גדולת מרדכי. גראמען (מר' שלמה לעזער שליט"א)

Catalog entry: זמנים סעודת שושן פורים no. ⁨2⁩ Pocket Guide p. 24 תשמ"ט (1988–89) Yiddish 53 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 53 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Mashgiach's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Mashgiach explains why Mordechai, whom the Gemara ranks lower for leaving Torah study to save lives, was in truth the head of all tzaddikim and the Moshe of his generation, whose bond with Torah was never broken.

The Mashgiach opens with the Gemara that Mordechai, listed after four men in one passuk and after five in another, dropped in rank once he left Torah study for public affairs, from which Rav Yosef learns that Torah study is greater than saving lives. He asks why, then, only some of the Sanhedrin separated from him, and shows Mordechai's stature: the Gemara finds him in the Torah as mor dror, the Midrash calls him head of all tzaddikim, and the Zohar calls him the soul of Moshe. The greatest tzaddikim, like Yaakov and the Avos, stay bound to Torah even in worldly affairs. The Gemara and Ezra wrote by pshat, each tzaddik according to his soul's root; the minority of the Sanhedrin were souls of pshat, like the Beis Yosef. Mordechai is mor dror, misjudged by some, and every level is true. At the end come grammen by another speaker.

Topics: Chazal and Gedolei Yisroel · The Power and Greatness of Torah · Levels and Root of the Soul · Pshat, Remez, Drush and Sod

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Mordechai's lower ranking and Torah versus saving lives listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach brings the Gemara that Mordechai is listed after four men in one passuk and after five in another, because he became the king's second and could no longer learn as before; from here Rav Yosef learns that Torah study is greater than saving lives. He raises the difficulty that saving a life overrides the whole Torah, and asks why Mordechai's situation should show a weakness in his Torah.

  2. 4:42 Mordechai, head of all tzaddikim listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach asks why the rest of the Sanhedrin did not separate from Mordechai, and shows his stature: the Gemara finds him in the Torah as mor dror, the Midrash calls him head of all tzaddikim, and the Zohar says he was the soul of Moshe. He explains that the greatest tzaddikim, like Yaakov tending Lavan's sheep and the Avos, never interrupted their bond with Hashem in worldly affairs, and that Mordechai's way was hidden.

  3. 10:26 Each tzaddik writes by his soul's root listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that the Gemara speaks by pshat. With the Zohar and the Rema MiFano on Hadar, the eighth king, whose death the Torah does not record but Ezra's pesukim do, he shows that each tzaddik writes by his soul's root, so Ezra's ranking of Mordechai reflects Ezra's level. Moshe too did not truly die, and Haman, who knew Moshe died in Adar but not that he was born in Adar, did not know that Mordechai was the Moshe of his generation.

  4. 15:36 The minority of the Sanhedrin: souls of pshat listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that the minority of the Sanhedrin who separated were souls of pshat, which does not make them smaller, just as the Arizal told the Beis Yosef that his root was teaching halachah. The majority understood that Mordechai, like the Avos, never left the depths of Torah; he adds a hint from the initials of the names in the passuk, whose shin alludes to the three Avos.

  5. 19:12 Mor dror, and every level is true listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach brings the dispute of the Rambam and the Raavad over musk, mor dror, and says Mordechai is like it: some cannot understand him and judge him unfit, and mor dror equals in gematria that Moshe was born on the seventh of Adar. With the Chiddushei HaRim on Yaakov bowing to Esav he explains that each level is true, and closes that the Megillah ends with Mordechai seeking the good of his people, as in every generation Mordechai brings salvation to Jews.

  6. 29:10 Announcements and grammen on doubled words (Another speaker) listed in the guide

  7. 39:01 Grammen: the tale of the new chassid (Another speaker) listed in the guide

  8. 46:19 Grammen: threefold mercy and Moshiach (Another speaker) listed in the guide

The shiur, written up

Mordechai's lower ranking and Torah versus saving lives

1:24

The Mashgiach brings the Gemara that Mordechai is listed after four men in the passuk in Ezra but after five in Nechemiah. At first he could still engage in Torah; once he became the king's second, he could not learn as much. From this Rav Yosef learns that Torah study is greater than saving lives. b,c,a

3:17

The Mashgiach finds this hard, since saving a life overrides the whole Torah. If Hashem placed Mordechai where he had to close his Gemara, why should it count against him, so that the passuk says he was accepted only by most of his brothers? d

