ביאור על "פני כל אחיו נפל'" וסמך לי' "אלה תולדות יצחק"
Catalog entry: פרשת השבוע תולדות no. 2 Pocket Guide p. 5 תשל"ה (1974–75) Yiddish 56 min
Listen
About this shiur
Building on the Ba'al HaTurim that Yishmael's fall at the end of Chayei Sarah is followed by 'Eleh toldos Yitzchak', the Mashgiach explains why Yishmael rose so high in our time as a sign of the coming geulah, and that Torah study, especially teaching others, and tzedakah are what bring it.
The Mashgiach opens with the Bnei Yissaschar: the Torah reading of Yishmael's success on Rosh Hashanah arouses mercy, since if Avraham's son Yishmael is so blessed, Yaakov's children surely are. He brings the Ba'al HaTurim that Yishmael's fall precedes 'Eleh toldos Yitzchak', the sprouting of Moshiach, and explains the sedra's name: Yaakov receives the blessings while dressed in Esav's garments. Through Rabbeinu Bachya and the Zohar he shows that the galus of Yishmael is the deepest spiritually, a maidservant inheriting her mistress, and that Yishmael holds Eretz Yisrael through an empty bris. He explains that a time of the ketz brings accusation and upheaval, that the world's degeneration is demolition before rebuilding, and that Yishmael was made great only to fall. From Rashi on Yishmael's years he derives that Yaakov's toil in Torah brought Yishmael's death, and he urges Torah of chesed, teaching others, tzedakah, drawing in those without yichus, and kindling new light in Kislev.
Topics: Signs of the Generation Before Moshiach · The Exiles and Their Kingdoms · The Time of the Geulah and the Ketz · The Power and Greatness of Torah
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Yishmael's fall and the toldos of Yitzchak listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Bnei Yissaschar on why Yishmael's blessings are read on Rosh Hashanah, then the Ba'al HaTurim linking 'al pnei chol echav nafal' to 'Eleh toldos Yitzchak'. He explains the name Toldos through Yaakov receiving the blessings in Esav's garments.
-
5:58 Bread and water for the enemy; the galus of Yishmael listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings Rabbeinu Bachya that Avraham foresaw Yishmael's great hatred of Israel and therefore gave him bread and water, as the passuk in Mishlei advises with an enemy. He explains that the galus of Yishmael, though physically easier than Edom, is spiritually the lowest: a maidservant inheriting her mistress.
-
10:09 An empty bris for an empty land listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Zohar that Bnei Yishmael were given Eretz Yisrael, empty, in the merit of their empty milah. He contrasts it with a Jew's bris, a lifelong task of guarding the eyes, the tongue and the bris itself.
-
13:12 'Drive out the maidservant' and the accusation at the ketz listed in the guide
The Mashgiach contrasts Sarah's demand to drive out Yishmael with today's nations who want to drive Jews out of Eretz Yisrael, and asks why it happens now. He explains the two kinds of geulah time, and that when a ketz arrives the Satan accuses, so that a missed ketz brings harsh decrees, as in the years of Tach and in the 1940s.
-
19:47 A ketz in the air and the Chofetz Chaim's Mississippi
The Mashgiach brings a ketz from the Ta'amei HaMitzvos of Rabbi Chaim Vital and asks whether we are ready to greet Moshiach. He notes that even the world's experts call the situation a powder keg, and tells how the Chofetz Chaim in Radin spoke of the Mississippi flood as a call to teshuvah.
-
25:27 Demolition before building; Yishmael made great to fall listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains the Gemara's picture of a degenerate world before Moshiach as demolishing the old to build the new, brings Rabbeinu Bachya that the nations will agree to Yaakov's blessings and Rabbi Yehuda HaLevi's poem of the maidservant, and concludes that Yishmael was made great so that his fall would be great.
-
30:13 Torah and tzedakah; Yaakov's learning and Yishmael's death listed in the guide
The Mashgiach says that Moshiach is brought by Torah and tzedakah, not by rallies, citing the passuk of Tziyon redeemed through tzedakah and the Or HaChaim. He then brings Rashi that Yishmael's years are counted to reveal Yaakov's fourteen years at Shem and Ever, and derives that Yaakov's toil in Torah caused Yishmael's death.
-
36:56 Toras chesed: learning with others
The Mashgiach brings Chazal that Torah taught to others is 'Toras chesed', and the passuk of the rich and poor meeting, where Hashem made both. He calls for renewing the program in which older bachurim give half an hour to learn with weaker younger ones, since bachurim can give tzedakah with their Torah and time.
