יו"ט ליהודים בעלי מדריגה' ומרדכי לא יכרע- היה בטוח בה'' יו"ט של לעתיד לבא' פעמונים בשולי המעיל- דור אחרון
Catalog entry: זמנים סעודת שושן פורים no. 1 Pocket Guide p. 24 תשמ"ג (1982–83), תשמ"ד (1983–84), תשמ"ו (1985–86), תשמ"ז (1986–87) Yiddish 1 hr 32 min
Listen
-
Part 1 of 4 · 24 min
-
Part 2 of 4 · 36 min
-
Part 3 of 4 · 20 min
-
Part 4 of 4 · 11 min
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains Shushan Purim as the Yom Tov of the higher levels, Mordechai's refusal to bow as a deeper standard of emunah, and Purim as a foretaste of the complete wiping out of Amalek in the days of Moshiach.
The Mashgiach asks why new Amalekites rose against the Jews in Shushan on the second day and why Esther asked only then for Haman's ten sons to be hanged. He answers that Purim reaches the lowest Jews while Shushan Purim belongs to the higher ones, the walled-city Jews tied to Jerusalem; what is no sin for one is a sin for another, so finer Amalekites and the ten sons, the soul's ten powers, are destroyed on the second day. He then reads the Targum on Mordechai's refusal to bow to Haman and resolves its contradiction with the Divrei Yoel: Avraham's tractate Avodah Zarah had 400 chapters, and for Mordechai believing that Haman provides one's bread is idolatry. Every Jew, he says, must know this truth and never despair. Turning to Megillah 7a, he explains that the Megillah holds the light of Moshiach, links Shushan Purim to a bris milah, and closes with Esther's wish that the Yom Tov bind the Jews of the last generation to Jerusalem.
Topics: Shushan Purim · Bitachon · Doubts in Emunah and Amalek · Megillas Esther
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Amalek's brazenness and the second day listed in the guide
The Mashgiach describes Amalek's brazenness, which made Haman's descendants reveal themselves by rising against the Jews. He asks why new Amalekites appeared in Shushan on the second day and why Esther asked only then for Haman's ten sons to be hanged.
-
4:48 Purim for the low, Shushan Purim for the high listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that Purim reaches the lowest Jews while Shushan Purim belongs to the walled-city Jews tied to Jerusalem. He brings the Targum Sheni that Mordechai came to Shushan only to raise Esther, because his light could be revealed only in a place of hiddenness.
-
9:52 Each by his level, and finer Amalekites listed in the guide
The Mashgiach teaches that what is permitted for one Jew is a sin for a higher one, and so there are finer Amalekites who count as Amalek only for the higher Jew; these sprang up on the second day. He connects Shushan with Jerusalem through the Shushan gate of the Temple Mount.
-
14:14 Esther and Shoshanah; rejoicing together listed in the guide
The Mashgiach contrasts Esther, hiddenness, with Shoshanah, the rose whose beauty is revealed. He says both days must be kept: Jews outside rejoice with the higher Jews tied to Mordechai, and the Jews of Jerusalem rejoice with the Jews of exile.
-
17:38 Haman, his ten sons, and inner Torah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that Haman attacks the basic emunah in Divine providence that every Jew has, while his ten sons are the soul's ten powers, which the Shushan Purim Jew must uproot. He notes that where inner Torah took hold, among the Ba'al Shem Tov's disciples, Shushan Purim became a real Yom Tov, and in the days of Moshiach it will spread to the whole world.
-
24:12 The Targum on Mordechai's refusal to bow listed in the guide
The Mashgiach reads the Megillah with the Targum: Mordechai bowed neither to the idol nor to Haman, who had sold himself to him for a loaf of bread. Later the Jews complain, and Mordechai answers that Haman wore images on his garment; the Mashgiach points out the contradiction and asks why Mordechai's Sanhedrin sat at the king's gate.
-
32:53 Avraham's 400 chapters of Avodah Zarah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Divrei Yoel on the Gemara that Avraham's tractate Avodah Zarah had 400 chapters while ours has five: idolatry has many levels, and what is not idolatry for a simple person is idolatry for a greater one. He insists the Targum's contradiction cannot be dismissed as differing midrashim.
-
36:47 The king's funds and Mordechai's emunah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach suggests that Achashverosh supported religions, so Mordechai's Sanhedrin, funded by the king, sat at the king's gate, and Haman administered all the funds. Everyone bowed to Haman, but Mordechai stood firm in emunah that wealth and honor come from Hashem, and the Jews complained that his refusal brought the decree.
