מלכות של אסתר ע"י רוח הק'

Catalog entry: זמנים סעודת שושן פורים no. ⁨5⁩ Pocket Guide p. 25 תש"נ (1989–90) Yiddish 1 hr 28 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 1 hr 28 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Mashgiach's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Mashgiach explains that Esther's 'malchus' was ruach hakodesh, and that this was her answer to the Chachamim when she asked them to write the Megillah for all generations.

The Mashgiach opens with the Gemara in Megillah: Esther asked the Chachamim to write the Megillah for all generations, they feared arousing the envy of the nations, and she answered that it was already written in the chronicles of the kings of Madai and Paras. He finds this dialogue in the verses at the end of the Megillah and asks why the verse about Achashverosh's tax interrupts it. He rejects reading Esther's words as a queen's command: she always submitted to Mordechai and the Chachamim, and a queen has no such authority. Rather, Esther's malchus was ruach hakodesh, like the kingship of Shlomo HaMelech that will be revealed in the future Yerushalayim. Achashverosh, written without a vav, was a taker and not a true king; Mordechai and Esther were the true kings. He ends with Shushan Purim, the Kosel Maaravi in every Jew's heart, and a tefillah for Yerushalayim.

Topics: Megillas Esther · Shushan Purim · Shlomo HaMelech

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Singing at the seudah (Singing)

  2. 6:55 Esther asks the Chachamim to write the Megillah listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach brings the Gemara in which Esther asks the Chachamim to fix the Megillah for all generations and answers their fear of the nations' envy, and Rav Nachman bar Yitzchak's proof that the Megillah was said with ruach hakodesh. He finds the dialogue in the verses at the end of the Megillah and asks why the verse about Achashverosh's tax stands between the question and the answer.

  3. 13:02 Did Esther speak with a queen's authority? listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach brings the Gra, who explains that Esther spoke to the Chachamim with the authority of a queen, and asks: she always obeyed Mordechai and asked the Chachamim her questions, and a queen, unlike a king, has no law of obedience. He then notes that Achashverosh's name in the interrupting verse is written without a vav.

  4. 16:06 Malchus as ruach hakodesh: Esther and Shlomo listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that Esther's malchus means ruach hakodesh, as the Gemara reads 'Esther clothed herself in malchus', and compares it to Shlomo HaMelech, whose kingship over upper and lower worlds came from ruach hakodesh. Shlomo's rule without war is a model of the future Yerushalayim whose wall will be Hashem Himself, and the 'sixty mighty men' around him were, in the Midrash, sixty masechtos.

  5. 21:45 Achashverosh the taker, Mordechai and Esther the kings listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that Mordechai and Esther were the true kings and Achashverosh only an imitation, so Esther's answer about the 'kings of Madai and Paras' refers to their own kingship of ruach hakodesh. The interrupting verse sets this up: a Jewish king gives, while Achashverosh, who levies a tax, is a taker, and like Efron he loses a vav from his name.

  6. 28:31 Why the Jews of Shushan received an extra day

    The Mashgiach explains Esther's request for another day for Shushan: its Jews had an added sin, so even Purim was not enough for them and they needed a greater day. The love of Hashem hidden in every Jew, revealed on Purim, is a point that can never be burned, and Shushan Purim is Yerushalayim's day, when only Yerushalayim reads the Megillah as its Hallel.

  7. 32:22 The Kosel Maaravi in every heart, and a tefillah for Yerushalayim

    The Mashgiach explains 'the city will be rebuilt on its ruin' as the Kosel Maaravi, which remains in every Jew's heart, and tells what he heard about the Satmar Rav's last drasha in Yerushalayim. He closes with a tefillah that all turn to Yerushalayim and soon see it surrounded by a wall of fire.

  8. 36:14 Singing (Singing)

  9. 42:33 Words of other speakers at the seudah (Another speaker)

  10. 45:57 A Purim badchan song (Singing)

  11. 1:05:20 Announcements at the seudah (Another speaker)

  12. 1:11:55 Bentching and closing

The shiur, written up

Esther asks the Chachamim to write the Megillah

7:06

The Mashgiach opens with the Gemara in Megillah 7a: Esther asked the Chachamim to fix the Megillah for all generations, they feared it would arouse the envy of the nations, and she answered that it was already written in the chronicles of the kings of Madai and Paras. The same Gemara brings Rav Nachman bar Yitzchak's proof that the Megillah was said with ruach hakodesh. The Mashgiach suggests his point is the next verse, 'Esther HaMalkah wrote', since 'malkah' means ruach hakodesh. a,b

11:25

He finds the whole dialogue in the verses: 'umaamar Esther' (Esther 9:32) is her request, and 'halo hem kesuvim' (Esther 10:2) her answer. But between them stands 'Achashverosh levied a tax' (Esther 10:1). Why does it interrupt? c,d,e

Did Esther speak with a queen's authority?

