התורה מודיע שישמעאל מת (מפלתו). ורש"י מגלה שזה בגלל שיעקב למד תורה
Catalog entry: פרשת השבוע תולדות no. 5 Pocket Guide p. 6 תשמ"א (1980–81) Yiddish 1 hr
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains why the Torah reveals Yaakov's years of learning in Beis Ever only through the count of Yishmael's years: the fall of Yishmael depends on Yaakov taking on the yoke of Torah, and the fire Yishmael holds belongs to the children of Yitzchak.
The Mashgiach opens with the closing verses of Chayei Sarah, where Yishmael 'fell', and the Baal HaTurim's remark that when Yishmael falls at the end of days Moshiach will sprout from the offspring of Yitzchak. Rashi at the end of Toldos derives from Yishmael's years that Yaakov hid fourteen years in Beis Ever. The Mashgiach asks why the Torah teaches this only through Yishmael, and why Moshiach is tied to Yitzchak. He answers that Yishmael died just when Yaakov went to learn: the fall of Yishmael depends on the Jews accepting the yoke of Torah. Yitzchak is the attribute of fire, the fire of the mizbeach and of 'Bereishis'; today Yishmael controls fire and energy and the place of the mizbeach, and when he falls he must return it to Yitzchak's children. He then explains Yitzchak's tefillah as praise sung before the salvation, the passing of a tzaddik as the day all his days gather, Yaakov's growth at Avraham's passing and Esav's at Nimrod's, and closes on toiling to dig the well within.
Topics: The Exiles and Their Kingdoms · The Power and Greatness of Torah · Signs of the Generation Before Moshiach
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Yishmael's fall and Yaakov's hidden years listed in the guide
The Mashgiach links the opening of Toldos to the end of Chayei Sarah, where Yishmael 'fell', and brings the Baal HaTurim that Moshiach comes from Yitzchak's offspring when Yishmael falls. He then lays out Rashi's calculation from Yishmael's years that Yaakov spent fourteen years in Beis Ever.
-
4:41 Two questions, and Yishmael's power today listed in the guide
The Mashgiach asks why the Torah teaches Yaakov's learning only through Yishmael, and why the Baal HaTurim ties Moshiach to Yitzchak rather than to Avraham or Yaakov. He then shows how 'his hand against all and all hands against him' is being fulfilled today, as all nations must come to the Arab lands for oil.
-
10:04 Torah learning brings Yishmael's fall listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that the final exile is that of Yishmael, who holds Eretz Yisroel in the merit of milah, and that Torah brings Moshiach. Yishmael died exactly when Yaakov went to learn, a sign for his descendants: when Yishmael is at his height, his fall comes when Yaakov's children accept the yoke of Torah.
-
17:53 Yitzchak and the fire of the mizbeach
Avraham is chesed, water; Yitzchak is gevurah, fire. The Mashgiach finds the mizbeach and its fire in the word 'Bereishis', ties fire to the creation with midas hadin and to the Akeidah on the place of the mizbeach, and says that in Moshiach's days the world will be led with midas hadin.
-
22:40 Yishmael holds fire that is not his
Today the element of fire, energy, is in Yishmael's hands, and so is the place of the mizbeach. The Mashgiach explains that fire belongs to Yitzchak, and when Yishmael falls he will have to return what he took to the children of Yitzchak; this is why Moshiach is tied to 'the offspring of Yitzchak'.
-
26:47 Barrenness for the sake of tefillah
On 'Vaye'tar Yitzchak', the Mashgiach brings Rabbeinu Bachya that tefillah is the first cause: Hashem desires the prayers of tzaddikim, so Rivkah was barren in order that they daven. Every tefillah of a Jew is accepted, and twenty years of their tefillos became a store of prayer for Klal Yisroel.
-
30:26 Praise before the salvation
From an acrostic in the machzor, Yitzchak on one side and Rivkah on the other, the Mashgiach reads 'opposite his wife' and explains that their tefillah was not crying but songs of praise with trust. Tzaddikim thank Hashem in advance, as in the words said before Kiddush and in Modim, and the women at the sea prepared drums before the salvation.
-
36:54 Thirteen or fifteen, and Elisha's double portion
Rashi says 'the lads grew' means age thirteen, yet Avraham died when they were fifteen. The Mashgiach turns to Elisha's request for a double portion and explains that on the day of a person's passing all his days gather together, as with Moshe Rabbeinu, the end of Shabbos and Shemini Atzeres, so at that moment a double portion can be given.
