מרדכי תיקן קצת חטא עץ הדעת
Catalog entry: זמנים סעודת שושן פורים no. 6 Pocket Guide p. 25 תשנ"ג (1992–93) Yiddish 59 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains how Mordechai, by refusing to bow to Haman, repaired on the level of drush a flaw left by the sin of Adam and by Yaakov's bowing to Esav, bringing a tikun of the future world that makes the Megillah and Purim eternal.
The Mashgiach opens with the Manos HaLevi: Mordechai's refusal to bow repaired Yaakov's bowing to Esav. The Midrash criticizes that bowing while the Zohar praises it; the Chiddushei HaRim resolves this through the four worlds matching sod, drush, remez and pshat, which Adam's sin set out of line. Yaakov chose a great tikun in the world of sod at the cost of a flaw in the world of drush. The Gemara's criticism of Devorah and Chulda shows a similar flaw: a time when men had to submit to women and din ruled over chesed. Adar is a reversed month, and the Purim miracle began with 'let every man rule in his house', the turn from din to chesed. Mordechai, from the world of tikun, repaired the drush flaw, which is why the Megillah becomes an iggeres on Purim, will never be nullified, and is expounded by the Gemara from beginning to end.
Topics: Megillas Esther · Pshat, Remez, Drush and Sod · Adam HaRishon and Gan Eden · Yitzchak, Yaakov and Esav
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Yaakov's bowing to Esav: Midrash and Zohar listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Manos HaLevi that Mordechai repaired Yaakov's bowing to Esav, then contrasts the Midrash, which criticizes that bowing, with the Zohar, which praises it. He resolves the contradiction with the Chiddushei HaRim: the four worlds match sod, drush, remez and pshat, Adam's sin set them out of line, and Yaakov chose a tikun in the world of sod at the cost of a flaw in the world of drush.
-
6:15 Devorah, Chulda and the order of honor
The Mashgiach brings the Gemara in Megillah that haughtiness does not befit women, shown by the unflattering names of Devorah and Chulda, and asks why only women, and what they did wrong at all. He lays out the order of honor between navi, kohen gadol and king, and how a king must stand before the kohen gadol who brings the word of Hashem through the Urim v'Tumim.
-
9:41 The flaw is the situation, not the women
The Mashgiach shows that Chulda and Devorah acted correctly, since a prophecy and a judge appointed by Hashem's word demand that the man submit, as Tosafos explains. Following the Chiddushei HaRim he answers that the complaint is against the situation itself: leadership through din, a man submitting to a woman, is a flaw in creation, while chesed must be joined over din, as many halachos that give the right side precedence show.
-
13:49 Adar reversed and the first letters listed in the guide
The Mashgiach calls Adar a reversed month, citing the Bnei Yissaschar and the Arizal on its letter combination, in which din precedes chesed. The miracle begins with the first letters, 'let every man rule in his house': against Rashi's reading, which the Chasam Sofer calls forced, the Mashgiach explains them as the start of a new order turning din to chesed. Mordechai, of the world of tikun, brought a tikun never seen before, not even at Matan Torah.
-
17:53 Mordechai's tikun and the Megillah as an iggeres listed in the guide
The Mashgiach returns to Yaakov: he knowingly left a flaw in the world of drush for a greater tikun in the world of sod, and Mordechai repaired that flaw, preparing the days of Moshiach. From the Rambam's ruling that a Megillah written with the other Kesuvim is invalid, he explains that on Purim the Megillah is an iggeres of the world of tikun, which is why it alone will never be nullified.
-
22:48 Doresh tov l'amo and Shushan Purim listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that the Gemara expounds the whole Megillah, unlike any other book, because Mordechai repaired the world of drush, as its closing words 'doresh tov l'amo' hint. Shushan Purim is the Purim of Yerushalayim, written in the Megillah in its complete form, and Mordechai was beyond the grasp of others. He closes with a tefilah for the coming of Moshiach and the rebuilding of Yerushalayim.
-
26:51 Interlude
-
38:35 Purim remarks on Haman and Amalek (Another speaker)
-
42:21 Rhymed Purim song on serving Hashem with joy (Another speaker)
The shiur, written up
Yaakov's bowing to Esav: Midrash and Zohar
The Mashgiach brings the Manos HaLevi: Mordechai, a spark of Yaakov's soul, repaired by not bowing to Haman what Yaakov did when he bowed to Esav. Yet the Midrash criticizes that bowing, while the Zohar praises Yaakov's great wisdom in it. b,c,d,e
The Chiddushei HaRim resolves this. Four worlds correspond to sod, drush, remez and pshat, which normally fit like a well-sewn garment, but Adam's sin left places where they do not. In the world of drush the bowing was a flaw; in the world of sod it was a great tikun. Yaakov knew both and chose the tikun, worth far more than the loss, so both views are true. f
Devorah, Chulda and the order of honor
The Gemara in Megillah says haughtiness does not befit women: Devorah sent for Barak instead of going to him, and Chulda said 'tell the man' rather than 'tell the king', so they received unflattering names. The Mashgiach asks why only women, and what they did wrong. A king outranks a kohen gadol, yet when he comes for the Urim v'Tumim he must stand before him. g,h,i,j
The flaw is the situation
So Chulda, answering with Hashem's word, rightly made the king submit, and Devorah, a judge by Hashem's word as Tosafos explains, rightly had Barak come to her. The Mashgiach answers with the Chiddushei HaRim: the complaint is against the situation. A time when a man must submit to a woman and din rules is itself a flaw in creation, while chesed should rule over din, as halachos giving the right side precedence show, as in the Gemara in Shabbos. k,f,l
Adar reversed and the first letters
Adar is a reversed month, the Mashgiach says, citing the Bnei Yissaschar and the Arizal on its letter combination, where din precedes chesed. The miracle began with the first letters, 'let every man rule in his house'. Rashi explains that they made the king look a fool, which the Chasam Sofer calls forced; the Mashgiach explains that they began a new order turning din to chesed. m,n,o
This flaw came from Adam's sin, but Mordechai belonged to the world of tikun and brought a tikun never seen before, not even at Matan Torah.