-
40:52 The chassid who gives of himself
The Mashgiach brings a saying comparing the chassid to sugar that dissolves into the tea, and a saying in the name of the Ba'al HaTanya on burning nail clippings even at a cost to oneself. He adds that giving time to another does not make one poorer, citing the Gemara on tzedakah and the early chassidim who spent hours on tefillah.
-
44:23 Tzaddik ben rasha as shaliach tzibur
The Mashgiach asks how Rashi's 'the prayer of a tzaddik ben tzaddik is not like that of a tzaddik ben rasha' fits with the halachah preferring a shaliach tzibur without yichus. He answers that in tefillah b'tzibur all merits combine, so nothing is lost and the merit of drawing near the distant is added, and he urges drawing in bachurim without family advantages.
-
49:12 Avraham born in hiding from the Satan
The Mashgiach brings the Arizal that Avraham's holy soul came into a lowly family because the Satan blocked it, as he blocks Moshiach, and that Yaakov's blessings likewise came only through a ruse. Avraham had to break through the coarseness of his upbringing, and the Mashgiach brings a similar saying from a great tzaddik about his own father.
-
52:25 Breaking through the darkness; new light in Kislev
The Mashgiach describes the darkness of the present generation, flooded with foreign culture and ideas, as the demolition before the building, to be broken through with Torah and tzedakah. He closes with Chanukah and Kislev: each night a new light, and lighting another's candle does not diminish one's own.
The shiur, written up
Yishmael's fall and the toldos of Yitzchak
The Mashgiach brings the Bnei Yissaschar on why the Torah reading of Rosh Hashanah tells of Hashem's promise to make Yishmael a great nation: it arouses mercy, for if Yishmael receives such abundance only because he is Avraham's son, Yaakov's children surely deserve far more blessing. a,b
He then brings the Ba'al HaTurim on the last passuk of Chayei Sarah, 'al pnei chol echav nafal', placed beside 'Eleh toldos Yitzchak': when Yishmael falls at the end of days, ben Dovid will sprout from Yitzchak. This, the Mashgiach says, explains the name Toldos. The sedra's theme is Yaakov receiving the blessings in Esav's garments, and the Midrash reads 'his garments' as 'his traitors'. Inwardly they are Yaakov's; only outwardly do they wear Esav's clothes, and as Avraham's children they still merit the blessing. c,d,e,f
Bread and water for the enemy
Rabbeinu Bachya on Vayera says Avraham foresaw that no nation would hate Israel like Yishmael, and so, following Mishlei's counsel to give an enemy bread and water, he sent him off with bread and water and made him great. The Mashgiach explains that this galus, though physically lighter than the galus of Edom, is spiritually the lowest, since in it the maidservant inherits her mistress and holiness is trampled. g,h,j
An empty bris for an empty land
Why did Bnei Yishmael merit Eretz Yisrael? The Zohar answers: through their milah, but because it is an empty milah, they received the land empty. A Jew's bris, the Mashgiach explains, does not end with the cut; it is a lifelong guarding of the eyes, the tongue and the bris, while Yishmael's contains nothing. i
'Drive out the maidservant' and the accusation at the ketz
The Rosh Hashanah reading tells how Sarah demanded that Avraham drive Yishmael out, for the maidservant's son will not inherit with Yitzchak, and Rashi stresses that this holds whatever Yitzchak's state. Today the nations argue the reverse, that Jews should be driven from Eretz Yisrael, and the Mashgiach asks why this comes in our generation. k,l
He explains the two kinds of geulah time in 'b'itah achishenah': a fixed time, and times when tzaddikim saw the geulah could come. When such a time passes without Moshiach, things become worse, because then the Satan accuses that Israel is unworthy. So, he says, the years of Tach brought terrible decrees instead of geulah, and a time awaited in the 1940s brought the deportations. m
A ketz in the air
The Mashgiach brings a ketz mentioned in the Ta'amei HaMitzvos of Rabbi Chaim Vital. He does not calculate ketzin, he says, but must ask whether we are ready to greet Moshiach. Even the world's experts describe a powder keg that could explode. n
He tells of the Chofetz Chaim, who in tiny Radin gave a drashah when the Mississippi flooded far away, calling it a sign to do teshuvah. When the whole world speaks of something, the Mashgiach says, something is happening.
