareness, and make a resolution to strengthen himself in Torah, mitzvos and purity.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avimelech, Avraham Avinu, Chamor, Dinah, Esav, Lavan, Mordechai HaTzaddik, Pharaoh, Rabbi Tzadok HaKohen of Lublin, Rachel Imeinu, Rashi, Sarah Imeinu, Shechem ben Chamor, the Chasam Sofer, the Chazon Ish, the Chofetz Chaim, the Radbaz, the Rambam, the Ramban, the Sfas Emes, Yaakov Avinu, Yosef HaTzaddik
Terms גוג ומגוג, חבלי משיח, טהרה, טומאה, יוונים, מעשה אבות סימן לבנים, משיח בן יוסף, פך השמן, רוח הקודש