מרדכי and אסתר Rectified the חטא עץ הדעת
Catalog entry: ZMANIM (English) פורים no. 14 Pocket Guide p. 66 תשס"ד (2003–04) English 55 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains that the root of Adam's sin, of the Golden Calf and of the error at Achashverosh's feast was not waiting, that Mordechai came to repair it, and that on Purim and in Parshas Parah Hashem reaches even the Jews who stand outside.
The Mashgiach opens with Rashi's account of the Golden Calf: the people counted Moshe's forty days from the day he went up, and erred. Why could they not apply the rule that part of a day counts as a whole? Through the Bnei Yissaschar's teaching that a mikveh's forty se'ah hold 960 lugin, and that Matan Torah is a rebirth like a mikveh, he shows that 960 full hours were needed. Every mistake has a root: the people did not wait, just as Adam did not wait for Shabbos to make Kiddush from the Tree of Knowledge. The same error recurred when the Jews miscounted the seventy years and went to Achashverosh's feast, while Mordechai warned them to wait. The Mashgiach applies this to waiting for Moshiach today. He then discusses the five final letters, Haman's shekalim, the forgotten hooks of the pillars, the rejected Jews of the tribe of Dan, Tehillim 34, and Parshas Parah as a salvation reaching those who are outside.
Topics: Purim · Adam HaRishon and Gan Eden · Awaiting Moshiach · The Golden Calf and the Thirteen Middos · Hashem's Love for Klal Yisroel
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Forty full days: Matan Torah as a mikveh
The Mashgiach asks, from Rashi on the Golden Calf, why part of the first day could not count for Moshe's forty days. He brings the Bnei Yissaschar that a mikveh's forty se'ah are 960 lugin, the measure in which even a creature is nullified, so that the 960 hours of Elul to Yom Kippur are a mikveh, and applies this to Matan Torah, which needed 960 full hours.
-
8:39 The root of the mistake: not waiting
The Mashgiach says every mistake has a root: the people did not wait one more day, just as Adam did not wait for Shabbos to make Kiddush from the Tree of Knowledge. Had they waited, Matan Torah would have brought the perfected world. He tells of the Malbim describing to the maskilim how a Jew must wait before he may eat, and concludes that the whole Torah is built on waiting.
-
15:14 Achashverosh's feast and Mordechai's repair listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Gemara that the seventy years were miscalculated, and explains that the Jews went to Achashverosh's feast because they thought the redemption would no longer come, while Mordechai warned them to wait. Mordechai was thus a repair of Adam's sin, since the Tree of Knowledge mixed good and evil and waiting for Shabbos would have left only its good.
-
20:32 Our task now: waiting for Moshiach
The Mashgiach applies the lesson: the repair of the sin is to wait for Moshiach. Though the signs in the Gemara fit this generation, one must not think the redemption has come; he calls the State of Israel a mixture of good and evil, and brings the navi's words about waiting for Hashem who hides His face.
-
24:26 The five final letters: din and geulah
The Mashgiach brings, from the Bnei Yissaschar in the name of the Arizal, that the five final letters are letters of din, the 280 judgments, and also, according to the Midrash, letters of redemption, each tied to a geulah from Avraham to the final one. He brings the passuk in Yeshayahu about awaiting the tzaddik and shows the five letters in Haman, Zeresh and his wise men.
-
29:43 Haman's shekalim and the forgotten Jews
The Mashgiach explains that Haman's ten thousand kikar matched the half-shekel of the 600,000, but not the extra 1775 shekalim that Moshe forgot and that became the hooks of the pillars. These correspond to the letters at the very end of the Torah and to the rejected Jews of the tribe of Dan, whom the cloud did not protect and Amalek attacked; Haman gave nothing against them, and they brought the salvation.
-
36:37 Tehillim 34 and the tribe of Dan
The Mashgiach brings that Tehillim 34, whose verse forms the letter combination of Dan's month, follows the whole aleph-beis and adds one last verse outside it, about Hashem redeeming His servants; this verse belongs to Dan's rejected ones and equals in gematria the hooks of the pillars. The whole aleph-beis with the five final letters totals 1775, the forgotten shekalim, showing they are included in Klal Yisrael.
-
43:00 Kol Yisrael: the root no sin reaches
The Mashgiach asks why Hashem cares so much for the rejected of Dan, and answers from Parshas Ki Sisa, read near Purim: Hashem shows favor even to those who do not deserve it, looking to the root of the Jewish soul. He brings the Yismach Moshe on the 'island' of Kol Yisrael that no sin can blemish and the Rambam that every Jew inwardly wants Hashem's will, and ties this to the salvation of Purim and to 'ad delo yada'.