Mordechai, head of all tzaddikim

4:57

Why, then, did the rest of the Sanhedrin not separate from him? Mordechai's stature was immense: the Gemara in Chullin finds him in the Torah in the words mor dror, and the Midrash says that as mor heads all spices, Mordechai heads all tzaddikim. The Zohar, on 'kimu vekiblu' written in the singular, says he was the soul of Moshe Rabbeinu. On Purim his light comes down, a light greater than at Matan Torah. e,f,g

7:12

Mordechai, the Mashgiach says, neglected no Torah. The greatest tzaddikim can be busy with worldly matters while their whole occupation is Torah, as the Arizal explained the passuk of 'righteous statutes and laws'. Yaakov brought deep Torah out of tending Lavan's sheep; the Avos are the chariot, which the Tanya explains as never turning their minds from Hashem. Mordechai's way was hidden. h,j,k

Each tzaddik writes by his soul's root

10:30

The Gemara, the Mashgiach explains, speaks by pshat, and by pshat Torah study is greater. He brings the Zohar on Hadar, the eighth king, of whom the Torah does not write 'and he died', while Ezra writes it in Divrei Hayamim. The Rema MiFano explains that Ezra could not reach Moshe's understanding, for each tzaddik writes by his soul's root. So Ezra's placing of Mordechai reflects Ezra's level. l,m,n

13:47

Moshe too did not truly die, as the Gemara in Sotah says, despite the passuk that he died. Haman saw that Moshe died on the seventh of Adar but not that he was born then: Moshe remains in every generation, and Mordechai was the Moshe of his. p,o,q

The minority of the Sanhedrin: souls of pshat

15:38

The minority of the Sanhedrin who separated, the Mashgiach explains, were souls of pshat, which does not lessen them. So the Arizal told the Beis Yosef, who asked to learn the secrets of Torah, that his root was teaching halachah. The majority understood that Mordechai, like the Avos, never left the depths of Torah. He adds that the first three names in the passuk form a shin, which the Zohar says alludes to the three Avos. r

Mor dror, and every level is true

19:16

The Mashgiach brings the dispute over musk, mor dror: the Rambam rules it kosher, since it has become a new substance, while the Raavad forbids it. So it is with Mordechai: some do not understand him and say he is unfit, and that is why part of the Sanhedrin separated. Mor dror equals in gematria 'on the seventh of Adar Moshe was born'. s

21:18

Ezra too wrote the truth according to his level, and every level is true. The Chiddushei HaRim says this of Yaakov bowing to Esav: the Midrash criticizes it, while the Zohar sees in it a great tikkun. Yaakov knew both and chose the greater, and each is true in its own world. t,u,v

22:50

Just as the Torah ends with Moshe's death though he lives on, the Megillah ends with Mordechai accepted by most of his brothers, seeking the good of his people. In every generation, the Mashgiach concludes, Mordechai brings salvation to the Jews. o,d

Sources

Torah

  1. h apparently Devarim 4:8 index In the write-up: 7:12
  2. m apparently Bereishis 36:39 index In the write-up: 10:30
  3. o Devarim 34:5 text index In the write-up: 13:47, 22:50

Kesuvim

  1. b Ezra 2:2 text index In the write-up: 1:24
  2. c Nechemiah 7:7 text index In the write-up: 1:24
  3. d Esther 10:3 text index In the write-up: 3:17, 22:50
  4. n apparently Divrei Hayamim I 1:51 index In the write-up: 10:30

Talmud Bavli

  1. a Megillah 16b text index In the write-up: 1:24
  2. e Chullin 139b text index In the write-up: 4:57
  3. p apparently Sotah 13b index In the write-up: 13:47
  4. q apparently Megillah 13b index In the write-up: 13:47

Midrash

  1. f Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 4:57
  2. j apparently Bereishis Rabbah 47:6 index In the write-up: 7:12
  3. u Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 21:18

Zohar and Kabbalah

  1. g Zohar (place not identified) index In the write-up: 4:57
  2. i Zohar (place not identified) 8:16 index
  3. l Zohar (place not identified) index In the write-up: 10:30
  4. r Zohar (place not identified) index In the write-up: 15:38
  5. v Zohar (place not identified) index In the write-up: 21:18

