ביאורי מהר"ל על מגילת אסתר - כל דבר שהוא יותר בקדושה הוא יותר בהסתרה. ועוד

Catalog entry: זמנים פורים no. ⁨3⁩ Pocket Guide p. 23 תשל"ח (1977–78) Yiddish 56 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 56 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Mashgiach's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Mashgiach explains, largely following the Maharal, that the holier a thing is the more it must be hidden, and shows how the hidden miracle of Purim, Achashverosh's feast and the Megillah's message to the 'distant' all flow from this.

The Mashgiach opens with the Gemara's allusion to Esther in 'haster astir': her salvation came from a hidden place, and the Purim miracles are greater precisely because they are concealed. Following the Maharal he links this to wine, to Binyamin as the last-born, to Yaakov's later emergence than Eisav, and to the hadas whose leaves cover its wood. Through Rabbi Pinchas of Koritz he ties the four parshiyos to the hidden light, which only tzaddikim can bear, and shows that every great holiness, from a sefer Torah to a Jew's head, needs more covering. The Megillah hides Hashem's name, yet 'the King' alludes to Him and Achashverosh's kingdom mirrors the heavenly one. Achashverosh's feast celebrated the end of the seventy years without redemption; the Jews' sin was rejoicing that kingship stayed in exile. He ends with the king who values the distant pearl, and Adar as the month of the distant.

Topics: Hester Panim and Suffering · Purim · Megillas Esther

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Esther: salvation from a hidden place listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach brings the Gemara's allusion to Esther in 'haster astir' and explains that some salvations come from a hidden source, and that the Purim miracles are greater because they are concealed. With the Maharal he connects this to wine, to Binyamin as the last tribe born, to Yaakov emerging after Eisav, and to the hadas whose leaves cover its wood.

  2. 4:11 The hidden light, Shabbos and the Torah listed in the guide

    Through Rabbi Pinchas of Koritz the Mashgiach links the four parshiyos to the hidden light, which only tzaddikim can bear and which the wicked cannot tolerate on Shabbos. He shows that Moshe Rabbeinu, Shabbos and the Torah all share this light, and explains why a sefer must not be left open.

  3. 8:43 More holiness needs more covering listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach shows that Jews add garments for davening and before a great man, cover the head, wear a gartel, and wrap the sefer Torah, because greater holiness needs greater protection; he brings the Gemara's story of the boy whose covered head guarded him. He ties the reading of the mishkan's coverings to Adar and explains the extra sifrei Torah on the four parshiyos and on Simchas Torah.

  4. 17:00 The hidden King of the Megillah listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach notes that the Megillah never mentions Hashem's name, yet a great chesed came down hidden; therefore shalach manos is covered. 'The King' in the Megillah alludes to Hashem, earthly kingship mirrors heavenly kingship, and the Maharal explains Achashverosh's 127 provinces as seven, twenty and one hundred, corresponding to three worlds.

  5. 23:24 The seventy-year reckoning listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach brings the Gemara that the Persians knew of the prophecy that the Beis Hamikdash would be rebuilt after seventy years; Belshazzar miscalculated, used the Temple vessels and was killed, and Achashverosh made his own reckoning. He explains that the nations, deep inside, sense that there is a Creator and fear the prophecy.

  6. 28:33 No one knows the time of redemption listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach says even Daniel erred in the reckoning, and brings the Rambam that Rabbi Akiva thought Bar Koziva was Moshiach: no one can reveal the time of redemption. Achashverosh, sensing that the return of kingship to Yerushalayim would end his own, celebrated in the third year; the Mashgiach then brings the Gemara that the Jews were liable for enjoying that feast.

  7. 31:48 Kosher food, but a feast of exile listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach asks what the sin was, since Chazal make clear the food was kosher and each guest got what he wished. He answers that the feast celebrated kingship staying with the nations; joining it meant rejoicing in the exile of malchus, a disgrace to the honor of Heaven. The Jews repented by fasting, and so Purim is celebrated with a great feast; he contrasts Achashverosh's kingdom with Shlomo HaMelech's.

  8. 39:42 Achashverosh's imitation throne listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach says the Megillah is eternal: in every generation there is an Achashverosh with a feast that may be kosher, yet the kingdom is theirs. He brings the Midrash and Targum Sheni that Achashverosh tried to copy Shlomo's throne, which symbolized Hashem's kingship, and produced only a cheap imitation; the angels protested the feast, and Hashem answered with days corresponding to days, because Jews had desecrated Shabbos.