-
43:08 Every tzaddik and his counterpart
The Mashgiach brings the Chasam Sofer's regret at missing his rebbe's passing, and the Gemara about Rabbi Yehoshua ben Chananya and the heretics, to show that for every tzaddik there is a rasha of equal strength. Avraham's lifelong war was with Nimrod, who was killed the day Avraham died, and Esav likewise died the day of Yaakov's burial.
-
49:49 The day both lads grew
Yaakov, at fifteen, was present at Avraham's passing and received a double portion of holiness, while Esav, who killed Nimrod that day, drew Nimrod's power of tumah onto himself. So 'the lads grew' was fulfilled that day, and this is why Yaakov told Esav to sell the birthright 'as of this day'.
-
53:40 Blessings come through digging
Toldos is a parsha of blessings, given on the night of Pesach according to Targum Yonasan, and this Shabbos brings blessings to every Jew who wants them. Through the dreams of the butler and the baker the Mashgiach shows that one must work for it, and like the Avos digging wells, each person must dig to reach the living water of his soul.
The shiur, written up
Yishmael's fall and Yaakov's hidden years
The Mashgiach notes that the opening of Toldos follows the last verse of Chayei Sarah, where Yishmael 'fell', and Rashi explains that this word, in place of 'dwelt', marks Yishmael's fall. The Baal HaTurim learns from the juxtaposition that when Yishmael falls at the end of days, the son of David will sprout from the offspring of Yitzchak. a,b
Two questions, and Yishmael's power today
The Mashgiach asks why the Torah lets us know about Yaakov's learning only through Yishmael's years, when it could simply have said it. He also asks why the Baal HaTurim ties Moshiach to Yitzchak: Jews are called children of Avraham or of Yaakov, not of Yitzchak, and the Torah is exact in every detail. b
Torah learning brings Yishmael's fall
The Mashgiach says the Zohar teaches that the final exile is that of Yishmael, who holds Eretz Yisroel in the merit of milah until the Jews take it from him, and that he will not let it go easily at the end of the exile. In our time, small as we are, the keys of the geulah have been handed to us, and Torah and good deeds can hasten it. h
He brings the Ohr HaChaim in Vayechi that Moshiach comes in the merit of Torah, and finds a hint of it here: Yishmael died exactly when Yaakov went to learn. The deeds of the Avos are a sign for their children, and Yishmael's life foreshadows his descendants. i
This answers the first question. Knowing only that Yishmael died, we would not know why; the missing fourteen years reveal that his fall came because Yaakov took on the yoke of Torah. So when Yishmael reaches his height at the end of days, his fall will come when Yaakov's children accept the yoke of Torah.
Yitzchak and the fire of the mizbeach
To explain why Yitzchak, the Mashgiach says Avraham is chesed, water, and Yitzchak is gevurah, fire. Fire first appears in the word 'Bereishis': the Gemara reads it as the shafts beneath the mizbeach, where the eternal fire burns. The Zohar reads it as a covenant of fire, and Rashi says the world was first meant to be created with midas hadin, which is fire. j,l,m,k
Yishmael holds fire that is not his
Today, the Mashgiach says, the element of fire, energy, has been given to Yishmael, and anyone who needs fire must come to him. Yishmael also holds the place of the mizbeach on the Temple Mount. But fire is not his; it belongs to Yitzchak.
Barrenness for the sake of tefillah
On 'Yitzchak entreated Hashem opposite his wife, for she was barren', the Mashgiach brings Rabbeinu Bachya: the verse puts the tefillah first because it was the first cause. Hashem desires the prayers of tzaddikim, so Rivkah was barren in order that they would daven, as the Gemara says. o,p,q
No tefillah is lost; even prayers without kavanah are raised by one with kavanah. Their twenty years of tefillos became a reserve for Klal Yisroel.
Praise before the salvation
The Mashgiach points to a page in the Rosh Hashanah machzor printed in two columns: one spells Yitzchak from the initials of words for the righteous, the other spells Rivkah from words of praise. This is Yitzchak 'opposite his wife'.
