ממוכן Awakens the Merit of the לחם הפנים

Catalog entry: ZMANIM (English) פורים no. ⁨13⁩ Pocket Guide p. 66 תשס"א (2000–01) English 59 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 59 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Mashgiach's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Mashgiach explains why Memuchan, who is Haman, has a heavenly counterpart pleading with the merit of the lechem hapanim: the bread that stayed warm shows that Hashem's love for even the rejected Jews never grows cold, and that is the miracle of Purim.

The Mashgiach opens with the Rokeach linking Purim to the lechem hapanim, and the Gemara that the names of Achashverosh's advisers are angels pleading with the merits of the korbanos, the last, Memuchan, with the lechem hapanim, though Memuchan is Haman. He explains that Amalek attacked the cast-outs of Shevet Dan, and that their surplus silver went for the hooks of the pillars, outside the kedushah, which is why Moshe forgot them. The ben ish Mitzri mocked the lechem hapanim, holding like Amalek that Hashem's love for Dan had gone stale. The Mashgiach answers that every Jew has a hidden point that is never a rasha, shown by the two identical goats of Yom Kippur and the Rambam's 'I want'. Haman's ten thousand talents matched only the main half-shekels and ignored the surplus; that surplus neutralized him. Purim is the Yom Tov of the plain Jew, and the Mashgiach ends with this year's three-day Purim in Yerushalayim and a call for tzedakah.

Topics: Purim · Hashem's Love for Klal Yisroel · The Pintele Yid: The Inner Point of Every Jew · The Mishkan and the Kohanim

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Memuchan and the lechem hapanim listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach says Purim is misunderstood and greater in a way than Yom Kippur. He brings the Rokeach linking Purim to the lechem hapanim and the Gemara that Memuchan's heavenly counterpart pleads with the lechem hapanim, and asks why, since Memuchan is Haman.

  2. 5:30 Amalek and the cast-outs of Dan listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that Hashem's anger at Amalek exceeds that at any other nation because Amalek attacked the idol-worshipping cast-outs of Shevet Dan, who were outside the Clouds of Glory. Hashem's answer is that they are still His children.

  3. 9:58 The forgotten silver of the hooks listed in the guide

    From the reckoning in Parshas Pekudei, the Mashgiach shows that the 600,000 half-shekels went for the sockets and the surplus for the hooks of the pillars, which were outside the kedushah. He reasons that this surplus came from the rejected of Dan, which is why Moshe Rabbeinu forgot it until he was reminded.

  4. 18:23 The ben ish Mitzri and the warm bread listed in the guide

    Following Rashi, the Mashgiach describes how the ben ish Mitzri mocked the lechem hapanim, which stayed warm for nine days, and insisted on a place in Dan's camp. He explains the dispute: the neighbors argued from the twelve separately baked loaves, each dear to Hashem and kept warm, that Dan is not rejected, while he denied the miracle and so took Amalek's position.

  5. 30:00 The hidden point in every Jew listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach teaches that every Jew has an inextinguishable point where he is not a rasha, citing the Ba'al Shem Tov, Reb Tzadok HaKohen on the two identical goats of Yom Kippur and on Yaakov and Esav, and the Rambam on a forced 'I want'. Yom Kippur and Purim both bring this inner will to the surface.

  6. 39:48 Haman's silver and the surplus listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach brings Tosafos that Haman's ten thousand talents matched the half-shekels of the 600,000 and asks why Haman did not pay for the surplus. He answers that Haman, like Amalek, discounted the rejected Jews, and their surplus silver came first and nullified his shekalim; Purim is thus the Yom Tov of the plain Jew.

  7. 45:03 Haman as the Mitzri, and our generation listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach brings the Yaaros Devash that Haman was a gilgul of the Mitzri whom Moshe killed and Mordechai a gilgul of Moshe, and adds that the ben ish Mitzri therefore shared Haman's view. He returns to the lechem hapanim as proof of the hidden point, and suggests that today's generation are gilgulim of Shevet Dan.

  8. 49:00 The Yom Tov of the rejected listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach says Purim is the Yom Tov of the rejected, whose joy is simply being a Yid, as Mordechai would not bow because he was a Yid. He contrasts milah, the point of the Jew, with tefillin, the mitzvos, says Purim has both, and that each Purim grows greater as the generations fall lower.

