The Hidden נס of the מגילה
Catalog entry: ZMANIM (English) פורים For Children no. 3 Pocket Guide p. 65 תשנ"ז (1996–97) English 27 min
for children (per file name)
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach shows children that the Megillah is full of hidden miracles, cloaked in nature like the month of Adar, and that Purim trains a person to find Hashem behind everything that happens.
Speaking to boys, the Mashgiach says Purim is not a costume holiday but the foundation of emunah. Yet before the Megillah we bless Hashem for making miracles, and walking through the story he finds none: unlike the plagues and the splitting of the Sea, everything could have been read in a newspaper. He brings the Bnei Yissaschar's parable of a dying man for whom an unexpected doctor and an unexpected medicine arrive at the same moment, and adds his own image of a watch that reassembles itself when shaken. Then he explains two kinds of miracles: those that break nature, like the manna, and nature itself, which only habit hides. Nisan is the month of open miracles; Adar, from 'aderes', a cloak, is the month of cloaked ones. The Megillah's perfect timing, and events in our own day, show Hashem's hand. Purim, he concludes, trains a person to find Hashem in his own life.
Topics: Miracles and Nature · Megillas Esther · Hashgacha Pratis · Chodesh Adar · Purim
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Searching the Megillah for miracles listed in the guide
The Mashgiach tells the boys that Purim is not a Jewish Halloween but the foundation of emunah, and notes that before the Megillah we bless Hashem for making miracles. He then walks through the whole story, contrasts it with the plagues and the splitting of the Sea, and finds no miracle at all: everything could have been read in a newspaper.
-
5:11 The doctor, the medicine and the watch listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Bnei Yissaschar's parable of a man with two hours to live, whose only cure is a medicine six months away that only a distant doctor can give, until both the doctor and the medicine unexpectedly arrive at the door. He asks whether that is not a miracle, and adds a parable of a watch taken apart and put in a can, which reassembles itself when shaken.
-
11:49 Two kinds of miracles: Nisan and Adar listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains two kinds of miracles: the manna, which breaks nature, and wheat growing from the ground, which is no less a miracle but is taken for granted; he brings the Chasam Sofer's picture of the generation born in the desert who saw bread grow from the ground as a wonder. Nisan is named for the open miracles of the Exodus, while Adar, from 'aderes sei'ar', a cloak, is the month of cloaked miracles.
-
16:50 Hidden miracles in the Megillah and today listed in the guide
The Mashgiach contrasts the open miracles of the Beis HaMikdash with golus, where Hashem is shrouded in nature, and goes back through the Megillah showing how each event came exactly when it was needed. He tells of the Iraqi Scud missiles, where only one man was killed, a man the Steipler had cursed, and brings the Midrash that 'the King' in the Megillah refers to the Ribono shel Olam.
-
21:31 Purim as hide-and-seek with Hashem listed in the guide
The Mashgiach concludes that Purim teaches how to read the Megillah, history and current events, calling it a game of hide-and-seek in which Hashem says 'find Me'. The costumed visitor at the seudah shows that all the world's rulers are only cloaked, and the same Hashem who made the plagues and the manna makes miracles today. He tells the boys to train themselves to look for Hashem in everything that happens and to know He takes care of them.
The shiur, written up
Searching the Megillah for miracles
The doctor, the medicine and the watch
The Bnei Yissaschar answers with a parable. A doctor gives a sick man two hours to live, then adds that a medicine in China could cure him, six months' travel away, and that only a trained doctor in America could give it. As he speaks, someone bursts in with the American doctor, just off the boat, and then another arrives with the medicine. The man recovers. b
No miracle appeared, the Mashgiach says, yet doctor and medicine both came unexpectedly at the exact moment: that is a miracle. Likewise a watch taken apart and shaken in a can, if every part fell into place, would be a miracle.