The Megillah as an iggeres
Yaakov knowingly left a flaw in the world of drush for a greater tikun in sod; Mordechai, refusing to bow, repaired it and prepared the days of Moshiach. He was already of the future day that is entirely Shabbos, so he sent an iggeres about Purim. c
The Rambam rules that a Megillah written with the other Kesuvim is invalid. All year it is one of those books, but on Purim it is an iggeres of the world of tikun. Therefore, as the Midrash and the Rambam at the end of Hilchos Megillah say, all Kesuvim will be nullified but the Megillah remains. q,r,s
Doresh tov l'amo and Shushan Purim
The Gemara expounds the Megillah from its first verse to its last, which it does for no other book, because Mordechai repaired the world of drush, and the Megillah ends with 'doresh tov l'amo'. Shushan Purim is the Purim of Yerushalayim, and Mordechai was beyond the grasp of others. The Mashgiach closes with a tefilah for Moshiach and a rebuilt Yerushalayim. u,a
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 0:21 Mordechai, a spark of Yaakov's soul, repaired by refusing to bow to Haman what Yaakov did in bowing to Esav.
- 3:09 The four levels of Torah, pshat, remez, drush and sod, correspond to four worlds, and because of Adam's sin they do not always fit one another, so the Midrash and the Zohar can disagree.
- 11:43 A situation in which a man must submit to a woman, leadership through the attribute of din, is itself a flaw in creation; this, not the women's conduct, is the target of the Gemara's criticism of Devorah and Chulda.
- 15:02 The Purim miracle began with the first letters, 'let every man rule in his house', which set up a new order turning din into chesed, 'v'nahafoch hu'.
- 16:42 Mordechai came from the world of tikun and brought down a tikun of the future that did not exist even at Matan Torah, which is why Purim will remain when all else is nullified.
- 20:30 On Purim the Megillah is no longer one of the books of Kesuvim but an iggeres bound up with the world of tikun, and therefore it may not be written together with the other Kesuvim and will never be nullified.
- 23:12 Because Mordechai repaired the world of drush, the Gemara expounds the Megillah from beginning to end, which it does for no other book of Tanach.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 2:46 How can the Midrash criticize Yaakov for bowing to Esav while the Zohar praises his wisdom in doing so?
Answer: 2:58 Each speaks from a different world: in the world of drush the bowing was a flaw, while in the world of sod it was a great tikun, and Adam's sin left these worlds not fully aligned.
-
Question: 7:34 Why does the Gemara single out women for haughtiness, and what did Devorah and Chulda do wrong, when a judge and a prophetess speaking Hashem's word were right to have the man come to them?
Answer: 11:43 The criticism is not of them but of the situation: a time when a man must submit to a woman and din rules is itself a flaw in creation.
-
Question: 15:30 Why did the first letters, 'let every man rule in his house', matter, when Rashi's explanation that the king was thought a fool is forced, as the Chasam Sofer says?
Answer: 15:42 They were the beginning of the miracle: a new order in which the month turns from din to chesed.
-
Question: 20:01 Why is a Megillah written together with the other books of Kesuvim invalid?
Answer: 20:30 On Purim the Megillah is an iggeres belonging to the world of tikun and has no connection to the other books, which will one day be nullified while it remains.
-
Question: 23:12 Why does the Gemara expound the entire Megillah, which it does not do for the account of the Exodus or of Matan Torah?
Answer: 23:53 Because Mordechai repaired the world of drush.
Insights
- 4:49 The Midrash and the Zohar on Yaakov's bowing are both true: each speaks from its own world, and Yaakov, who knew both, chose to accept a flaw in the world of drush for a far greater tikun in the world of sod.
- 12:03 The Gemara's unflattering names for Devorah and Chulda do not fault them personally; they mark a time when the world was out of order, with din ruling over chesed.
- 15:40 The first letters, 'let every man rule in his house', were not a foolish decree but the very beginning of the miracle, reversing the order of din over chesed.
- 20:30 The Megillah has two statuses: all year it is one of the books of Kesuvim, but on Purim it becomes an iggeres of the world of tikun, so that being written together with the other books is a disgrace to it.
- 22:42 The word iggeres, spelled out in full, equals in gematria 'yom shekulo Shabbos', the day that is entirely Shabbos, for Mordechai belonged to that future world.
- 23:12 Because Mordechai repaired the world of drush, the Gemara expounds the Megillah verse by verse from beginning to end, and the Megillah itself ends with 'doresh tov l'amo'.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Adam HaRishon, Barak, Chuldah the prophetess, Devorah, Esav, Mordechai HaTzaddik, Rashi, the Arizal, the Chasam Sofer, the Chiddushei HaRim, the Rambam, the Ramban, Yaakov Avinu
Terms אגרת, ונהפוך הוא, יום שכולו שבת, לעתיד לבוא, מדת הדין, מדת החסד, עולם הבריאה, עולם היצירה, עולם העשיה, עולם התיקון, פרד"ס, צירוף, קלקול, שם הוי"ה, תיקון