  9. 53:58 Three-day Purim and a call for tzedakah

    The Mashgiach describes this year's three-day Purim in Yerushalayim, which Shabbos magnifies, and says it reaches all of Klal Yisrael at a time of danger with no natural solution. He closes by urging the listeners to rest, hear every word of the Megillah, and give more tzedakah than they can, since the miracle came through the extra silver.

The shiur, written up

Memuchan and the lechem hapanim

1:51

The Mashgiach opens by saying that nobody truly understands Purim, and that in a way it is greater than Yom Kippur, which is called Kippurim, 'like Purim'. He brings the Rokeach, who notes that in the parsha of the Yamim Tovim, after the lamps, comes the parsha of the lechem hapanim, the twelve loaves, and says that this is Purim. Where, the Mashgiach asks, does the lechem hapanim come into Purim? a

3:45

To answer, he brings the Gemara that the names of Achashverosh's advisers are names of angels who pleaded for the Jews with the merit of the korbanos. The last, Memuchan, stands for the table and the lechem hapanim, and the Gemara says that Memuchan is Haman. Why should Haman's counterpart plead with the lechem hapanim? b

Amalek and the cast-outs of Dan

6:24

The Mashgiach notes that Hashem's anger at Amalek, from thousands of years ago, has not settled, more than at Mitzrayim or Bavel. The reason is whom Amalek attacked: according to the Targum Yonasan, members of Shevet Dan who had an idol with them were cast out of the camp, beyond the Clouds of Glory, and Amalek could wage war against them. Hashem's answer to Amalek, he explains, is that they are still His children, whatever they deserve. c

The forgotten silver of the hooks

10:29

The Mashgiach turns to the reckoning in Parshas Pekudei. The 600,000 half-shekels made a hundred talents of silver, one for each socket, but there were some three thousand more Jews, and their 1,775 shekels were a surplus. A Midrash relates that Moshe Rabbeinu did not remember what he had done with it until he was reminded, and the Mashgiach mentions a version that Rabbi Akiva's neshamah reminded him. d,e

13:35

The surplus went for the hooks on the pillars of the courtyard, which, following Rashi, held the curtains and protruded outside. Every other part of the Mishkan was within the kedushah, and the Alshich explains that each donation went according to the giver's level. f

17:00

From this the Mashgiach reasons that the silver for the hooks, which were outside, came from Jews who were also outside: the cast-outs of Dan. This is why Moshe forgot it. They were forgotten Jews, outside the camp, and their money went for the part of the Mishkan that was outside.

The ben ish Mitzri and the warm bread

19:28

The Mashgiach brings Rashi on the ben ish Mitzri: he came out from the parsha of the lechem hapanim and mocked it. The loaves stayed on the table a week and reached the kohanim nine days old, yet miraculously stayed warm and fresh, as the passuk in Shmuel calls it hot bread on the day it was taken. He scoffed that a king eats fresh bread, not stale bread, and denied the miracle. g,h

22:23

He also insisted on pitching his tent in the camp of Dan. The Mashgiach suggests his argument: Dan is last of the twelve tribes, as Adar is last of the months, which the Pri Tzaddik connects to Dan; Dan sinned and its cast-outs were killed by Amalek, so its camp is not truly part of the Jewish camp. j

25:04

His neighbors answered from the lechem hapanim. The Gemara teaches that each of the twelve loaves had to be kneaded and baked separately, showing that each tribe is dear to Hashem in its own right, and the miracle that all stayed warm shows that His love never becomes stale. He replied that the loaves were cold and the love had grown old. By denying the miracle, the Mashgiach says, he took Amalek's position that a Jew who sins is rejected. i

The hidden point in every Jew

30:00

Why did Hashem take the side of idol worshippers? The Mashgiach answers that every Jew has a point, an inheritance from the forefathers, that can never be extinguished, though it may be covered over. The Ba'al Shem Tov says there is a chamber in every Jew's heart where he is not a rasha.

