שהיו ליצני הדור אומרים. . . הגריעותא של ליצנות
Catalog entry: פרשת השבוע תולדות no. 3 Pocket Guide p. 5 תשל"ז (1976–77) Yiddish 1 hr 10 min
Listen
About this shiur
Starting from Rashi's 'the scoffers of the generation', the Mashgiach explains leitzanus as the root of tumah and the opposite of emunah, and traces it through Pharaoh, the nachash and Esav, against the truth of Avraham, Yaakov and Moshiach.
The Mashgiach asks why Rashi speaks of 'the scoffers of the generation' rather than its tzaddikim, and answers from the sefarim that emunah opens kedusha while leitzanus opens tumah. A joke, he explains, is laughter at what is absurd and untrue; leitzanus lets a person deny reality, which is how Pharaoh withstood plague after plague. Emunah is the opposite: the spark of kedusha in a person draws him to greater kedusha, as Elisha was drawn after Eliyahu, as a magnet draws iron. From the Rambam's ruling that Moshiach need not show signs, the Mashgiach explains that Moshiach, like Avraham and unlike Eliyahu at Carmel, will draw the world by the truth of his words alone. Esav, born sixty years after Yitzchak, is the root of leitzanus. The Mashgiach then explains Yaakov's 'mirmah' as a se'ir la'azazel directed by prophecy, and ends with the brachos of the parsha.
Topics: Doubts in Emunah and Amalek · Yitzchak, Yaakov and Esav
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Why 'the scoffers of the generation' listed in the guide
The Mashgiach opens with Rashi that the scoffers of the generation said Sarah conceived from Avimelech, and asks why Chazal speak of scoffers rather than tzaddikim of the generation. He brings from the sefarim that emunah begins kedusha and leitzanus begins tumah, and that leitzanus is the opposite of truth.
-
3:29 What makes people laugh listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that a joke is funny because it is absurd and far from reality, and that a person has a power that takes pleasure in the opposite of truth. This is also why people laugh at a madman, who lives in a world of fantasy away from reality.
-
6:37 Pharaoh the scoffer and the plagues listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings Rashi that Hashem 'mocked' Mitzrayim and the Chasam Sofer that Egypt's whole success through Yosef and his family was a joke played on it, measure for measure for Pharaoh's leitzanus. He asks where Chazal saw that Pharaoh was a scoffer, and answers that only leitzanus, which escapes reality with a joke, let him hold out against plague after plague.
-
12:05 Leitzanus, the opposite of emunah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that leitzanus denies what the mind itself sees while emunah believes beyond what is seen, so leitzanus is the root of tumah. Hashem answers scoffers with mockery; one jest pushes away much rebuke; leitzanus is the opposite of Yaakov's truth. The nachash, the first scoffer, answered Chava's reasoning with mockery.
-
16:11 The spark of kedusha and the magnet
The Mashgiach explains that emunah comes from the spark of kedusha that gives every creation its existence, which is drawn to greater kedusha. Scoffers mock when a tzaddik passes; Elisha ran after Eliyahu as iron to a magnet, and a strong enough magnet draws even weaker metal. Ehrliche Yidden are drawn to tzaddikim of every kind, those one understands and those one does not.
-
22:01 The Rambam: Moshiach needs no signs
The Mashgiach reads the Rambam in Hilchos Melachim that Moshiach need not perform signs and wonders, since Rabbi Akiva served Ben Koziva as Moshiach, and the Raavad's gloss. He contrasts this with the grand picture of Moshiach Yidden carried through galus at the Shabbos table, and says the Rambam's plain description can seem a disappointment.
-
28:35 Eliyahu's miracle and Avraham's word
The Mashgiach explains that the Rambam's view of Moshiach is in fact very great. Eliyahu needed fire from heaven to bring the people to say Hashem is G-d, while Avraham Avinu made Hashem known on earth without miracles, through the truth and power of his person; true words enter the heart. He adds a story of a man whose doubts in emunah dissolved through words of truth.