Rishonim

  1. s Rambam, Mishneh Torah (place not identified) index In the write-up: 19:16

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. k Tanya (place not identified) index In the write-up: 7:12
  2. t Chiddushei HaRim (place not identified) index In the write-up: 21:18

Key points

  1. 1:02 From Mordechai's lower ranking in the second passuk, the Gemara learns that Torah study is greater than saving lives.
  2. 5:26 Mordechai is the head of all tzaddikim and the soul of Moshe Rabbeinu, and on Purim his great light comes down into the world.
  3. 7:30 The greatest tzaddikim, like Yaakov at Lavan's house and the Avos, can be busy with worldly matters while their whole occupation remains Torah.
  4. 12:33 Every tzaddik writes according to the root of his soul, so Ezra's placing of Mordechai reflects Ezra's level of understanding.
  5. 15:38 The minority of the Sanhedrin who separated from Mordechai were souls of pshat, while the majority understood that he never left the depths of Torah.
  6. 21:30 Opposing views of a tzaddik can each be true on its own level, as the Chiddushei HaRim says of the Midrash and the Zohar on Yaakov bowing to Esav.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 1:24 Why is Mordechai listed after four men in one passuk and after five in another?

    Answer: 1:47 The first passuk speaks of the time before he took up saving lives, when he could still engage in Torah; the second, of after he became the king's second and could not learn as much.

  2. Question: 4:45 If Torah study is greater than saving lives, why did only a minority of the Sanhedrin separate from Mordechai?

    Answer: 16:15 The majority understood that Mordechai, like the Avos, never left the depths of Torah while busy with public affairs; only the minority, souls of pshat, judged by appearance.

  3. Question: 13:24 How could Ezra write Mordechai in a lower place if he was head of all tzaddikim?

    Answer: 12:33 Each tzaddik writes according to his soul's root, as Ezra wrote 'and he died' of Hadar where the Torah does not; Ezra wrote according to his own level of understanding.

  4. Question: 14:19 If Haman could find out that Moshe died on the seventh of Adar, why did he not find out that Moshe was born then?

    Answer: 14:39 The meaning is different: Moshe left the world yet remains in every generation, and Haman did not know that the Moshe of his generation was Mordechai.

  5. Question: 21:36 The Midrash criticizes Yaakov for bowing to Esav while the Zohar praises it; which is true?

    Answer: 21:57 Both are true, each in its world: in the world of the Midrash he should not have bowed, while in the world of sod it was a great tikkun, and Yaakov knew both and chose the greater.

Stories

  1. 15:48 The Arizal and the Beis Yosef

    The Beis Yosef used to fall asleep at the Arizal's derashos. When he asked the Arizal to learn the secrets of the Torah with him, the Arizal refused, telling him that he had come into the world to teach halachos to Jews, and that this was the root of his soul; he should not enter what was not his root.

    In the story: the Arizal, Rabbi Yosef Karo (the Beis Yosef)

    told in 3 other shiurim →

Insights

  1. 12:39 The Torah does not write 'and he died' of Hadar, the eighth king, while Ezra's pesukim do; the Mashgiach learns from this that each tzaddik records events by his own soul's root, which explains why Ezra placed Mordechai lower.
  2. 14:06 Haman's error was that he saw Moshe had died in Adar but did not know that Moshe was born in Adar, meaning that Moshe lives on in Mordechai, the Moshe of the generation.
  3. 20:28 Mordechai is mor dror, musk, which the Rambam holds kosher and the Raavad forbids; so too some judged Mordechai unfit, and mor dror equals in gematria 'on the seventh of Adar Moshe was born'.
  4. 8:34 Yaakov's dealings with Lavan's sheep, and all his work in Lavan's house, brought out deep Torah from hiding.
  5. 17:40 The first three names in the passuk form the initials of a shin, whose three heads allude to the three Avos, hinting that the men listed before Mordechai were counted by appearance alone.
  6. 6:15 On Purim the light of Mordechai's soul-root comes down, a light so great that even at Matan Torah no such light came down.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Esav, Ezra HaSofer, Hadar, Haman, Lavan, Mordechai HaTzaddik, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbi Yosef Karo (the Beis Yosef), Rav Yosef, the Arizal, the Chiddushei HaRim, the Raavad, the Rambam, the Rema MiPano, Yaakov Avinu

Terms מרכבה, סודות התורה, פיקוח נפש, קימו וקבלו, שורש הנשמה

Report an error on this page