31:55

He connects this to Yom Kippur. The Gemara requires the two goats to be identical, one for Hashem and one for Azazel. Reb Tzadok HaKohen explains that Klal Yisrael has tzaddikim, beinonim and resha'im, but in the hidden root reaching back to Avraham Avinu all are equal. On the passuk in Malachi he explains that Yaakov may look just like Esav, yet Hashem loves Yaakov for that point, and so the two goats look the same. k,l

36:05

The Mashgiach adds the Rambam: when a man is compelled until he says 'I want', it is valid, because his refusal comes from his yetzer, and once that is subdued his neshamah speaks. Yom Kippur brings out every Jew's 'I want', and Purim does the same. m

Haman's silver and the surplus

40:00

Amalek, the ben ish Mitzri and Haman made the same mistake. Haman offered ten thousand talents of silver, which Tosafos explains matched the half-shekels of the 600,000, and the Mashgiach adds that Haman gave it to charity to equal their merit. But then he should have paid for the surplus too. He did not, the Mashgiach answers, because it came from the cast-outs, whom he considered cold and worthless, people who would never do teshuvah. o,p

43:42

That is the miracle: Hashem's shekalim came before Haman's, and the extra shekalim of the rejected nullified his decree. Purim is therefore the Yom Tov of being a Yid, not for being a tzaddik as with Shavuos, Pesach or Sukkos, but a plain, ordinary Jew. r

Haman as the Mitzri, and our generation

45:26

The Mashgiach brings the Yaaros Devash that Haman was a gilgul of the Mitzri whom Moshe killed, and Mordechai a gilgul of Moshe, which is why Haman hated him. He adds that the ben ish Mitzri therefore held like Haman, that the rejected are cast off. The lechem hapanim proves otherwise, since even the twelfth loaf never becomes stale. He then suggests that today's Jews are gilgulim of Shevet Dan, which is why so many do not know what Shema Yisrael means. q

The Yom Tov of the rejected

49:06

Purim is the Yom Tov of the rejected, and its simcha is to be happy with one's root, that one is a Yid. The Mashgiach explains that Mordechai did not bow to Haman simply because he was a Yid. He contrasts milah, given to a child as the point of the Jew whether or not he keeps mitzvos, with tefillin, begun at bar mitzvah for the mitzvos, and says Purim has both.

52:11

He adds that every Purim grows greater through history: the generations fall lower, and the lower they are, the greater the Purim, because Purim was meant for the rejected.

Three-day Purim and a call for tzedakah

54:08

The Mashgiach notes that this year Purim in Yerushalayim falls on Shabbos and lasts three days, and that Shabbos magnifies it; whatever happens in Yerushalayim affects all of Klal Yisrael. With no military or diplomatic solution to the danger there, Hashem gives an extra Purim, the day He shows His love for the Jews only because they are Jews.

57:17

He closes by urging the listeners not to stay up all night, so as to hear every word of the Megillah, and to give tzedakah beyond their means, since the miracle came through the extra silver that outweighed Haman's.

Sources

Torah

  1. d Shemos 38:25-28 text index In the write-up: 10:29

Nevi'im

  1. h Shmuel I 21:7 text index In the write-up: 19:28
  2. l Malachi 1:2 text index In the write-up: 31:55

Kesuvim

  1. o Esther 3:9 text index In the write-up: 40:00

Targum

  1. c apparently Targum Yonasan, Shemos 17:8 index In the write-up: 6:24

Talmud Bavli

  1. b Megillah 12b text index In the write-up: 3:45
  2. i Gemara (place not identified) index In the write-up: 25:04
  3. k apparently Yoma 62a index In the write-up: 31:55
  4. n apparently Sanhedrin 97b 36:48 index
  5. r apparently Megillah 13b index In the write-up: 43:42

Midrash

  1. e Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 10:29

Rishonim

  1. a Rokeach (place not identified) index In the write-up: 1:51
  2. f Rashi (place not identified) index In the write-up: 13:35
  3. g Rashi, Vayikra 24:10 text index In the write-up: 19:28
  4. m apparently Rambam, Hilchos Geirushin 2:20 index In the write-up: 36:05
  5. p Tosafos (place not identified) index In the write-up: 40:00

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. j Pri Tzaddik (place not identified) index In the write-up: 22:23
  2. q Yaaros Devash (place not identified) index In the write-up: 45:26