-
35:08 Moshiach's greatest miracle
The Mashgiach explains that the Rambam rules only that Moshiach need not show signs: his word will slay the kefirah in people's hearts, and his miracle will be turning all nations to call in Hashem's name and bringing all Yidden to Eretz Yisrael by his word alone. Eliyahu, who needed a miracle, will be Moshiach's armor-bearer, as Rabbi Akiva was Ben Koziva's; emunah is the power to follow beyond the mind, and leitzanus its opposite.
-
43:00 Esav the scoffer and the bechorah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings that Esav is called 'shav', the opposite of Yaakov's truth, and is the nachash itself. Among Esav's sins was despising the bechorah, yet he later wept over the brachos; the Mashgiach answers that Esav truly believed, having grown up in Yitzchak's holy home, but mocked his belief away. This is why Adar, whose sense is laughter, is the month that defeats Esav and Amalek.
-
48:51 Esav's birth and the scoffers' answer listed in the guide
The Mashgiach returns to Rashi: when Esav, root of leitzanus and of the kelipah of Amalek, was about to be born, the scoffers of the generation had to be answered, so Hashem made Yitzchak's face like Avraham's. Esav was punished by mockery, as Pharaoh was: he planned with Yitzchak that whoever came with Yaakov's voice would be Esav, so when Yaakov came with his own voice the plan turned against Esav.
-
53:11 'Bemirmah' and the portion of the sitra achra
On 'your brother came bemirmah', the Mashgiach brings the Targum 'with wisdom' and the Midrash 'with the wisdom of his Torah'. He explains that tumah must exist until it is removed from the earth, so the Torah directs giving it a measured portion, as with the seudah at a siyum and the se'ir la'azazel, which the Ramban explains is sent to the sitra achra and would be idolatry without the Torah's command.
-
57:31 Shadchan money, Rivka's prophecy and Yaakov
From the Zohar that every year Yaakov receives the brachos on Rosh Hashanah and a gift is sent to Esav on Yom Kippur, the Mashgiach explains Rabbi Yaakov Emden on shadchan money: since Hashem makes the match, the shadchan's fee is the portion thrown to the other side. Yitzchak and Rivka's holy shidduch needed none, but Yaakov's brachos did; Yaakov, who would never lie, did so only because Rivka told him it came by prophecy, so Yitzchak found no opposition.
-
1:05:18 Esav's material brachos and Yaakov's bracha
The Mashgiach explains that the 'mirmah' nullified the accusation, and that the wisdom of the Torah measures when it is allowed. Esav's brachos were only material, and he was given Italia shel Yavan, which did not yet exist, while Yaakov's bracha 'v'yiten lecha haElokim' was Torah and Hashem Himself. He closes that this parsha of the brachos gives strength to go with Elokus and that the main bracha is to feel Hashem and Moshiach.
The shiur, written up
Why 'the scoffers of the generation'
The Mashgiach opens with Rashi: the scoffers of the generation said that Sarah had conceived from Avimelech. The expression is striking, he says, since one usually speaks of the tzaddikim of a generation. He brings from the sefarim that everything in kedusha has a counterpart in tumah: kedusha begins with emunah, and tumah begins with leitzanus, scoffing, which is the opposite of truth. a
What makes people laugh
Why does one laugh at a joke? Because it is absurd and holds no truth; the further from reality, the better the joke. The Mashgiach says there is a power in a person that takes satisfaction in the opposite of truth. That is why people laugh even at the sight of a madman, who has left reality for a world of fantasy.
Pharaoh the scoffer and the plagues
Rashi explains that Hashem 'mocked' Mitzrayim, and the Chasam Sofer explains the joke: Egypt thought it had succeeded through Yosef and his family, who made it a leading land, yet the whole matter ended with the Yidden taking out its wealth. This was measure for measure, for Pharaoh was a scoffer. b,c
Where did Chazal see that? Pharaoh saw the hand of Hashem already at the third plague; only leitzanus, which escapes reality, let him hold out. After each blow a good joke gave his people relief and the courage to keep resisting.