Demolition before building
The world before Moshiach will be degenerate in every area, the Mashgiach explains, because the old is torn down to build the new. Rabbeinu Bachya says the nations will one day agree to Yaakov's blessings, and today's universal agreement that Eretz Yisrael belongs to Yishmael may be the reversal before that. He cites Rabbi Yehuda HaLevi's poem in which the maidservant claims her mistress's place. o
Yishmael therefore had to become great, the Mashgiach concludes, because one who is to fall is first made great. The greater his fall, the greater the sprouting of ben Dovid from Yitzchak.
Torah and tzedakah; Yaakov's learning and Yishmael's death
If Moshiach may be near, each person must do his part. Israel is redeemed through tzedakah and, as the Or HaChaim brings, through Torah; so the Mashgiach says Moshiach is brought not by gatherings in squares but by learning and giving tzedakah. p,q
Why does the Torah give Yishmael's age at his death? Rashi says it is to calculate Yaakov's years, revealing fourteen years at the yeshiva of Shem and Ever. The Mashgiach adds that Yishmael died exactly when Yaakov began toiling there, so Yaakov's Torah caused Yishmael's fall, and this is how the geulah is brought. r,s
Toras chesed: learning with others
On 'Toras chesed', Chazal say Torah taught to others is Torah of chesed. On 'the rich and the poor meet, Hashem made them all', the Mashgiach explains that the one able to learn should teach the one who cannot, since Hashem could have reversed their gifts. t,u,v
He recalls a yeshiva program in which older bachurim gave half an hour to learn with struggling younger ones, and says it should be renewed: bachurim have no money for tzedakah, but they can give it with their Torah and their time.
The chassid who gives of himself
The Mashgiach brings a saying that the chassid is like sugar that dissolves into the tea, while another is like rock candy that stays whole. In the name of the Ba'al HaTanya he explains the Gemara's ranking on nail clippings: the chassid burns them even at a cost to himself. A little time for another, he adds, makes no one poorer, as with tzedakah, and the early chassidim spent hours on tefillah yet succeeded in their learning. w,x,y
Tzaddik ben rasha as shaliach tzibur
On Yitzchak and Rivkah's tefillah Rashi says Hashem answered Yitzchak, for the prayer of a tzaddik ben tzaddik exceeds that of a tzaddik ben rasha. Yet the Shulchan Aruch prefers a shaliach tzibur without yichus, because of 'shalom shalom larachok v'lakarov'. z,aa,ab
The Mashgiach answers that a tzibur davens as one body, with every merit combined through the shaliach tzibur, so nothing is lost and drawing near the distant is added. Yitzchak and Rivkah davened as individuals. He urges drawing in bachurim lacking yichus or family advantages.
Avraham born in hiding from the Satan
Citing the Arizal, the Mashgiach explains that Avraham's soul came into a lowly family because the Satan, who blocks Moshiach, would otherwise have blocked it; likewise Yaakov's blessings came through a ruse. Avraham had to break through the coarseness of his home, and a great tzaddik said the same of his own upbringing.
New light in Kislev
Never, the Mashgiach says, was there such darkness, with foreign culture entering Jewish homes; this is demolition before building, to be broken through with tzedakah, time and Torah. Yishmael's reading still echoes from Rosh Hashanah.
Chanukah brings a new light each night, the light of Torah. In Kislev, he says, each should kindle another's candle, for that does not diminish his own.
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
- f Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 2:37
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
- d apparently Ba'al HaTurim on Bereishis 25:18 index In the write-up: 2:37
- g apparently Rabbeinu Bachya on Bereishis 21:14 index In the write-up: 5:58
- l apparently Rashi on Bereishis 21:10 index In the write-up: 13:35
- o Rabbeinu Bachya (place not identified) index In the write-up: 25:39
- s apparently Rashi on Bereishis 25:17 index In the write-up: 32:23
- z apparently Rashi on Bereishis 25:21 index In the write-up: 44:28
Acharonim and Chassidus
Other
Key points
- 2:37 Following the Ba'al HaTurim, the fall of Yishmael ('al pnei chol echav nafal') is the signal for the rise of Yitzchak's line and the coming of Moshiach ben Dovid.
- 5:08 Yishmael's great success comes only because he is a child of Avraham, so Avraham's true children, Yitzchak's seed, will surely receive blessing even when they seem clothed in Esav's garments.
- 8:22 The galus of Yishmael, though physically lighter than the galus of Edom, is spiritually the lowest, because it is a maidservant taking over from her mistress.
- 28:59 Yishmael was made so great in our time so that his fall should be great, and the greater the fall, the greater the rise of Yitzchak's line, the sprouting of ben Dovid.