13:03

The Gra on Esther 9:32 explains that Esther spoke with a queen's authority. The Mashgiach asks: she had to convince the Chachamim, who had the last word; she obeyed Mordechai even as queen (Esther 2:20) and brought her questions to the Chachamim. And a queen is not a king, who has no one above him but Hashem. f,g,h

Malchus as ruach hakodesh

16:14

The Mashgiach answers that Esther's malchus was not Vashti's. The Gemara reads 'Esther clothed herself in malchus' as ruach hakodesh, and counts her among the seven prophetesses. So too, Shlomo HaMelech is not counted with the kings who ruled the world, because he ruled over the upper and lower worlds; his kingship came from ruach hakodesh. l,m,j

19:18

Shlomo ruled the world without war, a model of the future Yerushalayim, whose wall will be Hashem Himself. Though sixty mighty men surrounded him, he called for a sword; the Midrash says those sixty are the sixty masechtos. n,o,p,q

Achashverosh the taker

22:11

Mordechai, too, was among the prophets, and was really above Achashverosh. Achashverosh was only an imitation king; Chazal say 'the king' in the Megillah means the Ribono shel Olam. This was Esther's answer: the 'kings of Madai and Paras' are she and Mordechai, and by her ruach hakodesh she revealed that the Megillah must be written. The Chachamim then found the hint in the Torah's word 'basefer'. d,t

26:01

That is why the tax verse comes first. A Jewish king gives kedushah to his people, while a king of the nations takes from them. Achashverosh, who levies a tax, is written without a vav, like Efron in Bereishis 23:16, who lost his vav for his stinginess, since the vav is the letter of giving. e,u

The Jews of Shushan

28:49

The Mashgiach explains the extra day for Shushan. All Jews had one sin; the Jews of Shushan had an added one, so even Purim was not enough for them, and Esther understood they needed a greater day.

29:56

Every Jew holds a hidden love for Hashem, revealed on Purim, a point never burned. Shushan Purim is Yerushalayim's day, when only it reads the Megillah, which the Gemara calls Purim's Hallel. z

The Kosel Maaravi in every heart

32:22

'The city will be rebuilt on its ruin' (Yirmeyahu 30:18) is the Kosel Maaravi, which was never destroyed, and the Mashgiach says a Kosel Maaravi stands in every Jew's heart. He tells that at the Satmar Rav's last drasha in Yerushalayim, the Satmar Rav wept at leaving, but said he would remain there, since the Chesed L'Avraham writes that one who supports Yerushalayim is as if he were in it. aa,ab

35:28

He closes with a tefillah that all turn to Yerushalayim and soon see it with its wall of fire. n

Sources

Torah

  1. i Devarim 17:15 14:36 text index
  2. u Bereishis 23:16 text index In the write-up: 26:01

Nevi'im

  1. n Zechariah 2:9 text index In the write-up: 19:18, 35:28
  2. o Melachim I 3:24 text index In the write-up: 19:18
  3. aa Yirmeyahu 30:18 text index In the write-up: 32:22
  4. ac apparently Melachim I 8 35:34 index

Kesuvim

  1. c Esther 9:32 text index In the write-up: 11:25
  2. d Esther 10:2 text index In the write-up: 11:25, 22:11
  3. e Esther 10:1 text index In the write-up: 11:25, 26:01
  4. g Esther 2:20 text index In the write-up: 13:03
  5. k Divrei HaYamim I 29:23 17:01 text index
  6. p Shir HaShirim 3:7-8 text index In the write-up: 19:18
  7. s Esther 10:3 22:05 text index
  8. x Esther 9:13 29:03 text index
  9. y Tehillim 147:12 31:10 text index

Talmud Bavli

  1. a Megillah 7a text index In the write-up: 7:06
  2. b Megillah 7a text index In the write-up: 7:06
  3. h apparently Megillah 13b index In the write-up: 13:03
  4. j Megillah 11b text index In the write-up: 16:14
  5. l Megillah 14b text index In the write-up: 16:14
  6. m Megillah 14a text index In the write-up: 16:14
  7. r apparently Megillah 15a 21:45 index
  8. t Megillah 7a text index In the write-up: 22:11
  9. z Megillah 14a text index In the write-up: 29:56

Midrash

  1. q Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 19:18

Rishonim

  1. v apparently Rashi on Bereishis 23:10 27:14 index
  2. w Rabbeinu Bachya (place not identified) 27:34 index

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. ab Chesed L'Avraham (place not identified) index In the write-up: 32:22