Leitzanus, the opposite of emunah
Emunah believes what one does not see; leitzanus does not believe even what the mind says, which is why it is the root of tumah. Hashem answers scoffers in kind, as Mishlei and Tehillim say, and one jest pushes away many rebukes, as Mesilas Yesharim notes. The nachash, the first scoffer, met Chava's words with mockery instead of argument. d,e,f
The spark of kedusha and the magnet
Emunah comes from a person's inner point, drawn to what is akin to it. Every creation, even the forces of tumah, exists only through a spark of kedusha from the word of Hashem, since falsehood has no existence of its own. So people are drawn when great kedusha appears, while the scoffer mocks a passing tzaddik. h
The Rambam: Moshiach needs no signs
The Rambam in Hilchos Melachim writes that one should not think Moshiach must perform signs and wonders, for Rabbi Akiva served as armor-bearer to Ben Koziva and the sages thought him Moshiach until it became clear he was not. The Mashgiach also brings the Raavad's gloss there. k,l
In galus, he says, Yidden sustained themselves with talk of Moshiach at the Shabbos table: how he would show great wonders and, as the Midrash on 'yarum v'nisa v'gavah me'od' says, be greater than Avraham and Moshe. Beside this, the Rambam's Moshiach, a king who learns Torah, fights Hashem's wars and builds the Mikdash, with no change in nature, can seem a disappointment. o,p,m,n
Eliyahu's miracle and Avraham's word
Yet the Rambam's view is very great. In Eliyahu's time Yidden served Baal, and only seven thousand had not bowed to it; Eliyahu needed fire from heaven before the people cried out that Hashem is G-d. q,r
Avraham Avinu did this without a miracle. As Rashi explains, he made Hashem, until then G-d of the heavens, known as G-d of the earth too. His face shone with kedusha and his true words entered every heart, so a word sufficed where Eliyahu needed a miracle. The Mashgiach recalls a story of a man whose doubts in emunah fell away on hearing true words in the davening. s
Moshiach's greatest miracle
The Rambam does not say Moshiach will show no signs, only that the halachah does not require them, for he sees in Tanach and Chazal that Moshiach will bring the world to believe. He will slay the wicked with the breath of his lips: his word will enter the heart and kill the kefirah there. u
His greatest miracle will be turning all the nations to call in Hashem's name. As Elisha left his oxen and parents, Yidden will leave homes and bank accounts at his word, something no state today can achieve. His soul is a magnet drawing every Yid with a spark of Elokus; to need a sign would be a disgrace for him. v
So Eliyahu, who needed fire, will be Moshiach's armor-bearer, as Rabbi Akiva was Ben Koziva's. Emunah is the power to follow beyond what one sees; leitzanus, its opposite, denies what the mind does say.