- 34:47 Yishmael died when Yaakov began toiling in Torah at the house of Shem and Ever, which shows that Yaakov's Torah brings Yishmael's fall and the geulah.
- 31:53 Israel is redeemed through Torah and tzedakah, and Torah taught to others is 'Toras chesed', a form of tzedakah that even bachurim without money can give.
- 46:11 In tefillah b'tzibur the merits of everyone combine, so choosing a tzaddik ben rasha as shaliach tzibur loses nothing and adds the merit of drawing near the distant.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 0:55 Why is the passage of Yishmael's success read on Rosh Hashanah?
Answer: 1:01 To arouse mercy: if Avraham's son Yishmael receives such blessing, the children of Yaakov surely deserve much more.
-
Question: 10:09 Why did Bnei Yishmael merit to hold Eretz Yisrael?
Answer: 10:14 Because of their milah, but since it is an empty milah, they received the land empty.
-
Question: 28:59 Why did Yishmael have to become so great in our time?
Answer: 29:02 Because his fall is the signal for the geulah, and one who is to fall is first made great, so that the fall and the rise of Yitzchak's line will be great.
-
Question: 32:31 Why does the Torah tell us how old Yishmael was when he died?
Answer: 32:52 Rashi says it is to calculate Yaakov's years, revealing that he spent fourteen years learning at Shem and Ever.
-
Question: 44:53 If the prayer of a tzaddik ben tzaddik is greater, why does the halachah prefer a shaliach tzibur without yichus?
Answer: 46:02 Because in a tzibur all the merits combine, so the tzaddik ben tzaddik's power is still there, and choosing the one without yichus adds the merit of drawing near the distant.
Stories
-
23:37 The Chofetz Chaim and the Mississippi flood
The Mashgiach heard from someone who was there that many years earlier the Mississippi flooded, thousands of miles away. In Radin, a small town, the Chofetz Chaim gave a drashah about it, saying that when people are killed in such a disaster it is a sign that teshuvah is needed. The Mashgiach notes that the Chofetz Chaim was perhaps the only one in Radin who had even heard of the Mississippi.
In the story: the Chofetz Chaim, Rabbi Avraham Kalmanowitz, Rav Yaakov Kamenetsky
Insights
- 3:31 The Mashgiach reads the name 'Toldos' as the theme of the whole sedra: the inner reality of Yaakov's children is not Esav's garments they appear to wear, and their blessing comes from being Avraham's children.
- 10:22 Yishmael's hold on Eretz Yisrael matches his bris: an empty milah earns an empty land, while a Jew's bris is a lifelong guarding of eyes, tongue and bris.
- 16:51 A time ripe for geulah that passes unused does not leave things as they were; because the Satan accuses at such a time, it brings harsher decrees.
- 26:19 The world-wide agreement that Eretz Yisrael belongs to Yishmael may itself be the reversal before the geulah, just as the nations will soon agree to Yaakov's blessings.
- 35:09 From Rashi's calculation the Mashgiach derives that Yaakov's beginning of Torah toil at Shem and Ever is what caused Yishmael's death, so Yishmael's fall comes through Jewish Torah study.
- 40:09 Bachurim, who have no money for tzedakah, can still join in the two things that redeem Israel, since teaching Torah to another is itself chesed.
- 46:04 Rashi's ranking of a tzaddik ben tzaddik applies to an individual's tefillah, but in a tzibur everyone's merits pass through the shaliach tzibur, so a tzaddik ben rasha at the amud adds the merit of drawing near the distant.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 32:03 The Mashgiach says Moshiach is brought not by rallies or other activities but by learning Torah and giving tzedakah.
- 39:14 He calls for older bachurim to give some of their time to learn with younger bachurim who find learning hard.
- 48:11 He urges drawing in bachurim who lack yichus or family advantages.
- 55:34 In Kislev, he says, each person should kindle a new light of Torah in another Jew, since lighting another's candle does not diminish one's own.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Esav, Ever, Rabbeinu Bachya, Rabbi Chaim Vital, Rabbi Shlomo of Karlin, Rabbi Yehuda HaLevi, Rashi, Rivka Imeinu, Sarah Imeinu, Shem, the Arizal, the Baal HaTurim, the Bnei Yissaschar (Rabbi Tzvi Elimelech of Dinov), the Chofetz Chaim, the Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh, Yaakov Avinu, Yishmael, Yitzchak Avinu
Terms בעתה אחישנה, יגיעה, ישיבת שם ועבר, קטרוג, רבונו של עולם, שליח ציבור