Two kinds of miracles: Nisan and Adar
There are miracles that change nature, like manna falling from heaven, but a kernel rotting in the ground and yielding thousands of kernels is no less a miracle; we are just used to it. The Chasam Sofer pictures the children born in the desert entering Eretz Yisroel and marveling at bread from the ground.
Hidden miracles in the Megillah and today
Purim as hide-and-seek with Hashem
Purim, the Mashgiach concludes, teaches how to read the Megillah, history and current events. It is hide-and-seek: Hashem says 'find Me', and one trained on the Megillah finds Him in his own life. A costumed collector frightens nobody, and so too the world's rulers are only cloaked in Adar's 'aderes'.
The same Hashem who made the plagues and the manna makes miracles today. The Mashgiach tells the boys to look for Him in whatever happens and to drill themselves in emunah, knowing He watches each one with hashgachah pratis.
Sources
Torah
Mishnah
Midrash
- f Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 19:31
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 0:36 Purim is not a Jewish Halloween but, the Mashgiach says, the foundation of emunah in the Ribono shel Olam.
- 2:17 Read on the surface, the Megillah has no open miracle: every event is natural, unlike the plagues and the splitting of the Sea.
- 11:55 There are two kinds of miracles: those where Hashem changes nature, and those hidden inside nature, which people take for granted only because they are used to them.
- 15:30 Nisan is the month of open miracles, while Adar, related to 'aderes', a cloak, is the month of miracles cloaked in nature.
- 17:15 In golus Hashem hides in nature, but the Megillah shows His hand through perfect timing: each event happened exactly when it was needed.
- 21:47 Purim teaches how to read the Megillah, history and current events, and to find Hashem hiding in one's own life, as in a game of hide-and-seek.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 5:03 Why do we bless Hashem for making miracles on Purim, if the Megillah contains no miracle?
Answer: 5:24 Its miracles are hidden in nature: like the doctor and medicine arriving together, every event in the Megillah came exactly when it was needed.
-
Question: 13:18 Is the natural growth of wheat a miracle?
Answer: 13:22 Yes; it seems ordinary only because we are used to it, as shown by the children of the desert who saw it as a great miracle.
Stories
-
19:27 The Scud missiles on Eretz Yisroel
The Mashgiach recalls that the Iraqis fired 39 Scud missiles at Eretz Yisroel, which brought down many buildings, yet only one person was killed. That man had hung a sign on his door saying he eats pig and had ridden his motorcycle into a beis medrash on Shabbos, and the Steipler had cursed him. When the Iraqis fired a single Scud at the American army, some thirty soldiers were killed.
In the story: the Steipler
Insights
- 4:57 Read event by event, the Megillah contains nothing a newspaper could not report; its miracle lies only in how the natural events fit together.
- 13:12 Natural growth of wheat is as great a miracle as the manna; the children born in the desert, used to bread from heaven, saw bread from the ground as the wonder.
- 15:30 The months descend from Nisan, named for open miracles, to Adar, whose name means a cloak, so Adar's miracles are the cloaked ones.
- 17:47 The Mashgiach calls the Megillah's hidden miracles 'even bigger' than the supernatural miracles of the Exodus.
- 23:41 Purim's costumes become a lesson: the world's kings and rulers are only dressed in the 'aderes' of Adar, while Hashem controls them from behind.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 25:18 The Mashgiach tells the boys that when something happens in their lives, their families or the news, their first reaction should be to look for where Hashem is hiding in it.
- 25:55 He urges them to use Purim as a drill in emunah, training themselves to know that Hashem controls everything with hashgachah pratis and that they have nothing to worry about.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Achashverosh, Bigsan and Teresh, Charvonah, Esther HaMalkah, Haman, Mordechai HaTzaddik, the Bnei Yissaschar (Rabbi Tzvi Elimelech of Dinov), the Chasam Sofer, the Steipler, Vashti
Terms אדרת, אמונה, השגחה פרטית, טבע, יציאת מצרים, מן, נס, עשר מכות, קללות, קריעת ים סוף, רבונו של עולם