  9. 45:43 The far ones first: the king's pearl listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach brings the dispute of Rav and Shmuel whether inviting the distant first made Achashverosh wise or foolish, asks how either could call the other's view foolish, and explains with the Maharal that they disagree whether kingship is shown more through the far or the near. He brings the mashal from Sidduro shel Shabbos of the king who valued a pearl from the deep above diamonds, and applies it to the service of one who was far.

  10. 52:05 Adar, the month of the distant listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that Mordechai's letters 'to the near and the far' are addressed above all to the distant, and that Adar is the month of the distant. The Megillah was written for a people in exile to show that Hashem works miracles even in hiddenness; it opens with a feast because in Heaven the main feast is for the distant, whose small service in exile is dearer than the great avodah of Temple times.

The shiur, written up

Esther: salvation from a hidden place

0:10

The Mashgiach opens with the Gemara's hint to Esther in the Torah's words 'haster astir'. Some salvations come from a source that seems unconnected to the world, and so they must come hidden. The Purim miracles, which cannot be seen in the Megillah, are therefore greater than others. a

2:04

Following the Maharal, he links this to wine, which must be kept covered, to Binyamin as the last tribe born, and to Yaakov emerging after Eisav. Esther is called Hadassah, like the hadas whose leaves cover its wood. b,c

The hidden light, Shabbos and the Torah

4:23

Citing Rabbi Pinchas of Koritz, the Mashgiach says the hidden light shines strongly in the weeks of the four parshiyos. That light is for tzaddikim; the wicked cannot bear Shabbos and wait for it to leave. Moshe Rabbeinu, of whom it says 'ki tov hu', the Torah and Shabbos all belong to this light. d

7:19

This, he explains, is why Sefer Chassidim warns against leaving a sefer open: an open sefer that no one learns lets the outside forces draw from the hidden light of the Torah, and forgetting results. e

More holiness needs more covering

8:45

From here the Mashgiach draws a rule: the holier a thing, the more it is covered. Jews add garments to daven or to visit a great talmid chacham, a yarmulke and over it a hat, because the Shechinah rests on the head of one who serves Hashem.

10:11

He brings the Gemara's account of a child whom stargazers said would be a thief; his mother kept his head covered, and the one time it was uncovered he took from a fig tree. A covered head denies the outside forces a hold on the place of holiness. f

11:57

In Adar, the covered month, the parshiyos of the mishkan's coverings are read. Rabbi Pinchas of Koritz compared a Jew without a gartel to a barrel without hoops. A sefer Torah is wrapped and opened only to learn; on the four parshiyos two are taken out, a sign of great hidden light.

The hidden King of the Megillah

17:30

The Megillah, the Mashgiach notes, never mentions Hashem's name, yet a chesed came down so great that it had to come hidden. For this reason, he says, shalach manos is carried covered.

19:02

The Midrash teaches that 'the King' in the Megillah alludes to Hashem; Achashverosh was the garment through which the exiled Shechinah worked. Since earthly kingship mirrors heavenly kingship, his 127 provinces reflect the worlds above. The Maharal explains them as seven for the lower world, twenty for the middle and one hundred for the upper. g,h,i

The seventy-year reckoning

23:38

The Gemara says the Persians knew the Beis Hamikdash would be rebuilt seventy years after its destruction. Belshazzar made a reckoning, used the Temple vessels at a feast, and was killed that night after the writing on the wall. j,k

25:21

The Mashgiach explains that the nations do sense there is a Ribono shel Olam, but refuse to admit it because it would obligate them. So they feared the prophet's word, and when the years passed Achashverosh breathed with relief.

No one knows the time of redemption

28:33

Yet he erred, as even Daniel did: no one, not even the greatest prophets, knows the time of redemption, and the Rambam brings that Rabbi Akiva thought Bar Koziva was Moshiach. Sensing that the return of kingship would end his own, Achashverosh celebrated in his third year, and the Gemara says the Jews were liable for enjoying that feast. l,m,n,o

Kosher food, but a feast of exile

31:50

The Mashgiach asks what the sin was, since Chazal make clear the food was kosher and each guest received what he wished. The Jews repented by fasting three days, and since the sin came through eating, Purim is celebrated with a feast. p

35:05

His answer: Achashverosh felt that kingship, which belongs to Hashem, would now stay with him and not return to Yerushalayim. Joining his feast meant rejoicing that malchus and the Shechinah are in exile.