One might think they pleaded with a broken heart. The Mashgiach suggests their tefillah was of another kind: songs of praise, as tzaddikim with bitachon trust that Hashem, like a merciful father, will help. Tzaddikim thank Hashem in advance, as one says before Kiddush, thanking Him for kindness He will do. r
Thirteen or fifteen, and Elisha's double portion
On 'the lads grew', Rashi says they were thirteen. Yet Avraham died when they were fifteen; the Mizrachi's answer is questioned, and Rabbeinu Bachya says they were fifteen. u,v,w,x
The Mashgiach turns to Elisha's request for a double portion of Eliyahu's spirit. How can one give double what he has? Eliyahu answered that if Elisha saw him taken, he would receive it. y
Moshe said 'I am a hundred and twenty years old today': on the day of his passing all his years gathered into that day, and so he is called 'man of G-d' then. Likewise the end of Shabbos and Shemini Atzeres hold everything that came before. At the moment of passing, Eliyahu could give double. z,aa
Every tzaddik and his counterpart
The Chasam Sofer, in a hesped for his rebbe Rav Nosson Adler, regretted not being present at his passing, for he would then have become twice as great. ab
Against every tzaddik stands a rasha of equal strength. The Gemara tells that Rabbi Yehoshua ben Chananya answered students who asked who would stand against the heretics: when he goes, they go, like Esav's words 'I will go opposite you'. ac,ad
Avraham's counterpart was Nimrod. Avraham made Hashem known as G-d of the earth, as Rashi says; Nimrod led the world to rebel and threw Avraham into the fire, and Rashi identifies him with Amrafel. Chazal say Esav killed Nimrod the day Avraham died. So too Esav died the day of Yaakov's burial, as Rivkah said, 'Why should I be bereaved of you both in one day?' ae,af,ag
The day both lads grew
Blessings come through digging
The Mashgiach calls Toldos a parsha of blessings, received on the night of Pesach according to Targum Yonasan. This Shabbos great blessings come to every Jew who wants them, since the parsha is relived each week, but one must work for them. aj
Sources
Torah
- f Bereishis 16:12 text index In the write-up: 7:33
- l Vayikra 6:6 text index In the write-up: 18:24
- o Bereishis 25:21 text index In the write-up: 26:50
- t Shemos 15:20 text index In the write-up: 35:25
- u Bereishis 25:27 text index In the write-up: 37:12
- z Devarim 31:2 text index In the write-up: 39:36
- aa Devarim 33:1 text index In the write-up: 39:36
- ad Bereishis 33:12 text index In the write-up: 43:55
- ag Bereishis 27:45 text index In the write-up: 45:54
- ai Bereishis 25:31 text index In the write-up: 52:20
- ak apparently Bereishis 40:9-19 index In the write-up: 55:49
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Targum
Talmud Bavli
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
- a Rashi on Bereishis 25:18 text index In the write-up: 0:10
- b apparently Baal HaTurim, Bereishis 25:18-19 index In the write-up: 0:10, 4:46, 26:04
- c Rashi on Bereishis 28:9 text index In the write-up: 3:07
- d Rashi on Bereishis 25:17 text index In the write-up: 3:07
- k Rashi on Bereishis 1:1 text index In the write-up: 18:24
- n apparently Rambam, Hilchos Beis HaBechirah ch. 2 index In the write-up: 21:39
- p apparently Rabbeinu Bachya, Bereishis 25:21 index In the write-up: 26:50
- v Rashi on Bereishis 25:27 text index In the write-up: 37:12
- w apparently Mizrachi on Rashi, Bereishis 25:27 index In the write-up: 37:12
- x apparently Rabbeinu Bachya, Bereishis 25:27 index In the write-up: 37:12
- ae Rashi on Bereishis 24:7 text index In the write-up: 45:54
- af Rashi on Bereishis 14:1 text index In the write-up: 45:54
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 3:07 Rashi learns from the count of Yishmael's years that Yaakov spent fourteen hidden years learning in Beis Ever, and Yishmael died exactly when Yaakov left for Charan.
- 13:23 The Torah ties the two facts together to teach that the fall of Yishmael depends on Yaakov, and his children, accepting the yoke of Torah.
- 18:34 Yitzchak is the attribute of fire and of the mizbeach; the fire Yishmael controls today is not his, and when he falls he must return it to the children of Yitzchak.
- 27:24 Rivkah was barren so that Yitzchak would daven; tefillah is the first cause, and every tefillah of a Jew is accepted and stored.
- 32:15 The tefillah of tzaddikim is song and thanks before the salvation, out of trust that Hashem will help.