-
44:00 Haman's garment: idolatry from front and back listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains Mordechai's answer through the Divrei Yoel: believing one must bow to Haman because he provides one's bread is idolatry on a higher level, and even forgetting for a moment that Hashem rules is the image 'from behind'. Mordechai hinted that he feeds Haman, since all blessing comes first to Israel.
-
50:18 Knowing the truth, and the dance listed in the guide
The Mashgiach says the Jews fell silent because they understood: even one not on Mordechai's level must know the truth and recall it in hard moments, when tempted to flatter whoever seems to give his livelihood. He compares this to dancing at a simcha, when a person jumps above his own height though he will come down again.
-
54:24 Every Jewish heart is Jerusalem listed in the guide
The Mashgiach asks what Shushan Purim means to Jews outside Jerusalem and answers that every Jewish heart is Jerusalem. A Jew who feels he wasted Purim should remember that ruined Jerusalem will be rebuilt, and so will he; he closes with 'layehudim haysah orah' and a blessing that the beauty of a Jew be revealed.
-
1:00:33 'Three and not four': the Megillah's place listed in the guide
The Mashgiach opens with the Gemara in Megillah where Esther asks to be written for generations and the Sages answer that Amalek is written three times and not four, and with the dispute whether Esther defiles the hands. He explains the 24 holy books as the 24 ornaments of the bride, the Shechinah, each prophet bringing down an ornament already prepared in heaven.
-
1:05:40 The light of Moshiach in the Megillah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Likkutei Torah of Chernobyl that the Megillah holds the light of Moshiach, given so that Jews can grow used to that great light. Purim will remain when other festivals are annulled because its essence is the wiping out of Amalek, the preparation for Moshiach; until that is complete the Megillah's full holiness is still 'in heaven'.
-
1:09:52 The seudah of Shushan Purim as a bris listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Bnei Yissaschar that the Megillah needs the laws of holy writings only as an object of the mitzvah on Purim. He explains that a bris milah, like Purim, gives a glimmer of the days of Moshiach as the orlah is removed and the holy point is revealed, so the seudah of Shushan Purim is a seudas bris milah.
-
1:15:24 Blessing for the bris; why only three times listed in the guide
The Mashgiach blesses the newly circumcised child, whose bris falls on Shushan Purim, and all present. He then returns to 'three and not four': Amalek was only weakened by Yehoshua, Shaul left Agag, and in the Megillah too Hashem's name is hidden, so the Sages hesitated to write it until they found it in a passuk.
-
1:20:40 Bells on the hem: Esther's Yom Tov for the last generation listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that the bells and pomegranates on the hem of the Kohen Gadol's robe hint at the last generations, the simple Jews 'full of mitzvos like a pomegranate'. Esther could not ask Achashverosh for a Yom Tov for Jerusalem, so she asked for Shushan, knowing Shushan would vanish while Jerusalem remains; the day binds the last generation to Jerusalem.
The shiur, written up
Amalek's brazenness and the second day
The Mashgiach begins with Amalek's trait of brazenness. When all the nations trembled at the Jews, Amalek alone felt no fear, and so on Purim the descendants of Amalek rose against the Jews and thereby revealed who they were. On the first day five hundred were killed in Shushan; yet on the second day three hundred more appeared. a,b
Purim for the low, Shushan Purim for the high
To answer, the Mashgiach distinguishes the two days. Purim is for the lowest levels, where the light of Mordechai lowers itself to strengthen Jews; Shushan Purim is for the higher ones, the walled cities tied to Jerusalem. He brings the Targum Sheni that Mordechai, 'who was exiled from Jerusalem' of his own accord, really lived in Jerusalem and went to Shushan only to raise Esther. d,e,f
Why not bring her to Jerusalem? Because the light of Mordechai is revealed only within Esther, hester panim, and Mordechai wished to plant for all generations that hidden Jews could bind themselves to it. So he raised Esther in exile, as the passuk says he 'was raising Hadassah, she is Esther'. g
Each by his level, and finer Amalekites
The Mashgiach explains that every Jew is judged by his level: what is permitted for one is a sin for a higher Jew. So too there are levels of Amalek. The three hundred of the second day carried a finer spark of Amalek; to a simple Jew they are not Amalek at all, but to the Shushan Purim Jew they are, and so they sprang up only then.
