The Eternal נסים of מגילת אסתר
Catalog entry: ZMANIM (English) פורים no. 5 Pocket Guide p. 65 תשס"ב (2001–02) English 39 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains that the miracles of the Megillah are hidden inside nature, just as Hashem's name is hidden in it, and that reading the Megillah trains a Jew to find Hashem behind world events and his own daily life.
The Mashgiach opens with the joy of Adar and asks how we can make the bracha 'she'asa nisim' over a Megillah that reads like an ordinary court story, with no split sea and no mention of Hashem's name. He answers that Nisan, the first month, is the month of revealed miracles, while Adar, the last, means a cloak: its miracles are covered by nature. Nature itself is a miracle, as bread from the ground would be to someone raised on the mann. Through a parable of a dying patient saved by a medicine and a doctor arriving just in time, he shows that the Megillah's nes is a jigsaw puzzle of natural events, and that current events, from the Gulf War onward, are a Megillah being written now. 'HaMelech' means Hashem, rulers are marionettes, and His name hides in the words. Reading the Megillah teaches a Jew to read the world and his own life.
Topics: Miracles and Nature · Megillas Esther · Hashgacha Pratis
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 A Megillah without open miracles listed in the guide
The Mashgiach opens with the joy of Adar and the great kedusha of Megillas Esther, written with ruach hakodesh. He points out that Hashem's name never appears in it and that it reads like a plain court story, and asks how we can then make the bracha 'she'asa nisim'.
-
4:06 Nisan and Adar: revealed and cloaked miracles listed in the guide
The Mashgiach contrasts Nisan, the first month and the month of revealed miracles, with Adar, the last month, whose name means a cloak, as in 'aderes se'ar'. He explains that nature is itself a miracle, using the example of a child raised on the mann who first sees bread grow from the ground.
-
10:13 Parable of the patient and the medicine listed in the guide
The Mashgiach tells a parable of a dying patient whose only cure is a medicine from China and a doctor from America, both months away, who both arrive just in time. Nothing supernatural happened, yet anyone sees there was a plan, and this, he says, is the kind of nes in the Megillah.
-
13:50 The jigsaw puzzle of the Megillah and of today listed in the guide
The Mashgiach shows how every detail of the Megillah, from Vashti's removal to Mordechai understanding Bigsan and Teresh and the king's sleepless night, is a screw in one machine. He applies this to current events such as the Gulf War and the fall of Russia, and explains that court gossip a yeshiva boy rightly ignores was, in Achashverosh's time, the unfolding of a nes.
-
21:48 Why Hashem's name is missing; 'HaMelech' listed in the guide
The Mashgiach gives a simple reason why Hashem's name is absent from the Megillah and brings the Midrash that 'HaMelech' alludes to Hashem, comparing it to a believer reading about the president in the newspaper. He brings the passuk that the hearts of kings are in Hashem's hand and Rashi that Amalek conceals Hashem's name and throne.
-
25:58 Rulers as marionettes listed in the guide
The Mashgiach describes a marionette show whose thin strings the audience cannot see. Achashverosh's sudden change from Haman's side to Esther's shows that he was a marionette, and the Mashgiach applies the same to the leaders of his day, who turn this way and that as Hashem pulls the strings.
-
29:49 Hashem's hidden name in the Megillah and in history listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains why some ba'alei kriah read 'Yavo hamelech v'Haman hayom' in one breath: the Arizal explains that its first letters spell Hashem's name, which appears at turning points of the story, sometimes backwards in final letters. Likewise Hashem's hand is hidden in history, where the empires that oppressed the Jews are gone and the Jews live on.
-
34:15 Learning to read the Megillah and the world listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains the bracha 'al mikra Megillah' as learning to read, like a doctor reading an x-ray, and calls the Megillah a drill in finding Hashem in newspapers and history books. With the masked collector at the Purim seudah and a late lunch at home, he concludes that the world is masked, Hashem directs every detail, and one who learns this fears no one.
The shiur, written up
A Megillah without open miracles
The Mashgiach opens with Chazal's words that when Adar enters we increase in joy, and sets out to find the message of the Megillah, which was written with ruach hakodesh and carries great kedusha. Yet Hashem's name never appears in it. Before reading it we bless Hashem 'she'asa nisim', who made miracles, but from beginning to end there is no miracle: a king, a queen, a minister, a plot uncovered. The sea did not split; everything was natural. How, he asks, can we make that bracha? a,b
Nisan and Adar: revealed and cloaked miracles
The calendar begins with Nisan, the first month, and descends to Adar, the last and furthest from it. Nisan is the month of revealed miracles. Adar has miracles too, but concealed: the name means a cloak, as in Esav's 'aderes se'ar', a hairy cloak. Its miracles are covered by nature. c,d
Who made nature? Hashem, so nature is also a miracle. A child born in the desert ate mann from heaven every day; crossing the Jordan and seeing bread grow from the ground, he would call that the wonder. We miss it only because we see it daily; the same Hashem makes both. The Megillah is a nes that happened within nature.
The patient and the medicine
The Mashgiach gives a parable from about two hundred years ago. A dying patient could be saved only by a medicine from China, administered by a single doctor in America, each six months away. Suddenly one man arrives with the medicine, then another with the doctor, and the patient recovers. No one called it supernatural, yet anyone sees a plan. These, he says, are the nissim of the Megillah.
The jigsaw puzzle of the Megillah and of today
Learned with its commentaries, the Megillah reveals hundreds of small items, each a screw in one machine. Haman advised removing Vashti, making room for Esther; Mordechai, a member of the Sanhedrin who knew seventy languages, understood Bigsan and Teresh; the king could not sleep the very night before Haman came to ask to hang Mordechai; Charvona was there to report the gallows. Without one piece, the Mashgiach says, the whole nes would not have happened.