-
48:18 Parshas Parah: salvation outside the camp
The Mashgiach explains that Parshas Parah after Purim continues Purim and sweetens the 280 judgments. He brings the Tanya's question why the red heifer atones more than a chatas, and adds that the parah is done outside the camp, bringing salvation to those outside, like the last letters of the Torah. He closes with a brachah to be purified for Pesach.
The shiur, written up
Forty full days: Matan Torah as a mikveh
The Mashgiach opens with Rashi on the Golden Calf: the people counted Moshe's forty days from the day he went up, but that day lacked its night, so they erred by a day. He asks why they could not apply the rule that part of a day counts as a whole. a
He brings the Bnei Yissaschar: a mikveh's forty se'ah hold 960 lugin, and the Yerushalmi says that in 960 even a whole creature becomes nullified. One leaves the mikveh reborn, and the 960 hours of the forty days from Rosh Chodesh Elul to Yom Kippur are such a mikveh, as the Zohar calls Yom Kippur a mikveh of Yisrael. b,c,d
The root of the mistake: not waiting
Every mistake, the Mashgiach says, has a root: they should have waited one more day, and they did not. This was also Adam's sin. The Midrash, brought by the Arizal, says Adam was meant to wait until Shabbos and make Kiddush over the juice of the Tree of Knowledge's grapes, and then the world would have been as Hashem planned it. h
At Matan Torah, the Gemara says, the impurity of that sin left the Jews; had they completed the forty days, the perfected world would have come at once. They spoiled it on the last day by not waiting. The Mashgiach then tells how the Malbim described to the maskilim how long a Jew must wait before he may eat, and concludes that the whole Torah is built on waiting. g
Achashverosh's feast and Mordechai's repair
The Gemara says the seventy years were miscalculated. The Jews thought the redemption would not come and went to Achashverosh's feast, held to celebrate that, while Mordechai warned them to wait. The same mistake as at the Calf recurred. j
Mordechai was therefore, in a small way, a repair of Adam's sin. The Tree of Knowledge held good and evil; had Adam waited for Shabbos, when evil has no hold, only its good would have remained.
Our task now: waiting for Moshiach
The repair for us, the Mashgiach says, is to wait for Moshiach. The signs in the Gemara in Sotah and Chelek fit this generation, yet one must not think the redemption has come. He calls the State a mixture of good and evil, and brings the navi's words about waiting for Hashem who hides His face. k,l
The five final letters
From the Bnei Yissaschar, citing the Arizal, the Mashgiach explains that the five final letters stand outside the aleph-beis and are letters of din, the 280 judgments. Yet the Midrash calls them letters of redemption: chaf for Avraham, mem for Yitzchak, nun for Yaakov, pei for Egypt, and tzadi for the final redemption. m,n
Haman's shekalim and the forgotten Jews
Haman offered ten thousand kikar of silver to offset the half-shekel of the 600,000. But there were 1775 extra shekalim, used for the hooks of the pillars, which Moshe forgot. Why, if the Torah was given to him as a gift so he would not forget? p,q,r
The Mashgiach explains that these match the letters at the end of the Torah that Yehoshua wrote, and the rejected Jews of Dan, whom the cloud did not shelter and Amalek attacked. No Jew is ever rejected by Hashem. Haman gave nothing against them, so they brought the salvation; like the hooks protruding outside the curtains, they stood outside. s
Tehillim 34 and the tribe of Dan
Kol Yisrael: the root no sin reaches
Why does Hashem care so for Dan's rejected? Parshas Ki Sisa, read near Purim, teaches that Hashem shows favor even to the undeserving, looking to the soul's root. The Yismach Moshe describes an 'island' called Kol Yisrael that no sin can blemish, and the Rambam says every Jew inwardly wants Hashem's will. v,w,x
Parshas Parah: salvation outside the camp
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
- e Gemara (place not identified) index In the write-up: 6:39
- g Shabbos 146a text index In the write-up: 11:15
- i apparently Avodah Zarah 5a 12:06 index
- j Megillah 11b text index In the write-up: 15:14
- k apparently Sotah 49b; Sanhedrin 97a index In the write-up: 20:37
- s apparently Bava Basra 15a index In the write-up: 31:50
- y Megillah 7b text index In the write-up: 47:18, 51:30
Talmud Yerushalmi
Midrash
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
- b Bnei Yissaschar (place not identified) index In the write-up: 1:36
- f Yismach Moshe (place not identified) 7:07 index
- m Bnei Yissaschar (place not identified) index In the write-up: 24:26
- u Bnei Yissaschar (place not identified) index In the write-up: 37:50
- w apparently Yismach Moshe, Parshas Devarim index In the write-up: 43:24
- z Bnei Yissaschar (place not identified) 48:55 index
- aa Tanya (place not identified) index In the write-up: 48:18
Key points
- 4:31 Matan Torah was a rebirth like immersion in a mikveh, so it required forty complete days of 24 hours, 960 hours matching the 960 lugin of a mikveh; the rule that part of a day counts as a whole does not apply.