Esther and Shoshanah
Haman, his ten sons, and inner Torah
Haman, the Mashgiach explains, is the root of all impurity, set against the basic emunah that nothing in the world is chance and that Hashem watches over everything. That threat touches every Jew, so Haman himself was hanged on Purim. His ten sons are the ten powers of the soul, and only of the Shushan Purim Jew is it expected that he uproot every trace of them; hence Esther asked for them on the second day.
He notes that where the inner Torah took hold, among the Ba'al Shem Tov's disciples, Shushan Purim became a full Yom Tov, greater even than Rosh Chodesh; elsewhere it has not yet taken root. When Moshiach comes and all Jews are 'walled', Shushan Purim will be kept throughout the world.
The Targum on Mordechai's refusal to bow
The Mashgiach reads the passuk that all the king's servants bowed to Haman while Mordechai would not, together with the Targum Sheni. There were two things: an idol Haman had set up, and Haman himself. Mordechai bowed to neither: not to the idol because he was a Jew, and not to Haman because Haman had sold himself to him as a slave for a loaf of bread. k,l
Then, on the night the king could not sleep, the Jews gathered and complained that Mordechai's refusal had brought the decree. He answered that Haman wore images on his garment front and back, so bowing to him was bowing to an idol, and they fell silent. The Mashgiach points out that this contradicts the Targum's earlier account, where Haman himself was no idol. m,l
Avraham's 400 chapters of Avodah Zarah
The Mashgiach brings the Divrei Yoel on the Gemara that Avraham's tractate Avodah Zarah had four hundred chapters, while ours has five. Idolatry has many levels: what is not idolatry for a simple person is idolatry for a greater one, even serving Hashem for others' approval. Avraham, the great seeker of his Creator, had four hundred chapters by his level, and we have five by ours. o,p
He stresses that the Targum, by Rabbi Yonasan ben Uziel, cannot be answered as two differing midrashim; both accounts are true.
The king's funds and Mordechai's emunah
First the Mashgiach explains the Sanhedrin. Achashverosh wanted to be seen as everyone's king, so he supported religions and colleges with grants. A great college like Mordechai's Sanhedrin received the king's programs, and whatever the king funded sat at the king's gate. Haman, second to the king, administered all the funds, so everyone had to come to him.
Idolatry from front and back
Mordechai's answer about images front and back, the Mashgiach says, was a piece of Divrei Yoel. To believe one must bow to a man because he provides one's livelihood and programs is, at a higher level, idolatry: it forgets that Hashem alone rules and that no one can do good or harm except by His will. Even when Haman is absent, a passing thought that he is the source is the image 'from behind'. o
Knowing the truth, and the dance
The Jews fell silent because they understood. The Mashgiach says that whether or not one holds at this level, every Jew must know the truth. In hard moments, when tempted to flatter whoever seems to give his livelihood, one must at least remember that everything comes from Hashem.
Every Jewish heart is Jerusalem
The Mashgiach notes that the Rema treats Shushan Purim as a day of joy and asks what it means to Jews not in Jerusalem. Every Jew is Jerusalem, as the Zohar teaches; every Jewish heart is a Mikdash. A person may feel he wasted Purim; let him remember that Jerusalem received Shushan Purim for its honor, and that it now lies in ruins. u,t
'Three and not four'
The Mashgiach brings the Gemara: Esther asked the Sages to write her for generations, and they answered that Amalek is written three times and not four, in Beshalach, in Zachor, and in Shmuel at Shaul's war with Agag. Tannaim and Shmuel dispute whether Esther defiles the hands, though the Megillah has laws of holy writing. x,y,z,aa
The light of Moshiach in the Megillah
The Likkutei Torah of Chernobyl says the Megillah holds the light of Moshiach. That light will be too great to bear, so Hashem gave us the Megillah and Purim to grow used to it. Hence, as the Rambam rules, the Megillah remains when others are annulled: Purim's essence is the wiping out of Amalek, the preparation for Moshiach. ae,af
Until that is complete, the Megillah's holiness is not yet in its full expression.