37:39

Achashverosh's kingdom stood opposite Shlomo's, the glory of Jewish history when each man sat under his vine. Rejoicing in its replacement was a disgrace to the honor of Heaven. q

Achashverosh's imitation throne

39:44

The Megillah is eternal, the Mashgiach says: every generation has its Achashverosh, its Mordechai and Esther, and its Haman. Such a feast may be fully kosher, but the kingdom is theirs.

40:47

The Midrash and Targum Sheni tell that Achashverosh tried to copy the throne of Shlomo, who sat 'on the throne of Hashem', and got only a cheap imitation, like a monkey copying a man. The angels protested the feast, and Hashem answered 'days corresponding to days', because Jews had desecrated Shabbos and greatness passed for a time to the nations. r,s,t

The far ones first: the king's pearl

46:13

Achashverosh first feasted those from distant lands, then the people of Shushan. Rav and Shmuel dispute whether this made him wise or foolish, and the Mashgiach asks how either could call the other's approach foolish. With the Maharal he answers that they disagree whether kingship is shown more by the far or by the near. u,v

49:22

Sidduro shel Shabbos tells of a king who built a wall of gems from every land. A devoted servant brought a pearl from the depths of the sea, and the king set it highest, for it showed his rule reaches even the place of darkness. So, the Mashgiach says, the service of one who was far is precious like a great tzaddik's. w

Adar, the month of the distant

52:18

Mordechai sent letters 'to the near and the far'; the Mashgiach explains that the Purim letters speak especially to the distant, and Adar is their month. y

53:45

The Megillah was written for a people in exile, to show that Hashem works miracles for them even when His name is hidden. It opens with a feast because in Heaven the main feast was for the distant, whose small service in Adar is dearer than the great avodah of Temple times.

Sources

Torah

  1. d Shemos 2:2 text index In the write-up: 4:23

Nevi'im

  1. q Melachim I 5:5 text index In the write-up: 37:39

Kesuvim

  1. b Esther 2:7 text index In the write-up: 2:04
  2. i Esther 1:1 text index In the write-up: 19:02
  3. k Daniel 5:25 text index In the write-up: 23:38
  4. n Esther 1:3 text index In the write-up: 28:33
  5. p Esther 1:8 text index In the write-up: 31:50
  6. r Esther 1:2 text index In the write-up: 40:47
  7. t Divrei Hayamim I 29:23 text index In the write-up: 40:47
  8. u Esther 1:5 text index In the write-up: 46:13
  9. y Esther 9:20 text index In the write-up: 52:18

Targum

  1. s apparently Targum Sheni on Esther 1:2 index In the write-up: 40:47

Talmud Bavli

  1. a Chullin 139b text index In the write-up: 0:10
  2. c apparently Sukkah 32b index In the write-up: 2:04
  3. f Shabbos 156b text index In the write-up: 10:11
  4. h Berachos 58a text index In the write-up: 19:02
  5. j Megillah 11b text index In the write-up: 23:38
  6. l apparently Megillah 12a index In the write-up: 28:33
  7. o Megillah 12a text index In the write-up: 28:33
  8. v Megillah 12a text index In the write-up: 46:13

Midrash

  1. g apparently Esther Rabbah 3:10 index In the write-up: 19:02

Rishonim

  1. e Sefer Chassidim (place not identified) index In the write-up: 7:19
  2. m Hilchos Melachim 11:3 text index In the write-up: 28:33

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. w Sidduro shel Shabbos (place not identified) index In the write-up: 49:22