- 9:08 The root of the error at the Golden Calf, and of Adam's sin before it, was not waiting: Adam should have waited for Shabbos to make Kiddush over the juice of the Tree of Knowledge.
- 16:25 The Jews who went to Achashverosh's feast repeated the same mistake: they thought the seventy years had passed without redemption, while Mordechai warned them to wait, making him a repair of Adam's sin.
- 20:37 The Mashgiach says the task of our generation is to wait for Moshiach and not to think that the redemption has already come.
- 30:27 The extra 1775 shekalim, which became the hooks of the pillars, correspond to the rejected Jews of the tribe of Dan who stood outside the camp, and Haman's money did not counter their merit.
- 44:13 At the root of every Jewish soul, called Kol Yisrael, no sin can reach, and from there Hashem shows favor even to those who do not deserve it, as on Purim.
- 48:26 Parshas Parah, read after Purim, continues Purim: the red heifer is burned outside the camp and brings salvation to those who are outside.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 1:06 Why could the people not count part of the first day toward Moshe's forty days, as with the rule that part of a day counts as a whole?
Answer: 6:42 Because Matan Torah is like a mikveh and needs 960 full hours, as a mikveh needs 960 lugin; it is a matter of hours, not days.
-
Question: 16:12 Why did the Jews go to Achashverosh's feast despite Mordechai's warning?
Answer: 16:47 They miscounted the seventy years and thought the promised redemption would not come; they did not wait.
-
Question: 31:11 Why did Moshe forget the 1775 extra shekalim, when the Torah was given to him as a gift so that he would not forget?
Answer: 31:26 They correspond to the rejected Jews outside the camp and to the letters at the end of the Torah that Moshe did not write, so they stood outside and were forgotten.
-
Question: 43:02 Why does Hashem care so much for the rejected Jews of the tribe of Dan?
Answer: 44:13 Because Hashem looks to the root of the Jewish soul, Kol Yisrael, where no sin can reach, and shows favor even to the undeserving.
-
Question: 50:48 Why does the red heifer atone more than a chatas offering?
Answer: 51:20 A chatas atones only for unintentional sins while the parah atones even for intentional ones, coming from a higher place; the Mashgiach adds that it is done outside the camp.
Stories
-
13:21 The Malbim and the maskilim
The Mashgiach tells that the Malbim used to debate the maskilim and always won. He once described to them how much he must wait: he wakes hungry but must first daven at length, then wash, make a brachah and dip the bread in salt three times before he may eat. They, he said, can eat breakfast in bed and need not wait.
In the story: the Malbim
Insights
- 3:20 The 960 hours of forty full days correspond to the 960 lugin of a mikveh, the measure in which even a whole creature is nullified, so Matan Torah, a rebirth like a mikveh, could not use 'part of the day counts as a whole'.
- 9:43 Adam's sin, the error before the Golden Calf and the error at Achashverosh's feast share one root, not waiting, and Mordechai, who urged the Jews to wait, was a repair of Adam's sin.
- 26:15 The five final letters are letters of din, yet the Midrash calls them letters of redemption; the purpose of din is to be transformed into geulah.
- 34:05 Haman's ten thousand kikar offset only the shekalim of the 600,000; the extra 1775 shekalim, linked to the rejected Jews of Dan, had nothing against them, and so it was they who brought the salvation.
- 41:41 The sum of the whole aleph-beis together with the five final letters is 1775, the number of forgotten shekalim, showing that those outside are still included in Klal Yisrael.
- 51:30 Beyond the Tanya's answer, the Mashgiach adds that the red heifer is prepared outside the camp, unlike a chatas, and so it brings salvation to those who are outside, like the rejected of Dan.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 20:47 The Mashgiach says we must wait for Moshiach and not make the mistake of thinking the redemption has already come.
- 33:51 The Mashgiach says that no Jew is ever rejected by Hashem, even the lowest.
- 54:08 The Mashgiach blesses that through Parshas Parah all should be purified and merit to enter Pesach in holiness.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Achashverosh, Adam HaRishon, Avraham Avinu, Daniel, Haman, Mordechai HaTzaddik, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rebbe Elimelech of Lizhensk (the Noam Elimelech), the Arizal, the Bnei Yissaschar (Rabbi Tzvi Elimelech of Dinov), the Malbim, Yaakov Avinu, Yehoshua bin Nun, Yirmiyahu HaNavi, Zeresh
Terms ווי העמודים, כלל ישראל, לבלתי ידח ממנו נדח, מחוץ למחנה, מחצית השקל, מקוה, עד דלא ידע, עולם התיקון, עץ הדעת, פרה אדומה, צירוף