The seudah of Shushan Purim as a bris
The Mashgiach brings the Bnei Yissaschar: the Megillah needs the laws of holy writings as an object of mitzvah on Purim, like a lulav on Sukkos, but not after Purim. The light comes down on Purim, but full holiness awaits the wiping out of Amalek. ag
A bris milah also gives a glimmer of Moshiach: the orlah is removed and the holy point revealed. So, he says, citing the Chasam Sofer, the seudah of Shushan Purim is a seudas bris milah. In the Megillah Jerusalem is written with a yud, the revealed point.
Blessing for the bris; why only three times
Today, the Mashgiach says, the seudah of Shushan Purim is also a seudas milah, and he blesses the child, from a family of Torah and Chassidus, that as he entered the bris so he enter Torah, chuppah and good deeds.
Bells on the hem: Esther's Yom Tov for the last generation
The Mashgiach speaks of the Kohen Gadol's robe, which covered him from top to bottom and includes all the generations of Israel down to the lowest. The bells and pomegranates on its hem hint at the end of time, the souls before Moshiach. They are the Jews of whom the Gemara says even the empty ones are full of mitzvos like a pomegranate, and before Hashem they are gold. ah,ai
Esther wanted Jews bound to Jerusalem but could not ask Achashverosh for a Yom Tov for Jerusalem, as his feast celebrated that the Mikdash was not rebuilt. So she named Shushan, knowing Shushan would leave no trace while Jerusalem remains, the one place that is surely walled. aj
The day is for Jews outside Jerusalem who bind the end, the generation of Moshiach's footsteps, to the beginning, Jerusalem. He closes with a blessing for wonders as in Mordechai's days and the rebuilding of Jerusalem.
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
- a Esther 9:6 text index In the write-up: 1:09
- b Esther 9:15 text index In the write-up: 1:09
- c Esther 9:13 text index In the write-up: 3:39
- d Esther 2:6 text index In the write-up: 4:55
- g Esther 2:7 text index In the write-up: 6:29
- i Shir HaShirim 2:2-3 text index In the write-up: 14:31
- j Esther 9:27 text index In the write-up: 15:48
- k Esther 3:2 text index In the write-up: 25:14
- m Esther 6:1 text index In the write-up: 28:11
- r Divrei HaYamim I 29:12 text index In the write-up: 39:45, 52:17
- v Esther 8:16 text index In the write-up: 56:45
Targum
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
- e apparently Megillah 13a index In the write-up: 4:55
- n apparently Megillah 15b index In the write-up: 32:00
- p Avodah Zarah 14b text index In the write-up: 32:53
- q apparently Megillah 15a index In the write-up: 41:58
- w apparently Berachos 6a index In the write-up: 56:45
- x Megillah 7a text index In the write-up: 1:00:33, 1:18:44
- ai Gemara (place not identified) index In the write-up: 1:21:14
- aj apparently Megillah 11b index In the write-up: 1:25:00
Midrash
- ad Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 1:03:17
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
- o Divrei Yoel (place not identified) index In the write-up: 32:53, 44:23
- u Shulchan Aruch (Rema) (place not identified) index In the write-up: 54:27
- ae Likkutei Torah (Chernobyl) (place not identified) index In the write-up: 1:05:49
- ag Bnei Yissaschar (place not identified) index In the write-up: 1:09:52
Key points
- 4:55 Purim reaches down to the simplest Jews, while Shushan Purim is the Yom Tov of the higher levels, the walled-city Jews connected to Jerusalem.
- 10:15 Each Jew is judged by his level: what is permitted for one is a sin for a higher one, so there are Amalekites that count as Amalek only for the higher Jew.
- 17:50 Haman attacks the basic belief in Divine providence that every Jew has, while his ten sons are the soul's ten powers, which only the Shushan Purim Jew is expected to uproot.
- 44:27 For Mordechai, believing that one must bow to Haman because he controls one's funding is itself avodah zarah, a chapter in a higher tractate of Avodah Zarah.
- 51:02 Every Jew must know that wealth and honor come only from Hashem, and must not despair over his low state, just as Jerusalem will be rebuilt.
- 1:05:49 Amalek was written in Scripture only three times because it was never fully destroyed; the Megillah carries the light of Moshiach and lets Jews grow used to it.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 3:39 Why did new Amalekites rise up in Shushan on the second day, and why did Esther ask only then for the ten sons of Haman to be hanged?
Answer: 11:50 Shushan Purim is for the higher Jews; for them finer Amalekites count as Amalek, and the ten sons, the soul's ten powers, must be uprooted only at their level.