Other

  1. f apparently Gra on Esther 9:32 index In the write-up: 13:03

Key points

  1. 10:38 The Gemara's dialogue between Esther and the Chachamim is hinted in the closing verses of the Megillah: her request in 'umaamar Esther' and her answer in 'halo hem kesuvim'.
  2. 14:24 Esther did not press the Chachamim with a queen's authority; her 'malchus' was ruach hakodesh, and with it she revealed that the Megillah must be written.
  3. 22:59 Achashverosh was not a true king but a taker; the true kings of Madai and Paras were Mordechai and Esther.
  4. 16:42 Shlomo HaMelech's kingship over the upper and lower worlds came from ruach hakodesh and is a model of the kingship that will be revealed in the future.
  5. 28:49 The Jews of Shushan, who sinned more, received a greater day, Shushan Purim, because the inner point of a Jew, like the Kosel Maaravi, is never destroyed.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 12:42 Why does the verse about Achashverosh's tax stand between the Chachamim's objection and Esther's answer?

    Answer: 24:41 It establishes the premise of her answer: Achashverosh was not a true king; Esther was the queen, with the authority of ruach hakodesh.

  2. Question: 13:44 How could Esther press the Chachamim with a queen's authority, when she always submitted to Mordechai and the Chachamim, and a queen has no law of obedience?

    Answer: 16:24 Her malchus was not political power but ruach hakodesh, and with it she revealed that the Megillah must be written.

  3. Question: 16:28 Why is Shlomo HaMelech not counted among the kings who ruled the whole world?

    Answer: 16:37 He ruled over upper and lower worlds; his kingship came from ruach hakodesh and has nothing in common with theirs.

  4. Question: 15:49 Why is Achashverosh's name in the verse about the tax written without a vav, the only such place in the Megillah?

    Answer: 26:56 The vav stands for giving; Achashverosh was a taker, like Efron, whose name also lost its vav.

  5. Question: 28:49 Why did the Jews of Shushan need an extra day beyond Purim?

    Answer: 29:06 They had an added sin, so Purim was not enough for them; Esther understood they needed a greater day.

  6. Question: 21:08 Why did Shlomo call for a sword, when sixty mighty men with swords surrounded him?

    Answer: 21:31 The Midrash says the sixty mighty men are the sixty masechtos; that was his kingship.

Stories

  1. 34:36 The Satmar Rav's last drasha in Yerushalayim

    The Mashgiach heard from a man who was present at the last drasha the Satmar Rav gave in Yerushalayim, when he sensed he would not return. The Satmar Rav wept greatly and said it was very hard for him to leave Yerushalayim. Yet he would remain in Yerushalayim, because the Chesed L'Avraham writes that one who gives money for the upkeep of Yerushalayim is as if he were there.

    In the story: the Satmar Rav (Rabbi Yoel Teitelbaum)

Insights

  1. 10:24 The Mashgiach reads 'malkah' in 'Esther HaMalkah wrote' as ruach hakodesh, not political rank: her authority over the Chachamim came from prophecy, not from the throne.
  2. 24:41 The verse about Achashverosh's tax, which seems to interrupt Esther's dialogue with the Chachamim, is the premise of her answer: he was no king, so the 'kings of Madai and Paras' are Mordechai and Esther.
  3. 26:07 A Jewish king is a giver of kedushah and a king of the nations is a taker; Achashverosh, who levies a tax, loses the vav of giving from his name, as Efron did.
  4. 18:55 Shlomo HaMelech, who ruled the world without war, is a model of the future Yerushalayim that will need no physical wall because Hashem will be its wall of fire.
  5. 29:06 The Jews of Shushan, who had sinned more, received a greater day precisely because nothing remained in them but the indestructible inner point of Yerushalayim.
  6. 32:40 The Mashgiach reads 'kosel' as the Name of Hashem together with 'tel', a ruin: even in destruction the Name is there, and so the Kosel Maaravi in every Jew's heart can never be destroyed.

What the Mashgiach says to take from it

  1. 34:27 The Mashgiach says that on this day all Jews turn toward Yerushalayim, and that by supporting Yerushalayim one is bound up with it.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Achashverosh, Achav, Avraham Avinu, Efron, Esther HaMalkah, Mordechai HaTzaddik, Moshe Rabbeinu, Nevuchadnetzar, Rabbeinu Bachya, Rabbi Avraham Azulai (Chesed L'Avraham), Rav Nachman bar Yitzchak, Shlomo HaMelech, the Satmar Rav (Rabbi Yoel Teitelbaum), the Vilna Gaon, Vashti

Terms כותל המערבי, משפיע ומקבל, נשמה כללית, קנאה, קרי וכתיב, רוח הקודש, שושן פורים

Report an error on this page