Esav the scoffer and the bechorah
Esav embodies leitzanus. The Midrash calls him 'shav', emptiness, the opposite of Yaakov's truth; the Targum describes him as a nachash, and the sefarim note that nachash equals Moshiach in gematria. The Gemara counts five sins he did that day, the last being that he despised the bechorah. w,x,y
Why, then, did Esav cry bitterly that Yaakov took his bechorah and his bracha? The Mashgiach answers that Esav believed: he had seen ruach hakodesh and angels in Yitzchak's house. He denied it through leitzanus, as the nachash did. Therefore Adar, whose sense according to Sefer Yetzirah is laughter, defeats Esav and Amalek. z,ab
Esav's birth and the scoffers' answer
Back to Rashi: once Esav, root of leitzanus and of the kelipah of Amalek, was born, Hashem had to act against the scoffers. Esav's punishment was mockery, like Pharaoh's. Knowing Yaakov would come for the brachos, he told Yitzchak that whoever came with Yaakov's voice would be Esav imitating it. When Yaakov came with his own voice, Yitzchak took him for Esav, and the scheme turned on its author. a
'Bemirmah' and the sitra achra's portion
On 'your brother came bemirmah', the Targum renders 'with wisdom' and the Midrash 'with the wisdom of his Torah'. Tumah, the Mashgiach explains, must exist until it is removed from the earth, so the Torah directs giving it a measured portion: a siyum has a seudah, the physical share for the other side. The Ramban explains that the se'ir la'azazel is sent to the sitra achra, which without the Torah's command would be idolatry. ad,ae,af,ag,ah
Shadchan money, Rivka's prophecy and Yaakov
The Zohar says the story of Yaakov and Esav recurs yearly: Yaakov receives the brachos on Rosh Hashanah, Esav accuses, and on Yom Kippur a gift is sent to him. The Mashgiach applies this to Rabbi Yaakov Emden on the shadchan: Hashem makes matches, every great good faces opposition, so a bone is thrown, and the shadchan's money is that portion. ai
Yitzchak and Rivka's holy shidduch needed none; Eliezer thanked Hashem for leading him in truth. Yaakov's brachos did. Yaakov would never lie on his own, but Rivka answered him 'alai kil'lascha', which the Targum renders as said by prophecy, so he obeyed as one obeys the Torah. Yitzchak, asking 'mah zeh miharta', expected opposition, but none came. ak,am,an
Esav's material brachos and Yaakov's bracha
Sources
Torah
- j Devarim 4:8 text index In the write-up: 18:27
- z Bereishis 27:36 text index In the write-up: 45:37
- aa apparently Bereishis 3:1 47:34 index
- ac Bereishis 27:22 51:02 text index
- ad Bereishis 27:35 text index In the write-up: 53:20
- ak Bereishis 24:48 text index In the write-up: 1:01:48
- al apparently Bereishis 27:12 1:04:01 index
- an apparently Bereishis 27:20 index In the write-up: 1:01:48
- ao apparently Bereishis 27:39 1:06:31 index
- aq Bereishis 27:28 text index In the write-up: 1:07:31
- as apparently Bereishis 27:27 1:09:32 index
Nevi'im
- g Michah 7:20 14:37 text index
- i apparently Melachim I 19:19-20 18:27 index
- o Yeshayahu 52:13 text index In the write-up: 24:54
- q Melachim I 19:18 text index In the write-up: 28:48
- r apparently Melachim I 18:38-39 index In the write-up: 28:48
- u apparently Yeshayahu 11:4 index In the write-up: 35:09
- v Tzefaniah 3:9 text index In the write-up: 36:32
- ag apparently Zechariah 13:2 index In the write-up: 53:20
Kesuvim
Targum
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
- p apparently Tanchuma Toldos 14 index In the write-up: 24:54
- t Midrash (place not identified) 31:47
- w Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 43:00
- af apparently Bereishis Rabbah 67:4 index In the write-up: 53:20
- aj apparently Bereishis Rabbah 68:4 59:39 index
- ar Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 1:07:31
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
- a Rashi on Bereishis 25:19 text index In the write-up: 0:18, 49:28
- b Rashi on Shemos 10:2 text index In the write-up: 6:43
- k Hilchos Melachim 11:3 text index In the write-up: 22:03
- l apparently Raavad on Hilchos Melachim 11:3 index In the write-up: 22:03
- m Hilchos Melachim 11:4 text index In the write-up: 24:54
- n apparently Hilchos Melachim 12:1 index In the write-up: 24:54
- s Rashi on Bereishis 24:7 text index In the write-up: 30:50
- ah Ramban on Vayikra 16:8 text index In the write-up: 53:20
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 2:07 Just as emunah is the entrance to kedusha, leitzanus is the entrance and root of tumah.
- 3:02 Laughter is aroused by what is absurd and departs from truth; leitzanus is the power to deny reality and the conclusions of one's own mind.
- 16:24 Emunah comes from the spark of kedusha in every person, which draws him to greater kedusha, as Elisha was drawn to Eliyahu and as a magnet draws iron.
- 33:40 The Rambam's Moshiach needs no signs because he will draw the whole world to emunah by the truth of his word, like Avraham Avinu and greater than Eliyahu's miracle at Carmel.