A newspaper does not show Hashem's name either, yet one who follows events sees a puzzle assembled over years. Before the Gulf War, Iraq threatened Eretz Yisrael and America feared Russia; just when the yeshuah was needed, Russia collapsed. Every day, he says, is a new piece of a Megillah being written now.
A boy learning who refuses to hear about scandal in Achashverosh's court is right; his mind belongs in Torah. Yet that scandal was a nes, without which the Jews would not exist today. Hashem is making nissim now too, and a time will come when they are all seen.
Why Hashem's name is missing; 'HaMelech'
One simple reason for the missing name is that the Megillah was also written down where it might be desecrated. The Midrash teaches that 'HaMelech' in the Megillah, beyond its plain meaning, refers to Hashem, who directs its events. A believer reading about the president likewise knows the president has no power of his own, as the passuk says the hearts of kings are in Hashem's hand. e,f
Rulers as marionettes
In a marionette show, tin soldiers and animals dance on a stage, moved by threads too thin to see. Achashverosh was first wicked and ready to destroy the Jews, then suddenly took Esther's side. He had no choice, the Mashgiach explains; strings were pulled from above. So too President Bush shifts between the Jews and Arafat, and Arafat and Sharon can do nothing on their own: all are marionettes in Hashem's hand.
Hashem's hidden name
Hashem's name is in the Megillah, but hidden. Some ba'alei kriah read 'Yavo hamelech v'Haman hayom' fast in one breath; the Arizal explains that the first letters spell the name. It appears dozens of times, at each turning point, sometimes backwards in the final letters, but one must look for it. h
So too in history. The Roman and Greek empires that oppressed the Jews are gone, and the Jews are alive because Hashem is there, to be found between the cracks of the words.
Learning to read the Megillah and the world
The bracha 'al mikra Megillah' means reading. As a doctor reads an x-ray that looks like mere lines to others, one must learn to read the newspapers and history books; the Megillah is a drill in finding Hashem there. One who can read it can bless 'she'asa nisim' over hidden nissim.
At the seudah a figure bursts in with red pants and a sword, but under the costume is a collector. The whole world is masked, and Hashem directs every nation and person. If lunch is ten minutes late, the Mashgiach says, one who sees this is not upset. Whoever learns to read the Megillah fears no tyrant: Hashem took care of the Jews and always will.
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Rishonim
Key points
- 2:09 The Megillah tells a seemingly natural story with no open miracle and no mention of Hashem's name, yet we make the bracha 'she'asa nisim' over it.
- 4:15 Nisan is the month of revealed miracles; Adar, the month furthest from it, means a cloak, and its miracles are hidden in nature.
- 6:35 Nature itself is a miracle made by the same Hashem who makes open miracles; we fail to see it only because we are used to it.
- 14:27 The nes of the Megillah is a jigsaw puzzle of many small natural events, each one needed, put together by Hashem.
- 22:27 In the Megillah 'HaMelech' alludes to Hashem, and in the same way world leaders are marionettes moved by strings from above.
- 29:51 Hashem's name is in the Megillah, hidden in the first and last letters of words, and one has to look for it.
- 34:45 The Megillah is a drill in reading the world: one who learns to read it can find Hashem in current events and in his own life.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 2:26 How can we say 'she'asa nisim' over the Megillah when it contains no visible miracle?
Answer: 5:46 Adar's miracles are real but cloaked in nature, and nature itself is Hashem's miracle.
-
Question: 21:51 Why does Hashem's name not appear in the Megillah?
Answer: 21:56 A simple reason is that the Megillah was also written down where the name could be desecrated; further, Amalek conceals Hashem's name, so in the Megillah it is hidden.
-
Question: 28:07 What made Achashverosh suddenly change from wanting to kill the Jews to taking Esther's side?
Answer: 28:15 He had no choice; he was a marionette moved by strings from above.
-
Question: 30:41 Why do some ba'alei kriah read 'Yavo hamelech v'Haman hayom' quickly in one breath?
Answer: 30:49 The Arizal explains that the first letters of these four words spell Hashem's name.
Insights
- 5:26 Adar, from 'aderes', a cloak, is the month furthest from Nisan: Nisan's miracles are revealed, Adar's are wrapped in nature, a nes twelve levels removed from an open nes.
- 7:48 For a child raised in the desert on the mann, bread rising from the ground would be the wonder; what we call nature is a miracle we are simply used to.
- 18:27 The news of the day is a Megillah being written now: events like Russia's collapse just before the Gulf War are pieces of one plan to protect the Jews.
- 20:24 Gossip from the king's court that a yeshiva boy rightly refuses to hear was, in Shushan, the very unfolding of the nes without which the Jews would not exist today.
- 23:05 Just as 'HaMelech' in the Megillah alludes to Hashem, a believer reading about the president in the newspaper understands that the real ruler is Hashem, and the leaders are marionettes.
- 36:18 Purim masks teach that the whole world is a masked world, and under the mask Hashem directs nations, families and every small happening.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 34:48 The Mashgiach says one must learn to read the newspapers and the history books so as to find Hashem in them.
- 36:53 He says that if lunch is ten minutes late, one who knows how to see should not get angry, since Hashem made it so; one should find Hashem in one's own life.
- 21:08 He says yeshiva boys have no business filling their minds with the trivial news of the day; their minds belong in learning.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Achashverosh, Amalek, Bigsan and Teresh, Charvonah, Esther HaMalkah, Haman, Mordechai HaTzaddik, Rashi, the Arizal, Vashti
Terms אדר, אדרת, בעל קורא, הסתר פנים, טבע, מן, נס, רבונו של עולם, רוח הקודש