Key points

  1. 4:45 According to the Gemara, Memuchan's heavenly counterpart pleads with the merit of the lechem hapanim, and Memuchan is Haman; the shiur sets out to explain the connection.
  2. 7:23 Amalek attacked the cast-outs of Shevet Dan, who were outside the Clouds of Glory, and Hashem's anger at Amalek is the greatest because they started with His children.
  3. 15:29 The surplus silver of the half-shekel, given by the Jews who were outside, went for the hooks of the pillars, the one part of the Mishkan outside the kedushah, which is why Moshe Rabbeinu forgot it.
  4. 25:57 The warm lechem hapanim shows that Hashem's love for every tribe, even Dan, never becomes stale; the ben ish Mitzri who denied the miracle sided with Amalek.
  5. 30:00 Every Jew has a hidden point, rooted in Avraham Avinu, where he is not a rasha; this is why the two goats of Yom Kippur must be identical.
  6. 40:28 Haman's ten thousand talents matched only the 600,000 half-shekels, not the surplus of the rejected, and that surplus is what nullified his decree.
  7. 44:19 Purim is the Yom Tov of the simple Jew, celebrating only that he is a Yid, and in the lowest generations it grows greater.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 5:11 Why is Memuchan identified with Haman, and why does his heavenly counterpart plead with the lechem hapanim?

    Answer: 46:45 Haman held that Hashem's love for the rejected Jews had grown cold; the lechem hapanim, which stayed warm, proves that even the twelfth loaf never goes stale.

  2. Question: 5:30 Why is Hashem's anger at Amalek greater than at any other nation that oppressed the Jews?

    Answer: 8:25 Because Amalek started with the cast-outs of Dan, and Hashem says they are still His children.

  3. Question: 11:47 Why did Moshe Rabbeinu forget what he did with the surplus silver?

    Answer: 17:34 The surplus came from the rejected Jews who were outside, and went for the hooks that were outside; they were forgotten Jews.

  4. Question: 29:39 If the cast-outs of Dan were idol worshippers, why did Hashem take their side against Amalek?

    Answer: 30:00 Every Jew has an inextinguishable point, inherited from the forefathers, where he is not a rasha.

  5. Question: 42:20 If Haman meant to match the Jews' half-shekels, why did he not pay for the surplus too?

    Answer: 43:00 The surplus came from the rejected, and Haman, like Amalek, held that they were not counted as Jews and would never do teshuvah.

  6. Question: 51:15 Why is milah given to an infant rather than when he is old enough to value the great mitzvah?

    Answer: 51:30 Milah is the point of the Jew, regardless of his mitzvos, while tefillin, begun at bar mitzvah, stands for the mitzvos.

Insights

  1. 5:23 The angel opposite Memuchan, who is Haman, pleads with the lechem hapanim because Haman's error was the opposite of its lesson: he held that Hashem's love for the rejected had gone cold, while the bread that stayed warm shows that it never does.
  2. 17:00 The surplus silver used for the protruding hooks, outside the kedushah of the Mishkan, came from the cast-outs of Dan, and Moshe Rabbeinu forgot it because they were forgotten Jews.
  3. 24:35 The ben ish Mitzri's mockery of the stale lechem hapanim and his claim that Dan's camp was open to him were one position, the same as Amalek's: that the rejected are outside Hashem's love.
  4. 34:38 The two goats of Yom Kippur must be identical because Yaakov and Esav can look the same, yet Hashem loves Yaakov for the hidden point within him.
  5. 43:05 Haman matched the main half-shekels but ignored the surplus of the rejected; that overlooked silver, given first, is what nullified his decree.
  6. 48:38 The Mashgiach suggests that today's Jews are gilgulim of Shevet Dan, so Purim, the Yom Tov of the rejected, is their Yom Tov and grows greater the lower they fall.

What the Mashgiach says to take from it

  1. 57:17 The Mashgiach urges not to stay up late on Purim night, so as to be rested and hear every word of the Megillah.
  2. 57:38 The Mashgiach urges giving much tzedakah on Purim, more than one can and then more, since the miracle came through the extra silver.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Avraham Avinu, Esav, Esther HaMalkah, Haman, Memuchan, Mordechai HaTzaddik, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbi Akiva, Rabbi Tzadok HaKohen of Lublin, Rabbi Yonasan Eybeschutz, Rashi, the Alshich, the Baal Shem Tov, the Chasam Sofer, the Rambam, Vashti, Yaakov Avinu

Terms אדנים, ווי העמודים, לחם הפנים, מחצית השקל, ענני הכבוד, פורים המשולש, רבונו של עולם, רוצה אני, שורש הנעלם, שעיר לעזאזל

Report an error on this page