- 45:55 Esav, the root of leitzanus, truly believed, but mocked away what he knew; his birth is why Rashi speaks of the scoffers of the generation.
- 54:46 The Torah measures exactly what portion the sitra achra must be given, as with the se'ir la'azazel; Yaakov's 'mirmah' was such a portion, done only by prophecy.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 0:47 Why does Rashi speak of the scoffers of the generation, when one usually speaks of the tzaddikim of the generation?
Answer: 49:28 Because Esav, the root of leitzanus, was about to be born, and the scoffers' power had to be answered.
-
Question: 8:37 Where did Chazal see that Pharaoh was a scoffer?
Answer: 10:54 From his holding out through plague after plague, which only the power of leitzanus to deny reality could make possible.
-
Question: 22:09 Why does the Rambam rule that Moshiach need not show signs, when Yidden pictured him so grandly?
Answer: 36:23 Because Moshiach is greater than signs: his word will draw the whole world to emunah, a greater miracle than any sign.
-
Question: 45:01 If Esav denied techiyas hameisim and despised the bechorah, why did he weep over the brachos?
Answer: 45:55 He truly believed, having seen the holiness of Yitzchak's home, but denied it through leitzanus.
-
Question: 1:03:32 How could Yaakov, who is truth itself, act with deception?
Answer: 1:04:23 Only because Rivka told him it was by prophecy; like the se'ir la'azazel, it was done where Hashem's word commands.
-
Question: 1:05:39 How may a Jew speak with 'mirmah'?
Answer: 1:05:42 Through the wisdom of the Torah, which measures exactly when it is allowed, as it measures the portion of the se'ir la'azazel.
Stories
-
34:11 Doubts dissolved by words of truth
The Mashgiach recalls a story he had told before. A man troubled by doubts in emunah came while the davening was in the middle of Mizmor l'Sodah. Hearing the words said there, all his questions were answered and the stones fell from his heart, and he became a complete believer, because they were words of truth.
Insights
- 12:38 Leitzanus is not mere lightheadedness: it is the power to deny what one's own mind recognizes, which makes it the exact counterpart of emunah, the power to believe beyond what the mind sees.
- 10:42 Pharaoh could withstand plague after plague, though he clearly saw the hand of Hashem, only because a good joke gave him and his people relief and courage to deny what they saw.
- 33:40 The Rambam's ruling that Moshiach need not show signs elevates him: Eliyahu needed fire from heaven, while Avraham, and Moshiach after him, draw the world by the truth of their word alone; needing a sign would be a disgrace for Moshiach.
- 45:55 Esav was not an unbeliever: he grew up seeing angels and ruach hakodesh in Yitzchak's home, and his weeping over the brachos shows he believed; his kefirah was the kefirah of leitzanus, mocking away what he knew.
- 54:54 The principle of the se'ir la'azazel, giving the sitra achra a measured portion only as the Torah directs, explains the seudah at a siyum, shadchan money, and Yaakov's 'mirmah', which he did only by Rivka's prophecy.
- 1:06:57 Since Yaakov had already received the blessing of the existing world, Esav had to be given something that did not yet exist, Italia shel Yavan, formed later in the sea.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avimelech, Avraham Avinu, Bar Kochba (Ben Koziva), Dovid HaMelech, Eliezer, servant of Avraham, Elisha HaNavi, Eliyahu HaNavi, Esav, Moshe Rabbeinu, Pharaoh, Rabbi Akiva, Rabbi Yaakov Emden (the Yaavetz), Rashi, Rivka Imeinu, Sarah Imeinu, the Chasam Sofer, the Raavad, the Rambam, the Ramban, Yaakov Avinu, Yitzchak Avinu, Yosef HaTzaddik
Terms אמונה, בכורה, טומאה, ליצנות, משיח בן יוסף, ניצוצות, נס, סטרא אחרא, עמלק, שידוך, שעיר לעזאזל, תחיית המתים