Tefillah and Piyut

  1. x Vaye'esayu (piyut of the Yamim Noraim) (place not identified) 51:27 index

Key points

  1. 0:50 The Mashgiach teaches that the greater the holiness of a thing, the more it must be hidden and covered, and that the Purim miracles are greater because they come in concealment.
  2. 4:23 The hidden light of creation rests in Shabbos, in the Torah and in Moshe Rabbeinu, and it shines especially on the Shabbosos of the four parshiyos, when two sifrei Torah are taken out.
  3. 17:30 The Megillah never names Hashem, yet 'the King' in it alludes to Him, and Achashverosh's rule over 127 provinces mirrors the structure of the heavenly kingdom.
  4. 27:56 Achashverosh's feast celebrated his belief that the seventy years had ended without redemption, so that kingship would remain with him rather than return to Yerushalayim.
  5. 31:50 The food at the feast was kosher; the Jews' sin was that by attending they rejoiced that kingship remained in exile, a disgrace to the honor of Heaven, and they repented by fasting.
  6. 53:45 The Megillah was written for a people in exile who feel far from Hashem, to show that He is with them even in concealment and that the service of the distant is especially precious to Him.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 0:53 Why are the miracles of the Megillah hidden, with no open miracle in it?

    Answer: 1:04 Because they are greater than other miracles, and something so great had to be concealed.

  2. Question: 7:19 Why must a sefer not be left open?

    Answer: 7:47 Because the Torah holds the hidden light, and an open sefer not being learned gives the outside forces a chance to draw from it, which causes forgetting.

  3. Question: 31:29 If the food at Achashverosh's feast was kosher, what was the Jews' sin in attending?

    Answer: 36:04 The feast celebrated kingship remaining with the nations, so attending meant rejoicing that malchus is in exile, a disgrace to the honor of Heaven.

  4. Question: 34:56 What exactly was Achashverosh celebrating at his feast?

    Answer: 35:05 He felt that the seventy years had passed and kingship would now stay with him and not return to Yerushalayim.

  5. Question: 47:13 How could Rav or Shmuel call Achashverosh foolish for acting as the other holds is right?

    Answer: 47:54 Following the Maharal, the dispute is whether a king's true kingship is shown better through the distant or through the near.

  6. Question: 52:18 Why do Mordechai's letters go 'to the near and the far'?

    Answer: 52:33 The letters of Purim are addressed even, and especially, to those far from Hashem, and through them Mordechai speaks to the distant in every generation.

Stories

  1. 10:11 The boy whose covered head guarded him

    The Mashgiach brings the Gemara's account of a child whose mother kept his head covered, because the stargazers had said he would be a thief. She told him to cover his head so that he would have fear of Heaven. Once his head became uncovered, and at that moment he took from a fig tree. The Mashgiach explains that covering the head guards the place of holiness so that the outside forces have no hold there.

Insights

  1. 0:57 The Purim miracles are not lesser for being hidden; they are greater, and precisely because they are so great they had to be concealed so that no harm could take hold of them.
  2. 8:54 Jewish dress works opposite to the nations' custom: they honor by uncovering, while Jews honor and guard holiness by adding layers, a yarmulke and over it a hat, because the Shechinah rests on the head of one who serves Hashem.
  3. 21:21 Achashverosh's 127 provinces express a lowered image of the heavenly order: seven for the lower world, twenty for the middle world and one hundred for the upper world, each placed in a lower 'digit'.
  4. 36:04 The sin at Achashverosh's feast was not the food but its spirit: attending a celebration that kingship remains with the nations is rejoicing in the exile of the Shechinah, even when everything served is kosher.
  5. 47:54 The dispute whether Achashverosh was wise or foolish is really a dispute about what reveals true kingship: the far who accept it, or the near who stand around the king.
  6. 55:28 In Heaven the feast that opens the Megillah is read as a feast for the distant: Hashem showed the Jews of the exile that the small service of a Jew in Adar outweighs the great avodah of Temple times.

What the Mashgiach says to take from it

  1. 40:02 The Mashgiach says that even a fully kosher gathering of the nations that celebrates their kingdom is something a Jew should recognize as rejoicing in the exile of malchus.
  2. 51:00 The Mashgiach says a Jew who has been far and takes himself in hand to serve Hashem should know that his service is reckoned like that of the greatest tzaddik.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Achashverosh, Avraham Avinu, Bar Kochba (Ben Koziva), Belshatzar, Binyamin, Daniel, Esav, Esther HaMalkah, Haman, Mordechai HaTzaddik, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbi Akiva, Rabbi Pinchas of Koretz, Rav (the Amora), Shlomo HaMelech, the Maharal of Prague, the Rambam, Yaakov Avinu, Yehoshua bin Nun

Terms אור הגנוז, גלות השכינה, הסתר, חיצונים, משלוח מנות

Report an error on this page