-
Question: 6:07 Why did Mordechai, who was not exiled, go to Shushan to raise Esther instead of bringing her to Jerusalem?
Answer: 6:37 The light of Mordechai is revealed only within Esther, hiddenness; brought to Jerusalem it would no longer be Esther.
-
Question: 32:17 Why did Mordechai's Sanhedrin sit at the king's gate, near a house of idols?
Answer: 37:34 Achashverosh supported religions and colleges, and whatever the king funded was arranged at the king's gate.
-
Question: 30:36 The Targum first says Mordechai refused to bow to Haman because Haman was his slave, yet later he tells the Jews it was because of idols on Haman's garment. How do these fit?
Answer: 44:23 Following the Divrei Yoel, believing one must bow to Haman for one's livelihood is itself idolatry at a higher level, which is what Mordechai explained to the Jews.
-
Question: 1:06:30 Why will Purim remain when the other festivals are annulled?
Answer: 1:06:46 Purim's essence is the wiping out of Amalek, the preparation for Moshiach, so it reaches its full expression only in the future.
-
Question: 1:00:47 Why did the Sages answer Esther 'I have written it three times and not four'?
Answer: 1:18:53 Amalek was never fully wiped out, neither by Yehoshua, nor Shaul, nor Mordechai and Esther; a fourth writing would require the complete destruction of Amalek.
Stories
-
29:16 The Jews' complaint to Mordechai on the night of the king's sleeplessness
As the Mashgiach reads it from the Targum, on the night the king could not sleep the Jews gathered around Mordechai and complained that his refusal to bow to Haman had brought the whole trouble upon them. Mordechai answered that Haman wore a garment with images painted on its front and back, so bowing to him would be bowing to an idol. Hearing this, the Jews fell silent and complained no more.
In the story: Mordechai HaTzaddik, Haman
Insights
- 11:30 The 300 killed in Shushan on the second day were new Amalekites: men with a finer spark of Amalek who would not count as Amalek for a simple Jew but do for the higher Jew of Shushan Purim.
- 6:37 Mordechai left Jerusalem for Shushan to raise Esther because his light could be revealed only in a place of hester panim, planting for all generations the power of hidden Jews to bind themselves to the light of Purim.
- 14:06 In Shushan the light is called Shoshanah rather than Esther: Esther is hiddenness, while Shoshanah is the rose that blooms openly in its beauty.
- 44:23 Mordechai's two answers in the Targum do not contradict: bowing to Haman as the controller of one's livelihood is idolatry in the higher tractate of Avodah Zarah, and Haman's image 'from behind' is even a passing thought that someone other than Hashem gives one's bread.
- 47:50 Mordechai turned the slave-for-bread claim around: it is not Haman who gives him bread but he who gives Haman bread, since all blessing comes down first to Israel and only through them to the nations.
- 1:11:39 The seudah of Shushan Purim is a seudas bris milah: both remove the orlah and reveal the holy point, giving a glimmer of the days of Moshiach.
- 1:25:00 Esther named Shushan only because Achashverosh would never grant a Yom Tov for Jerusalem, knowing that Shushan would vanish while Jerusalem, the one place that is certainly a walled city, would remain.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 15:48 The Mashgiach says one must keep both days and rejoice together with the higher Jews, the talmidei chachamim who are like walled cities.
- 51:02 The Mashgiach says that even one not on Mordechai's level must know the truth, and in hard moments, when tempted to flatter a provider, must at least remind himself that everything comes from Hashem.
- 58:08 The Mashgiach says no Jew should despair on seeing how low he is, but should aspire to the highest levels in Torah, avodah and kindness.
- 1:14:56 The Mashgiach says that Purim and Shushan Purim, kept properly, are a time to turn to Hashem and accept anew a covenant with Him.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Achashverosh, Agag, Avraham Avinu, Esther HaMalkah, Haman, Mordechai HaTzaddik, Shaul HaMelech, Shmuel (the Amora), the Baal Shem Tov, the Bnei Yissaschar (Rabbi Tzvi Elimelech of Dinov), the Chasam Sofer, the Rambam, the Satmar Rav (Rabbi Yoel Teitelbaum), Yehoshua bin Nun, Yonasan ben Uziel
Terms הסתר פנים, השגחה פרטית, כוחות הנפש, מוקפין חומה, מחיית עמלק, סודות התורה, עבודה זרה, עמלק, ערלה, שושן פורים