- 40:08 On the day of a person's passing all the days of his life gather together, which is why one present at a tzaddik's passing can receive a double portion.
- 55:34 The blessings of the parsha come only to one who works for them, like digging a well to reach living water.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 4:46 Why does the Torah let us know that Yaakov learned in Beis Ever only through the count of Yishmael's years, instead of saying it directly?
Answer: 13:23 To show that Yishmael's fall came about because Yaakov accepted the yoke of Torah at that very time.
-
Question: 5:58 Why does the Baal HaTurim say Moshiach will sprout from the offspring of Yitzchak, and not from Avraham or Yaakov?
Answer: 24:31 Because Yishmael now holds the fire that belongs to Yitzchak, and when he falls he must return it to Yitzchak's children.
-
Question: 27:08 Why does the verse put Yitzchak's tefillah before 'for she was barren'?
Answer: 27:24 Rabbeinu Bachya explains that the tefillah is the first cause: Hashem wanted their tefillah, so Rivkah was made barren.
-
Question: 39:12 How could Eliyahu give Elisha double of what he himself had?
Answer: 40:08 At the moment of passing all of a person's days gather together, so then he can give double.
-
Question: 37:25 Rashi says 'the lads grew' at thirteen, but Avraham died when they were fifteen; how does this fit?
Answer: 52:20 On the day of Avraham's passing, at fifteen, both lads grew: Yaakov in holiness and Esav in tumah.
Stories
-
9:39 His rebbe's chumash class on Yishmael's greatness
The Mashgiach recalls that his rebbe, Reb Mendlowitz, used to learn chumash with the students. When they reached the verse that Yishmael would become great, someone asked when this would happen, since Yishmael had never been great. The Mashgiach says it came about much faster than had been imagined.
In the story: Rav Shraga Feivel Mendlowitz
-
44:04 Rabbi Yehoshua ben Chananya's passing
Rabbi Yehoshua ben Chananya used to debate the heretics. When he was about to pass away his students asked who would now stand up to them. He answered that if he goes away, they go away too: the heretics were as great as he was, and when he departs they must diminish as well.
In the story: Rabbi Yehoshua ben Chananya
Insights
- 15:25 The Torah hides the fact of Yaakov's fourteen years in Beis Ever inside the count of Yishmael's years to teach that Yishmael's death came about through Yaakov accepting the yoke of Torah.
- 22:50 The Mashgiach reads Yishmael's control of oil and energy as holding the element of fire, which belongs to Yitzchak; this explains why the Baal HaTurim links Yishmael's fall to the sprouting of Moshiach from Yitzchak's offspring.
- 30:53 A machzor acrostic spells Yitzchak in one column and Rivkah opposite it in words of praise, showing that their prayer 'opposite each other' was praise sung before the salvation.
- 40:08 On the day of passing all of a person's days gather into one, so Eliyahu could give Elisha double what he had only at the moment he was taken.
- 52:20 Rashi's 'thirteen' and the fact that Avraham died when they were fifteen are reconciled: on the day of Avraham's passing Yaakov grew in holiness and Esav, killing Nimrod, grew in tumah, so 'the lads grew' happened that day.
- 56:03 Pharaoh's butler dreamed of working the grapes into wine, a healthy dream of toil, while the baker dreamed of bread growing on his head; the Mashgiach reads the different outcomes as the difference between working for something and wishing for it.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 12:04 The Mashgiach says that in our generation the keys of the geulah are in our hands, and good deeds and Torah can bring it sooner.
- 33:09 The Mashgiach teaches that a Jew should thank Hashem constantly, even in advance, for the miracles and kindness He does with him.
- 57:18 The Mashgiach says one must prepare for Shabbos already from Thursday, toiling in Gemara and in davening with kavanah, also when it is hard.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Elisha HaNavi, Eliyahu HaNavi, Esav, Moshe Rabbeinu, Nimrod, Rabbeinu Bachya, Rabbi Nosson Adler, Rabbi Yehoshua ben Chananya, Rashi, Rav Shraga Feivel Mendlowitz, Rivka Imeinu, the Baal HaTurim, the Chasam Sofer, Yaakov Avinu, Yishmael, Yitzchak Avinu
Terms הסתלקות, ישיבת שם ועבר, מדת הדין, מקום המקדש, עקרה, עשו, פי שנים